Option B4: Key topic 1: Queen, government and religion, 1558–69 - 1 The situation on Elizabeth’s accession — Edexcel GCSE History
Test yourself on Option B4: Key topic 1: Queen, government and religion, 1558–69 - 1 The situation on Elizabeth’s accession with PEARSON EDEXCEL GCSE practice questions.
A week of Premium from your first lesson · Then the free plan continues · No card, no charge
Option B4: Key topic 1: Queen, government and religion, 1558–69 - 1 The situation on Elizabeth’s accession explained
In 1558, Elizabethan society was strictly hierarchical, structured around the Great Chain of Being.
Read the full explanation
In the countryside, the social ladder ranged from the nobility and gentry down to yeomen, tenant farmers, and landless labourers. Urban society was similarly stratified, dominated by wealthy merchants and professionals, followed by skilled craftsmen and unskilled workers. Government was highly centralised around the monarch, who ruled by Divine Right. Elizabeth relied on her Privy Council for daily administration and policy advice, while Parliament was called primarily to grant taxes and pass laws. At the local level, Justices of the Peace (JPs) were crucial unpaid officials who enforced the law, collected taxes, and maintained order, ensuring the Queen's authority reached across the realm.
The Virgin Queen: the problem of her legitimacy, gender, marriage. Her character and strengths.
In 1558, Elizabeth faced severe challenges regarding her legitimacy, gender, and marriage. Catholics viewed her as illegitimate, rejecting Henry VIII's marriage to Anne Boleyn. In a patriarchal society, many believed a female monarch was too weak to rule and required a husband to govern and provide an heir. Yet, marriage was risky: an English husband could spark factional rivalry, while a foreign match might subordinate England's interests. Despite these hurdles, Elizabeth possessed formidable strengths. She was highly educated, charismatic, and politically astute. She turned her unmarried status into a political tool, cultivating the 'Virgin Queen' image, and drew upon the resilience and caution forged during her perilous youth to assert her authority.
Challenges at home and from abroad: financial weaknesses, religious divisions, the French threat.
In 1558, Elizabeth inherited a realm facing severe domestic and foreign crises. Financially, the Crown was £300,000 in debt due to Mary I's costly wars, forcing Elizabeth to drastically reduce expenditure and avoid new conflicts. Religiously, England was deeply divided between Catholics and Protestants, creating a volatile atmosphere where any new religious settlement risked sparking rebellion. Abroad, the French threat was acute. France was allied with Scotland through the marriage of Mary, Queen of Scots, to the French Dauphin, effectively surrounding England. Furthermore, the recent loss of Calais had humiliated England, removing its last continental foothold and leaving Elizabeth highly vulnerable to a coordinated Franco-Scottish invasion.
Your focus
- Describe the hierarchical structure of Elizabethan society in both rural and urban areas.
- Explain the roles and relative power of the monarch, Privy Council, and Parliament in 1558.
- Assess the importance of Justices of the Peace in enforcing royal authority at a local level.
Show all 9 objectives
- Explain the reasons why Elizabeth's legitimacy was questioned upon her accession.
- Analyse the political advantages and disadvantages of Elizabeth marrying an English or foreign suitor.
- Evaluate how Elizabeth's character and education helped her overcome the prejudices against a female ruler.
- Quantify the financial weaknesses inherited by Elizabeth and explain their causes.
- Analyse the domestic risks posed by the religious divisions between Catholics and Protestants in 1558.
- Evaluate the severity of the French threat, considering both the loss of Calais and the alliance with Scotland.
Option B4: Key topic 1: Queen, government and religion, 1558–69 - 1 The situation on Elizabeth’s accession exam tips
Marking Points
- Describe the hierarchical nature of Elizabethan society, distinguishing between rural (nobility, gentry, yeomen) and urban (merchants, craftsmen) structures.
- Explain the concept of the Great Chain of Being and how it justified the rigid social order and obedience to the monarch.
- Outline the role of the Privy Council in advising the Queen and managing the daily administration of the country.
- Detail the function of Justices of the Peace (JPs) in maintaining local law and order on behalf of the central government.
- Explain why Catholics considered Elizabeth illegitimate due to the Pope's refusal to recognise Henry VIII's marriage to Anne Boleyn.
- Describe the contemporary patriarchal view that women were unfit to rule, creating pressure on Elizabeth to marry.
- Analyse the political dilemmas of marriage, including the risks of factionalism with an English suitor and foreign dominance with an overseas match.
- Identify Elizabeth's personal strengths, such as her high level of education, political caution, and ability to use patronage to control her court.
- Identify the scale of the financial weakness, noting the £300,000 Crown debt inherited from Mary I.
- Explain how religious divisions between Catholics and Protestants threatened domestic stability and complicated the creation of a new religious settlement.
- Describe the strategic threat posed by the 'Auld Alliance' between France and Scotland, which geographically surrounded England.
- Analyse the impact of the loss of Calais, both as a blow to national prestige and a strategic vulnerability against French invasion.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Memorise the specific roles of the Privy Council, Parliament, and JPs to accurately describe the structure of Elizabethan government.
- 💡Use the term 'hierarchy' when discussing society to demonstrate an understanding of the rigid class structure.
- 💡Link the role of JPs to the lack of a standing police force, highlighting their importance in maintaining local control.
- 💡When discussing her gender, explicitly mention the patriarchal nature of 16th-century society to explain why her ability to rule was questioned.
- 💡Use the term 'Virgin Queen' to explain how she eventually turned her unmarried status into a symbol of stability and devotion to England.
- 💡Link her character strengths directly to how she overcame the initial weaknesses of her position in 1558.
- 💡Memorise the figure of £300,000 to provide specific evidence of the financial weakness Elizabeth inherited.
- 💡Link the French threat directly to Mary, Queen of Scots, to show how foreign policy and dynastic challenges were interconnected.
- 💡When discussing religious divisions, explain that Elizabeth had to find a compromise to avoid civil war or foreign Catholic intervention.
Common Mistakes
- Stating that Parliament held the most power; Parliament was only called by the Queen and its main role was granting taxation, not governing.
- Assuming social mobility was common; society was highly rigid, and people were expected to remain in the social class they were born into.
- Confusing the roles of the Privy Council and Parliament; the Privy Council advised on daily policy, whereas Parliament passed legislation and approved taxes.
- Claiming Elizabeth never wanted to marry from the start; she used marriage negotiations strategically as a diplomatic tool for many years.
- Stating that Protestants doubted her legitimacy; it was primarily Catholics who viewed her as illegitimate, while Protestants supported her claim.
- Ignoring her early life experiences; failing to recognise how her imprisonment and the execution of her mother shaped her cautious political character.
- Blaming Elizabeth for the financial debt; the £300,000 debt was inherited from Mary I's reign, primarily due to her war with France.
- Assuming the French threat was only from across the Channel; the presence of French troops in Scotland posed a direct land threat to England's northern border.
- Stating that England was entirely Protestant in 1558; the country was deeply divided, with strong Catholic support, especially in the North.