Theme C: The existence of God and revelation — AQA GCSE Religious Studies
Test yourself on Theme C: The existence of God and revelation with AQA GCSE practice questions.
7 days Premium · Then free forever · No card, no charge
Theme C: The existence of God and revelation explained
When believers claim to have experienced God, their accounts often contradict one another, creating significant philosophical and theological problems.
Read the full explanation
For example, a Christian might experience a vision of Jesus affirming the Trinity, while a Muslim might experience a revelation affirming the absolute oneness of Allah (Tawhid). Because these different ideas about the divine arise from subjective experiences, they cannot all be objectively true. This conflicting evidence undermines the reliability of religious experiences as proof for the existence of a specific God. Sceptics argue that if a single, universal God were revealing themselves, the resulting ideas about the divine would be consistent across all cultures and religions, rather than reflecting the believer's pre-existing cultural conditioning.
Your focus
- Identify why different religious experiences lead to conflicting ideas about the divine.
- Explain how these conflicting ideas undermine the reliability of religious experience as proof of God.
- Evaluate the argument that religious experiences are products of cultural conditioning rather than genuine divine encounters.
Theme C: The existence of God and revelation exam tips
Marking Points
- Explain how conflicting religious experiences challenge the existence of a single, universal God.
- Provide examples of how different religions claim exclusive truths based on subjective experiences.
- Discuss the argument that experiences reflect cultural conditioning rather than objective divine revelation.
- Evaluate the impact of these contradictory claims on the reliability of religious experience as an argument for God's existence.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Use the concept of 'pluralism' to discuss how multiple religions claim truth, and explain why this weakens the argument from religious experience.
- 💡Contrast a specific Christian vision with a vision from another faith to clearly illustrate the problem of conflicting divine ideas.
- 💡When evaluating, argue both sides: sceptics see contradictions as proof of human invention, while believers might argue human minds interpret the same divine reality differently.
Common Mistakes
- Error: Stating that all religious experiences prove the same God exists. Correction: Acknowledge that different religions report experiences of different, mutually exclusive deities or divine concepts.
- Error: Ignoring the word 'problems' in the specification. Correction: Explicitly explain why conflicting ideas create a logical problem for the validity of religious experiences.
- Error: Confusing different ideas about the divine with different types of experience. Correction: Focus on the conflicting theological conclusions drawn from the experiences, not just the format of the experience itself.