Greeks and barbarians — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation
In summary: Greeks and barbarians is a key topic in OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation. Key exam tip: Ensure you can link specific literary passages to the broader themes of the component.
Exam Tips for Greeks and barbarians
- Ensure you can link specific literary passages to the broader themes of the component.
- When analyzing visual sources, always consider the purpose, audience, and context of the object.
- Use the prescribed literary sources to support your arguments in essays, not just as a summary of the plot.
- Practice comparing the 'Greek view' of the barbarian with the 'reality' of Persian culture as evidenced by Persian sources.
- In commentary questions, focus on how the author shapes meaning through language and narrative techniques.
Common Mistakes
- Treating Greek literary depictions of Persians as objective historical fact rather than cultural constructs.
- Failing to distinguish between the different purposes and contexts of the literary sources (e.g., tragedy vs. history).
- Ignoring the limitations of visual/material evidence, such as the fragmentary nature of archaeological remains.
- Over-generalising 'Greek' identity without acknowledging the autonomy and diversity of individual poleis.
- Neglecting to use secondary academic views to substantiate arguments in essay responses.
Marking Points
- Knowledge and understanding of the geographical extent of the Greek world and the concept of Greek identity.
- Analysis of the Persian Wars as a catalyst for Greek unity and the crystallisation of the 'barbarian' stereotype.
- Critical evaluation of literary sources (Herodotus, Aeschylus, Euripides) regarding their portrayal of Persians and barbarians.
- Understanding of the role of binary oppositions (Greek/foreigner, man/woman, slave/free) in the Greek worldview.
- Ability to interpret visual/material sources (e.g., Persian art, Greek depictions of battles) and their limitations.
- Comparison of Greek literary/artistic depictions with the historical reality of the Achaemenid Empire.
- Use of secondary scholars and academic works to support arguments in extended responses.
Overview of Greeks and barbarians
The topic 'Greeks and barbarians' explores how the ancient Greeks defined themselves in opposition to non-Greek peoples, whom they collectively termed 'barbarians' (barbaroi). This concept was central to Greek identity from the Archaic period through the Classical era, particularly in the context of the Persian Wars (490–479 BCE). The term originally mimicked the sound of foreign languages ('bar-bar'), but over time it acquired connotations of cultural inferiority, though attitudes were complex and varied by region, author, and period. Key sources include Herodotus' Histories, which contrasts Greek freedom with Persian despotism, and Athenian tragedy, such as Aeschylus' Persians, which both reinforces and subtly challenges stereotypes.
For OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation, this topic is part of the 'Greek World' component and requires analysis of literary, historical, and archaeological evidence. Students must examine how Greek writers constructed the 'barbarian' as a foil to Greek virtues like rationality, democracy, and self-control, while also recognising that Greeks did not always view barbarians uniformly—some, like the Scythians or Egyptians, were admired for their wisdom or simplicity. The topic also connects to broader themes of imperialism, ethnicity, and cultural exchange, especially in the Hellenistic period after Alexander the Great's conquests.
Understanding 'Greeks and barbarians' is crucial for grasping the foundations of Western identity and the origins of ethnocentrism. It also sharpens critical thinking about how societies define 'us' and 'them', a skill applicable beyond the ancient world. In exams, students are expected to use specific examples from prescribed sources (e.g., Herodotus, Euripides' Medea, or vase paintings) to support arguments about Greek attitudes, and to evaluate the extent to which these views were consistent or contradictory.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the ancient Greeks mean by 'barbarian'?
The term 'barbarian' (barbaros) originally referred to anyone who did not speak Greek, imitating the sound of foreign languages ('bar-bar'). Over time, especially after the Persian Wars, it acquired negative connotations of cultural inferiority, such as being slavish, emotional, or tyrannical. However, some Greeks admired certain barbarian peoples, like the Egyptians for their ancient wisdom or the Scythians for their simple lifestyle.
How did the Persian Wars affect Greek views of barbarians?
The Persian Wars (490–479 BCE) were a turning point. Greek victories, especially at Marathon and Salamis, fostered a sense of Greek superiority and freedom versus Persian despotism. Writers like Aeschylus in 'The Persians' portrayed the Persian king Xerxes as arrogant and effeminate, reinforcing stereotypes. However, Herodotus, while celebrating Greek freedom, also showed respect for Persian customs, indicating that views were not uniformly negative.
Were all barbarians seen as the same by Greeks?
No, Greeks distinguished between different barbarian groups. For example, Egyptians were often respected for their ancient culture and religious piety, while Scythians were seen as noble savages—fierce but uncorrupted by luxury. Persians were stereotyped as wealthy and decadent, but also as brave warriors. The Thracians and Illyrians were often dismissed as primitive. So, there was a hierarchy of barbarians, not a single monolithic view.
What role did women play in the Greek-barbarian dichotomy?
Barbarian women in Greek literature often embodied the 'other' in extreme ways. For instance, Medea in Euripides' play is a barbarian princess who uses magic and kills her own children, linking barbarism to uncontrolled emotion and dangerous femininity. In contrast, Greek women were ideally modest and controlled. This contrast reinforced Greek ideas of self-restraint as a marker of civilisation.
How did Alexander the Great change Greek attitudes toward barbarians?
Alexander's conquests (336–323 BCE) led to a more cosmopolitan outlook. He encouraged intermarriage between Greeks and Persians, adopted Persian court rituals, and founded cities that blended cultures. This challenged the traditional Greek-barbarian divide, though some Greeks criticised him for 'going native'. The Hellenistic period that followed saw increased cultural exchange, but stereotypes persisted.
What sources do OCR A-Level students need to know for this topic?
Key sources include Herodotus' 'Histories' (especially his descriptions of Egypt, Persia, and Scythia), Aeschylus' 'Persians', Euripides' 'Medea' and 'Bacchae', and vase paintings showing Greeks fighting Persians or Amazons. Students should also know about the 'Scythian archer' vases and the 'Persian' motifs in Athenian art. Archaeological evidence like the Persepolis reliefs can also be used to compare Greek and Persian perspectives.
← Back to Classical Civilisation OCR A-Level Specification · All Classical Civilisation Topics