Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Politics of the Late Republic (H408/33) - Cicero as orator: In Verrem 1 — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation

    Politics of the Late Republic (H408/33) - Cicero as orator: In Verrem 1 explained

    Politics of the Late Republic (H408/33) - Cicero as orator: In Verrem 1 covers 5 specification points, including The courtroom setting, partial delivery and… and The form, structure and style of Roman legal….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    the courtroom setting, partial delivery and subsequent publication of the Verrine speeches

    This clause asks you to explain the courtroom setting of Cicero's prosecution of Gaius Verres for extortion as governor of Sicily in 70 BCE, and how the speeches later reached readers. The speech In Verrem 1 belongs to the first stage of the case, the actio prima, which was delivered in court. Verres went into exile before the full trial, so the planned second action was never spoken to a jury. Cicero's material was instead prepared as written texts and published, meaning the set reflects partial delivery followed by revision. Use a clear method: identify the stage of proceedings, separate what the court heard from what was published, and assess how publication shaped the message for a wider readership.

    the form, structure and style of Roman legal oratory including devices such as anaphora, apostrophe, tricolon, and hyperbole

    This clause asks you to analyse how Cicero's prosecution speech is built and written, covering its form and structure as a Roman legal speech and its stylistic devices. Forensic oratory typically moved through an opening, a statement of facts, an argument that proved guilt, and a closing appeal, so identify which stage a passage belongs to. Within each stage, locate the devices and explain their effect. Anaphora repeats a word at the start of successive clauses to build emphasis. Apostrophe turns from the jury to address an absent person or abstraction directly. Tricolon groups three parallel items, often rising in force. Hyperbole exaggerates to make the charge seem grave. A strong answer names the device, identifies where it occurs in the text, and links it to persuading the jury that Verres deserved condemnation.

    the ways in which the speech is typical of Roman rhetorical practice

    This criterion asks how In Verrem 1 follows the conventions of Roman forensic oratory. Map the speech's structure first: an opening that builds Cicero's credibility, a statement of the charges and a section that answers the defence in advance. Then test features such as exempla, appeals to the jury's duty, antithesis, rhetorical questions and emotive language against Roman practice. Explain what each achieves in this prosecution, for example how Cicero casts himself as champion of the provincials rather than a rival seeking personal glory. Build a sustained argument rather than a list, linking every feature to its effect on the jury and to the expectations of a Roman courtroom.

    the themes of corruption, justice and the necessity of upholding the state

    This criterion asks you to trace corruption, justice and the necessity of upholding the state through In Verrem 1. Start with corruption: how Cicero presents Verres's abuse of office in Sicily and its harm to provincials. Next, examine justice, both as the outcome Cicero demands and as a standard the court must meet. Then show how Cicero links these to the state, arguing that punishing a corrupt magistrate protects the authority of Roman government. Ground each point in the speech itself, and build a sustained argument on how each theme persuades the jury. Keep later events as labelled causal context only.

    his portrayal of Verres and his corruption, and how this is created

    This criterion asks you to analyse how Cicero portrays Verres and his corruption in In Verrem 1, and how that portrayal is created. Start by identifying the charges, such as extortion from Sicilian communities and the removal of valuable works of art. Portrayal is built through characterisation: Cicero presents Verres's conduct and associates against the standards expected of a Roman governor. Key methods include vivid narrative of individual acts, contrast with the provincials Verres harmed, emotive language and the use of witnesses. Show how these methods combine to make corruption seem systematic, supporting each point with close reference to the speech.

    Your focus

    1. Identify the stage of the prosecution at which In Verrem 1 was delivered.
    2. Explain how the courtroom setting and partial delivery affect the way the Verrine speeches should be read.
    3. Assess how publication shaped the audience and political message of the Verrine speeches.
    Show all 15 objectives
    1. Identify anaphora, apostrophe, tricolon and hyperbole in a passage from In Verrem 1.
    2. Describe how the form and structure of a Roman legal speech organise Cicero's argument.
    3. Explain how stylistic devices contribute to the persuasive effect of the speech.
    4. Identify at least three rhetorical features of In Verrem 1 with reference to its sections.
    5. Explain how each feature contributes to Cicero's persuasive aim in the prosecution of Verres.
    6. Evaluate the extent to which the speech follows Roman rhetorical conventions.
    7. Identify passages in In Verrem 1 that present corruption, justice and the state.
    8. Explain how Cicero uses each theme to persuade the jury.
    9. Evaluate how the three themes combine to support the prosecution of Verres.
    10. Identify the charges of corruption that Cicero makes against Verres in In Verrem 1.
    11. Explain how Cicero's rhetorical techniques create his portrayal of Verres.
    12. Evaluate the effect of this portrayal on the persuasiveness of Cicero's prosecution.

    Politics of the Late Republic (H408/33) - Cicero as orator: In Verrem 1 exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies the prosecution as a trial for extortion heard before a jury in a Roman court, not a private or ceremonial occasion.
    • Places In Verrem 1 within the first stage of the case, the actio prima, which was delivered in court.
    • Explains that the planned second action was not delivered to a jury, so the wider set reached readers through publication.
    • Distinguishes between material the court heard and material Cicero revised and released as written texts.
    • Explains how publication allowed the speeches to address a readership beyond the jury, shaping their political message.
    • Identifies the typical stages of Roman forensic speech, such as opening, statement of facts, argument and closing appeal, and places passages within them.
    • Explains anaphora as repetition of a word at the start of successive clauses, and states the emphasis it creates.
    • Explains apostrophe as a turn to address an absent person or abstraction, and links it to heightening the charge.
    • Describes tricolon as three parallel items that build force, and explains how this supports the argument.
    • Explains hyperbole as deliberate exaggeration used to make Verres's conduct appear graver to the jury.
    • Identifies specific rhetorical features in the speech and explains how each one works on the jury.
    • Links each feature to recognised Roman forensic practice rather than describing it in isolation.
    • Explains how Cicero's self-presentation, such as his claim to speak for the provincials, supports the prosecution.
    • Evaluates how the speech's structure answers the defence's likely objections in advance.
    • Uses accurate reference to the speech's sections without relying on memorised quotation.
    • Identifies passages where Cicero presents Verres's conduct as corrupt and explains the harm done to provincials.
    • Explains how Cicero frames justice as both the outcome for the Sicilians and a standard the court must uphold.
    • Explains how Cicero connects punishing a corrupt magistrate with the authority of the Roman state.
    • Shows how the three themes work together to strengthen the prosecution rather than treating them separately.
    • Supports each theme with accurate reference to sections of the speech without relying on memorised quotation.
    • Identifies the specific charges Cicero brings against Verres and links each charge to the evidence he presents in the speech.
    • Explains how Cicero characterises Verres through his conduct, greed and associates rather than through general abuse alone.
    • Analyses the contrast between Verres and the Sicilian provincials to show the human cost of his corruption.
    • Evaluates how narrative, emotive language and the use of witnesses build an impression of systematic corruption.
    • Connects the portrayal to Cicero's prosecution aim of persuading the jury of Verres's guilt.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Begin by stating which stage of the proceedings a speech belongs to, then link that stage to the speech's purpose.
    • 💡Use the fact of partial delivery as evidence when discussing who Cicero was addressing at any point in the speeches.
    • 💡Support any claim about publication by explaining what changed between the spoken case and the written text.
    • 💡Name each device, identify where it occurs in the text, and explain its effect on the jury in the same sentence.
    • 💡Place each passage within a stage of the speech so that your analysis of style is linked to structure.
    • 💡Keep your analysis focused on persuasion, showing how each device helps Cicero's argument against Verres.
    • 💡Open with a clear claim about how the speech is typical of Roman practice, then support it with two or three specific features.
    • 💡Use a consistent pattern for each point: name the feature, give an example from the speech, then explain its effect on the jury.
    • 💡Address both conventional features and any ways the speech departs from them, so your judgement is visible.
    • 💡Begin with a precise claim about how Cicero uses corruption, justice and the state together, then test it against the speech.
    • 💡Use sections of the speech as anchors for each theme so your reference is accurate and checkable.
    • 💡Explain the persuasive purpose of each theme for the jury, rather than only identifying that it appears.
    • 💡Plan by sorting your evidence into charges, methods and effects, so that each paragraph analyses one clear method.
    • 💡Refer to the passages you use by the section or reference your course materials provide, and name the feature you are analysing in each one.
    • 💡Finish each point by stating how the portrayal serves the prosecution, so your answer addresses how as well as what.
    Common Mistakes
    • Assumes every Verrine speech was spoken to the jury; correct this by separating delivered material from prepared and published material.
    • Treats publication as irrelevant to meaning; correct this by explaining how revision and wide circulation shaped Cicero's political message.
    • Confuses the stages of the prosecution; correct this by placing each passage within the actio prima or the unspoken second action.
    • Labels any repeated word as anaphora; correct this by requiring repetition at the start of successive clauses.
    • Calls any address to the audience apostrophe; correct this by requiring a turn to an absent person or abstraction.
    • Treats every list of items as a tricolon; correct this by requiring three parallel items that build effect.
    • Presents hyperbole as factual reporting; correct this by explaining the exaggeration and its persuasive purpose.
    • Lists rhetorical devices without explaining their purpose in this prosecution; explain the effect on the jury for each device.
    • Treats rhetoric as decoration and ignores its role in persuading the court; link each feature to the argument it advances.
    • Assumes all Roman speeches share one fixed format; recognise the broad conventions and show how this speech applies or adapts them.
    • Presents a memorised quotation with no link to the point; quote only where the wording is secure and analyse it directly.
    • Treats corruption as a personal failing of Verres alone and ignores its effect on provincial communities; link the theme to the harm done to the Sicilians.
    • Describes justice only as punishment and misses its role as a standard the court itself must meet.
    • Introduces later Roman events as if they were part of the speech; separate them clearly as causal context.
    • Discusses the three themes in isolation with no argument about how they combine; connect each theme to the prosecution's overall case.
    • Treats Verres as a stock villain and lists insults without showing how Cicero constructs the portrait.
    • Describes the charges without explaining the methods Cicero uses to make them convincing.
    • Relies on paraphrase of events and never evaluates how Cicero's choices of presentation shape the reader's response.