Democracy idealised — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation
In summary: Democracy idealised is a key topic in OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation. Key exam tip: Ensure you can explicitly link the reforms of Solon and Cleisthenes to the later 5th-century democratic system
Exam Tips for Democracy idealised
- Ensure you can explicitly link the reforms of Solon and Cleisthenes to the later 5th-century democratic system
- When analyzing Aristophanes, focus on the specific political context of the play and the nature of his satire rather than just summarizing the plot
- Use the prescribed literary sources as the foundation for your arguments; do not just describe them, but analyze how they shape meaning
- Practice evaluating the 'Democracy critiqued' section by contrasting the ideal of the common good with the practical dangers of demagogues and 'popular' leaders as presented by Plato and others
Common Mistakes
- Failing to distinguish between the different stages of democratic development (Solonian, Cleisthenic, and 5th-century)
- Treating all ancient sources as equally objective or representative of the 'average' Athenian view
- Neglecting the specific context of the prescribed literary extracts when analyzing them
- Over-generalizing about 'Athenian democracy' without acknowledging its internal contradictions or the critiques leveled against it by contemporaries
Marking Points
- Understanding of the reforms of Solon and Cleisthenes and their impact on Athenian democracy
- Knowledge of the organs of democracy: the Assembly, the Boule, the law-courts, and the role of magistrates
- Analysis of how democracy shaped Athenian identity and its perceived benefits
- Evaluation of contemporary critiques of democracy, particularly from Plato and the 'Old Oligarch'
- Interpretation of political satire and commentary in the comedies of Aristophanes
- Ability to use prescribed literary sources to support arguments about the nature and reception of Athenian democracy
Overview of Democracy idealised
The concept of 'Democracy idealised' in Classical Civilisation (OCR A-Level) focuses on how ancient Greek thinkers, particularly in Athens, constructed an idealised vision of democracy as a system of government by the many. This topic explores the philosophical and rhetorical foundations of Athenian democracy, drawing heavily on sources such as Pericles' Funeral Oration (as recorded by Thucydides), Plato's critiques, and Aristotle's classifications. Students examine how democracy was presented as a model of freedom, equality, and civic participation, while also considering the gap between this ideal and the reality of Athenian society, which excluded women, slaves, and metics.
Understanding this idealisation is crucial because it shaped Western political thought and continues to influence modern debates about democracy. The topic requires students to analyse primary sources critically, recognising how rhetoric and philosophy construct ideals that may not reflect historical practice. It also connects to broader themes in Classical Civilisation, such as the tension between individual liberty and collective responsibility, and the role of leadership in a democratic state. By studying the idealised version, students gain insight into how the Athenians themselves understood and promoted their political system.
This topic fits within the OCR specification's 'Politics and Society' component, where students compare Athenian democracy with other systems like oligarchy and tyranny. It also links to the study of Athenian imperialism, the Peloponnesian War, and the works of key figures like Pericles and Socrates. Mastery of this topic enables students to evaluate the legacy of Athenian democracy and its enduring appeal as a political ideal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between Athenian democracy and modern democracy?
Athenian democracy was a direct democracy where citizens voted on laws and policies themselves, whereas modern democracies are typically representative, with elected officials making decisions. Additionally, Athenian citizenship was restricted to adult males born to Athenian parents, excluding women, slaves, and metics, while modern democracies generally have broader suffrage. The Athenian system also relied on random selection for many offices (sortition) rather than elections, which were seen as oligarchic.
Why is Pericles' Funeral Oration important for understanding Athenian democracy?
Pericles' Funeral Oration, as recorded by Thucydides, is a key source for the idealised vision of Athenian democracy. It praises Athens as a model of freedom, equality, and civic duty, highlighting values like isonomia and isegoria. However, it is a rhetorical piece delivered during war, so it omits the exclusion of non-citizens and the realities of Athenian imperialism. Historians use it to understand how Athenians wanted to be seen, not necessarily how they actually were.
What did Plato think about democracy?
Plato was highly critical of democracy. In his work 'The Republic', he argued that democracy leads to chaos and mob rule because it gives power to the uneducated masses. He believed that the best government is an aristocracy ruled by philosopher-kings who have knowledge of the Forms, especially the Form of the Good. Plato's ideal state is hierarchical and authoritarian, contrasting sharply with Athenian democratic ideals.
How did Aristotle classify different types of government?
Aristotle classified governments based on who rules and for whose benefit. He identified three 'correct' forms: monarchy (rule by one for the common good), aristocracy (rule by a few for the common good), and polity (rule by many for the common good). Their 'deviant' counterparts are tyranny, oligarchy, and democracy (rule by the many for their own interest). For Aristotle, democracy was a perversion of polity, where the poor rule in their own interest rather than for all.
Was Athenian democracy really democratic?
Athenian democracy was democratic for a small minority: only adult male citizens (about 10-20% of the population) could participate. Women, slaves, and metics (resident foreigners) had no political rights. Additionally, the system relied on slavery, which provided citizens with the leisure to participate in politics. So while it was a radical form of direct democracy for citizens, it was built on the exclusion and exploitation of the majority.
What is isonomia and why is it important?
Isonomia means 'equality before the law' and was a key ideal in Athenian democracy. It implied that all citizens had equal legal rights and protections, regardless of wealth or status. Pericles highlighted isonomia in his Funeral Oration as a cornerstone of Athenian freedom. However, in practice, isonomia applied only to citizens, and even among them, wealthy individuals often had more influence. The concept remains important as a precursor to modern ideas of legal equality.
← Back to Classical Civilisation OCR A-Level Specification · All Classical Civilisation Topics