Overview
Appraising music is the cornerstone of your musical education. It is not merely about deciding whether you 'like' a piece of music; rather, it is the rigorous process of dismantling a composition to understand its inner workings. As a candidate, you are expected to act as a musical detective, listening actively to identify specific features, describing them with precise terminology, and analysing how they contribute to the overall effect. This skill is assessed directly in the listening examination, but it also fundamentally informs your own performing and composing coursework. By understanding how masterful composers manipulate musical elements, you can apply these techniques to your own creative work.
Key Knowledge & Theory
Core Concepts: The Musical Elements
The foundation of appraising music is a comprehensive understanding of the musical elements. These are the building blocks of all compositions. Examiners will award marks to candidates who can accurately identify these elements and explain their function.
Melody: The primary tune or sequence of single notes. You must consider its contour (conjunct/stepwise or disjunct/leaping), range (narrow or wide), and the use of motifs and sequences.
Harmony and Tonality: The chordal structure and key. Is the tonality major, minor, modal, or atonal? Look for modulations (key changes), cadences (perfect, imperfect, plagal, interrupted), and the use of dissonance or chromaticism to create tension.
Rhythm, Metre, and Tempo: The organisation of time. Rhythm refers to note lengths, metre to the time signature (e.g., simple, compound, irregular), and tempo to the speed. Consider how syncopation, cross-rhythms, or changes in tempo affect the music's momentum.
Texture: How the musical layers interact. Key terms include monophonic (single line), homophonic (melody and accompaniment), polyphonic/contrapuntal (multiple independent lines), and heterophonic.
Timbre and Sonority: The unique tone colour of instruments or voices. This includes playing techniques (e.g., pizzicato, arco, con sordino) and the overall sound quality produced by specific combinations of instruments.
Dynamics and Articulation: The volume and how notes are played. Use terms like pianissimo, fortissimo, crescendo, and diminuendo for dynamics, and staccato, legato, or marcato for articulation.
Structure and Form: The overall architecture of the piece. Common forms include binary (AB), ternary (ABA), rondo (ABACA), strophic, and sonata form. Understanding structure helps you navigate the piece and identify how themes are developed.
Instrumentation: The specific forces used. Is it a string quartet, a full symphony orchestra, or a jazz combo? How does the composer exploit the different sections to create contrast?
Key Practitioners/Artists/Composers
| Name | Period/Style | Key Works | Relevance |
|---|
| J.S. Bach | Baroque | Brandenburg Concertos | Master of polyphonic texture, complex counterpoint, and functional harmony. Essential for understanding early Western classical traditions. |
| L.v. Beethoven | Classical/Romantic | Symphony No. 5 | Pivotal figure bridging two eras. Demonstrates thematic development, structural expansion, and the expressive use of dynamics and instrumentation. |
| Claude Debussy | Impressionism | Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune | Broke traditional harmonic rules. Use of whole-tone scales, parallel chords, and focus on timbre/sonority over functional harmony. |
| John Williams | Film Music | Star Wars, Jurassic Park | Exemplifies the use of leitmotifs, full orchestral forces, and late-Romantic harmonic language to create specific emotional and narrative effects. |
Technical Vocabulary
To access the higher mark bands, candidates MUST use precise, subject-specific terminology. Avoid vague descriptions.
- Instead of "it gets louder," use crescendo.
- Instead of "the tune goes up and down," describe the melodic contour as having ascending leaps or descending conjunct movement.
- Instead of "different tunes playing at once," use polyphonic texture.
- Instead of "it sounds sad," state that it is in a minor tonality with dissonant harmony.
Practical Skills
Techniques & Processes: The Appraising Framework
When faced with an unfamiliar listening extract or a set work essay, employ a systematic approach:
- Listen Actively: Do not merely hear the music; listen with intent. On the first hearing, identify the broad strokes: tempo, mood, performing forces, and overall texture.
- Identify Musical Elements: On subsequent hearings, focus on specific elements. Listen for the bassline to determine harmony, track the main melody, and note the rhythmic patterns.
- Describe & Analyse: Use your technical vocabulary to describe what is happening. More importantly, analyse how these elements interact. For example, how does a sudden forte dynamic combined with a dissonant chord create a specific dramatic effect?
- Compare & Contextualise: Relate the music to its historical period, genre, or the composer's other works. How does it conform to or break the conventions of its time?
- Evaluate & Justify: Form a reasoned judgement about the effectiveness of the music, supported entirely by the musical evidence you have identified.
Materials & Equipment
Your primary equipment is your ear, supported by a thorough knowledge of the score (if applicable) and your glossary of terms. For written exams, practice reading full orchestral scores, identifying transposing instruments, and following complex textures visually as well as aurally.
Portfolio/Coursework Guidance
Assessment Criteria
While appraising is primarily assessed in the written/listening exam, it directly impacts your coursework. Examiners look for:
- Analytical Depth: In composition logs or performance evaluations, can you accurately describe your own work using the same rigorous terminology applied to set works?
- Application of Knowledge: Have you successfully applied techniques learned through appraising (e.g., a specific harmonic progression or textural device) to your own compositions?
Building a Strong Portfolio
When writing program notes or composition logs, explicitly link your creative decisions to your appraising studies. For example: "I utilised a polyphonic texture in the B section, inspired by Bach's fugal writing, to create a sense of intellectual complexity before returning to the homophonic A section."
Exam Component
Written Exam Knowledge
The listening and appraising paper tests your ability to identify features aurally and apply theoretical knowledge under timed conditions. Questions range from short-answer identification (e.g., "Name the cadence at bar 12") to extended essay responses requiring comparison and contextual analysis.
Practical Exam Preparation
To prepare, you must practice active listening daily. Use past papers to familiarise yourself with the speed at which extracts are played and the specific phrasing of questions. Create summary sheets for each set work, categorised by the musical elements (MHRTTDSI), ensuring you have at least three specific musical examples for each element.