Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Greek Religion (H408/31) - Religion and philosophy — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation

    Greek Religion (H408/31) - Religion and philosophy explained

    Greek Religion (H408/31) - Religion and philosophy covers 5 specification points, including The rise of philosophical thinking and how… and The critique of the ‘gods of Homer’ and their….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    The rise of philosophical thinking and how this was viewed within Greek society, including the extent to which these ideas were truly ‘new’

    Study how thinkers such as Thales, Anaximander and Xenophanes in the sixth century BC sought explanations of the world and the divine through reasoned argument rather than inherited myth, and how later figures such as Anaxagoras and Socrates worked in Athens. Then judge reception: curiosity and influence sat beside suspicion, satire and impiety charges. Finally test novelty by setting the philosophers beside Homer, Hesiod and cult practice: did they invent a new method, or reshape ideas about origins, order and divinity already present? A strong answer weighs both views.

    The critique of the ‘gods of Homer’ and their anthropomorphism, as voiced by Xenophanes

    Xenophanes of Colophon, active in the sixth to fifth century BC, attacked the gods presented by Homer and Hesiod. His critique has two linked strands. First, moral: poets gave the gods behaviour that humans would call shameful, such as theft, adultery and deceit. Second, anthropomorphism: mortals picture gods with their own bodies, voices, clothing and birth, and different peoples make them resemble themselves; he suggests horses or oxen would draw horse-like or ox-like gods. He contrasts this with one greatest god, unlike mortals in body or thought. Learn to present these as his voice, not a general Greek view.

    Socrates and accusations of ‘impiety’, including:

    This statement asks you to understand the charge of asebeia, usually translated as impiety, brought against Socrates in Athens in 399 BCE. The word 'including:' signals a list of specific examples, but that list is not supplied here, so do not invent items for it. Check your specification for the exact examples. Begin by explaining what impiety meant in Athenian law: a failure to honour the gods recognised by the city, or conduct seen as threatening civic religion. Then apply this to Socrates. Plato's Apology presents two central accusations: that Socrates did not believe in the gods the city worshipped and introduced new divine beings, and that he corrupted the young. A useful method is to state the charge, identify the accuser and the evidence offered, then judge how far the charge reflected religious belief rather than political tension in Athens.

    Socrates’ ideas on the divine, justice and why he may have disagreed with the Homeric/Hesiodic idea of the gods

    This extended response asks you to set out Socrates' ideas on three linked areas: the divine, justice, and his reasons for disagreeing with the Homeric and Hesiodic picture of the gods. Start with the divine. In Plato's Apology, Socrates refers to a divine sign, the daimonion, and describes a mission he believes the god has given him to examine others. Next, cover justice. In Plato's Republic, Socrates argues that justice is a condition of the soul's proper order, which benefits the person who possesses it. Then address the critique. Homer and Hesiod portray gods who quarrel, deceive and act immorally. Socrates, in Euthyphro and Republic Book 2, questions whether such stories can be true of a good divinity. Because Plato presents Socrates' views, explain why he 'may have' disagreed as an interpretation supported by textual evidence, and weigh alternative readings.

    the extent to which his ideas were radical or controversial

    This statement asks you to judge how far a thinker's ideas were radical or controversial. Radical means departing from the roots of accepted belief; controversial means provoking dispute. These overlap but are not identical, so define each before applying it. 'The extent to which' asks you to weigh evidence on both sides and reach a reasoned judgement, not simply describe the ideas. Identify the specific ideas named in the question first. Then test them against the religious and civic beliefs of the period, asking whether they rejected or only reinterpreted tradition. Finally, consider reception by contemporaries and ancient critics. Conclude with a qualified verdict on which elements were most challenging.

    Your focus

    1. Explain how early Greek philosophers approached questions about the world and the gods, using named examples.
    2. Evaluate evidence for how Greek society viewed philosophical thinking, distinguishing reliable evidence from later tradition.
    3. Argue a supported judgement on how far philosophical ideas were truly new by comparing them with earlier Greek religious and poetic thought.
    Show all 15 objectives
    1. Define anthropomorphism and identify it in Xenophanes' critique of Homeric gods.
    2. Explain the moral and cultural arguments that Xenophanes uses against traditional portrayals of the gods.
    3. Distinguish Xenophanes' own voice and positive theology from the poetic tradition he criticises.
    4. Define asebeia and explain its relation to Athenian civic religion.
    5. Identify and explain the main accusations brought against Socrates in 399 BCE.
    6. Evaluate how far the charge of impiety reflected religious belief rather than political concerns.
    7. Explain Socrates' ideas on the divine, with reference to the daimonion.
    8. Explain Socrates' account of justice and its relation to the soul.
    9. Evaluate reasons why Socrates may have disagreed with Homeric and Hesiodic depictions of the gods.
    10. Define radical and controversial and explain the difference between them.
    11. Evaluate the extent to which named ideas departed from religious and civic belief, using evidence.
    12. Write a qualified judgement that weighs evidence on both sides of the question.

    Greek Religion (H408/31) - Religion and philosophy exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Explains the rise of philosophical thinking as an attempt to account for the cosmos, change and the divine through observation and argument, using named thinkers and the evidence studied.
    • Describes how philosophical ideas were received in Greek society, showing a range of responses such as interest, influence, suspicion, ridicule or prosecution for impiety.
    • Supports claims about reception with specific evidence, and distinguishes what the sources show from later tradition that may be exaggerated.
    • Compares philosophical ideas with Homeric and Hesiodic accounts and with traditional cult to judge how far the ideas were truly new.
    • Weighs elements of novelty, such as naturalistic explanation, open criticism of tradition and reasoned debate, against continuities, such as the continued use of divine language and inherited ideas about origins.
    • Reaches a supported judgement on the extent of newness that answers the wording of the question rather than describing philosophers in turn.
    • Identifies Xenophanes as a poet-thinker from Colophon who criticised the traditional gods as presented by Homer and Hesiod.
    • Explains anthropomorphism as the portrayal of gods with human form, birth, voice, clothing and character.
    • States that Xenophanes objected to poets attributing to gods acts that humans regard as disgraceful, such as theft, adultery and deceit.
    • Explains his argument from cultural relativity: peoples depict gods as resembling themselves, and animals would do the same if they could draw.
    • Connects the critique to his positive view of one supreme god who is unlike mortals in body and thought.
    • Recognises that the criticism is voiced by Xenophanes himself, and distinguishes it from the views of ordinary worshippers.
    • Defines asebeia as a legal charge concerned with failing to honour the gods, rather than a general insult.
    • Identifies the main accusations in Plato's Apology: not believing in the city's gods, introducing new divine beings and corrupting the young.
    • Links the charge to civic religion in Athens in 399 BCE, showing how religious observance and citizenship were intertwined.
    • Names Meletus as the principal accuser and explains the content of his charge.
    • Evaluates the charge by weighing Socrates' account of his divine sign, the daimonion, against the prosecution's claims.
    • Explains Socrates' view of the divine as good and rational, supported by a named passage such as his account of the daimonion in Plato's Apology.
    • Explains justice in the Republic as harmony within the soul, linking it to the claim that the just person is benefited.
    • Identifies the quarrelling, deceitful and immoral actions of the Homeric and Hesiodic gods as the basis of Socrates' objection, citing Euthyphro or Republic Book 2.
    • Weighs interpretations of why Socrates may have disagreed with Homer and Hesiod, using evidence from Plato's presentation and acknowledging the limits of that evidence.
    • Connects the three clauses, showing how a good divinity shapes the account of justice and the critique of traditional stories.
    • Defines radical and controversial separately before applying either term to the ideas.
    • Identifies the specific ideas the question names and sets out what each one claimed.
    • Places the ideas against the religious and civic beliefs of the period to show what they departed from.
    • Weighs evidence of radicalism, such as rejection of traditional practice, against evidence of continuity.
    • Considers how contemporaries or ancient critics received the ideas as evidence of controversy.
    • Reaches a judgement on the extent of radicalism or controversy, qualified by the evidence used.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Plan a two-sided argument before writing: list evidence for newness and evidence for continuity, then decide which carries more weight.
    • 💡Choose a small number of well-known thinkers and sources you can explain precisely, rather than naming many in passing.
    • 💡Return to the phrase about how far the ideas were truly new in your conclusion, and give a clear judgement that uses your earlier evidence.
    • 💡In a multiple-choice question, read every option against both strands of the critique, moral and anthropomorphic, before choosing.
    • 💡Eliminate options that make Xenophanes an atheist, or that give his views to Homer or to the gods themselves.
    • 💡Link each idea to its source: name Xenophanes as the voice of the critique and Homer and Hesiod as its targets.
    • 💡Plan your answer in four steps: define asebeia, state the accusations, explain the Athenian context, then reach a judgement.
    • 💡For multiple-choice questions, eliminate options that give a modern meaning of impiety rather than the Athenian legal sense.
    • 💡Keep dates and names accurate, such as 399 BCE and Meletus, and connect each detail to the question's focus.
    • 💡Plan three sections for the divine, justice and the critique, then write a short concluding paragraph that links them.
    • 💡Name specific passages accurately and paraphrase them unless you can reproduce the exact wording from your set text.
    • 💡Use hedged language for 'may have' and support each interpretation with textual evidence before judging it.
    • 💡Open with a brief definition of radical and controversial, then keep both terms in view throughout.
    • 💡Plan arguments for and against before writing, and decide which side carries more weight.
    • 💡Finish with a conclusion that states the extent, rather than a summary of the ideas.
    Common Mistakes
    • Presents philosophy as a sudden break with religion; show that many thinkers kept a divine element and that traditional cult carried on alongside new ideas.
    • Treats Greek society as uniformly hostile to philosophers; distinguish different groups, places and periods and use evidence to show a mixed reception.
    • Lists philosophers and their theories without evaluation; link each point to how it was received or to how new it was.
    • Asserts that ideas were either wholly new or wholly old; argue for a degree of newness and support it by comparison with earlier poetry and tradition.
    • Relies on vague references to anecdotes about trials or deaths; identify the source, say what it actually reports and note any doubt about its reliability.
    • Describes Xenophanes as an atheist; state that he rejects human-like gods but proposes a greatest god.
    • Attributes the horse and ox argument to Homer or to the gods; give it to Xenophanes as a satirical point about human projection.
    • Confuses anthropomorphism with immorality; separate the claim that gods look and think like humans from the claim that poets show them behaving badly.
    • Treats his critique as the view of all Greeks; present it as one thinker's challenge to widely shared poetic tradition.
    • Claims Xenophanes abolished cult practice; say that the evidence concerns his criticism of ideas about the gods, not an end to worship.
    • Treats impiety as simply atheism; correct by explaining that the charge concerned belief and honour directed to the city's gods and religious practice.
    • Presents the trial as purely religious; correct by linking it to political suspicion of Socrates' associations with figures seen as hostile to the democracy.
    • Assumes the examples after 'including:' are known; correct by checking the official specification rather than supplying unverified examples.
    • Treats Plato's Apology as an exact transcript of the trial; correct by recognising it as a literary and philosophical account shaped by Plato.
    • Treats Socrates' arguments as identical to Plato's own position; correct by distinguishing the character's arguments from Plato's views where scholars debate them.
    • Presents Socrates as a straightforward atheist; correct by showing his commitment to a divine order and the daimonion.
    • Describes justice only as obeying the law; correct by explaining the Republic's account of justice as the soul's internal harmony.
    • Asserts that Homer and Hesiod had no influence on Athenian religion; correct by noting that their stories were widely known and central to education and worship.
    • Treats radical and controversial as synonyms and so assesses only one quality; separate the two and test each.
    • Describes the ideas without evaluating how far they were radical; add a judgement on degree throughout the answer.
    • Assumes controversy from later fame alone; cite contemporary or ancient reaction as evidence instead.