Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Why do young people participate in deviant subcultures? — OCR A-Level Sociology

    Why do young people participate in deviant subcultures? explained

    This topic explores why young people participate in deviant subcultures, examining theoretical explanations, patterns and trends in youth deviance, and the role of the media in shaping perceptions of youth deviance.

    What to demonstrate

    1. Theoretical views of the role and formation of youth culture and subcultures (functionalism, Marxism/neo-Marxism, feminism, postmodernism)
    2. Subcultures as related to social class, gender, ethnicity, and hybridity
    3. Types of deviant subcultures: delinquent, criminal, spectacular youth subcultures, anti-school subcultures, and gangs
    Show all 6 objectives
    1. Patterns and trends in youth deviance related to social class, gender, and ethnicity
    2. Explanations for participation in deviant subcultures (functionalism/New Right, Marxism/neo-Marxism, interactionism, culture and identity)
    3. The role of the media in youth deviance: deviance amplification, folk devils, and moral panics

    Why do young people participate in deviant subcultures? exam tips

    Topic Overview

    This topic explores why young people form or join deviant subcultures—groups whose values, norms, and behaviours differ from mainstream society. In the OCR A-Level Sociology specification, it falls under the 'Youth Subcultures' option within the Crime and Deviance module. Understanding this helps explain patterns of delinquency, resistance, and identity formation among adolescents, linking to broader theories of social control, labelling, and inequality.

    Key sociological perspectives include functionalist explanations (e.g., Albert Cohen's status frustration), subcultural theories (e.g., Cloward and Ohlin's opportunity structures), and neo-Marxist approaches (e.g., the Birmingham Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies' work on resistance through style). Students must also consider postmodern views, such as the idea that subcultures are fragmented and fluid, reflecting individual identity projects rather than collective class-based responses.

    This topic matters because it challenges simplistic 'deficit' models of youth deviance, showing how subcultures can be creative responses to structural inequalities. It also connects to contemporary issues like knife crime, gang culture, and online subcultures, making it highly relevant for exam questions that ask students to apply theories to real-world examples.

    Key Concepts
    • →Status frustration: Cohen's concept that working-class boys, failing in middle-class schools, invert mainstream values to gain status within a delinquent subculture.
    • →Opportunity structures: Cloward and Ohlin's idea that access to illegitimate means (e.g., criminal, conflict, or retreatist subcultures) varies by neighbourhood.
    • →Resistance through rituals: The CCCS view that subcultural style (e.g., mods, punks) is a symbolic challenge to hegemony, though ultimately incorporated by the market.
    • →Moral panic: Cohen's concept of societal overreaction to youth subcultures (e.g., mods and rockers), amplifying deviance and creating folk devils.
    • →Postmodern subcultures: Maffesoli's 'neo-tribes' and Bennett's 'lifestyles'—fluid, identity-based groupings rather than fixed class-based subcultures.
    Marking Points
    • Theoretical views of the role and formation of youth culture and subcultures (functionalism, Marxism/neo-Marxism, feminism, postmodernism)
    • Subcultures as related to social class, gender, ethnicity, and hybridity
    • Types of deviant subcultures: delinquent, criminal, spectacular youth subcultures, anti-school subcultures, and gangs
    • Patterns and trends in youth deviance related to social class, gender, and ethnicity
    • Explanations for participation in deviant subcultures (functionalism/New Right, Marxism/neo-Marxism, interactionism, culture and identity)
    • The role of the media in youth deviance: deviance amplification, folk devils, and moral panics
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Ensure you can apply specific theoretical perspectives (functionalism, Marxism/neo-Marxism, feminism, postmodernism, interactionism) to the formation of subcultures and participation in deviance.
    • 💡Be prepared to discuss how social factors like class, gender, and ethnicity influence patterns of youth deviance.
    • 💡Understand the media's role in constructing youth deviance through concepts like moral panics and deviance amplification.
    • 💡Always define 'deviant subculture' in your answer and distinguish it from mainstream culture. Use sociological concepts like 'status frustration' or 'resistance' to show depth.
    • 💡Evaluate theories by considering their strengths and limitations. For example, Cohen's theory explains male delinquency but neglects gender and ethnicity. Use contemporary examples (e.g., drill music, incels) to show application.
    • 💡Link to the item or source in the exam paper. If the question mentions 'material deprivation', connect it to Cloward and Ohlin's opportunity structures or Miller's focal concerns.
    Common Mistakes
    • Misconception: All deviant subcultures are criminal. Correction: Many subcultures (e.g., goths, skaters) are non-criminal but may be labelled deviant due to style or values. Deviance is socially constructed.
    • Misconception: Subcultures are solely a working-class phenomenon. Correction: Middle-class subcultures exist (e.g., hippies, straight edge), often focused on political or lifestyle dissent rather than material deprivation.
    • Misconception: Subcultures are a recent phenomenon. Correction: Sociologists have studied youth subcultures since the 1950s (e.g., teddy boys), and they have evolved with social changes.
    Frequently Asked Questions
    What is the difference between a subculture and a counterculture?
    A subculture is a group with distinct norms and values that exist within a larger culture, often without directly opposing it (e.g., goths). A counterculture actively rejects and opposes mainstream values (e.g., hippies in the 1960s). In sociology, deviant subcultures can be either, but the term 'subculture' is more commonly used for youth groups.
    Why do working-class boys join delinquent subcultures according to Cohen?
    Albert Cohen argued that working-class boys face status frustration when they fail to achieve middle-class goals in school. Unable to gain status legitimately, they invert mainstream values and form a delinquent subculture that rewards non-utilitarian, malicious, and negativistic behaviour—like vandalism or fighting—as a way to achieve status among peers.
    How does Cloward and Ohlin's theory explain different types of deviant subcultures?
    Cloward and Ohlin extended Merton's strain theory by introducing the concept of illegitimate opportunity structures. They identified three subcultural types: criminal (in stable neighbourhoods with organised crime), conflict (in disorganised areas where violence provides status), and retreatist (for those who fail in both legitimate and illegitimate means, leading to drug use).
    What is the Birmingham School's view on youth subcultures?
    The Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies (CCCS) viewed youth subcultures as symbolic resistance to class oppression. They argued that subcultural style (e.g., mods' scooters, punks' safety pins) was a 'ritual' challenging hegemony, but that capitalism eventually incorporates these styles into mainstream fashion, neutralising their oppositional potential.
    Are youth subcultures still relevant today?
    Yes, but postmodern sociologists argue they are more fragmented and fluid. Instead of class-based subcultures, we now see 'neo-tribes' or 'lifestyles' (e.g., gamers, K-pop fans) based on individual identity and consumption. However, traditional subcultures like gang culture persist, and new forms like incel communities or drill music scenes show ongoing deviance.
    How can I evaluate subcultural theories in an exam?
    Evaluate by considering: (1) Gender bias—most theories focus on males; (2) Ethnicity—e.g., black Caribbean subcultures may respond to racism; (3) Postmodern critiques—subcultures are less class-based today; (4) Use contemporary examples like roadmen or online subcultures; (5) Compare theories—e.g., functionalist vs. Marxist views on whether subcultures are adaptive or resistant.