Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Is secularisation occurring? — OCR A-Level Sociology

    Is secularisation occurring? explained

    This topic explores the sociological debate regarding whether secularisation is occurring in contemporary society, focusing on changes in religious belief, practice, and the power and influence of religion, alongside theoretical perspectives on the decline or resurgence of religion.

    What to demonstrate

    1. Analysis of secularisation in relation to religious belief
    2. Analysis of secularisation in relation to religious practice
    3. Analysis of secularisation in relation to the power and influence of religion in society
    Show all 6 objectives
    1. Application of pro-secularisation theories
    2. Application of anti-secularisation theories, including postmodern views
    3. Evaluation of the resurgence versus decline of religion in societies

    Is secularisation occurring? exam tips

    Topic Overview

    Secularisation refers to the declining influence of religion in society. In the context of the UK, this topic examines whether religious beliefs, practices, and institutions are losing their social significance. Sociologists debate the extent to which secularisation is occurring, with some arguing that religion is in decline (e.g., Bruce) and others claiming it is simply changing form (e.g., Davie). This topic is central to the OCR A-Level Sociology specification, as it explores the relationship between religion and social change, and requires students to evaluate competing theories and evidence.

    The debate is important because it addresses fundamental questions about modernity: as societies become more rational, scientific, and individualistic, does religion inevitably decline? Students must consider a range of evidence, including church attendance figures, the rise of new religious movements, and the role of religion in public life. The topic also connects to broader themes such as globalisation, postmodernity, and the nature of belief in contemporary society. Understanding secularisation helps students critically assess the role of religion in shaping social norms, values, and institutions.

    To fully grasp this topic, students need to engage with key sociological perspectives: the secularisation thesis (supported by Wilson and Bruce), the religious economy model (Stark and Bainbridge), and the idea of spiritual revolution (Heelas and Woodhead). They must also evaluate the impact of factors such as science, education, and consumerism on religious decline. The OCR exam often requires students to apply these theories to specific examples, such as the decline of traditional Christianity in the UK versus the growth of Pentecostalism globally.

    Key Concepts
    • →Secularisation thesis: The theory that religion is declining in significance due to modernisation, rationalisation, and differentiation (e.g., Wilson, Bruce).
    • →Differentiation: The process by which social institutions (e.g., education, healthcare) become separate from religion, reducing its influence.
    • →Disenchantment: Weber's concept that the modern world is increasingly rational and scientific, leading to a decline in magical and religious thinking.
    • →Religious economy model: Stark and Bainbridge's argument that religion persists because it offers 'compensators' for unmet needs; secularisation is a myth.
    • →Spiritual revolution: Heelas and Woodhead's claim that traditional religion is declining but being replaced by subjective spirituality (e.g., holistic therapies).
    Marking Points
    • Analysis of secularisation in relation to religious belief
    • Analysis of secularisation in relation to religious practice
    • Analysis of secularisation in relation to the power and influence of religion in society
    • Application of pro-secularisation theories
    • Application of anti-secularisation theories, including postmodern views
    • Evaluation of the resurgence versus decline of religion in societies
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Ensure you can define secularisation clearly before evaluating it
    • 💡Use contemporary examples of religious resurgence to challenge the secularisation thesis
    • 💡Distinguish between 'vicarious religion' and active participation
    • 💡Structure arguments to address all three areas: belief, practice, and power/influence
    • 💡Always define secularisation clearly in your answer, distinguishing between different dimensions (e.g., institutional, individual, societal). This shows the examiner you understand the complexity of the concept.
    • 💡Use specific evidence to support your arguments, such as Grace Davie's 'believing without belonging' or Bruce's statistics on church attendance. Avoid vague references; precise data and named sociologists earn higher marks.
    • 💡Evaluate both sides of the debate. For example, while Bruce argues secularisation is inevitable, Stark and Bainbridge counter that religion is thriving in new forms. A balanced discussion that considers global and local trends will impress examiners.
    Common Mistakes
    • Confusing 'belief without belonging' with secularisation
    • Failing to distinguish between the decline of religious institutions and the persistence of individual spirituality
    • Over-generalising secularisation as a global phenomenon without considering regional variations
    • Neglecting to apply postmodern perspectives to the debate
    • Misconception: Secularisation means religion has disappeared entirely. Correction: Secularisation refers to a decline in influence, not complete disappearance; religion may still exist in private or alternative forms.
    • Misconception: Falling church attendance proves secularisation. Correction: Attendance figures only measure one aspect; belief may persist without attendance, and new forms of spirituality may be growing.
    • Misconception: Secularisation is a universal process. Correction: The thesis is Eurocentric; in many parts of the world (e.g., the US, Global South), religion remains strong or is growing.
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Is secularisation really happening in the UK?
    Evidence is mixed. Church attendance has declined sharply (e.g., from 40% in 1900 to under 10% today), and fewer people identify as Christian. However, Grace Davie argues that many still 'believe without belonging', and new forms of spirituality (e.g., yoga, mindfulness) are growing. So while institutional religion is declining, personal belief may persist in different forms.
    What is the difference between secularisation and secularism?
    Secularisation is a social process describing the declining influence of religion in society. Secularism is an ideology or political stance that advocates for the separation of religion from state affairs. In the UK, secularisation is observed, but secularism is not official policy (unlike France's laïcité).
    How do sociologists measure secularisation?
    They use three main indicators: 1) institutional decline (e.g., church attendance, membership), 2) individual belief (e.g., surveys on belief in God), and 3) societal influence (e.g., religion's role in politics, education). Each has limitations; for example, attendance figures may not capture private belief.
    Why do some sociologists argue secularisation is a myth?
    Stark and Bainbridge argue that religion is universal and persists because it offers 'compensators' for unmet needs. They point to the growth of new religious movements and the vitality of religion in the US. Similarly, Berger initially supported secularisation but later revised his view, noting that modernisation can also stimulate religious resurgence.
    What is the 'spiritual revolution' thesis?
    Heelas and Woodhead argue that traditional religion is declining but being replaced by a 'holistic milieu' of subjective spirituality (e.g., yoga, reiki, meditation). They found that in Kendal, UK, the number of people involved in spiritual activities was growing, while church attendance fell. This suggests a shift from 'religion' to 'spirituality'.
    How does globalisation affect secularisation?
    Globalisation can both promote and hinder secularisation. On one hand, it spreads secular values (e.g., science, human rights) and exposes people to diverse beliefs, potentially weakening traditional religion. On the other hand, it can fuel religious revival as a reaction to cultural change (e.g., Islamic fundamentalism). Thus, secularisation is not a uniform global trend.