Examples of choices of non-exam assessment texts and possible connections — AQA A-Level English Literature
This topic requires students to select appropriate non-exam assessment (NEA) texts for the AQA A-Level English Literature coursework, worth 20% of the qualification. Students must choose two texts, one pre-1900 and one post-1900, and craft a 2500-word comparative essay exploring connections such as theme, genre, or authorial method, supported by critical interpretations.
Examples of choices of non-exam assessment texts and possible connections explained
Examples of choices of non-exam assessment texts and possible connections covers 3 specification points, including John R.
Read the full explanation
Reed (1973) has suggested that the… and Compare and contrast the presentation of women…. Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
John R. Reed (1973) has suggested that the ‘unacknowledged crime’ of Wilkie Collins’ The Moonstone is the colonial guilt of the British Empire for its annexation of the entire Indian sub-continent rather than the theft of a single exquisite diamond. Compare and contrast the presentation of British attitudes to race and ethnicity in The Moonstone and in Zadie Smith’s White Teeth in the light of this view.
This is an example NEA connection, not an exam question. It pairs Wilkie Collins's The Moonstone (1868) with Zadie Smith's White Teeth (2000) and asks you to compare how each text presents British attitudes to race and ethnicity, using Reed's 1973 claim that the novel's real 'unacknowledged crime' is imperial guilt over the annexation of the Indian sub-continent rather than the diamond's theft. Build the comparison around textual evidence: track how Collins's narrators report the diamond's Indian origins and the characters who pursue it, and how Smith's multi-generational London narrative voices attitudes across colonial and post-colonial contexts. Weigh Reed's reading against the texts rather than accepting it, and keep both texts and the critical view in play throughout.
Compare and contrast the presentation of women in Keats’ narrative poems 'Lamia', 'Isabella' and 'The Eve of St Agnes' with that of Anne Brontë's in her novel The Tenant of Wildfell Hall. In what ways do you think the Gothic settings of these texts help the writers to shape their presentation of heroines in peril?
This is a non-exam assessment (NEA) task, so you design the question with your centre and write an extended essay, not a timed exam answer. The task asks you to do two connected things. First, compare how women are presented across Keats's three narrative poems and Brontë's novel: consider how Lamia, Isabella, Madeline and Helen Graham are characterised, who controls them, and what sympathy or judgement the writing invites. Second, analyse how Gothic settings — the enchanted palace, the feudal household, the moonlit chamber, Wildfell Hall and Grassdale — shape the portrayal of heroines in peril. Build a clear line of argument, support it with close reference to each text, and weigh similarities against differences rather than listing them.
Sarah Waters has argued that the Victorian ‘sensation novel’ genre ‘was at its best when tugging at the seams of certainties and easy solutions’. Compare and contrast the presentation of Sue Trinder in Fingersmith with Marian Halcombe in The Woman in White in the light of this view.
This is a non-exam assessment (NEA) task, so you frame the question with your centre and write an extended comparative essay. The task asks you to compare how Sue Trinder in Waters's Fingersmith and Marian Halcombe in Collins's The Woman in White are presented, and to test Waters's view that the sensation novel was strongest when unsettling certainties and easy solutions. Use the quotation as a critical lens: examine how each writer complicates reader certainty — through unreliable narration, secrets, deception and shifting sympathy — and where the texts instead offer resolution. Build a clear argument, support it with close reference to both novels, and weigh similarities against differences.
Your focus
- Compare and contrast the presentation of British attitudes to race and ethnicity in The Moonstone and White Teeth.
- Evaluate Reed's 1973 interpretation of the novel's 'unacknowledged crime' against textual evidence.
- Construct a sustained comparative argument that identifies speakers and narrators and reaches a reasoned judgement.
Show all 9 objectives
- Compare the presentation of women across Keats's narrative poems and Brontë's novel.
- Analyse how Gothic settings shape the portrayal of heroines in peril.
- Construct and support a sustained comparative argument with close textual reference.
- Compare the presentation of Sue Trinder and Marian Halcombe across the two novels.
- Apply Waters's critical view about unsettling certainties to both texts.
- Construct and support a sustained comparative argument with close textual reference.
Which command word is this?
Identify similarities and differences between texts, using comparative connectives and ensuring both texts are discussed in each paragraph. Marks are awarded for sustained comparison and exploration of connections (AO4).
Examples of choices of non-exam assessment texts and possible connections exam tips
Topic Overview
This topic focuses on the selection of two non-exam assessment (NEA) texts for the AQA A-Level English Literature coursework, which constitutes 20% of the final grade. Students must choose one text published pre-1900 and one post-1900, then write a 2500-word comparative essay exploring connections such as theme, genre, or authorial method. The choice of texts is crucial because it determines the scope for independent reading, critical engagement, and contextual analysis.
The NEA is assessed on four Assessment Objectives: AO1 (articulate informed, personal, and creative responses), AO2 (analyse ways in which meanings are shaped), AO3 (demonstrate understanding of the significance and influence of contexts), and AO4 (explore connections across literary texts). Success depends on selecting texts that offer rich comparative potential and allow students to integrate critical interpretations (AO5) seamlessly. This topic therefore sits at the heart of the A-Level, bridging students' wider reading with the analytical skills developed throughout the course.
Key Concepts
- →Text selection criteria: one pre-1900 and one post-1900 text, both of literary merit, offering clear thematic, generic, or contextual connections.
- →Comparative essay structure: introduction, comparative analysis of themes and methods, contextual discussion, critical interpretations, and a reasoned conclusion.
- →Assessment Objectives: AO1 (informed response), AO2 (analysis of methods), AO3 (context), AO4 (connections), and AO5 (critical interpretations).
- →Independent reading: texts should be chosen to demonstrate breadth and depth of reading, avoiding over-studied texts unless approached from a fresh angle.
- →Critical material: integration of named critics or theoretical perspectives (e.g., feminist, Marxist, psychoanalytic) to support and challenge interpretations.
Marking Points
- Compares how The Moonstone and White Teeth each present British attitudes to race and ethnicity, using evidence from both texts rather than treating them separately.
- Evaluates Reed's 1973 claim about imperial guilt and the annexation of the Indian sub-continent, testing it against specific moments in The Moonstone.
- Traces how Collins's narrators and characters frame the diamond's Indian origins and the figures who seek it, connecting this to attitudes about race and empire.
- Analyses how White Teeth presents attitudes to race and ethnicity across its post-colonial London settings and generational conflicts, linking these to the colonial context Reed identifies.
- Sustains a clear comparative argument that weighs the critical view against textual evidence and reaches a reasoned judgement.
- Compares the presentation of women across Keats's three narrative poems and Brontë's novel, addressing each named text rather than only one or two.
- Analyses how a specific Gothic setting shapes the portrayal of a heroine in peril, linking setting to character and mood.
- Weighs similarities and differences between the writers' presentations rather than listing them separately.
- Supports the argument with close reference to the texts, including quotation or detailed textual detail used accurately.
- Sustains a coherent comparative argument that answers both parts of the question across the whole essay.
- Compares the presentation of Sue Trinder and Marian Halcombe, addressing both novels rather than only one.
- Engages with Waters's view about unsettling certainties and easy solutions as a critical lens on the texts.
- Analyses how narrative technique, such as unreliable narration or withheld information, complicates reader certainty.
- Weighs similarities and differences between the two presentations rather than listing them separately.
- Supports the argument with close reference to both novels, including accurate quotation or detailed textual detail.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Anchor every comparative claim in a specific moment from each text, naming the narrator or speaker where relevant.
- 💡Keep Reed's phrase about the 'unacknowledged crime' visible in your argument, returning to it to show how your reading develops.
- 💡Plan by shared issue (for example, how each text voices attitudes to the diamond's origins or to mixed heritage) rather than by text, so comparison drives the structure.
- 💡Plan the essay around a clear comparative argument that answers both parts of the question.
- 💡Select precise textual detail from each named text and explain its effect rather than retelling plot.
- 💡Check the essay addresses the Gothic settings clause as fully as the presentation-of-women clause.
- 💡Discuss the question and chosen texts with your teacher, since NEA questions are set and approved by the centre.
- 💡Plan the essay around a clear argument that uses Waters's view to frame the comparison.
- 💡Select precise textual detail from both novels and explain its effect rather than retelling plot.
- 💡Check the essay tests the critical view rather than merely agreeing with it.
- 💡Discuss the question and chosen texts with your teacher, since NEA questions are set and approved by the centre.
- 💡Choose texts that you genuinely enjoy and are willing to read multiple times; your engagement will show in the quality of your analysis.
- 💡Plan your essay around key comparative points rather than text-by-text summaries; use connectives like 'similarly', 'conversely', and 'whereas' to maintain a comparative thread.
- 💡Integrate critical quotes concisely and always explain how they illuminate your argument; avoid name-dropping without analysis.
Common Mistakes
- Describes each novel in turn without comparing them; integrate points so each paragraph sets the two texts against each other on a shared issue of race or ethnicity.
- Accepts Reed's view as fact rather than testing it; treat the 1973 claim as an interpretation to be weighed against textual evidence.
- Ignores the colonial and historical contexts that separate 1868 from 2000; acknowledge the different periods while still drawing a valid comparison.
- Uses quotation without identifying who speaks or narrates; state whether a line is direct speech, narration or a narrator reporting another character, and name that speaker or narrator.
- Treats the task as a timed exam answer; instead plan and draft an extended NEA essay with a clear argument.
- Discusses only one or two of the named texts; instead address all three Keats poems and the Brontë novel.
- Describes Gothic settings without linking them to the presentation of heroines in peril; instead analyse how each setting shapes character and sympathy.
- Lists similarities and differences without weighing them; instead build a comparative argument that judges significance.
- Treats the task as a timed exam answer; instead plan and draft an extended NEA essay with a clear argument.
- Discusses only one of the two novels; instead compare Sue Trinder and Marian Halcombe across both texts.
- Uses Waters's view as decoration without testing it against the texts; instead apply the critical lens to specific moments.
- Lists similarities and differences without weighing them; instead build a comparative argument that judges significance.
- Students often believe that any two texts can be compared, but the NEA requires a meaningful connection that allows for sustained comparative analysis. Texts should share a theme, genre, or literary movement, but differ enough in context or form to enable AO3 and AO4 discussion.
- Many students think that critical interpretations (AO5) are optional or can be added as a separate paragraph. In fact, AO5 is embedded within AO1 and AO2, and critical views should be woven into the analysis to demonstrate independent judgement.
- Some students assume that the pre-1900 text must be a canonical novel, but poetry, drama, and prose from any genre are acceptable, provided they meet the criteria and offer comparative potential.
Revision Plan
- 1Week 1: Research and select two texts that share a clear connection but differ in context. Read both texts actively, annotating for theme, characterisation, and authorial method.
- 2Week 1-2: Gather critical material from academic journals, books, and reputable websites. Summarise key arguments and note how they relate to your chosen texts.
- 3Week 2: Draft a comparative essay plan, ensuring each paragraph addresses AO1, AO2, AO3, AO4, and AO5. Use a table to map connections and differences.
- 4Week 2: Write the first draft, focusing on integrating critical views and contextual analysis. Aim for a balanced comparison throughout.
- 5Week 2: Review and refine your draft, checking for clarity, coherence, and adherence to the word count. Seek feedback from your teacher and revise accordingly.
Exam Question Types
- 📋Comparative essay question: 'Compare how writers present [theme] in [text 1] and [text 2].' Advice: Ensure you address both texts equally and integrate context and critical views.
- 📋Contextual analysis question: 'How does the context of [text] influence its presentation of [theme]?' Advice: Link contextual factors to authorial methods and compare with the other text.
- 📋Critical interpretation question: 'To what extent do you agree with the view that [critical perspective] is the most useful lens for comparing these texts?' Advice: Evaluate the critical perspective, offering alternative readings and textual evidence.
Command Word Expectations (AQA)
Identify similarities and differences between texts, using comparative connectives and ensuring both texts are discussed in each paragraph. Marks are awarded for sustained comparison and exploration of connections (AO4).
Break down how meanings are shaped through authorial methods (AO2). Use precise terminology and explore the effects of language, form, and structure.
Make a judgement about the extent to which a statement or critical view is valid, supported by textual evidence and critical interpretation. Show awareness of alternative viewpoints (AO5).
How Students Lose Marks (Examiner Pitfalls)
Step-by-Step Worked Solutions
Question: Compare how the writers of 'The Great Gatsby' (1925) and 'A Streetcar Named Desire' (1947) present the theme of illusion versus reality. In your answer, you should consider the connections between the texts and how they are shaped by their contexts.
- 1.Step 1: Identify the shared theme: both texts explore the destructive nature of illusion, with Gatsby's idealised love for Daisy and Blanche's fantasy of refinement masking harsh realities.
- 2.Step 2: Analyse authorial methods: Fitzgerald uses Nick's retrospective narration and symbolic imagery (the green light) to critique the American Dream, while Williams employs expressionistic staging and Blanche's lyrical dialogue to expose the fragility of Southern belle identity.
- 3.Step 3: Compare contextual influences: Gatsby reflects 1920s consumerism and post-war disillusionment, whereas Streetcar critiques the decline of the Old South and the rise of a brutal new America, linking illusion to social and economic change.
- 4.Step 4: Integrate critical views: cite a Marxist reading of Gatsby's wealth as commodified desire and a feminist interpretation of Blanche's madness as resistance to patriarchal oppression.
- 5.Step 5: Conclude by evaluating which text presents a more pessimistic view of the possibility of escaping illusion, supporting your judgement with textual evidence.
Question: How do 'Wuthering Heights' (1847) and 'The Bloody Chamber' (1979) use Gothic conventions to explore gender and power? Compare and contrast the texts, considering the influence of their contexts.
- 1.Step 1: Define Gothic conventions: both texts employ the sublime, the monstrous feminine, and the uncanny to challenge patriarchal authority.
- 2.Step 2: Analyse Brontë's presentation: Catherine's ghost and Heathcliff's tyranny subvert Victorian gender norms, while the frame narrative distances the reader from the violence.
- 3.Step 3: Analyse Carter's presentation: 'The Bloody Chamber' rewrites fairy tales to expose sexual violence and female agency, using first-person narration to foreground the heroine's perspective.
- 4.Step 4: Compare contextual factors: Brontë writes in the shadow of Romanticism and Victorian morality, whereas Carter responds to second-wave feminism and post-war sexual politics.
- 5.Step 5: Evaluate critical interpretations: cite a psychoanalytic reading of the Gothic double in both texts and a feminist critique of Carter's reclamation of the Gothic as a subversive genre.