Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Politics of the Late Republic (H408/33) - Cicero and the res publica — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation

    Politics of the Late Republic (H408/33) - Cicero and the res publica explained

    Politics of the Late Republic (H408/33) - Cicero and the res publica covers 15 specification points, including Cicero’s ideas about the ideal state and how… and The role of concordia ordinum (‘agreement of….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    Cicero’s ideas about the ideal state and how it had developed in Rome, including:

    This criterion asks you to explain Cicero's ideas about the ideal state and how that state developed in Rome. Start with his view that the res publica belongs to a people bound by shared law and justice, and that a balanced constitution is best. Cicero draws on Polybius' mixed constitution of monarchy, aristocracy and democracy, applying it to Rome. Trace development in order: the early kings, the founding of the Republic, the Twelve Tables and the late Republican crises. The statement ends with a colon and no further items, so teach only what is listed and check the full specification. Ground answers in De Re Publica and De Legibus, explaining how these ideas respond to the problems of Cicero's day.

    the role of concordia ordinum (‘agreement of the Orders’)

    Concordia ordinum means 'agreement of the Orders', the alliance Cicero promoted between the senatorial order and the equestrian order (equites). Learners must explain its purpose and why Cicero presented it as a foundation for stable government in the res publica. A concrete case is 63 BC, when Cicero as consul drew on both orders against the Catilinarian conspiracy. Method: define the two orders, state the political aim (shared backing for senatorial leadership and protection of equestrian interests), then assess the limits, such as disputes over the jury courts. Focus on Cicero's presentation and political aim, not on a modern class theory.

    the ideal state of affairs as cum dignitate otium (‘peace with dignity’)

    Cum dignitate otium means 'peace with dignity', Cicero's ideal state of affairs: political peace in which the res publica is not torn by violence and the leading citizens keep their standing. Otium means political peace, not idleness, and dignitas means the public standing a citizen earns and must protect. Learners must explain how Cicero linked this ideal to senatorial authority and concord rather than to armed force or popular upheaval. Method: set the ideal against late Republican crises, such as the Catilinarian conspiracy, and identify what Cicero thought would restore it. Assess how realistic the ideal was in the period.

    how actions during his career can be rationalised with his political ideals

    This statement asks you to connect Cicero's career decisions with the political principles he professed, and to judge whether those actions can be rationalised by them. Begin by defining his ideals: the res publica as a shared community, the consensus of the boni, dignitas earned through service to the state, and otium cum dignitate. Then choose specific actions, such as the execution of Catilinarian conspirators without trial in 63 BC, his exile in 58 BC and his later alignment with Pompey. For each action, state the principle it appears to serve and test whether the link is convincing or strained. Strong answers recognise that one ideal can justify contradictory acts, so weigh rationalisation against inconsistency rather than simply labelling Cicero a hypocrite or a consistent defender of the constitution.

    his attempt to reconcile senators and equites in the concordia ordinum and the reasons why this failed

    This statement has two parts: first, Cicero's attempt to bring senators and equites together in the concordia ordinum; second, the reasons why that attempt failed. Explain the aim: after 63 BC Cicero sought to bind the propertied orders into a common front defending the state against disorderly or ambitious leaders, presenting equestrian interests and senatorial authority as compatible. Then analyse failure with evidence. Consider the tension between equestrian financial interests, such as provincial tax contracts, and senatorial resistance to them; the formation of the First Triumvirate in 60 to 59 BC, which drew power away from the Senate's leadership; and the vulnerability of a novus homo whose enemies, including Clodius, could exploit the 58 BC exile. Explain the attempt and the failure together, not as separate descriptions.

    explanation of his relationships with, and attitudes toward:

    This statement asks for an explanation of Cicero's relationships with, and attitudes toward, the people or groups named after the colon in the full published wording. The supplied text stops at the colon, so the missing object must not be guessed; check the complete H408 wording first. Explanation means reasoning about why Cicero held each position, linking it to his aims and the crises of the late Republic. Relationships are dealings, alliances or quarrels, so trace how they shifted. Attitudes are his stated views and underlying values, such as commitment to the res publica.

    the optimates, including Cato

    This statement asks learners to understand the optimates as a group, with Cato as a leading example. The optimates were conservative senators who defended senatorial authority and traditional practice, the mos maiorum. They opposed the populares, who used popular assemblies and tribunician power to back individual leaders. The term was loose in ancient writing, not a formal party. Cato the Younger, active in the first century BC, resisted the alliances of Pompey and Caesar; do not confuse him with Cato the Elder of the second century BC. In 63 BC, the optimate position and Cato's support shaped the Senate's debate over Catiline's conspirators, a key point in Cicero's career.

    the populares, including Clodius and Caesar

    Populares were politicians who claimed to champion the people, usually through the tribunate and popular assemblies. They challenged Senate authority, but the term denotes a loose grouping rather than a formal party. Clodius, tribune in 58 BC, passed legislation that led to Cicero's exile, showing how popular tactics could target an individual. Caesar, consul in 59 BC, used legislation and his alliance with Pompey and Crassus to advance his career. Both men used popular assemblies, but Caesar's ambitions extended to consular office and provincial command in ways Clodius's did not. Learners should explain why each man is grouped as a popularis and note that their aims and methods differed.

    Pompey

    Pompey was a leading military commander whose allegiances in the late Republic shifted between senatorial and popular interests, which makes him hard to categorise. Learners should not assume he was simply a member of the populares or the optimates. He was involved in the First Triumvirate of 60 BC with Caesar and Crassus, an informal private arrangement that worked outside normal senatorial channels. Later he aligned more closely with the Senate and was sole consul in 52 BC, when he passed laws responding to the disorder that followed Clodius's death. Cicero's writings present Pompey in varying ways, so learners should evaluate how his position is described in the source and why. The statement names Pompey alone, so focus on his role within Cicero's period rather than a full biography.

    the ‘first triumvirate’

    Know the ‘first triumvirate’ as an informal alliance formed in 60 BCE by Pompey, Crassus and Julius Caesar, who pooled their influence for their own ends. It had no legal basis or official powers, so it worked through private agreement and political pressure rather than through a magistracy. Learn its date, its members and its informal status. Connect it to Cicero: Caesar's consulship of 59 BCE had triumviral backing, and the tribune Clodius, acting in the triumvirs' interests, secured Cicero's exile in 58 BCE; Cicero's recall followed in 57 BCE. The word ‘first’ separates this arrangement from the second triumvirate of 43 BCE, which is later context only and must not replace the late Republic focus.

    Catiline

    Know Catiline (Lucius Sergius Catilina) as the aristocrat whose conspiracy against the Republic in 63 BCE became the central crisis of Cicero's consulship. Catiline had been defeated in electoral bids and was linked to plans for violence and to a group of disaffected men in Rome. Cicero, as consul, exposed the plot and spoke in the Senate, including the First Catilinarian, after which Catiline left Rome. Learn that the Senate's response against the leading conspirators, Lentulus and Cethegus among them, was carried out on 5 December 63 BCE without a trial, and that this decision later made Cicero vulnerable to attack. Catiline himself died in battle in 62 BCE at Pistoria. Use Cicero's speeches and Sallust's later account with care, weighing their bias.

    the provinces

    The phrase 'the provinces' names one topic within Cicero and the res publica, so treat it as a prompt to consider how overseas provinces shaped Cicero's political thinking and career. Cicero met provincial government directly. In 70 BC he prosecuted Verres, former governor of Sicily, for extortion, arguing that corrupt governors harmed provincials and damaged Rome's credibility. In 51–50 BC he governed Cilicia, where he managed provincial finances, frontier threats and relations with allied communities. For any provincial point, state the province, the governor or actor, the problem and the link to the wider res publica. Keep examples dated and specific, and never treat the provinces as one uniform category.

    land reform

    'Land reform' names a theme within Cicero and the res publica, so treat it as a question about how Roman land distribution was debated and how Cicero responded. Land reform meant proposals to redistribute public land, ager publicus, to poorer citizens. The Gracchi's reforms of 133 and 123–122 BC framed later debate. In 63 BC the tribune Publius Servilius Rullus proposed an agrarian bill giving a commission of ten men extensive powers, and Cicero opposed it in three speeches, De lege agraria. For any reform, identify the proposal, its supporters and critics, the powers granted, and Cicero's arguments about property and order. Keep Caesar's 59 BC law separate.

    the Civil War between Pompey and Caesar

    The statement concerns the Civil War between Pompey and Caesar, fought from 49 BCE until 45 BCE. Learn the sequence: Caesar crossed the Rubicon in January 49 BCE, Pompey was defeated at Pharsalus in 48 BCE, and the remaining resistance ended at Thapsus in 46 BCE and Munda in 45 BCE. For Cicero and the res publica, the war matters because it forced senators to choose sides and tested whether constitutional government could survive. Use Cicero's letters and speeches as evidence of how he judged both leaders, remembering that they are partisan. A strong answer links military events to political consequences, such as Caesar's clemency towards Cicero after Pharsalus and the concentration of power that followed.

    Mark Antony

    The statement names Mark Antony, Caesar's loyal lieutenant and a central figure after Caesar's death. Learn his role in sequence: he spoke at Caesar's funeral in March 44 BCE, then clashed with Cicero, whose Philippics attacked him. Antony's campaign against Decimus Brutus at Mutina in 43 BCE and the Second Triumvirate with Octavian and Lepidus, formed in November 43 BCE, led to the proscriptions, in which Cicero was killed in December 43 BCE. Treat the Philippics as partisan: they are Cicero's attacks, not neutral reports. Strong answers explain Antony's position in relation to Caesar's legacy and the Republic's collapse, not just his dates.

    Your focus

    1. Explain Cicero's view of the ideal state, using his own works as evidence.
    2. Trace how Cicero interprets the development of the Roman state from its early history to the late Republic.
    3. Evaluate how far Cicero's ideas respond to the political problems of his day.
    Show all 45 objectives
    1. Define the senatorial and equestrian orders in the context of Cicero's politics.
    2. Explain Cicero's aim in promoting concordia ordinum with reference to 63 BC.
    3. Evaluate the limits of the alliance between the two orders.
    4. Explain the meaning of otium and dignitas in the phrase cum dignitate otium.
    5. Explain how Cicero linked this ideal to senatorial authority and concord.
    6. Evaluate how realistic the ideal was in the late Republic.
    7. Identify the political ideals Cicero professed and explain their meaning in the late Republic.
    8. Evaluate how specific actions from Cicero's career can or cannot be rationalised by those ideals.
    9. Assess the strength of competing judgements about Cicero's consistency and reach a supported conclusion.
    10. Explain the aims behind Cicero's attempt to reconcile senators and equites in the concordia ordinum.
    11. Analyse the sources of conflict between the senatorial and equestrian orders in the late Republic.
    12. Evaluate the reasons why the concordia ordinum failed and justify which reason was most significant.
    13. Identify the complete published object of the statement from the specification text
    14. Construct a dated timeline of Cicero's relationships and attitudes within the section
    15. Explain the reasons behind a chosen change in Cicero's stance, using specific evidence
    16. Define the term optimates in a source-grounded sentence
    17. Identify Cato the Younger as a leading optimate and distinguish him from Cato the Elder
    18. Select the correct option in an MCQ by testing each choice against the definition of optimates
    19. Define populares and explain how they differed from a formal party.
    20. Identify the offices and key dated events associated with Clodius and Caesar.
    21. Compare the methods and aims of Clodius and Caesar using specific evidence.
    22. Identify the main dated events in Pompey's career that relate to Cicero's period.
    23. Explain how the First Triumvirate and the sole consulship of 52 BC shaped Pompey's political position.
    24. Evaluate how Cicero's portrayal of Pompey influences the historical judgement of his role.
    25. Identify the members and date of the first triumvirate.
    26. Explain why the alliance was informal and held no official magisterial powers.
    27. Link the first triumvirate to the events of Cicero's exile and recall.
    28. Identify Catiline's conspiracy and its date within Cicero's consulship.
    29. Explain how Cicero responded to the conspiracy in the Senate.
    30. Describe the consequences of the executions of 5 December 63 BCE for Cicero.
    31. Identify Verres' governorship of Sicily and his 70 BC prosecution as an example of provincial extortion.
    32. Explain Cicero's responsibilities as governor of Cilicia in 51–50 BC.
    33. Distinguish between individual provinces and the provincial system when answering a multiple-choice question.
    34. Identify the Gracchan reforms of 133 and 123–122 BC as earlier context for late Republican land debates.
    35. Explain the proposal and powers of Rullus' 63 BC agrarian bill.
    36. Distinguish Rullus' bill from Caesar's 59 BC agrarian law when answering a multiple-choice question.
    37. Sequence the key battles of the civil war between 49 and 45 BCE.
    38. Explain how the war forced Cicero to make political choices.
    39. Evaluate the partisan nature of Cicero's accounts of Pompey and Caesar.
    40. Sequence Antony's key actions between 44 and 43 BCE.
    41. Explain how Antony's conflict with Cicero shaped the end of Cicero's career.
    42. Evaluate the partisan nature of the Philippics as evidence.

    Politics of the Late Republic (H408/33) - Cicero and the res publica exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Explains Cicero's view of the res publica as a shared community bound by law and justice.
    • Identifies the mixed constitution as Cicero's preferred form and explains how its elements balance one another.
    • Traces the development of the Roman state in order, from the early kings to the late Republic.
    • Connects Cicero's ideas to the political problems of his own time rather than treating them as abstract theory.
    • Uses Cicero's own works, such as De Re Publica and De Legibus, as evidence for his views.
    • Defines the two orders as the senatorial order and the equestrian order, not as a general 'people'.
    • Explains concordia ordinum as cooperation between senators and equites for the stability of the res publica.
    • Links the ideal to Cicero's consulship in 63 BC and the Catilinarian conspiracy as a dated example.
    • Evaluates the limits of the alliance, such as disputes over the jury courts and rivalry between individuals.
    • Maintains focus on Cicero's presentation of the ideal rather than asserting it as a neutral historical fact.
    • Defines otium as political peace and freedom from civil strife rather than leisure or idleness.
    • Explains dignitas as the public standing a citizen earns and must protect within the res publica.
    • Links the ideal to senatorial authority and concord as the means of securing it.
    • Relates the ideal to late Republican crises, such as the Catilinarian conspiracy, as the context it addresses.
    • Assesses how realistic the ideal was given the political violence of the period.
    • Defines Cicero's ideals precisely, such as the res publica, the consensus of the boni and dignitas, before testing actions against them.
    • Selects specific actions, such as the 63 BC executions, the 58 BC exile and the alignment with Pompey, and states the principle each is said to serve.
    • Evaluates whether each rationalisation is convincing or strained rather than asserting consistency.
    • Recognises that one ideal can justify contradictory acts and weighs this against charges of inconsistency.
    • Reaches a supported judgement on the extent to which Cicero's career can be rationalised by his ideals.
    • Explains the purpose of the concordia ordinum as Cicero presented it, linking it to the defence of the state against disorder.
    • Identifies points of common interest and conflict between senators and equites, such as provincial tax contracts and control of the law courts.
    • Explains why the attempt failed, distinguishing structural conflict between the orders from the political impact of the First Triumvirate.
    • Assesses how Cicero's own vulnerability after 63 BC, particularly the 58 BC exile, weakened his capacity to lead the orders.
    • Weighs the reasons against each other and reaches a judgement on which was most significant.
    • Identifies the optimates as the conservative senatorial grouping that defended senatorial authority and traditional practice.
    • Recognises Cato the Younger as a leading optimate, noted for rigid adherence to the mos maiorum and opposition to Pompey and Caesar.
    • Distinguishes the optimates from the populares, who used popular assemblies and tribunician power to back individual leaders.
    • Links Cicero's alignment with optimate views to the Senate's debate over Catiline's conspirators in 63 BC.
    • Notes that optimates was a loose term in ancient writing rather than a formal party with written rules or fixed membership.
    • Defines populares as politicians who appealed to popular support through assemblies and the tribunate.
    • Distinguishes a loose grouping of politicians from a formal party with a fixed programme.
    • Identifies Clodius's tribunate of 58 BC and the exile of Cicero as evidence of popular tactics.
    • Explains Caesar's consulship of 59 BC and his alliance with Pompey and Crassus.
    • Evaluates the use of the label populares in Cicero's writings as a judgement that needs testing against other evidence.
    • Identifies Pompey's shifting relationships with senatorial and popular groups between 60 and 52 BC.
    • Explains the First Triumvirate of 60 BC as an informal alliance with Caesar and Crassus.
    • Links Pompey's sole consulship of 52 BC to the response to disorder after Clodius's death.
    • Evaluates how Cicero's portrayal of Pompey affects the reliability of the evidence used to judge him.
    • Identifies the alliance as Pompey, Crassus and Julius Caesar acting together in 60 BCE.
    • Explains that the arrangement was informal and held no official constitutional office.
    • Links the alliance to Caesar's consulship of 59 BCE and to the political pressure on Cicero.
    • Distinguishes the first triumvirate from the second triumvirate of 43 BCE and treats the later one as context only.
    • Identifies Catiline as the leader of a conspiracy against the Republic in 63 BCE.
    • Places the conspiracy within Cicero's consulship and his response in the Senate.
    • Explains that the executions of the leading conspirators on 5 December 63 BCE were carried out without a trial.
    • Recognises that Catiline died in battle at Pistoria in 62 BCE.
    • Identifies Verres' governorship of Sicily and the 70 BC prosecution as an example of provincial extortion.
    • Explains how Cicero's governorship of Cilicia in 51–50 BC shows his administrative responsibilities in the provinces.
    • Links provincial misgovernment to wider concerns about the authority and reputation of the res publica.
    • Distinguishes between individual provinces and the provincial system as a whole, naming each province separately.
    • Identifies the Gracchan reforms of 133 and 123–122 BC as earlier context for later land debates.
    • Explains what Rullus' 63 BC bill proposed, including the commission of ten and the powers it would hold.
    • Evaluates Cicero's objections to the bill, linking them to concerns about concentrated power and the res publica.
    • Distinguishes between Rullus' 63 BC proposal and Caesar's 59 BC agrarian law by date, proposer and purpose.
    • Identifies the war as a conflict fought from 49 BCE to 45 BCE between Pompey and Caesar.
    • Places the defeat at Pharsalus in 48 BCE as the decisive defeat of Pompey's forces, with Pompey's death in Egypt following that year.
    • Sequences the later campaigns at Thapsus in 46 BCE and Munda in 45 BCE to show the end of organised resistance.
    • Links the war to Cicero's choices, such as his position among Pompey's supporters and his later return under Caesar's clemency.
    • Distinguishes Cicero's private letters from his public speeches when assessing his judgement of the two leaders.
    • Identifies Antony as Caesar's loyal lieutenant whose actions after 44 BCE shaped the politics of the Republic's final years.
    • Places Antony's speech at Caesar's funeral in March 44 BCE as an early stage of his conflict with Cicero.
    • Connects the Philippics to Cicero's opposition, recognising them as partisan attacks rather than neutral reports.
    • Sequences the Mutina campaign of 43 BCE, the Second Triumvirate of November 43 BCE and Cicero's death in December 43 BCE.
    • Explains how the proscriptions of the Triumvirate removed Cicero from political life.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Name Cicero's works and state which idea each one supports, so that your evidence is precise.
    • 💡Organise the answer around the ideal state first, then the historical development, to keep the argument clear.
    • 💡Check the full published specification for any further items, because this statement's list is incomplete here.
    • 💡Open by defining both orders, then state Cicero's political aim in one clear sentence.
    • 💡Use 63 BC and the Catilinarian conspiracy as a dated example to anchor your explanation.
    • 💡Finish with a judgement on the limits of the ideal, citing one specific source of tension.
    • 💡Begin by translating both key terms and explaining their political meaning in Cicero's usage.
    • 💡Set the ideal against one specific late Republican crisis to show what it was reacting to.
    • 💡Close with a judgement on how realistic the ideal was, supported by named evidence from the period.
    • 💡Plan two or three actions before writing, and for each note the ideal you will link it to.
    • 💡Use precise terms such as res publica, boni and dignitas, and explain what each meant to Cicero rather than using them as labels.
    • 💡Finish with a judgement that states the extent of rationalisation, for example 'largely but not wholly', and justify it with the strongest counter-evidence you have considered.
    • 💡Separate the two parts of the statement in your plan, and allocate your argument to both the attempt and the failure.
    • 💡Use specific evidence about the orders' interests, such as the tax contracts and the courts, rather than general claims about 'the rich'.
    • 💡Conclude by ranking the reasons for failure and justifying your ranking with reference to the period 63 to 58 BC.
    • 💡Copy the complete published wording of the statement from the specification before creating your study plan.
    • 💡Make a two-column grid headed Relationships and Attitudes, and add dated evidence and a reason to each entry.
    • 💡After each study session, write one sentence explaining why a position changed, and check it against your timeline.
    • 💡Before reading the options, define the optimates in one line and use that definition to test each choice.
    • 💡Read every option in full, eliminating any that describe the populares or a different period.
    • 💡Check dates against the section, keeping the late Republic and Cicero's career in view.
    • 💡Name the office held by each figure and its date before writing about their methods.
    • 💡Explain what the label populares tells the reader and what it may conceal, rather than treating it as a neutral description.
    • 💡Support each claim about a popularis with one specific event, law or office, such as Clodius's tribunate in 58 BC.
    • 💡Place each event involving Pompey in a date sequence so that changes in his alignment are clear.
    • 💡Explain how a source's account of Pompey may be shaped by its author's own position.
    • 💡Use the sole consulship of 52 BC as a concrete example when discussing his relationship with the Senate.
    • 💡Learn the three named members and the date 60 BCE together so you can recall them quickly in a multiple-choice item.
    • 💡When an option describes a formal office or law, check whether it matches the informal character of the alliance before selecting it.
    • 💡Keep the word ‘first’ in mind and reject options that describe the 43 BCE arrangement unless the question explicitly asks about the later period.
    • 💡Memorise the key dates, 63 BCE for the conspiracy and 62 BCE for Catiline's death, and check each option against them.
    • 💡Link Catiline to Cicero's consulship in every answer, since the course focuses on Cicero and the res publica.
    • 💡When an option refers to the trial or execution of conspirators, check whether it describes the executions of 5 December 63 BCE accurately.
    • 💡Attach a specific date and province to every point, because multiple-choice options often differ only in dates or locations.
    • 💡Before selecting an answer, check each option against the sequence of Cicero's career to rule out chronologically impossible choices.
    • 💡Keep the link to the res publica explicit in your reasoning so that you can recognise options that describe provincial matters without political significance.
    • 💡Give the date and proposer of each land measure in your answer, since multiple-choice distractors often swap these details.
    • 💡When an option names Cicero, check whether it describes his opposition to Rullus, not general support for reform.
    • 💡Eliminate any option that places the Gracchi after 63 BC before choosing an answer.
    • 💡Memorise the key dates in order (49, 48, 46 and 45 BCE) so that you can place each option in sequence quickly.
    • 💡When an option names a battle, check it against Pharsalus, Thapsus and Munda before selecting it.
    • 💡Eliminate options that describe Pompey as winning at Pharsalus, since Caesar won that battle.
    • 💡Memorise the order of the March 44 BCE funeral, the 43 BCE Mutina campaign, the November 43 BCE Triumvirate and Cicero's death in December 43 BCE.
    • 💡Check each option against Antony's role after Caesar's death, rejecting options that present him as Caesar's opponent during the civil war.
    • 💡Identify which source a claim comes from before accepting it, because Cicero's Philippics present a hostile view of Antony.
    Common Mistakes
    • Treats Cicero's ideal state as a democracy, missing its mixed balance of monarchy, aristocracy and democracy.
    • Describes Rome's history as a list of events, without explaining how Cicero interprets its development.
    • Presents Cicero's ideas as purely theoretical, ignoring how they respond to late Republican crises.
    • Treats the orders as modern social classes locked in class conflict; correct by describing them as the senatorial and equestrian orders within Roman political life.
    • Presents concordia ordinum as a permanent, settled reality; correct by noting it was an ideal Cicero promoted in a contested political period.
    • Describes the equites as a single unified bloc; correct by recognising that members of the equestrian order had differing interests.
    • Translates otium as idleness or retirement; correct by using political peace free from disorder.
    • Treats cum dignitate otium as a description of actual conditions in the 60s BC; correct by presenting it as Cicero's ideal that the period did not yet achieve.
    • Reduces dignitas to personal pride; correct by linking it to public standing within the res publica.
    • Lists Cicero's career chronologically with no link to his political principles; relate each action to a named ideal.
    • Treats Cicero's ideals as fixed across his career; show how the same principle was applied to different situations and where its application shifted.
    • Declares Cicero simply hypocritical or simply consistent without evidence; weigh the evidence on both sides before reaching a justified judgement.
    • Describes the concordia ordinum as a single achieved alliance; explain it as an aspiration that was only partly realised.
    • Gives the failure one cause, such as Caesar alone; set out several connected reasons and explain how they interacted.
    • Attributes the 58 BC exile to the breakdown of concordia alone; identify Clodius as the tribune who prosecuted Cicero under a law targeting those who had executed citizens without trial.
    • Assumes the missing object and plans revision around a guessed list of names; check the full published wording in the specification instead.
    • Lists facts about Cicero without explaining why his relationships or attitudes arose; add the cause, purpose or circumstance for each point.
    • Treats relationships and attitudes as one undifferentiated narrative; separate dealings with others from his stated views and values.
    • Presents Cicero's stance as fixed across his career; trace how his positions changed in response to events.
    • Treats the optimates as a formal political party with a written programme; correct this by describing them as a loose senatorial grouping.
    • Confuses Cato the Younger, an optimate of the first century BC, with Cato the Elder, a figure of the second century BC; check the date before selecting an option.
    • Assumes every optimate opposed Cicero at every stage; correct this by checking the specific year and the evidence for that moment.
    • Selects an option that names a famous senator without checking whether that person was an optimate; test each option against the definition first.
    • Treats populares as a formal political party; correct this by describing them as a loose grouping with shared methods.
    • Assumes every popularis pursued the same reforms; correct this by comparing the methods and aims of Clodius and Caesar.
    • Presents Clodius and Caesar as identical figures; correct this by noting their different offices, careers and goals.
    • Classifies Pompey as a straightforward popularis; correct this by showing his changing alignments with the Senate.
    • Treats the First Triumvirate as an official magistracy; correct this by describing it as a private political arrangement.
    • Assumes Pompey's position stayed constant across the period; correct this by tracing his changes with dated events.
    • Treats the triumvirate as an official magistracy; correct this by stating that it was an informal private alliance with no legal powers.
    • Confuses the first triumvirate with the second of 43 BCE, which included Octavian, Antony and Lepidus; correct this by checking the date and members before answering.
    • Names Cicero as a member of the alliance; correct this by recognising that Cicero was a target of its influence and was not one of its three members.
    • Treats Catiline as a consul who held office during the conspiracy; correct this by recalling that Cicero was the consul in 63 BCE and Catiline was a defeated candidate.
    • Places Catiline's death in 63 BCE; correct this by dating his death to 62 BCE at Pistoria.
    • Describes Cicero's Catilinarian speeches as neutral reports; correct this by noting that they are partisan accounts that present Cicero's case.
    • Treats the provinces as one uniform category, ignoring the different problems of Sicily and Cilicia; name each province and its specific issue.
    • Places Verres in the Gracchan period, which is incorrect because he governed Sicily in 73–71 BC, before the 70 BC trial; check each date against the sequence of events.
    • Describes Cicero's Cilicia governorship as a prosecution, which confuses his administrative role with his legal work; keep governing and prosecuting as separate activities.
    • Treats all land reform as a single policy, merging the Gracchi, Rullus and Caesar; separate each proposal by date and aim.
    • Presents Cicero as a supporter of land redistribution, which misrepresents his 63 BC stance; state that he opposed Rullus' bill.
    • Places the Gracchi's reforms within Cicero's own career, which is incorrect because they predate it; treat them as earlier context.
    • Treats the war as beginning at Pharsalus; the conflict opens with Caesar's crossing of the Rubicon in 49 BCE.
    • Presents Caesar's victory as an immediate end to the Republic; the sources show a sequence of campaigns that ended resistance over several years.
    • Accepts Cicero's judgement of Pompey as neutral fact; his letters and speeches are partisan and must be evaluated as such.
    • Treats Antony as Caesar's enemy from the Rubicon onwards; his loyalty to Caesar is central to his early career.
    • Places the Second Triumvirate before Caesar's assassination; it was formed after Caesar's death, in November 43 BCE.
    • Presents the Philippics as an objective record of Antony's conduct; they must be assessed as Cicero's partisan speeches.