Question 1

What is the difference between just war and holy war?

Accepted Answer

Just war theory is a Christian doctrine that sets out conditions for a war to be morally acceptable, such as having a just cause and being declared by a legitimate authority. Holy war, on the other hand, is a war fought for religious reasons, often believed to be commanded by God. In Islam, holy war (jihad) can refer to armed struggle but has strict rules, while in Christianity, the Crusades are historical examples of holy wars. The key difference is that just war focuses on ethical criteria, whereas holy war emphasises religious duty.

Question 2

Do all Muslims believe in jihad as violence?

Accepted Answer

No, most Muslims understand jihad primarily as a personal spiritual struggle to live according to Islamic teachings. The 'greater jihad' is about self-improvement, while the 'lesser jihad' can involve armed conflict but only under strict conditions: it must be defensive, not harm civilians, and be declared by a legitimate religious authority. Extremist groups distort this concept to justify violence, but mainstream Islam condemns terrorism and emphasises peace.

Question 3

How can religion promote peace if it sometimes causes conflict?

Accepted Answer

Religion can promote peace through teachings on forgiveness, reconciliation, and love for others. For example, Christianity's 'Golden Rule' and Islam's concept of ummah (community) encourage harmony. Religious leaders often mediate conflicts, and interfaith initiatives work to reduce tension. However, when religion is misinterpreted or manipulated for political ends, it can be used to justify violence. The key is distinguishing between authentic religious teachings and their misuse.

Question 4

What is Christian pacifism and is it realistic?

Accepted Answer

Christian pacifism is the belief that Christians should never participate in war because Jesus taught non-violence, such as 'turn the other cheek' (Matthew 5:39). Pacifists argue that war is always wrong and that conflicts should be resolved through peaceful means. Critics say pacifism is unrealistic in the face of evil (e.g., Hitler), but pacifists counter that non-violent resistance can be effective, as seen in the Civil Rights Movement led by Martin Luther King Jr., who was inspired by Christian teachings.

Question 5

Why do some religious people support nuclear weapons?

Accepted Answer

Some religious people support nuclear weapons as a deterrent, arguing that possessing them prevents war by making the cost of attack too high. This is based on just war theory's principle of proportionality, but it is controversial because nuclear weapons cause massive civilian casualties. Others, including many Christian and Muslim leaders, oppose them on the grounds that they violate the sanctity of life and the principle of discrimination (only targeting combatants). The Catholic Church, for example, has called for nuclear disarmament.

Question 6

How should I structure a 12-mark question on religion and peace?

Accepted Answer

Start with a clear introduction stating your argument. Then, present one viewpoint (e.g., Christian just war theory) with scripture and explanation. Next, present a contrasting view (e.g., pacifism) with evidence. Evaluate both, discussing strengths and weaknesses. Finally, give a justified conclusion, explaining which view you find more convincing and why. Use connectives like 'however' and 'therefore' to show analysis. Remember to refer to the question throughout and include specific religious teachings.

Theme D: Religion, peace and conflict

Topic Overview

Key Concepts

What You Need to Demonstrate

Marking Points

Examiner Tips

Common Mistakes

Frequently Asked Questions

Before You Start

Key Terminology

Likely Command Words

Ready to test yourself?

Related Topics in AQA GCSE Religious Studies

Authority

Beliefs about the nature of human life

Beliefs and teachings

Buddhism

How to Revise Theme D: Religion, peace and conflict — AQA GCSE Religious Studies

Examiner Tips for Theme D: Religion, peace and conflict

Key Marking Points