Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    To what extent are roles and relationships within families and households changing? — OCR A-Level Sociology

    To what extent are roles and relationships within families and households changing? explained

    This topic explores the changing nature of roles and relationships within families and households in the contemporary UK, focusing on power dynamics between partners and between parents and children, while applying functionalist, Marxist, and feminist theoretical perspectives.

    What to demonstrate

    1. Domestic division of labour
    2. The 'dark side' of the family
    3. Growth of the child-centred family
    Show all 6 objectives
    1. Extension of childhood
    2. Impact of the ageing population on intergenerational relationships
    3. Application of functionalist, Marxist, and feminist theoretical approaches to power and roles

    To what extent are roles and relationships within families and households changing? exam tips

    Topic Overview

    This topic explores the extent to which family roles and relationships have changed in contemporary UK society, focusing on conjugal roles (between partners), parental roles, and wider kinship ties. It is central to the sociology of the family, as it challenges traditional views of the family as a stable, functional institution. Students examine key debates such as whether roles have become more equal (symmetrical) or remain unequal, and how factors like gender, class, ethnicity, and employment patterns shape family dynamics. Understanding these changes is crucial for evaluating sociological perspectives, including functionalism, feminism, and postmodernism, and for assessing claims about the 'crisis' of the family.

    This topic matters because it directly connects to real-world issues like gender equality, work-life balance, and the impact of social policies on family life. For example, the rise of dual-earner families and the decline of the male breadwinner model have significant implications for childcare, domestic labour, and emotional relationships. Sociologists such as Young and Willmott (1973) argued that families were becoming more symmetrical, while feminist critics like Ann Oakley (1974) highlighted persistent inequalities. More recent research by Duncombe and Marsden (1995) and Giddens (1992) explores the 'pure relationship' and the emotional dimensions of family life. By studying these changes, students can critically evaluate the extent of transformation and continuity in family roles.

    This topic fits into the wider A-level sociology curriculum by linking to theories of social change, gender, and social stratification. It also connects to research methods, as students evaluate studies based on their methodology (e.g., small-scale qualitative vs. large-scale quantitative). Additionally, it prepares students for debates about family diversity, the impact of policies (e.g., parental leave), and globalisation. Mastering this topic enables students to write nuanced essays that balance evidence of change with evidence of persistence, and to apply sociological concepts to contemporary family life.

    Key Concepts
    • →Conjugal roles: The roles played by married or cohabiting partners, including domestic, financial, and emotional responsibilities. Segregated roles (separate tasks) vs. joint roles (shared tasks).
    • →Symmetrical family: A concept by Young and Willmott (1973) describing a family where roles are more equal and partners share domestic work, childcare, and decision-making. They argued this was becoming the norm.
    • →Dual burden (or double shift): The idea that women still do the majority of domestic work and childcare even when they are in paid employment, as highlighted by feminist sociologists like Ann Oakley.
    • →Emotional work: The management of emotions and relationships within the family, often performed by women. Duncombe and Marsden (1995) argued that women do a 'triple shift' of paid work, domestic work, and emotional work.
    • →Pure relationship: Giddens' (1992) concept of a relationship based on mutual satisfaction and emotional equality, rather than traditional obligations. This is linked to individualisation and changing expectations in intimate relationships.
    Marking Points
    • Domestic division of labour
    • The 'dark side' of the family
    • Growth of the child-centred family
    • Extension of childhood
    • Impact of the ageing population on intergenerational relationships
    • Application of functionalist, Marxist, and feminist theoretical approaches to power and roles
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Ensure you apply a theoretical approach (functionalist, Marxist, or feminist) to all discussions of roles and relationships.
    • 💡Use specific sociological concepts when discussing power dynamics within the home.
    • 💡Consider the impact of demographic changes, such as the ageing population, on family relationships.
    • 💡Tip 1: Always evaluate the evidence. For example, when discussing Young and Willmott's symmetrical family, mention criticisms: their sample was limited to London, and they ignored power dynamics. Use phrases like 'however, feminists argue...' to show critical analysis.
    • 💡Tip 2: Use contemporary examples and statistics. Refer to recent ONS data on time use (e.g., women still do 60% more unpaid work than men) or studies like the British Social Attitudes Survey. This shows you are up-to-date and can apply knowledge.
    • 💡Tip 3: Structure your essay around the debate between change and continuity. Start with evidence of change (e.g., more shared parenting, rise of househusbands), then counter with evidence of continuity (e.g., gender pay gap, unequal division of domestic labour). Conclude by weighing up the extent of change.
    Common Mistakes
    • Misconception: The symmetrical family is now the dominant family type in the UK. Correction: While Young and Willmott claimed this trend was emerging, later research (e.g., by Oakley, and more recent studies by the ONS) shows that women still do significantly more domestic work and childcare, even in dual-earner couples. The extent of symmetry is debated.
    • Misconception: All families have become more equal in roles and relationships. Correction: Changes are uneven. For example, middle-class families may show more equality than working-class families, and ethnic minority families may have different patterns. Also, the division of emotional work remains highly gendered.
    • Misconception: The decline of the traditional nuclear family means family roles are now completely fluid. Correction: While there is more diversity (e.g., same-sex parents, lone parents), many traditional gender norms persist. For instance, even in same-sex couples, roles may be negotiated but often reflect broader societal expectations.
    Frequently Asked Questions
    What is the symmetrical family theory?
    The symmetrical family theory, proposed by Young and Willmott in their 1973 study 'The Symmetrical Family', argues that family roles were becoming more equal. They claimed that husbands were increasingly sharing domestic tasks and childcare, and that decision-making was more joint. However, this theory has been criticised for overstating equality and ignoring the persistence of gender inequalities, as later research showed women still did the majority of housework.
    Are gender roles in families becoming more equal?
    There is evidence of some change, such as more fathers taking parental leave and greater acceptance of shared parenting. However, research consistently shows that women still perform the majority of domestic work and childcare, even when employed full-time. The concept of the 'dual burden' or 'double shift' highlights this inequality. Overall, while attitudes have become more egalitarian, actual behaviour has changed more slowly.
    What is the difference between segregated and joint conjugal roles?
    Segregated conjugal roles involve a clear division of tasks between partners, with men typically responsible for paid work and women for domestic work and childcare. Joint conjugal roles involve sharing tasks and making decisions together. Young and Willmott argued that families were moving from segregated to joint roles, but feminists argue that many families still have segregated roles, especially in terms of emotional work.
    How do feminists criticise the idea of the symmetrical family?
    Feminists like Ann Oakley criticised Young and Willmott for ignoring power imbalances and for using a limited sample. Oakley's own research found that only a minority of husbands had high participation in housework. Later feminists like Duncombe and Marsden added that women also do 'emotional work', creating a 'triple shift'. Thus, feminists argue that the symmetrical family is more of an ideology than a reality.
    What is the 'triple shift'?
    The 'triple shift' is a concept developed by Duncombe and Marsden (1995) to describe the three types of work women perform: paid work, domestic work (housework and childcare), and emotional work (managing relationships and emotions within the family). This concept highlights that even when women work outside the home, they still bear the primary responsibility for the home and family wellbeing, leading to a 'triple burden'.
    How has the role of fathers changed in UK families?
    The role of fathers has changed significantly, with more emphasis on involved fatherhood and nurturing roles. Policies like shared parental leave (introduced in 2015) encourage fathers to take time off after childbirth. However, take-up remains low, and many fathers still feel pressure to be breadwinners. Research shows that while fathers spend more time with children than in the past, mothers still do the majority of childcare, especially routine tasks.