Plato on love and desire — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation
In summary: Plato on love and desire is a key topic in OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation. Key exam tip: Ensure you can clearly define and contrast the philosophical ideas of Plato and Seneca
Exam Tips for Plato on love and desire
- Ensure you can clearly define and contrast the philosophical ideas of Plato and Seneca
- Use specific examples from the prescribed literary sources to substantiate your arguments
- Practice comparing the different perspectives on love and desire across the different authors studied
- Be prepared to discuss the influence of Stoicism on Seneca's ideas
- In extended essays, explicitly integrate the views of secondary scholars to enhance your analysis
Common Mistakes
- Failing to distinguish between the philosophical views of Plato and Seneca and the literary representations in poetry
- Ignoring the social and historical context of the authors when analyzing their work
- Treating ancient concepts of love and marriage as identical to modern ones
- Lack of critical engagement with the fragmentary nature of Sappho's work
- Failure to use secondary scholars to support arguments in extended responses
Marking Points
- Knowledge and understanding of Greek and Roman thinking on the ideal qualities of men and women
- Understanding of the relative status of men and women domestically, civically, and legally
- Analysis of Greek and Roman thoughts on marriage, including what constitutes a good marriage and attitudes towards adultery
- Evaluation of Plato's definitions of love, physical symptoms of desire, and the distinction between love and desire
- Analysis of how and why desire should be controlled or resisted
- Understanding of homoerotic relationships in the ancient context
- Comparison of views in literature (Sappho and Ovid) with philosophical thought (Plato and Seneca)
- Ability to relate ideas to their social, historical, and cultural contexts
Overview of Plato on love and desire
Plato's philosophy of love and desire is primarily explored in his dialogues 'Symposium' and 'Phaedrus'. In the 'Symposium', a series of speeches culminate in Socrates' account of Diotima's teachings, which present love (Eros) as a fundamental human drive that can lead from physical attraction to the contemplation of eternal, abstract Beauty. This 'Ladder of Love' outlines a progression from loving a single beautiful body to loving all beautiful bodies, then beautiful souls, laws, knowledge, and finally Beauty itself. For Plato, true love is not about possession or physical gratification but about a desire for the good and the eternal, ultimately leading to philosophical wisdom.
In the 'Phaedrus', Plato uses the metaphor of the charioteer and two horses (one noble, one unruly) to illustrate the conflict between rational and irrational desires. Here, love is seen as a divine madness that can inspire the soul to remember the Forms, particularly the Form of Beauty, which it glimpsed before birth. This recollection (anamnesis) is a key aspect of Plato's theory of knowledge and links love to the pursuit of truth. For A-Level students, understanding Plato's view of love is crucial because it challenges modern, romanticised notions of love and instead frames it as an intellectual and spiritual journey towards the ultimate reality.
This topic fits within the broader study of Classical Civilisation by exploring how ancient Greek thinkers grappled with fundamental human experiences. It connects to Plato's Theory of Forms, his epistemology, and his ethics, as love is seen as a motivating force for moral and intellectual development. Students will also encounter contrasts with other ancient views, such as Aristotle's more empirical approach to friendship and desire, making it a rich area for comparative analysis in exams.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Ladder of Love in Plato's Symposium?
The Ladder of Love is a metaphor from Diotima's speech in Plato's 'Symposium'. It describes a progression from loving a single beautiful body, to all beautiful bodies, then beautiful souls, laws, knowledge, and finally the Form of Beauty itself. Each step represents a higher, more abstract form of love, moving from physical attraction to intellectual and spiritual contemplation.
Does Plato think love is a good or bad thing?
Plato sees love (Eros) as fundamentally good when properly directed. In the 'Symposium', love is a desire for the good and the eternal, leading to wisdom and virtue. In the 'Phaedrus', love is a divine madness that can inspire the soul to remember the Forms. However, unchecked physical desire (like the bad horse in the chariot allegory) can lead to harm, so love must be guided by reason.
What is the difference between Platonic love and romantic love?
Platonic love, as described by Plato, is not about romantic or sexual relationships but about a philosophical pursuit of truth and beauty. It begins with physical attraction but aims to transcend it to appreciate the Form of Beauty. Modern 'platonic love' often means a non-sexual friendship, but for Plato, it is a dynamic, ascending process of intellectual and spiritual growth.
How does the chariot allegory explain desire in Phaedrus?
In the 'Phaedrus', Plato compares the soul to a charioteer driving two horses: one white and noble (representing rational, spirited emotion) and one black and unruly (representing base appetites). The charioteer (reason) must control both horses. When the soul sees beauty, the black horse pulls towards physical gratification, while the white horse and charioteer aim for higher contemplation. This allegory illustrates the inner conflict between different types of desire.
Why does Plato think beauty is so important for love?
For Plato, beauty is the most accessible of the Forms because it is visible in the physical world. In the 'Phaedrus', he says beauty 'shines brightest' and triggers recollection (anamnesis) of the Form of Beauty. Love begins with the sight of a beautiful person, which awakens the soul's memory of true Beauty. Thus, beauty is the catalyst for the philosophical journey of love.
What does Plato mean by 'love is the desire for the perpetual possession of the good'?
This quote from Diotima in the 'Symposium' encapsulates Plato's view that love is not just about wanting something beautiful, but about wanting to possess the good forever. Since humans are mortal, they seek immortality through procreation (physical or intellectual). By creating beauty (e.g., children, art, laws, or knowledge), they achieve a form of eternal possession of the good. This links love to the pursuit of virtue and wisdom.
← Back to Classical Civilisation OCR A-Level Specification · All Classical Civilisation Topics