Nature of (old) comedy — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation
In summary: Nature of (old) comedy is a key topic in OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation. Key exam tip: Use the prescribed visual/material sources to support your analysis of theatrical staging
Exam Tips for Nature of (old) comedy
- Use the prescribed visual/material sources to support your analysis of theatrical staging
- Ensure you can define and explain key comic devices such as the agon and parabasis
- When discussing the cultural context, explicitly link the play's themes to Athenian society
- In commentary questions, focus on how the writer shapes meaning through specific language and dramatic techniques
- Use secondary scholars to support your arguments in the 30-mark essay
Common Mistakes
- Failing to link comic techniques to their intended effect on the audience
- Ignoring the visual/material evidence when discussing theatrical performance
- Treating the plays as purely historical documents rather than literary and dramatic works
- Lack of specific reference to the prescribed sources in extended responses
- Over-generalizing the 'nature of comedy' without referencing specific playwrights or conventions
Marking Points
- Understanding of the origins and development of comedy in the 5th century BC
- Knowledge of the role of actors and the Chorus in comic performance
- Analysis of comic techniques, including plot devices like the agon and parabasis
- Evaluation of the use of masks, costumes, and props in staging
- Ability to relate the subject matter of plays to their social, political, and religious context
- Understanding of common themes in Old Comedy
- Critical analysis of the prescribed literary and visual/material sources
Overview of Nature of (old) comedy
The 'Nature of (old) comedy' is a foundational topic in OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation, focusing on the distinctive features, themes, and cultural context of Old Comedy, primarily through the works of Aristophanes. Old Comedy, which flourished in 5th-century BCE Athens, is characterised by its outrageous humour, political satire, fantastical plots, and direct engagement with contemporary society. Unlike later New Comedy, Old Comedy is unafraid to mock real individuals, including politicians like Cleon and philosophers like Socrates, often using personal invective and obscenity. Understanding this genre is crucial for appreciating how comedy functioned as a form of social and political commentary in democratic Athens, and how it reflected the anxieties and values of its audience.
This topic requires students to analyse the structural elements of Old Comedy, such as the prologue, parodos, agon, parabasis, and exodos, and to explore recurring themes like war, peace, gender roles, and the critique of authority. Key plays include 'Lysistrata', 'The Frogs', 'The Clouds', and 'The Wasps', each offering unique insights into the genre's conventions. Students must also consider the performance context—the City Dionysia and Lenaea festivals—and the role of the chorus, costumes, and stage machinery. By studying Old Comedy, students gain a deeper understanding of Athenian democracy, religion, and social norms, as well as the enduring power of satire.
Mastery of this topic is essential for exam success, as it appears in both the 'World of the Hero' and 'Culture and the Arts' components of the OCR specification. Students should be able to discuss the purpose of Old Comedy—whether it was purely entertainment, a tool for social critique, or a ritualistic element of the festival—and evaluate its effectiveness. Comparative analysis with tragedy or New Comedy can also strengthen arguments. Ultimately, the 'Nature of (old) comedy' offers a vibrant window into ancient Greek culture, challenging modern assumptions about humour and censorship.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between Old Comedy and New Comedy?
Old Comedy (5th century BCE) is characterised by political satire, personal invective, fantastical plots, and a large chorus. It often mocks real individuals and contemporary issues. New Comedy (4th-3rd century BCE), represented by Menander, focuses on domestic situations, stock characters (e.g., the miser, the young lover), and avoids political commentary. The chorus in New Comedy is reduced to interludes between acts. Old Comedy is more outrageous and directly engaged with Athenian democracy, while New Comedy is more universal and romantic.
Why did Aristophanes use obscenity in his plays?
Obscenity in Old Comedy served multiple purposes. Firstly, it was part of the ritual license of the Dionysian festivals, where social norms were temporarily inverted. Secondly, it shocked the audience and grabbed attention, making the satire more memorable. Thirdly, it reinforced social norms by mocking deviant sexual behaviour or bodily functions. For example, in 'Lysistrata', the sex strike uses obscenity to highlight the absurdity of war. However, obscenity was not gratuitous; it was carefully integrated into the plot and themes.
What is the parabasis and why is it important?
The parabasis is a central section of Old Comedy where the chorus steps forward to address the audience directly, often speaking for the poet. It typically includes a discussion of contemporary issues, praise for the poet, and criticism of the audience or politicians. For example, in 'The Knights', the parabasis attacks Cleon. The parabasis is important because it breaks the dramatic illusion and allows the poet to express personal views, making it a key tool for political and social commentary. It also provides insight into the poet's intentions and the play's context.
How did Old Comedy reflect Athenian democracy?
Old Comedy reflected Athenian democracy through its freedom to criticise politicians, policies, and social norms. The genre thrived in the democratic environment of 5th-century Athens, where free speech (parrhesia) was valued. Plays like 'The Knights' directly mocked Cleon, a powerful demagogue, while 'The Wasps' satirised the Athenian jury system. By exposing flaws in democratic institutions, Old Comedy encouraged citizens to think critically. However, this freedom had limits—Aristophanes was prosecuted by Cleon for slandering the city in 'The Babylonians', showing the tension between comedy and authority.
What is the 'happy idea' in Old Comedy?
The 'happy idea' (or 'great idea') is a central concept in Old Comedy, referring to the protagonist's fantastical scheme that sets the plot in motion. It is often absurd and utopian, designed to solve a pressing problem. For example, in 'Lysistrata', the happy idea is a sex strike to force men to end the Peloponnesian War. In 'The Birds', two Athenians build a city in the sky to gain power over the gods. The happy idea allows Aristophanes to explore alternative realities and critique society by imagining how things could be different.
← Back to Classical Civilisation OCR A-Level Specification · All Classical Civilisation Topics