Component 3: Debates in contemporary society - Section B Option 1: Crime and deviance - 3. How can crime and deviance be explained? — OCR A-Level Sociology
Component 3: Debates in contemporary society - Section B Option 1: Crime and deviance - 3. How can crime and deviance be explained? explained
Theories of crime offer contrasting explanations.
Read the full explanation
Functionalism (Durkheim) views crime as normal, functional for boundary maintenance, and rooted in anomie (Merton). Traditional Marxism views crime as a rational response to capitalist exploitation and unequal law enforcement. Neo-Marxism and radical criminology frame deviance as political resistance against hegemony. Interactionism (Becker) analyses crime as the outcome of societal labelling. Subcultural theories explain collective delinquent solutions to status frustration. Left realism targets relative deprivation and marginalisation, while Right realism and the New Right emphasize rational choice, parental inadequacy, and zero tolerance. Feminism highlights female victimisation and patriarchal justice.
Your focus
- Match each named theory to its core explanation of crime and deviance.
- Distinguish structural, interactionist and control-based accounts.
- Recognise feminist and subcultural contributions to explaining crime.
Component 3: Debates in contemporary society - Section B Option 1: Crime and deviance - 3. How can crime and deviance be explained? exam tips
Marking Points
- Identifies functionalism as treating crime as normal and boundary-maintaining rather than as simply pathological.
- Links Marxism to class inequality and to the law serving ruling-class interests.
- Associates neo-Marxism and radical criminology with labelling, the state and resistance rather than with pure economic determinism.
- Explains interactionism through labelling and the self-fulfilling prophecy.
- Distinguishes left realism, which takes working-class victimisation and relative deprivation seriously, from right realism and the New Right, which stress rational choice and inadequate control.
- Recognises subcultural theories as explaining shared delinquent norms and feminism as examining gendered patterns and victimisation.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Read the stem to identify the exact theory before looking at the options.
- 💡Eliminate options that clearly belong to a rival tradition.
- 💡Check whether the stem stresses structure, interaction or control before choosing.
Common Mistakes
- Treats functionalism as claiming crime is always harmful; correct this by noting that functionalists see some crime as normal and boundary-maintaining.
- Confuses Marxism with interactionism; correct this by separating structural class analysis from labelling processes.
- Assumes left and right realism share the same explanation; correct this by contrasting left realism's focus on deprivation and victimisation with right realism's focus on rational choice and control.
- Ignores feminism or treats it as an add-on; correct this by recognising its focus on gendered patterns and victimisation.