Invention of the Barbarian (H408/23) - The Persian Wars and Greek (dis) unity — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation
Invention of the Barbarian (H408/23) - The Persian Wars and Greek (dis) unity explained
Invention of the Barbarian (H408/23) - The Persian Wars and Greek (dis) unity covers 3 specification points, including Relations between Greek poleis (cities) and… and The divisions and unity of the Greeks as….
Read the full explanation
Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
relations between Greek poleis (cities) and attempts to unify the Greeks during this period of conflict
This question asks you to explain how independent poleis (cities) related to one another during the Persian Wars, and how far attempts were made to unify them against the invader. Begin with structure. Each polis was autonomous, so cooperation depended on negotiation rather than central command. Relations ranged from willing alliance to neutrality, submission to Persia and open hostility between Greek states. Attempts at unity included the alliance formed at the Congress of Corinth in 481 BCE, which brought together a number of states with Sparta leading the land forces and Athens providing major naval strength. Consider the disputes over command and contribution that weakened cooperation, such as rivalry between Athens and Sparta. Link each point to a specific event, such as Thermopylae, Salamis or Plataea.
the divisions and unity of the Greeks as reflected in Herodotus’ narrative of key events
This statement asks you to examine how Herodotus portrays Greek divisions and unity during the Persian Wars, using his narrative of key events as evidence. Select events he describes, such as the stand at Thermopylae, the naval actions at Artemisium and Salamis, and the battle of Plataea. For each, identify where Greek states cooperate and where they quarrel, delay or refuse to join. Then analyse how Herodotus presents these patterns: through the choices of states and leaders, through the reported words of other characters, or through his own narrative comments. Support your argument with precise details from the text, and consider whether shared Greek identity appears fragile or strong. Focus on what the narrative reflects rather than on events beyond his account.
varying responses to the Persian threat; poleis (cities) which medised, and those which did not
This statement asks you to understand that Greek poleis did not respond uniformly to the Persian threat: some medised, meaning they submitted to Persian demands, while others resisted or stayed out of the conflict. Medising is a key term. In Herodotus' account it is associated with giving earth and water to Persian envoys, a sign of submission. To answer multiple-choice questions on this topic, learn examples on both sides. Thessaly and Thebes are described by Herodotus as medising states, while Athens, Sparta and Plataea are presented as resisting. Argos is shown as remaining neutral, so it cannot simply be placed among the resisters. Read each option carefully and test it against the narrative, deciding whether the polis is described as submitting, resisting or neutral before choosing your answer.
Your focus
- Explain why independent poleis needed negotiation to cooperate against Persia.
- Identify the Congress of Corinth in 481 BCE and describe its purpose.
- Assess how rivalry between leading states weakened attempts at Greek unity.
Show all 9 objectives
- Identify key Persian Wars events in Herodotus' narrative that show Greek cooperation or division.
- Explain how Herodotus' choice of events and reported speech shapes the presentation of Greek unity.
- Evaluate, with textual evidence, whether Greek identity appears fragile or strong in the narrative.
- Define medising as submission to Persian demands, using Herodotus' account of earth and water.
- Classify named poleis as medising, resisting or neutral according to the narrative.
- Select the correct answer to multiple-choice questions by eliminating options that misclassify a polis.
Invention of the Barbarian (H408/23) - The Persian Wars and Greek (dis) unity exam tips
Marking Points
- Explains the independence of poleis and why cooperation required negotiation rather than central command.
- Describes the range of relations, from alliance and neutrality to medism and open hostility.
- Identifies the Congress of Corinth in 481 BCE as an attempt to unify Greek states against Persia.
- Evaluates disputes over leadership and contribution, such as Athenian and Spartan rivalry, as limits on unity.
- Links relations and unity attempts to specific events such as Thermopylae, Salamis and Plataea.
- Identifies specific events from the narrative that show Greek cooperation, such as the combined naval effort at Artemisium and Salamis.
- Distinguishes between divisions among states, such as refusal to resist or hesitation, and disagreements within alliances over strategy.
- Explains how Herodotus' choice of incidents, speeches or reported debates shapes the picture of unity and division.
- Evaluates whether Herodotus presents shared Greek identity as fragile or durable, supported by textual evidence.
- Connects observations to the course theme of Greek identity set against Persian power, without drifting into events outside the narrative.
- Identifies medising as submission to Persian demands, shown in Herodotus through the giving of earth and water.
- Places Thessaly and Thebes among the poleis that medised in the narrative.
- Places Athens, Sparta and Plataea among the poleis that resisted Persian demands.
- Recognises that Argos is presented as neutral rather than as a resister or a medising state.
- Eliminates options that misclassify a polis, rather than relying on general knowledge of the period.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Read each option for scope words such as 'during this period', and eliminate options describing events after the Persian Wars unless they explain causation.
- 💡Check whether an option describes relations between poleis or only a single state's actions, and match it to the question's focus.
- 💡When two options seem plausible, prefer the one that names a specific attempt at unity or a specific source of disunity.
- 💡Plan three or four events, each showing a different pattern of unity or division, before you start writing.
- 💡Use precise references to what happens and which states or leaders act, so your evidence can be checked.
- 💡Reach a judgement in your conclusion about how fragile or strong Greek unity appears, and justify it with the events you selected.
- 💡Write a quick label beside each polis named in the options: medised, resisted or neutral.
- 💡Watch for options that swap two states, because one misplaced polis makes the whole option wrong.
- 💡When unsure, eliminate options you can rule out with certainty before choosing among the rest.
Common Mistakes
- Describes the Persian Wars as a simple Greek victory without showing the divisions among poleis; include disunity as well as unity.
- Treats all poleis as a single bloc; distinguish alliance members, neutral states and those that sided with Persia.
- Confuses the Congress of Corinth with the later Delian League; keep the answer within the Persian War period unless discussing causation.
- Gives dates without explaining their significance for relations between poleis or for unity.
- Treats all Greek states as united against Persia; correct this by identifying states that medised or stayed neutral in the narrative.
- Describes events in a list without evaluating what they reveal about unity or division; correct this by linking each event to an argument about Herodotus' presentation.
- Relies on modern historical reconstruction beyond the narrative; correct this by keeping evidence tied to what Herodotus reports and noting where his account is partial.
- Attributes speeches or reported opinions to Herodotus directly without identifying who speaks; correct this by naming the character or narrator who reports them.
- Treats every Greek polis as having resisted Persia; correct this by checking each option against the narrative's account of submission or resistance.
- Confuses neutrality with medising, so selects Argos as submitting; correct this by separating states that stayed out of the conflict from those that gave earth and water.
- Assumes Thebes resisted because it was a major city; correct this by recalling that Herodotus presents Thebes as medising.
- Equates medising with simple treachery without the narrative context; correct this by using the term in its precise sense of submission to Persia.