Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Invention of the Barbarian (H408/23) - Greeks and barbarians — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation

    Invention of the Barbarian (H408/23) - Greeks and barbarians explained

    Invention of the Barbarian (H408/23) - Greeks and barbarians covers 10 specification points, including Pre-Classical ideas of the ‘barbarian’… and The role of binary oppositions (for example….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    pre-Classical ideas of the ‘barbarian’ including the origin of the term and its original connotations

    This criterion asks you to explain how pre-Classical Greeks conceived of non-Greeks and what the term barbaros originally meant. Begin with its origin: barbaros is traditionally explained as a sound-based formation, imitating speech that a Greek listener heard as repeated bar-bar noise. Its original connotation was therefore linguistic, describing someone whose speech could not be understood, not a verdict on character or civilisation. Homer illustrates this: Iliad 2.867 calls the Carians barbarophonoi, speakers of unintelligible language. Your method is to define the term, trace its earliest pre-Classical sense, and then separate later moral and cultural meanings, which must not be read back into Homer.

    the role of binary oppositions (for example Greek/foreigner; man/woman; slave/free) in the Greek world view

    This criterion asks you to explain how binary oppositions shaped the Greek world view, using pairs such as Greek/foreigner, man/woman and slave/free. Each pair sets two terms against each other, with one treated as the norm and the other defined by lack or negation. Greek/foreigner shows how Greek identity was built by contrast, a structure that underpins the idea of the barbarian. Man/woman and slave/free apply the same logic inside Greek society, marking who held citizenship and social status. Your method is to name the pair, identify the privileged term, explain how the contrast supported Greek self-definition, and assess where real people did not fit neatly.

    the typical depiction of barbarians in classical Greek sources, including:

    This statement asks you to know the typical way Greek sources present barbarians: the broad picture that recurs across classical Greek writing, not one author's view alone. Greeks used barbaros for people whose speech sounded unintelligible to them, and writers then attached contrasting traits to foreigners, such as excess, luxury or servility, set against Greek moderation, freedom and self-control. The supplied wording ends with 'including:' but lists no items, so do not invent examples; check the full published list before revision. Work from named texts in your course, and for each one explain how the author builds the contrast with Greek identity and what that contrast is meant to achieve.

    the standard visual depiction of ‘barbarians’ in Greek art

    This statement asks you to know the standard way Greek art shows barbarians: the conventions painters and sculptors repeated so that viewers could identify a foreigner at once. The main visual tools are costume, headgear, facial hair and posture. Foreigners are often dressed in trousers, patterned or layered garments and soft, pointed caps such as the Phrygian cap, while Greek men are typically shown nude or in hoplite armour. In battle scenes the contrast is often sharpened by showing Greek fighters as composed and foreigners as fearful or fleeing. These images are artistic conventions rather than photographic records. When you use an example from your course, identify the object, its context and what its original viewers would take from it.

    their way of life and customs

    This statement concerns how Greek writers portrayed the everyday life and customs of non-Greeks, such as habits, dress, religion, marriage and burial. Such accounts often defined foreignness by contrast with Greek norms, so foreign practice appears as a reversal of the Greek. Herodotus' account of Egyptian customs is the standard example, where many practices are said to be the opposite of others'. To answer well, identify the custom described, state the Greek norm it is set against, and explain what the contrast reveals about Greek self-definition. Remember that Greeks wrote these accounts, so they reveal Greek assumptions as much as foreign reality.

    their character

    This statement concerns the innate qualities Greek writers attributed to non-Greeks, their character or temperament. Such accounts often explained character through environment and political system: the Hippocratic treatise Airs, Waters, Places links the temperament of Asian peoples to climate and monarchical rule. Aristotle's Politics goes further, presenting some foreign peoples as naturally suited to servitude. When answering, identify the quality attributed, the explanation offered, and whether the text treats it as fixed or shaped by circumstance. Consider what the attribution does for the Greek speaker, such as justifying rule or defining freedom. Keep to the texts and period you have studied.

    politics and hierarchy

    This statement asks how Greek writers presented the political systems and social hierarchies of foreign peoples. Politics means how power was organised, such as rule by one king or by a council. Hierarchy means the ranking of groups, such as nobles, commoners and slaves, and how they relate. For each example, identify the power structure or rank described, state what the source says about it, then explain what this reveals about the author's assumptions. A writer may contrast a court ruled by one man with Greek citizen participation. Ask whether the picture is admirable, threatening or merely strange.

    their religion and rituals

    This statement asks how Greek writers described the religion and rituals of peoples they regarded as foreign. Religion means the gods, beliefs and sacred institutions a people honoured, such as priesthoods and temples. Rituals means the set actions performed in worship, such as sacrifice, processions, festivals or burial customs. For each example, identify the practice, state what the source reports, then explain whether it is presented as Greek-like or strange. Herodotus, for example, presents Egyptian animal cults as unfamiliar, inviting comparison with Greek practice. Consider what the contrast reveals about the author's identity.

    the role of the historical context in this ‘invention’ of the barbarian, including:

    This statement asks you to assess how historical circumstances shaped the idea of the barbarian, a category the title places in scare quotes to show it was constructed rather than natural. Historical context means the events, power relations and cultural encounters that gave writers reasons to describe foreign peoples in particular ways. Teach it by linking one context to one feature of the image, for example Greek pride in speaking Greek set against non-Greek speech. The statement ends with 'including:' but supplies no sub-points, so do not invent a list; choose your own labelled strands of context and explain how each built the image.

    the role of the Persian wars in crystallising images of foreign peoples

    This statement asks you to explain how the Persian wars fixed existing images of foreign peoples into a more settled Greek picture. The Persian invasions, including the campaign of 490 BC that ended at Marathon and the expedition of 480–479 BC, gave Greeks vivid events against which to define themselves. Crystallising means the images became sharper, more widely shared and more durable, not that they were invented from nothing. Foreign peoples here chiefly means the Persians and the peoples of their empire, viewed through contrasts of freedom and subjection, and Greek and non-Greek. Use a method: name a feature of the image, show how a war event sharpened it, and evaluate how far earlier attitudes already existed.

    Your focus

    1. Define barbaros and explain its traditional sound-based origin.
    2. Identify Iliad 2.867 as evidence of the earliest use of barbarophonoi.
    3. Distinguish the early linguistic connotation of barbaros from later moral meanings.
    Show all 30 objectives
    1. Define a binary opposition and give one example from the Greek world view.
    2. Identify which term is privileged in each of the pairs Greek/foreigner, man/woman and slave/free.
    3. Evaluate the limits of binary frameworks using specific evidence.
    4. Explain the original meaning of barbaros and how it came to carry wider cultural connotations.
    5. Identify recurring stereotypes of foreign peoples in named classical Greek sources.
    6. Evaluate how these depictions shape Greek self-definition, using named evidence.
    7. Describe the costume, headgear and posture typically used to mark foreigners in Greek art.
    8. Compare Greek and foreign figures in named images using precise visual vocabulary.
    9. Evaluate whether artistic conventions reveal Greek attitudes rather than foreign reality.
    10. Identify a specific foreign custom described in a Greek text.
    11. Explain the Greek norm against which the custom is presented as different.
    12. Evaluate what the contrast reveals about Greek assumptions and the author's perspective.
    13. Identify a quality of character attributed to a non-Greek people in a Greek text.
    14. Explain the cause the text gives for that quality.
    15. Evaluate what the attribution does for the Greek author's argument.
    16. Identify the political system or social hierarchy attributed to a non-Greek people in a given source.
    17. Explain how a Greek writer uses political contrast to define Greek identity.
    18. Evaluate whether a description of hierarchy reflects the author's assumptions.
    19. Identify at least two religious beliefs or rituals attributed to a non-Greek people in a given source.
    20. Explain how a Greek author frames a foreign ritual in relation to Greek practice.
    21. Distinguish between religious belief and ritual practice in a source.
    22. Explains what historical context means in relation to the barbarian image.
    23. Selects and links at least two distinct historical contexts to features of the image.
    24. Evaluates how far the image reflects real encounters compared with inherited assumptions.
    25. Explains how the Persian wars sharpened existing images of Persians and other foreign peoples.
    26. Links at least two specific war events to particular features of the image.
    27. Evaluates the extent to which the wars created rather than reinforced these images.

    Invention of the Barbarian (H408/23) - Greeks and barbarians exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Defines barbaros as a term traditionally explained as sound-based, imitating unintelligible speech.
    • Explains that the earliest sense concerns language rather than moral or cultural inferiority.
    • Cites Iliad 2.867 and the word barbarophonoi as evidence of pre-Classical usage.
    • Distinguishes the early linguistic connotation from later moral and cultural meanings.
    • Keeps evidence within the pre-Classical period and does not project Classical attitudes onto Homer.
    • Defines a binary opposition as a pair of contrasting terms in which one term is privileged over the other.
    • Explains how Greek/foreigner defined Greek identity by contrast with non-Greeks.
    • Shows how man/woman and slave/free applied a similar hierarchical logic within Greek society.
    • Links the binary structure to the wider construction of the barbarian as the excluded other.
    • Assesses the limits of the framework by noting where real individuals and practices did not fit neatly.
    • Explains that barbaros originally described people whose speech seemed unintelligible to Greeks, and that the label later carried wider cultural meaning.
    • Identifies recurring contrasts, such as excess against moderation and servility against freedom, and links each contrast to a named source.
    • Distinguishes general stereotypes from the particular features a given author stresses for a given people.
    • Evaluates how the depiction supports a Greek sense of self-definition by setting Greeks against an opposing group.
    • Identifies costume, headgear and facial hair as the main visual markers that separate foreigners from Greeks.
    • Describes the contrast between nudity or hoplite armour for Greeks and trousers or patterned dress for foreigners.
    • Explains how battle scenes use posture and expression to set composed Greeks against fearful or fleeing foreigners.
    • Recognises that these depictions are conventions shaped by artistic and ideological purposes rather than neutral records.
    • Identifies a specific custom, such as a reversed practice described in Herodotus, rather than a general claim about foreigners.
    • States the Greek norm against which the foreign custom is set.
    • Explains what the contrast reveals about Greek self-definition or values.
    • Uses the content of the account as evidence and does not add invented details.
    • Recognises that the account was written by a Greek author and so reflects a Greek perspective.
    • Identifies a specific quality, such as a temperament or inclination, attributed to a foreign people.
    • Explains the cause the text gives for that quality, such as climate, institutions or nature.
    • Distinguishes whether the text presents the quality as innate or as shaped by circumstance.
    • Evaluates what the attribution serves for the Greek speaker, such as justifying Greek rule.
    • Supports the point with a named text and its content, without quotation unless the exact wording is supplied.
    • Identifies the specific power structure, such as monarchy or council rule, attributed to a non-Greek people and states where the source says so.
    • Describes the social ranks in a foreign community and explains how those ranks relate to one another.
    • Explains whether the author presents the political system or hierarchy as admirable, threatening or strange.
    • Uses a precise example from the source to support any claim about authority or rank.
    • Identifies a specific belief, deity or sacred institution attributed to a non-Greek people and states where the source reports it.
    • Describes a ritual practice accurately and explains how the author frames it in relation to Greek custom.
    • Explains whether the author presents the religion or ritual as familiar, strange or inferior.
    • Uses precise terms such as sacrifice, priesthood or festival only where the source supports them.
    • Defines historical context as specific events, power relations and cultural encounters rather than general background.
    • Explains how a named historical circumstance gives a reason for a particular image of a foreign people.
    • Connects each context to a specific feature of the barbarian image, such as language, government or behaviour.
    • Evaluates whether the image reflects real encounters, political needs or inherited Greek cultural assumptions.
    • Recognises that the scare quotes signal the category is a constructed idea rather than an objective fact.
    • Organises the answer into clearly labelled strands of context so the argument is easy to follow.
    • Explains the Persian wars as a catalyst that gave existing images of foreign peoples a sharper and more widely shared form.
    • Uses specific events, such as the battle of Marathon in 490 BC or the expedition of 480–479 BC, as evidence of the effect.
    • Identifies the contrast between free Greeks and subject Persians as a key way the images were fixed.
    • Distinguishes between crystallising existing attitudes and inventing new ones.
    • Evaluates the role of literary sources, such as Herodotus and Aeschylus' Persians, in preserving and shaping the image.
    • Evaluates the limits of the argument, such as pre-war stereotypes or later reworkings of the image.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Define the word first, then explain its connotation in one or two precise sentences.
    • 💡Name the text and location when you use Homer, for example Iliad 2.867.
    • 💡Write one sentence contrasting the early linguistic sense with a later sense to show how the meaning developed.
    • 💡Write each pair as a labelled contrast, then state which side is valued and why.
    • 💡Link each example back to the barbarian to show its relevance to the topic.
    • 💡End with one evaluative sentence on how far the framework explains the evidence.
    • 💡Build each answer around two or three named sources and state what each contributes to the depiction.
    • 💡Use the examples set out in your course, and check the full specification list before revision because this wording ends with a colon.
    • 💡Keep one clear argument per paragraph and link every example back to Greek self-definition.
    • 💡Name the object, its place and its context as set out in your course before describing its imagery.
    • 💡Use precise visual vocabulary: describe costume, pose and gesture rather than giving general impressions.
    • 💡Connect each visual feature to a statement about Greek identity and how viewers would have read it.
    • 💡Name the custom first, then the Greek practice it reverses, so each answer has a clear contrast.
    • 💡Explain the function of the contrast for Greek readers, such as clarifying Greek identity, rather than only restating the description.
    • 💡Check that every claim about a people is tied to the text you have studied and the period it describes.
    • 💡State the quality attributed, then the explanation given, then whether it is presented as fixed or changeable.
    • 💡Link the attribution to its function for the Greek author, such as justifying domination or defining Greek freedom.
    • 💡Keep every claim anchored to a named text and the period you have studied.
    • 💡Write the political structure or rank in one precise phrase before you evaluate it.
    • 💡Label each point as description or judgement so that you can see where the author's assumptions enter.
    • 💡Practise linking every example to a claim about Greek identity so that your answer explains significance, not just content.
    • 💡Keep a short note of each practice, its source and the author's framing before writing your answer.
    • 💡Write one sentence on belief and one on ritual so that the two aspects of the statement are both covered.
    • 💡Use one named example for each point and state what it shows about Greek perceptions of the foreign.
    • 💡Plan two or three distinct strands of context before writing, so the answer covers more than one kind of influence.
    • 💡Use one precise example per strand, such as a named war event or a named ancient author, and explain its effect on the image.
    • 💡Finish with a judgement on how far historical context explains the image compared with other factors, such as literary convention.
    • 💡Name a specific event and date for each point, such as 490 BC or 480–479 BC, and state what it did to the image.
    • 💡Use a source to support each claim, naming the author and work accurately, and explain what the source shows about the image.
    • 💡Weigh the Persian wars against earlier attitudes in your conclusion so that the answer reaches a judgement.
    Common Mistakes
    • Treats barbaros as an insult from the outset; correct this by showing that its earliest sense was descriptive and linguistic.
    • Presents the bar-bar explanation as proven fact; state that it is a traditional explanation and note that it is not certain.
    • Uses fifth-century Classical writers as evidence for pre-Classical ideas; limit your examples to earlier sources such as Homer.
    • Lists the three pairs without explaining which term is privileged; add the hierarchy for each pair.
    • Treats binary oppositions as neutral descriptions; explain that they encoded value judgements about status and identity.
    • Presents the oppositions as a rigid fact applying to every Greek; qualify the claim with evidence of variation and exceptions.
    • Treats all non-Greek peoples as one uniform group; separate Persians, Scythians and Egyptians and note that sources characterise each differently.
    • Presents the stereotypes as an accurate ethnographic record; state that they are constructions shaped by Greek authors' purposes.
    • Reads barbarian only in the modern sense of uncivilised; explain the original sense of a foreign or non-Greek speaker and its later connotations.
    • Treats every foreign figure as Persian; check the inscription, setting or costume before naming a people.
    • Describes the images without linking them to Greek self-image; explain what the contrast says about the Greek viewer.
    • Assumes the image is a reliable ethnographic record; state that it reflects artistic convention and audience expectations.
    • Treats a single anecdote as representative of an entire people; limit the claim to the custom the text actually describes.
    • Describes the foreign custom but omits the Greek norm it contrasts with; add the comparison that gives the description its meaning.
    • Presents the account as neutral ethnography; explain the Greek authorial perspective that shapes the description.
    • Treats attributed character as an objective fact about foreign peoples; explain it as a Greek construct shaped by the author's purpose.
    • Ignores the cause the author gives for the trait and offers only a description; add the explanation the text provides.
    • Assumes all Greek writers shared one view of foreign character; compare the views of the individual texts.
    • Treats one king or council in a source as proof of a whole people's political system; check how far the author generalises before drawing a wider conclusion.
    • Describes a social rank without explaining its place in the order of groups; state how the ranks are arranged and related.
    • Assumes a Greek author's contrast reflects the foreign people's own view; test the contrast against the author's purpose and audience.
    • Treats all foreign religions as a single system; separate the gods, rites and institutions of each people.
    • Reports a ritual without explaining the author's evaluation of it; add how the writer frames the practice.
    • Assumes a description of a foreign ritual is an objective record; consider the author's purpose and any possible distortion.
    • Treats historical context as a list of dates with no explanation; link each date to a specific effect on the image.
    • Assumes the barbarian was a fixed Greek view from the outset; show change and development over time where the evidence allows.
    • Describes foreign peoples in general without naming which groups or sources are involved; name specific examples.
    • Invents sub-points to match the trailing 'including:'; use your own clearly labelled strands of context instead.
    • Assumes the Persian wars created the image of foreign peoples from nothing; explain that they sharpened attitudes already present.
    • Describes the wars as a narrative of events without linking them to how images were fixed; connect each event to a specific effect.
    • Treats all foreign peoples as identical; distinguish the Persians from other groups and explain the particular images attached to each.
    • Uses the term 'barbarian' loosely without explaining its Greek usage; define it as a contrast drawn from Greek language and identity.