Pearson Edexcel · A-Level · Religious Studies

    Overview guide · Check your current course specification before revising.

    Knowledge of God's Existence

    This study guide provides a comprehensive analysis of the Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies topic on the Knowledge of God's Existence. It critically examines the core tension between Natural Theology (knowledge through reason) and Revealed Theology (knowledge through faith and grace), focusing on the pivotal arguments of Calvin, the Barth-Brunner debate, and Plantinga's Reformed Epistemology, equipping students to excel in AO1 and AO2."

    • 6 min read
    • 3 worked examples
    • 5 practice questions

    Study Notes

    Overview

    This topic requires a rigorous examination of the distinction between Natural and Revealed Theology. Candidates must evaluate whether human reason and observation (Natural) are sufficient to gain knowledge of God, or if the Fall has corrupted this capacity, necessitating faith and grace (Revealed). The core focus is the intellectual conflict between John Calvin's 'sensus divinitatis' and the 20th-century Barth-Brunner debate regarding the 'point of contact'. Examiners expect candidates to move beyond mere description to a critical evaluation (AO2) of these positions, contextualising them historically and assessing their theological coherence. Success in this area hinges on a precise understanding of key terms and the ability to construct a sustained, analytical argument regarding the epistemic possibilities for knowing God after the Fall.

    Key Individuals & Debates

    John Calvin (1509-1564)

    Role: A principal figure of the Protestant Reformation and a foundational theologian for this topic.

    Key Actions: In his 'Institutes of the Christian Religion' (1536), Calvin proposed that humans possess a 'sensus divinitatis' (an innate sense of the divine) and a 'semen religionis' (a seed of religion). This suggests a natural human disposition towards God.

    Impact: Calvin provides a framework for Natural Theology, arguing that God's existence is evident in creation (Romans 1:20). However, he crucially argues that the Fall has corrupted this sense, leading not to true knowledge but to idolatry. Therefore, while Natural Theology makes humanity accountable to God, it is insufficient for salvation, which requires Revealed Theology (Christ and Scripture).

    The Barth-Brunner Debate (1934)

    Knowledge of God's Existence – Religious Studies – A-LevelOpen full-size image (opens in a new tab)

    What happened: A landmark theological exchange between Swiss theologians Karl Barth and Emil Brunner over the validity of Natural Theology after the Fall.

    Why it matters: This debate defines the central conflict for exam questions. Brunner, in 'Nature and Grace', argued for a 'point of contact' (Anknüpfungspunkt), suggesting the 'Imago Dei' (Image of God) in humans was damaged but not destroyed, allowing a role for reason and apologetics. Barth, in his famous response 'Nein!' ('No!'), rejected this entirely. For Barth, the Fall obliterated any natural point of contact; God can only be known through His own self-revelation in Jesus Christ (Christocentrism). Barth's stance was heavily influenced by the rise of Nazism, fearing that Natural Theology could be co-opted to idolise the state or race.

    Specific Knowledge: Candidates must know the date (1934), the key terms ('point of contact', 'Nein!'), and the historical context (the rise of Nazism and the German Christian movement).

    Alvin Plantinga (1932-Present)

    Role: A contemporary American philosopher of religion.

    Key Actions: Developed 'Reformed Epistemology', arguing that belief in God can be a 'properly basic belief'. This means it can be rational and warranted without being based on evidence or other arguments, much like the belief in other minds or the external world.

    Impact: Plantinga provides a modern defence of a type of Natural Theology. He draws on Calvin's 'sensus divinitatis' to propose a cognitive faculty that, when functioning properly, produces belief in God. This sidesteps the need for traditional arguments for God's existence but raises questions about whether the 'sensus divinitatis' can be trusted post-Fall.

    Second-Order Concepts

    Causation

    • Long-term cause: The Fall of Man is the theological event that causes the central problem: is human reason now corrupt and unreliable for knowing God?
    • Mid-term cause: Calvin's formulation of the 'sensus divinitatis' sets the terms for the debate, creating a Protestant framework that accepts a form of natural knowledge while limiting its salvific power.
    • Trigger cause: The rise of the Nazi-aligned 'German Christian' movement, which used natural theology to justify its ideology, directly triggered Barth's forceful 'Nein!' and his absolute rejection of any natural point of contact.

    Consequence

    • Immediate consequence: The Barth-Brunner debate created a sharp and enduring division in Protestant theology between those who see a role for reason and culture in theology and those who adopt a strictly Christocentric, revelation-only position.
    • Long-term consequence: The debate continues to shape contemporary discussions on faith and reason, apologetics, and inter-faith dialogue. Plantinga's work is a direct continuation of this conversation in a modern philosophical context.

    Change & Continuity

    • Continuity: The fundamental questions asked by Paul in Romans 1 and Acts 17 about what can be known of God from creation continue throughout the centuries.
    • Change: The emphasis shifts from a pre-modern confidence in reason (like Aquinas) to a post-Reformation scepticism (Calvin) and then to a radical, crisis-driven rejection of reason by Barth in the 20th century.

    Significance

    This topic is significant because it forces a decision on the very foundations of religious knowledge. The position a candidate takes has profound implications for evangelism, ethics, and the relationship between Christianity and secular culture. Examiners view this as a test of a student's ability to handle complex, abstract theological arguments and their historical contexts.

    Source Skills

    Knowledge of God's Existence – Religious Studies – A-LevelOpen full-size image (opens in a new tab)

    When presented with a scriptural source like Romans 1:18-21 or Acts 17:22-31, candidates must analyse it from the perspective of the key thinkers.

    • Provenance: Who wrote it (e.g., Paul) and to whom? What was the context? (e.g., Paul addressing pagan philosophers in Athens).
    • Content: What does the source claim about knowledge of God? Does it support Natural Theology (as Brunner might argue) or highlight its failure (as Calvin and Barth would stress)?
    • Application: A top-level answer will use the source as evidence within the Barth-Brunner debate. For example: 'Brunner could use Paul's speech at the Areopagus as evidence for a point of contact, as Paul starts with their "unknown god". However, Barth would counter that Paul immediately pivots to the revelation of Christ and the resurrection, demonstrating the ultimate failure of their natural reason.'
      "

    Worked Examples

    3 worked examples — open one to explore the question and available guidance.

    Practice Questions

    Try the question, then reveal an answer plan or example response

    Q1

    Clarify Calvin's distinction between knowing that God exists and knowing God. (10 marks)

    10 marks
    standard

    Hint: Think about the difference between propositional knowledge and personal, relational knowledge. How does the Fall affect this?

    Q2

    Evaluate the claim that Barth's rejection of Natural Theology was driven more by politics than by theology. (20 marks)

    20 marks
    challenging

    Hint: Structure your essay to argue for and against the statement. Was his Christocentrism a pre-existing theological principle, or was it developed specifically in response to Nazism?

    Q3

    Clarify the arguments for Natural Theology presented in Acts 17 and Romans 1. (10 marks)

    10 marks
    standard

    Hint: Go through each passage separately and explain what it suggests about the possibility of knowing God through reason or observation.

    Q4

    Evaluate Plantinga's concept of belief in God as a 'properly basic belief'. (20 marks)

    20 marks
    challenging

    Hint: Strengths: It reflects how many people actually come to faith; it avoids the weaknesses of the traditional arguments. Weaknesses: Is it a free pass for any belief? What about the problem of the Fall corrupting the 'sensus divinitatis'?

    Q5

    Explain the difference between the formal and material aspects of the 'Imago Dei' in Brunner's theology. (10 marks)

    10 marks
    standard

    Hint: Material = the content, the relationship with God. Formal = the structure, the human capacity for reason/language.

    Ready to test yourself interactively?

    Active recall beats reading alone. Answer questions on Knowledge of God's Existence with instant AI scoring and mark scheme guidance.

    Start interactive practice

    A week of Premium from your first lesson · Then the free plan continues · No card, no charge

    Watch or listen (optional)
    🎙 Podcast Episode
    Knowledge of God's Existence
    0:00-0:00

    Test your understanding of Knowledge of God's Existence

    Active recall beats re-reading. Take an instant quiz now to test what you’ve learned and lock it into long-term memory.

    Take topic quiz

    A week of Premium from your first lesson · Then the free plan continues · No card, no charge

    More Religious Studies Study Guides

    View all

    Applied Ethics: Sexual Ethics

    Pearson Edexcel
    A-Level

    This study guide provides a comprehensive overview of Applied Ethics: Sexual Ethics for Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies. It explores the complex interplay between religious doctrines and secular philosophies, equipping candidates with the critical tools needed to analyse and evaluate these sensitive issues for high marks.

    Arguments for the Existence of God: Design (Teleological)

    Pearson Edexcel
    A-Level

    This study guide provides a comprehensive analysis of the Teleological Argument for the existence of God, a cornerstone of the Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies specification. It moves from Paley's classic watchmaker analogy to modern probabilistic arguments, equipping candidates with the critical tools to deconstruct and evaluate one of philosophy's most enduring questions."

    Arguments for the Existence of God: Ontological

    Pearson Edexcel
    A-Level

    The Ontological Argument is a unique philosophical proof for God's existence that uses pure reason rather than empirical evidence. This guide unpacks its complex logic, tracing its development from St. Anselm to modern debates, providing the critical analysis needed to excel in the Edexcel A-Level exam.

    Islamic Ethics and Moral Principles

    Pearson Edexcel
    A-Level

    This study guide provides a comprehensive overview of Islamic Ethics and Moral Principles for the Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies specification (9RS0/4C). It delves into the core concepts of Shari'ah and Fiqh, the sources of Islamic law, and the key ethical categories, equipping students with the knowledge and skills to excel in their exams."

    Religious Figures and Sacred Texts

    Pearson Edexcel
    A-Level

    This study guide explores the complex relationship between religious figures and sacred texts in A-Level Religious Studies. It delves into the critical debates surrounding divine revelation, textual authority, and scholarly interpretation, providing students with the analytical tools needed to excel in the Edexcel examination."

    Religious Life and Practices

    Pearson Edexcel
    A-Level

    This study guide provides a comprehensive analysis of Christian religious life and practices, specifically Baptism and Holy Communion, for the Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies exam. It delves into the core theological debates that have shaped Christian history, from the nature of Christ's presence in the Eucharist to the profound question of when and why baptism should be administered, equipping candidates with the critical tools needed to excel."