'Improper' Women
This topic explores the role of temples in ancient Greek and Roman religion, focusing on their layout, use, and the function of associated officials and rituals. It covers specific Greek temples (Parthenon, Temple of Zeus at Olympia) and Roman temples (Temple of Fortuna Virilis, Pantheon), alongside the roles of priests, priestesses, and sacrificial practices.
Topic Overview
In OCR GCSE Classical Civilisation, the topic of 'Improper' Women explores how ancient Greek and Roman societies defined and judged female behaviour that deviated from accepted norms. This includes women who challenged patriarchal authority, engaged in non-traditional roles, or were portrayed as morally transgressive in literature and art. Key figures such as Medea, Clytemnestra, and Dido are studied as examples of women who acted 'improperly' according to their societies, often with tragic consequences. The topic also examines how these portrayals reflect broader anxieties about female power, sexuality, and independence in the ancient world.
Understanding 'Improper' Women is crucial because it reveals the rigid gender expectations of classical societies and how they used myth and history to reinforce social norms. By analysing these figures, students gain insight into the limited roles available to women—primarily as wives, mothers, and daughters—and the severe repercussions for those who stepped outside these boundaries. This topic also connects to wider themes in the course, such as the role of the household (oikos), the concept of honour (kleos in Greece, fama in Rome), and the intersection of gender with power and justice.
For the OCR exam, students are expected to analyse ancient sources (e.g., Euripides' Medea, Virgil's Aeneid) and evaluate how they present 'improper' women. They must consider the historical context, the purpose of the source, and the audience's expectations. This topic also encourages critical thinking about how modern perspectives on gender can influence our interpretation of ancient texts, making it a rich area for discussion and debate.
Key Concepts
Core ideas you must understand for this topic
- →Patriarchy: The social system where men hold primary power, which defined women's roles as subordinate and confined to the private sphere (oikos). 'Improper' women are those who challenge this system.
- →Transgression: The act of violating social norms. In this context, women who overstep boundaries—such as Medea killing her children or Clytemnestra murdering her husband—are seen as monstrous or unnatural.
- →Hubris and Nemesis: In Greek thought, excessive pride (hubris) leads to downfall (nemesis). 'Improper' women often display hubris by asserting agency, leading to their punishment.
- →Pietas and Pudicitia: Roman concepts of duty (pietas) and female modesty (pudicitia). Women like Dido, who prioritise personal desire over duty, are portrayed as 'improper' and face tragic ends.
- →The Gaze: The idea that women in ancient literature are often depicted from a male perspective, reinforcing stereotypes. 'Improper' women are frequently objectified or demonised to serve a moral lesson.
What You Need to Demonstrate
Key skills and knowledge for this topic
- Understanding of temple layout including the naos/cella and cult statue
- Knowledge of the position and function of the altar
- Roles and responsibilities of Greek officials (hiereus, hiereia, mantis)
- Roles and responsibilities of Roman officials (Pontiffs, Pontifex Maximus, Augurs, Vestal Virgins, Haruspex)
- Understanding the purpose and process of animal sacrifice
- Ability to compare Greek and Roman temple use and religious practices
- Knowledge of specific prescribed temples: Parthenon, Temple of Zeus at Olympia, Pantheon, Temple of Fortuna Virilis
Marking Points
Key points examiners look for in your answers
- Understanding of temple layout including the naos/cella and cult statue
- Knowledge of the position and function of the altar
- Roles and responsibilities of Greek officials (hiereus, hiereia, mantis)
- Roles and responsibilities of Roman officials (Pontiffs, Pontifex Maximus, Augurs, Vestal Virgins, Haruspex)
- Understanding the purpose and process of animal sacrifice
- Ability to compare Greek and Roman temple use and religious practices
- Knowledge of specific prescribed temples: Parthenon, Temple of Zeus at Olympia, Pantheon, Temple of Fortuna Virilis
Examiner Tips
Expert advice for maximising your marks
- 💡Ensure you can identify and describe the key features of the prescribed temples
- 💡Be prepared to compare the role of priests and priestesses in both cultures
- 💡Use specific terminology (e.g., naos, cella, hiereus, haruspex) accurately
- 💡Practice linking visual evidence from temple architecture to the literary descriptions of sacrifice
- 💡Always refer to specific ancient sources (e.g., Euripides' Medea, lines 1021-1080) to support your points. Use quotations or close paraphrasing to demonstrate your knowledge of the text. This shows the examiner you have engaged directly with the material.
- 💡When analysing a character, consider the author's purpose and audience. For example, Virgil wrote the Aeneid to glorify Rome and Augustus; Dido's 'improper' behaviour (abandoning her duty) serves as a warning against emotional excess and a foil to Aeneas' pietas. Mentioning this context can elevate your answer.
- 💡Don't just describe what happens—evaluate. Use words like 'suggests', 'implies', 'portrays' to show critical thinking. For instance, 'Euripides portrays Medea as both sympathetic and monstrous, suggesting that her 'improper' actions are a response to her victimisation.' This analytical approach scores higher marks.
Common Mistakes
Pitfalls to avoid in your exam answers
- Confusing the roles of specific Greek and Roman religious officials
- Failing to link the physical layout of the temple to its religious function
- Generalising religious practices without distinguishing between Greek and Roman contexts
- Neglecting to use both literary and visual/material evidence in arguments
- Misconception: 'Improper' women were always punished because they were evil. Correction: Ancient authors often used these figures to explore complex themes like justice, revenge, and the conflict between personal desire and social duty. Medea, for example, is both a victim and a perpetrator, and her actions can be seen as a critique of patriarchal injustice.
- Misconception: All 'improper' women in ancient sources are fictional. Correction: While many are mythological, historical figures like Cleopatra or Agrippina the Younger were also labelled 'improper' by Roman writers due to their political influence and perceived sexual transgression. These portrayals were often biased by the authors' political agendas.
- Misconception: The concept of 'improper' women was the same in Greece and Rome. Correction: Greek and Roman societies had different values. For instance, Roman women had more legal rights (e.g., to own property) but were still expected to embody pudicitia. The portrayal of 'improper' women reflects these cultural nuances.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions students ask about this topic
Before You Start
Prior knowledge that will help with this topic
- •Basic understanding of Greek and Roman social structures, particularly the roles of women in Athens and Rome (e.g., the seclusion of Athenian women, the ideal of the Roman matrona).
- •Familiarity with key myths and historical figures such as Medea, Clytemnestra, Dido, and Cleopatra, as these are commonly studied examples.
- •Knowledge of literary genres (tragedy, epic) and their conventions, as 'improper' women often appear in these forms to explore moral and social issues.
Likely Command Words
How questions on this topic are typically asked
Ready to test yourself?
Practice questions tailored to this topic