WJEC · A-Level · Psychology
Overview guide · Check your current course specification before revising.
Ethical Costs of Research
This guide dissects the critical 'double obligation' dilemma in psychological research, balancing scientific progress against participant welfare. It provides a comprehensive breakdown of the BPS Code of Ethics, equipping WJEC A-Level candidates with the analytical tools needed to master AO2 application and AO3 evaluation.
- 5 min read
- 3 worked examples
- 5 practice questions
- 6 key terms
Study Notes
Overview
The study of ethics in psychology is not merely a set of rules, but a dynamic and challenging field of critical thinking. For WJEC A-Level candidates, mastery of this topic hinges on understanding the core conflict known as the 'double obligation': the researcher's duty to society to advance knowledge, versus their duty to the individual participant to ensure their rights and welfare are protected. This guide will deconstruct the BPS Code of Ethics and Conduct (2009), providing the framework to analyze complex scenarios. Examiners expect candidates to move beyond simple identification of issues like 'deception' and instead engage in a sophisticated cost-benefit analysis, weighing the scientific merit of a study against the ethical costs incurred by participants. This involves applying the four key principles—Respect, Competence, Responsibility, and Integrity—to novel situations and justifying judgements with precise terminology and evidence from stimulus material. Credit is awarded for demonstrating a nuanced understanding that ethical guidelines are not absolute bans, but frameworks for making difficult, justifiable decisions.
The Four BPS Principles
At the core of all ethical decision-making in UK psychology are the four principles from the BPS Code of Ethics and Conduct (2009). Candidates must not only memorize these but understand their practical application.
Open full-size image (opens in a new tab)
1. Respect
What it is: This principle is about valuing the dignity and worth of all persons. It involves respecting individual differences and protecting their rights to privacy, confidentiality, self-determination, and, crucially, valid consent.
Why it matters: In exam scenarios, this is often breached when participants are not given enough information to make a truly informed decision, or when their privacy is compromised. Using the term 'valid consent' over 'informed consent' will be credited by examiners as it aligns with specific BPS and WJEC terminology.
2. Competence
What it is: A researcher must operate within the boundaries of their own knowledge, skill, and training. It is a commitment to maintaining high standards of professional work and recognizing the limits of one's expertise.
Why it matters: Marks are awarded for identifying when a researcher might be stepping outside their area of competence, for example, by attempting to study a clinical population without the relevant qualifications, potentially leading to harm or misinterpretation of data.
3. Responsibility
What it is: This is the duty to protect participants from harm (both physical and psychological) and to uphold the reputation of the profession. It directly involves the process of risk management and the cost-benefit analysis.
Why it matters: This is the principle most directly linked to the 'double obligation'. Candidates should explicitly reference a researcher's responsibility to weigh the costs (e.g., participant distress) against the benefits (e.g., new knowledge about treating a disorder). A failure to protect participants from harm is a clear breach of this principle.
4. Integrity
What it is: This principle demands honesty, accuracy, and fairness in all professional interactions. It covers the reporting of data and the justification for any necessary deception within a study.
Why it matters: Deception is a key ethical issue, but simply stating 'deception is wrong' is a low-level response. A sophisticated answer will explain that while deception breaches the principle of Integrity, it may be justified if it is essential for the study's validity. This breach must then be mitigated through a comprehensive debriefing process.
Second-Order Concepts
Cost-Benefit Analysis
This is the central evaluative tool for this topic. It is not a simple tallying of pros and cons. A good analysis involves a qualitative assessment of the severity of the costs versus the significance of the benefits. Aronson's (1992) rule is a key piece of specific knowledge here: he argued that the benefits must be seen to clearly outweigh the costs. If it is a borderline case, the research should not proceed. Candidates should structure their AO3 evaluation around this model.
Open full-size image (opens in a new tab)
Dealing with Ethical Issues
Candidates often confuse ethical issues with the methods used to deal with them. It is vital to distinguish between the two for high marks.
| Ethical Issue | Method of Dealing with the Issue |
|---|---|
| Lack of Valid Consent | Gaining presumptive consent, prior general consent, or retrospective consent. |
| Deception | A full, restorative debrief that explains the true aim and offers aftercare. |
| Risk of Harm | A thorough risk assessment, and the participant's right to withdraw at any time. |
| Confidentiality | Anonymising data by removing all personally identifiable information. |
Check what you remember
Read the wording for your board, then hide it and explain Valid Consent in your own words. Rough notes are fine. This is a self-check, with no mark or grade.
Reference: WJEC
The process of ensuring a participant voluntarily agrees to take part in research, having been given comprehensive information about what is involved, including the aims, procedures, and potential risks.
Interactive Diagrams
1 interactive diagram to visualise key concepts
Diagram could not be rendered
A timeline showing the historical development of key ethical codes that influence current practice.
Worked Examples
3 worked examples — open one to explore the question and available guidance.
Practice Questions
Try the question, then reveal an answer plan or example response
Describe what is meant by 'valid consent' in the context of psychological research. (3 marks)
Hint: Think about the three components that make consent truly valid.
A study requires children to be observed in a playground. Explain how a researcher could deal with the ethical issue of consent in this situation. (4 marks)
Hint: Who gives consent when the participants are children?
Evaluate the use of deception in psychological research. (8 marks)
Hint: Use a cost-benefit structure. What are the arguments FOR deception (benefits) and what are the arguments AGAINST it (costs)?
What is a debrief and why is it important? (4 marks)
Hint: Think about the different functions of a debrief.
Explain the role of an ethics committee. (3 marks)
Hint: Who is on an ethics committee and what do they do?
Ready to test yourself interactively?
Active recall beats reading alone. Answer questions on Ethical Costs of Research with instant AI scoring and mark scheme guidance.
A week of Premium from your first lesson · Then the free plan continues · No card, no charge
Exam technique
How to turn what you know into marks
How to approach the question
1. **Identify Command Word**: What does it want you to do (Evaluate, Explain, Describe)? 2. **Identify Topic**: What specific part of the specification is this? (e.g., BPS principles). 3. **Identify Stimulus**: What information is given in the scenario? You MUST quote it.
How to structure your answer
- Essay questions
- Introduction setting out the debate (e.g., the 'double obligation'). Then have balanced paragraphs, each focusing on a different aspect of the ethical debate. Conclude with a justified judgement.
- Explain questions
- Use the PEEL structure: **P**oint (make a clear statement), **E**vidence (use specific knowledge or stimulus quote), **E**xplanation (explain *how* this demonstrates the point), **L**ink (link back to the question).
- Evaluation questions
- Structure using a cost-benefit analysis. Acknowledge the potential benefits or justification for the researcher's actions first, then introduce the ethical costs as a counter-argument. Always refer to specific BPS principles.
Timing
Approximately 1.5 minutes per mark. For a 12-mark question, this means around 18 minutes.
Common pitfalls
- Confusing anonymity and confidentiality.
- Stating 'deception is not allowed' - it is, but must be justified and debriefed.
- Generic evaluation (e.g., 'it was unethical') without linking to specific BPS principles or using the cost-benefit model.
- Not using the term 'valid consent'.
What the command words want
- Apply
- Use your knowledge to understand a novel scenario. Quote the stimulus material directly.
- Explain
- Provide a detailed account of *why* or *how*. E.g., 'Explain why deception might be used in psychological research.'
- Describe
- State the features of something. E.g., 'Describe two ways of dealing with deception.'
- Evaluate
- Make a judgement on the value/worth of something. Use a cost-benefit structure and come to a justified conclusion.
Test your understanding of Ethical Costs of Research
Active recall beats re-reading. Take an instant quiz now to test what you’ve learned and lock it into long-term memory.
A week of Premium from your first lesson · Then the free plan continues · No card, no charge