Paper 2: Texts in shared contexts - Option A: WW1 and its aftermath - Section A: Core set texts - Poetry — AQA A-Level English Literature
This component of AQA A-Level English Literature Paper 2 (Option A) requires students to analyse and compare the poetry of Wilfred Owen, Siegfried Sassoon, and other core set texts, exploring themes of conflict, memory, and loss. Success depends on close textual analysis, contextual understanding of WW1 and its aftermath, and the ability to construct a coherent comparative argument under timed conditions.
Paper 2: Texts in shared contexts - Option A: WW1 and its aftermath - Section A: Core set texts - Poetry explained
Paper 2: Texts in shared contexts - Option A: WW1 and its aftermath - Section A: Core set texts - Poetry covers 2 specification points, including ed.
Read the full explanation
Brian Gardner Up the Line to Death and ed. Catherine Reilly Scars Upon My Heart. Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
ed. Brian Gardner Up the Line to Death
This anthology, edited by Brian Gardner, gathers First World War poetry written during and shortly around the conflict, and you study it as a core set text for the WW1 and its aftermath option. An extended response asks you to build a sustained argument about the poems, using close reference to wording, form and structure, and connecting individual poems to the shared context of the war and its aftermath. Treat the anthology as a constructed selection: consider which voices, ranks and perspectives the editor includes, how poems speak to one another across the collection, and how attitudes to combat, loss, duty and memory develop. Quote precisely from poems you know, name the speaker or narrator of any reported utterance, and locate lines only where you can verify them. Compare poems within this anthology rather than assuming a fixed pairing.
ed. Catherine Reilly Scars Upon My Heart
This anthology, edited by Catherine Reilly, collects poetry by women writing about the First World War and its aftermath, and you study it as a core set text for the WW1 and its aftermath option. An extended response asks you to argue a case about the poems, analysing close detail of wording, form and structure, and connecting them to the shared context of the war. Treat the anthology as a deliberate selection: consider whose voices the editor gathers, how women's perspectives on combat, loss, work and memory are presented, and how poems speak to one another. Quote precisely, name the speaker or narrator of any reported utterance, and locate lines only where you can verify them. Compare poems within this anthology rather than assuming a fixed pairing.
Your focus
- Construct a sustained analytical argument about poems from the anthology in response to a question.
- Analyse how language, form and structure create meaning and effect in chosen poems.
- Relate individual poems to the shared context of the First World War and its aftermath, comparing poems within the anthology.
Show all 6 objectives
- Construct a sustained analytical argument about poems from the anthology in response to a question.
- Analyse how language, form and structure create meaning and effect in chosen poems.
- Relate individual poems to the shared context of the First World War and its aftermath, comparing poems within the anthology.
Which command word is this?
Students must investigate and analyse the text in detail, considering multiple interpretations and using textual evidence. They should not simply describe or list features.
Paper 2: Texts in shared contexts - Option A: WW1 and its aftermath - Section A: Core set texts - Poetry exam tips
Topic Overview
This topic focuses on the poetry of the First World War and its aftermath, with a core set of poems by writers such as Wilfred Owen, Siegfried Sassoon, and Rupert Brooke. Students must study these poems in depth, exploring how they present themes of conflict, memory, loss, and the contrast between patriotic idealism and the brutal reality of trench warfare. The unit is part of Paper 2: Texts in shared contexts, which examines literature through a specific historical and cultural lens.
Studying this poetry is crucial because it develops skills in close textual analysis, comparative argument, and contextual understanding. It also encourages students to engage with the emotional and psychological impact of war, both on individuals and society. This topic fits into the wider subject by demonstrating how literature can respond to and shape historical events, and by refining the analytical and essay-writing skills needed for all A-Level English Literature exams.
Key Concepts
- →The contrast between propaganda and reality: many WW1 poets initially wrote patriotic verse but later subverted it to expose the horrors of war.
- →The use of poetic form and structure: sonnets, ballads, and free verse are employed to reflect order, chaos, or tradition, and to challenge reader expectations.
- →The role of context: biographical, historical, and literary context (e.g., the influence of Romantic poetry, the censorship of war reporting) must be integrated into analysis.
- →Themes of memory, trauma, and mourning: poems often explore how the dead are remembered, the psychological scars of survivors, and the inadequacy of traditional mourning rituals.
- →Comparative analysis: students must compare poems, exploring similarities and differences in theme, tone, and technique, and evaluate how each poet presents their perspective.
Marking Points
- Builds a sustained argument that answers the specific question and sustains a clear line of reasoning across the whole response.
- Analyses the wording of chosen poems closely, explaining how specific word choices create meaning and effect.
- Explains how form and structure, such as stanza shape, rhyme, rhythm and line breaks, shape the reader's response.
- Connects individual poems to the shared context of the First World War and its aftermath, including attitudes to combat, loss and memory.
- Compares poems within the anthology, showing how they speak to or qualify one another.
- Names the speaker or narrator of any quoted or reported utterance and distinguishes direct speech from narration.
- Locates a quotation by poem and line only where the position can be verified from the text.
- Builds a sustained argument that answers the specific question and sustains a clear line of reasoning across the whole response.
- Analyses the wording of chosen poems closely, explaining how specific word choices create meaning and effect.
- Explains how form and structure, such as stanza shape, rhyme, rhythm and line breaks, shape the reader's response.
- Connects individual poems to the shared context of the First World War and its aftermath, including women's perspectives on loss, work and memory.
- Compares poems within the anthology, showing how they speak to or qualify one another.
- Names the speaker or narrator of any quoted or reported utterance and distinguishes direct speech from narration.
- Locates a quotation by poem and line only where the position can be verified from the text.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Plan a clear argument before writing, deciding which poems best support your line of reasoning on the question.
- 💡Use short, precise quotations and analyse the effect of individual words rather than long block quotations.
- 💡Keep returning to the shared context of the war and its aftermath, linking each point to attitudes, experience or memory.
- 💡Leave time to check that every quotation is accurate and that you have named the speaker of any reported utterance.
- 💡Plan a clear argument before writing, deciding which poems best support your line of reasoning on the question.
- 💡Use short, precise quotations and analyse the effect of individual words rather than long block quotations.
- 💡Keep returning to the shared context of the war and its aftermath, linking each point to women's experience, attitudes or memory.
- 💡Leave time to check that every quotation is accurate and that you have named the speaker of any reported utterance.
- 💡Always address the question directly. Underline the key words and ensure every paragraph links back to the focus of the question.
- 💡Use precise terminology when analysing form and structure (e.g., 'caesura', 'enjambment', 'volta', 'iambic pentameter') and explain their effect.
- 💡Integrate context subtly. Instead of writing a separate context paragraph, weave contextual details into your analysis of the poet's choices.
- 💡Plan your essay to ensure a balanced comparison. Aim to discuss both poems in each paragraph rather than writing about one and then the other.
Common Mistakes
- Retells the plot or paraphrases a poem instead of analysing how language creates meaning; select short quotations and comment on specific words.
- Treats the anthology as a random collection rather than an edited selection; consider how the editor's choices shape the range of voices and perspectives.
- Attributes a quoted line to the wrong speaker or assumes the poet speaks directly; identify the speaker or narrator and distinguish direct speech from narration.
- Invents a fixed comparison pair or a prescribed structure; compare poems within the anthology as the question invites rather than assuming a set pairing.
- Retells the situation of a poem instead of analysing how language creates meaning; select short quotations and comment on specific words.
- Assumes every poem expresses the poet's own direct experience; identify the speaker or narrator and distinguish direct speech from narration.
- Treats the anthology as a random collection rather than an edited selection; consider how the editor's choices shape the range of women's voices and perspectives.
- Invents a fixed comparison pair or a prescribed structure; compare poems within the anthology as the question invites rather than assuming a set pairing.
- Students often assume all WW1 poetry is anti-war. In fact, some early war poetry (e.g., Rupert Brooke's 'The Soldier') is patriotic and idealistic, and even later poems can contain complex, ambivalent attitudes.
- Students may think that context is just historical facts about WW1. Context also includes the poet's biography, literary influences, and the expectations of the audience at the time.
- Students sometimes believe that analysing form and structure is less important than language. However, form and structure are integral to meaning and are assessed in AO2.
Revision Plan
- 1Week 1: Read and annotate all core set poems. For each poem, note key themes, poetic techniques, and contextual links. Create a revision grid comparing poems by theme, tone, and method.
- 2Week 1-2: Practise close analysis of key quotations. For each poem, select 3-4 quotations and write detailed analytical paragraphs, focusing on language, form, and structure, and integrating context.
- 3Week 2: Write comparative essays under timed conditions. Use past paper questions and mark schemes to self-assess. Focus on integrating comparison and meeting all assessment objectives.
- 4Ongoing: Memorise key quotations and contextual facts. Use flashcards or active recall to test your knowledge. Review examiner reports for common pitfalls.
Exam Question Types
- 📋Comparative essay question: 'Compare how poets present the theme of [e.g., loss, memory, conflict] in [Poem A] and [Poem B].' Advice: Plan your argument, ensure integrated comparison, and use textual evidence.
- 📋Close analysis question: 'Explore how [Poet] presents [theme/idea] in [Poem].' Advice: Focus on close reading of language, form, and structure, and link to context.
- 📋Context-focused question: 'How does the historical context of WW1 influence the presentation of [theme] in [Poem] and [Poem]?' Advice: Integrate context into analysis, avoid separate context paragraphs.
- 📋Unseen poem comparison: 'Compare the ways in which [Poem A] and [unseen poem] present [theme].' Advice: Apply the same analytical skills to the unseen poem, focusing on similarities and differences.
Command Word Expectations (AQA)
Students must investigate and analyse the text in detail, considering multiple interpretations and using textual evidence. They should not simply describe or list features.
Students must identify similarities and differences between texts, and explore how these relate to the question. Integrated comparison is expected, not separate summaries.
Students must break down the text into its constituent parts (language, form, structure) and explain how these create meaning and effects. Close reference to the text is essential.
How Students Lose Marks (Examiner Pitfalls)
Step-by-Step Worked Solutions
Question: Explore how Owen presents the theme of loss in 'Futility' and one other poem from the core set texts. (25 marks)
- 1.Step 1: Identify the key command word 'Explore' and the focus on 'loss' in 'Futility' and one other poem (e.g., 'Anthem for Doomed Youth').
- 2.Step 2: Analyse 'Futility' - consider the sun as a life-giving force that has failed, the tenderness of 'Move him into the sun', the shift from hope to despair, and the final rhetorical question 'Was it for this the clay grew tall?'.
- 3.Step 3: Analyse the second poem - in 'Anthem for Doomed Youth', loss is presented through the absence of proper funeral rites, the 'monstrous anger of the guns' replacing 'passing-bells', and the 'drawn blinds' and 'flowers' as inadequate substitutes for mourning.
- 4.Step 4: Compare how both poems convey loss - Owen emphasises the waste of life and the indifference of nature in 'Futility', while in 'Anthem' he focuses on the dehumanising effect of war and the lack of spiritual consolation.
- 5.Step 5: Integrate context - Owen's experiences at Craiglockhart and his witnessing of death inform both poems; his anger at the waste of young life is a recurring theme.
- 6.Step 6: Conclude with a clear judgement on how Owen presents loss, linking back to the question and the wider collection.
Question: Compare how Sassoon and Owen present the relationship between soldiers and those at home in 'The Send-Off' and 'Dulce et Decorum Est'. (25 marks)
- 1.Step 1: Decode the question - focus on 'relationship between soldiers and those at home' and compare two named poems.
- 2.Step 2: Analyse 'The Send-Off' - the soldiers leave secretly at night, 'down the close, darkening lanes', with 'no bell' and 'no cheers'; the crowd's 'dull, hoarse, murmuring' and the 'grimly gay' flowers suggest a muted, almost shameful departure. The final stanza's 'They were not ours' implies a disconnect between civilians and soldiers.
- 3.Step 3: Analyse 'Dulce et Decorum Est' - the soldiers are described as 'beggars' and 'hags', far removed from the heroic image; the 'old Lie' is taught to children at home, showing a gap between civilian ignorance and soldier suffering. The gas attack scene is visceral and immediate, contrasting with the distant, abstract patriotism of 'the old Lie'.
- 4.Step 4: Compare - Sassoon presents the relationship as one of secrecy and emotional distance, with the home front unable or unwilling to acknowledge the reality of war. Owen presents it as one of betrayal, where civilians perpetuate lies that send soldiers to their deaths.
- 5.Step 5: Integrate context - both poets were soldiers who felt alienated from civilian society upon return; Sassoon's 'The Send-Off' reflects his own experience of embarkation, while Owen's poem is a direct response to Jessie Pope's pro-war poetry.
- 6.Step 6: Conclude with a comparative judgement on how the poets present the gulf between soldiers and civilians.