The study of Luis de Castresana's 1967 novel, 'El otro árbol de Guernica', as a prescribed literary work for the A2 Unit 5 Critical and analytical response
Topic Synopsis
The study of Luis de Castresana's 1967 novel, 'El otro árbol de Guernica', as a prescribed literary work for the A2 Unit 5 Critical and analytical response in writing examination.
Key Concepts & Core Principles
- Narrative structure: The novel uses a non-linear timeline, alternating between the present (the requiem mass) and flashbacks to Paco's life. This structure emphasises memory and guilt, as Mosén Millán's recollections reveal his betrayal.
- Symbolism: Key symbols include the requiem mass (representing hypocrisy and failed redemption), the horse (Paco's freedom and later his death), and the bell (community and warning). The 'campesino' (peasant) symbolises the innocent victims of the war.
- Characterisation: Paco is an idealistic, Christ-like figure who fights for social justice, while Mosén Millán is a conflicted priest whose cowardice leads to Paco's death. The contrast highlights themes of betrayal and moral failure.
- Social and political context: The novel critiques the alliance between the Church, the landowners (caciques), and the Nationalists. Sender, a Republican, exposes how institutions failed the poor during the war.
- Themes: Innocence vs. guilt, memory and trauma, social injustice, betrayal, and the loss of rural life. The novel also explores the idea of 'requiem' as both a prayer for the dead and an indictment of the living.
Exam Tips & Revision Strategies
- The exam is closed-book; ensure thorough knowledge of the text
- Choose one of the two questions provided in the exam
- Aim for approximately 400 words in the response
- Focus on analytical depth rather than just plot summary
Common Misconceptions & Mistakes to Avoid
- Using pre-learnt material that does not directly answer the specific question
- Failing to provide a critical and analytical response
- Neglecting to link the analysis to the cultural and social context of the work
Examiner Marking Points
- Detailed understanding of the novel
- Ability to appreciate and analyse the work
- Critical appreciation of concepts and issues covered
- Critical and analytical response in writing in Spanish
- Critical and analytical response to features such as form and technique of presentation
- Understanding the work within its cultural and social context