Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Love and Relationships (H408/32) - Plato on love and desire — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation

    Love and Relationships (H408/32) - Plato on love and desire explained

    Love and Relationships (H408/32) - Plato on love and desire covers 10 specification points, including Plato’s ideas about love and desire, including: and the definitions of love.

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    Plato’s ideas about love and desire, including:

    This statement introduces Plato's ideas about love and desire within Love and Relationships. It ends with 'including:', but the list of sub-points is not supplied here, so do not assume any idea beyond what the full specification lists. Find that list first, then read the set Plato material against it. For each listed idea, note where the text presents it, which speaker voices it and how it links to love and desire. Keep a reading log with one column per idea. Check course materials for the exact text list and passage guidance.

    the definitions of love

    This statement asks you to know how Plato defines love, so that you can state a definition accurately and recognise it in an unfamiliar question. In the Symposium, Socrates narrates the teaching of Diotima, who presents Eros as a desire for something one lacks: the beautiful and the good, to be one's own for ever. Learn the parts of this definition: the lack, the desire, the object (beauty and goodness) and the aim of possession. Phaedrus offers a different framing, in which love is a form of divine madness that enters the lover through beauty. Practise by writing a one-sentence definition for each account, then checking that every element of it appears in your source. In multiple-choice items, distractors often describe what love produces or how it feels, so choose the option that names the nature of love itself.

    the physical symptoms of desire

    This statement asks you to know the bodily reactions that Plato associates with desire, so that you can identify them and explain what they show about the lover. In the Phaedrus, Socrates, in his second speech, describes a lover who is overcome by the sight of beauty. The lover's soul shivers, sweats and burns with heat, and a painful itching accompanies the growth of the soul's wings. Learn these symptoms as a set, and note that Socrates presents them as signs of the soul's response to beauty rather than as medical conditions. Practise by listing each symptom, then writing one sentence that links it to the lover's desire. In multiple-choice items, watch for distractors that attribute these reactions to the beloved, or that describe symptoms from a different account, such as medical explanations of bodily states.

    the differences between love and desire

    This statement asks you to distinguish love from desire, a contrast Plato develops across dialogues. In the Symposium, Diotima presents eros as a longing for what one lacks, aimed at beauty and ultimately at the good, so love has a higher object and purpose. Desire, understood as bodily appetite, is a more general pull towards immediate satisfaction, and Plato's Republic places it in the lowest part of the soul. To answer well, identify which feature is at stake: the object (a particular body or beauty itself), the aim (possession or wisdom), or the part of the soul involved. Multiple-choice items often test this through short scenarios, so practise matching each description to one concept.

    how and why desire should be controlled

    This statement asks how and why Plato thinks desire should be controlled, so address both parts. The how concerns the means: in the Republic, reason should govern the soul while spirit supports it and appetite is ruled. In the Phaedrus, the charioteer must restrain the unruly horse of appetite. In the Symposium, Diotima describes an ascent that redirects eros from one body towards beauty itself. The why concerns the outcome: unrestrained appetite produces disorder in the individual and the city, whereas reason in control brings harmony and justice. Plato aims at redirection towards the good rather than mere suppression, so explain both the means and the goal.

    how and why desire can be resisted

    This statement asks you to explain how desire can be resisted and why Plato thinks it should be. The how is the method: reason restrains desire, as in the Phaedrus, where Socrates likens the soul to a charioteer controlling a noble horse and an unruly horse. The why is the justification: an unrestrained soul is disordered and cannot grasp truth. In the Republic, the tripartite soul places reason over appetite for the same reason. In the Symposium, Socrates reports Diotima's account of erōs as desire for the good to be possessed forever, so redirecting desire upward, from a beautiful body towards beautiful laws, knowledge and the Form of beauty, becomes a means of resistance. Use one named passage for each point, and explain what that passage shows about the soul or erōs.

    homoerotic relationships

    This statement asks you to understand homoerotic relationships, meaning erotic attachment between males, as Plato presents them in the Symposium and Phaedrus. Plato treats male-male erōs as a recognised part of Athenian life, but he does not describe it uncritically. In the Symposium, Pausanias distinguishes a heavenly Aphrodite, which values the beloved's character, from a common Aphrodite, which values the body. Aristophanes tells a myth of split halves seeking reunion, which covers male, female and mixed pairs. In the Phaedrus, Socrates analyses the lover's desire for a young male beloved and how that desire can be channelled into the beloved's moral improvement. For each passage, identify the speaker and check whether the speaker endorses or criticises the attachment. Keep your knowledge to the texts and the social context they describe.

    ideas regarding the nature of ‘good’ and ‘bad’ conduct which emerge

    This statement asks you to identify the moral ideas about good and bad conduct that emerge from Plato's treatment of love and desire. Emerge means the judgements must come from the arguments, imagery and speakers of the set texts. Start by isolating conduct the dialogue presents as admirable, such as desire turned towards beauty, and conduct it presents as harmful, such as surrendering to appetite. Then explain the nature of each judgement: is goodness located in the soul, in self-control or in the object loved? Show how an idea develops through reasoning, such as an argument about desire leading to a view of the good life. Name the speaker whose view you report.

    how Plato’s contemporary context influenced his ideas

    This statement asks you to explain how the world Plato lived in shaped his ideas about love and desire. Contemporary means his own lifetime, roughly the late fifth and early fourth centuries BCE, including the Peloponnesian War and the execution of Socrates in 399 BCE. Choose a specific feature, such as Athenian customs of relationships between older and younger men, or the symposium as a setting for debate, and link it to a specific idea in the texts. Show whether Plato agrees with, adapts or critiques that context, and state which one you argue. Do not claim context alone explains an idea; weigh it against Plato's own philosophical aims.

    how these ideas might have been received by his contemporary audience

    This asks you to judge reception: how Plato's ideas on love and desire might have been understood by the audience who first met them in fourth-century BCE Athens. First identify the ideas themselves, such as love drawing the lover upward towards beauty and wisdom. Then reconstruct the contemporary audience: elite male Athenians, Plato's own circle and readers familiar with erotic conventions of the symposium. Ask which ideas would have matched expectations, which would have challenged them and which would have seemed unfamiliar. 'Might' invites hedged judgement, so tie each claim to evidence from the text or known social context and acknowledge uncertainty.

    Your focus

    1. Locate the full list of Plato's ideas about love and desire in the OCR specification.
    2. Create a reading log that records passage, speaker and idea for each listed item.
    3. Select passages from the set Plato material that directly illustrate each listed idea.
    Show all 30 objectives
    1. State Diotima's definition of Eros in the Symposium in your own words, naming the lack, desire and object.
    2. Identify the option in a multiple-choice question that defines love rather than describing its effects.
    3. Distinguish the Symposium definition of love from the Phaedrus account of divine madness in a written list.
    4. List the physical symptoms of desire described in the Phaedrus, including the painful itching linked to wing growth.
    5. Identify the correct symptom in a multiple-choice question by checking it against the lover's experience.
    6. Explain in writing how the Phaedrus links bodily reactions to the soul's response to beauty.
    7. Distinguish eros from bodily appetite using object, aim and part of the soul.
    8. Select the correct concept that matches a short scenario drawn from Plato's account of love and desire.
    9. Explain why Plato treats love as directed towards beauty and the good rather than only bodily satisfaction.
    10. Explain how reason governs desire using Plato's account of the tripartite soul.
    11. Explain why Plato treats unrestrained desire as harmful to the individual and the city.
    12. Evaluate whether Plato's account describes suppression or redirection of desire, supported by reference to his dialogues.
    13. Explain, with reference to the Phaedrus, how the charioteer image represents reason restraining desire.
    14. Compare suppression of desire with redirection of desire as Plato presents them in the Symposium.
    15. Justify, using the Republic, why an ordered soul is preferable to an appetitive one.
    16. Identify the speaker and context of Pausanias's distinction between heavenly and common Aphrodite.
    17. Explain how Aristophanes' myth places male-male erōs alongside male-female and mixed pairs.
    18. Explain how the Phaedrus links the lover's desire for a young male to the beloved's moral improvement.
    19. Identify conduct presented as good or bad in Plato's treatment of love and desire.
    20. Explain the criteria behind a moral judgement in a set text.
    21. Evaluate how an ethical idea emerges through a speaker's argument.
    22. Identify features of Plato's Athenian context relevant to love and desire.
    23. Explain how a contextual feature shapes a specific idea in a set text.
    24. Evaluate the extent to which context accounts for Plato's ideas.
    25. Identify at least two ideas on love and desire from the prescribed Plato material.
    26. Describe the social and cultural expectations of a contemporary Athenian audience.
    27. Evaluate how likely different groups were to accept or reject Plato's ideas, supporting each judgement with evidence.

    Love and Relationships (H408/32) - Plato on love and desire exam tips

    Marking Points
    • States that Diotima's account in the Symposium defines Eros as desire for what one lacks.
    • Identifies the object of love as the beautiful and the good, and the aim as possessing them for ever.
    • Distinguishes the Phaedrus account of love as divine madness from the Symposium definition.
    • Explains that a correct definition concerns the nature of love rather than its outcomes or feelings.
    • Recognises that Socrates is the narrator when Diotima's teaching is reported in the Symposium.
    • Identifies Socrates's second speech in the Phaedrus as the source of the lover's bodily symptoms.
    • Lists shivering, sweating, heat and a fever-like burning as symptoms of the lover's desire.
    • Explains that the painful itching accompanies the growth of the soul's wings in the lover.
    • Links each physical symptom to the lover's response to beauty rather than to the beloved's condition.
    • Distinguishes the Phaedrus account of symptoms from medical explanations of bodily states.
    • Distinguishes love, directed at beauty and the good, from desire understood as bodily appetite.
    • Identifies lack as the starting point of eros when a scenario describes longing for something absent.
    • Recognises that the object of love may be beauty itself rather than a single body.
    • Links appetite for immediate bodily satisfaction to the lowest part of the soul in the Republic.
    • Selects the option whose aim (possession, wisdom or the good) matches the scenario described in the stem.
    • Explains the means of control, such as reason governing the appetitive part of the soul.
    • Uses the Phaedrus image of the charioteer restraining the unruly horse to explain restraint of appetite.
    • Describes the redirection of eros through the Symposium ascent rather than simple suppression.
    • Explains why unrestrained desire causes disorder in the individual and the city.
    • Connects the outcome of control to harmony and justice in the soul.
    • Addresses both the how and the why rather than only one part of the statement.
    • Identifies a specific mechanism of resistance, such as reason restraining appetite, rather than a general claim that desire is bad.
    • Explains why resistance matters by linking it to the order and health of the soul.
    • Uses the Phaedrus charioteer image accurately, identifying the charioteer as reason and the two horses as the spirited and appetitive elements.
    • Explains Diotima's redirection of erōs from bodies to laws, knowledge and beauty itself, and attributes the account to Socrates reporting Diotima.
    • Distinguishes between suppressing desire and redirecting it upwards, and explains which of these Plato favours.
    • Connects the Republic's tripartite soul to the justification for ruling desire with reason.
    • Identifies homoerotic relationships as erotic attachment between males in the Symposium and Phaedrus.
    • Distinguishes Pausanias's heavenly and common Aphrodite and links the heavenly form to attachment based on character.
    • Explains that Aristophanes' myth of split halves covers male, female and mixed pairs, so male-male erōs is one case among several.
    • Places the lover and young male beloved within the Athenian social framework of age and status.
    • Attributes each argument to the correct speaker, such as Pausanias, Aristophanes or Socrates, before judging its status.
    • Notes that the Phaedrus links the lover's desire to the beloved's moral improvement.
    • Identifies a specific form of conduct from the set texts that is presented as good or bad, and states what makes it so.
    • Explains the basis of each judgement, such as whether goodness lies in the soul, in self-control or in the object of desire.
    • Traces how an evaluative idea develops across a stage of argument, naming the speaker who advances it.
    • Distinguishes ideas the dialogue endorses from those a speaker advances only to be refuted or qualified.
    • Connects the moral ideas to Plato's wider account of the soul or the good life.
    • Identifies a specific feature of Plato's Athens, dated within his lifetime, and states why it is relevant to love and desire.
    • Links that contextual feature to a particular idea about love or desire found in the set texts.
    • Explains whether Plato agrees with, adapts or critiques the contextual influence, supported by textual reasoning.
    • Weighs contextual influence against Plato's philosophical aims rather than treating context as a sufficient explanation.
    • Keeps examples within the period boundary of Plato's own lifetime, or labels later reception clearly as a separate point.
    • Identifies specific ideas on love and desire from the prescribed Plato material before judging how they were received.
    • Reconstructs the contemporary audience, including its social position, gender and familiarity with Athenian erotic conventions.
    • Sets out which ideas would have matched audience expectations and supports this with evidence.
    • Identifies ideas that would have challenged or seemed unfamiliar to contemporaries and explains why.
    • Uses hedged language such as 'might' or 'probably' and acknowledges the limits of the surviving evidence.
    • Links reception judgements to the dialogue form and to the setting in which the ideas are presented.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Write the full list of items that follow 'including' into your notes before reading anything else.
    • 💡Create a reading log with one row per idea and record the passage reference and speaker for each entry.
    • 💡Revisit your log before each practice essay and check that every idea has at least one supported passage.
    • 💡Before reading the options, write a short definition of love in your own words, naming the lack, the desire and the object.
    • 💡Eliminate any option that describes the effects of love, such as offspring or emotional states, unless it also defines what love is.
    • 💡Check which source each option belongs to, and keep the Symposium and Phaedrus accounts separate when they conflict.
    • 💡Before reading the options, list the symptoms you recall, then check each option against that list rather than against memory of the wording alone.
    • 💡Reject any option that gives the symptoms to the beloved or describes them as an illness, since the question concerns the lover's desire.
    • 💡Where two options both name real symptoms, choose the one that matches the source exactly, including the link to wing growth.
    • 💡Read the stem first and decide whether it asks about object, aim or the part of the soul before reading the options.
    • 💡Eliminate options that describe bodily appetite when the stem refers to longing for beauty or wisdom.
    • 💡Check whether an option uses love and desire as synonyms, since the question tests the distinction between them.
    • 💡Plan two developed sections, one for the means of control and one for its purpose, before writing.
    • 💡Anchor each point to a named dialogue and the feature of the soul or the ascent it illustrates.
    • 💡Conclude by weighing whether Plato's control is suppression or redirection, using evidence you have already given.
    • 💡Plan two linked paragraphs, one on method and one on justification, and connect them in your final sentence.
    • 💡Support each claim with a named passage and state what that passage shows about the soul or erōs.
    • 💡Keep your answer within Plato's framework, using terms such as reason, appetite, the spirited element, erōs and the good.
    • 💡Identify the speaker of each passage before using it as evidence of Plato's own view.
    • 💡Use a single sentence to compare how the Symposium and the Phaedrus treat the attachment.
    • 💡Use the terms erōs, lover and beloved accurately and consistently.
    • 💡Plan three or four contrasting examples of good and bad conduct before writing, and tie each one to a passage you can recall.
    • 💡Spend substantial time on the reasoning that produces a judgement, because the statement asks how the ideas emerge.
    • 💡Finish with a sentence on what the ideas reveal about Plato's ethics, linking back to the wording of the question.
    • 💡Memorise three dated contextual features, each with a clear link to a text, such as the Peloponnesian War or the execution of Socrates.
    • 💡Structure your judgement on influence around the three options of agreeing with, adapting or critiquing the context.
    • 💡Keep a brief final evaluation of how far context explains the ideas, rather than assuming that it does.
    • 💡Plan two columns, one for ideas that fit contemporary expectations and one for ideas that would have jarred, then develop each with evidence.
    • 💡Open with a brief statement of the audience you are reconstructing so the reader can follow your frame.
    • 💡Reserve a final paragraph to weigh which reception seems most likely and to state the limits of the evidence.
    Common Mistakes
    • Treats the colon after 'including' as the end of the content when the listed items are missing here; correct this by consulting the full specification for the list.
    • Selects passages because they are long or familiar rather than because they illustrate a listed idea; correct this by choosing passages according to how directly they show each idea.
    • Memorises one speech and applies it to every idea, ignoring the different speakers' perspectives; correct this by recording which speaker voices each idea.
    • Treats love as identical to sexual pleasure; correct this by stating that Diotima defines love as desire for the beautiful and the good.
    • Locates love in the beloved's qualities; correct this by placing love in the lover's desire for what they lack.
    • Presents Diotima's account as Socrates's own unqualified view; correct this by naming Socrates as the narrator reporting Diotima's teaching.
    • Describes Eros simply as a god; correct this by noting that Diotima presents Eros as a great spirit, intermediate between mortal and divine.
    • Attributes the symptoms to the beloved rather than to the lover; correct this by assigning the reactions to the lover who sees beauty.
    • Presents the symptoms as a medical diagnosis; correct this by explaining that Socrates describes them as the soul's response to beauty.
    • Names Socrates as the lover describing his own experience without noting he presents the lover's case; correct this by stating that Socrates is speaking about a lover in his speech.
    • Omits the wing-growth symptom when listing the physical reactions; correct this by including the painful itching linked to the growth of the soul's wings.
    • Treats love and desire as interchangeable; separate eros, aimed at beauty and the good, from appetite for immediate satisfaction.
    • Assumes all desire is spiritual; recall that bodily appetite is a distinct form of desire in Plato's account.
    • Chooses an option because of its tone rather than the object or aim the stem specifies; check the feature the question asks about first.
    • Treats control as total suppression of desire; correct by showing that Plato redirects desire towards the good.
    • Answers only the how or only the why; address both parts of the statement in separate developed points.
    • Describes the parts of the soul without explaining how that structure governs desire; state the relationship of control explicitly.
    • Treats resistance as simple denial of desire; correct this by showing that Plato's model orders desire under reason.
    • Attributes the charioteer image to the Republic; correct this by locating it in the Phaedrus.
    • Presents Diotima's ladder as Plato's own direct speech; correct this by naming Socrates as the reporter of Diotima's teaching in the Symposium.
    • Answers the how without giving any why; correct this by stating the justification, such as harmony of the soul or access to truth.
    • Imports modern psychological terms such as repression without textual support; correct this by using Plato's terms, including appetite, reason and erōs.
    • Treats male-male erōs as the only form of love Plato discusses; correct this by noting that Aristophanes' myth also covers male-female pairs.
    • Assumes Plato approves every form of homoerotic attachment; correct this by checking whether Pausanias separates heavenly and common forms.
    • Attributes Pausanias's distinction to Socrates; correct this by naming Pausanias as the speaker in the Symposium.
    • Reads the Athenian pederastic framework as a modern identity category; correct this by using the Greek framework of age and status.
    • Imports modern notions of consent or personal freedom as if Plato held them; anchor each judgement in the arguments of the set texts.
    • Treats every speaker's view as Plato's own; name the speaker and note whether the dialogue endorses or challenges that view.
    • Lists examples of admirable or harmful conduct without explaining the criterion behind each judgement; state the reasoning that makes it good or bad.
    • Assumes that Athenian social custom directly determines Plato's ideas; show the link through argument and state whether Plato accepts or challenges the custom.
    • Describes Athenian history in general without naming a feature connected to love or desire; select one specific context and link it explicitly to an idea.
    • Draws examples from Roman or later periods as if they reflected Plato's context; keep material within his lifetime or label it clearly as later reception.
    • Treats reception as a summary of the ideas and never considers who received them; add a clear account of the audience.
    • Describes Plato's ideas accurately but leaves out the audience entirely; move from explanation to reconstructed reception.
    • Assumes that all Athenians shared Plato's views; recognise that contemporaries held varied and sometimes opposing attitudes.
    • Presents reception as established fact; use hedged language and support each claim with evidence.
    • Judges ancient reception by modern attitudes; assess the ideas against ancient social norms instead.