Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions; considering contemporary and potential future scenarios from different perspectives, such as ethics and the environment — Eduqas GCSE Design and Technology

    How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions; considering contemporary and potential future scenarios from different perspectives, such as ethics and the environment explained

    This topic focuses on the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies to inform design decisions, specifically considering contemporary and future scenarios through the lenses of ethics, the environment, and sustainability.

    What to demonstrate

    1. Understanding of sustainability and environmental issues in design and manufacture
    2. Application of the SIX R's (rethink, reuse, recycle, repair, reduce, refuse)
    3. Use of Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) to determine environmental impact
    Show all 5 objectives
    1. Understanding of Fair-trade policies and carbon/ecological footprints
    2. Consideration of social, cultural, economic, and environmental responsibilities

    How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions; considering contemporary and potential future scenarios from different perspectives, such as ethics and the environment exam tips

    Topic Overview

    This topic explores how designers critically evaluate new and emerging technologies—such as AI, 3D printing, smart materials, and biotechnology—to inform their design decisions. You'll learn to assess these technologies from multiple perspectives, including ethics, environmental impact, economics, and social implications. Understanding this evaluation process is crucial because it ensures that design choices are responsible, sustainable, and aligned with future societal needs.

    In the WJEC GCSE Design and Technology course, this topic sits within the 'Designing and Making Principles' section. It requires you to think beyond the immediate function of a product and consider its wider consequences. For example, when designing a smartphone, you must evaluate the ethical implications of rare earth mineral mining, the environmental cost of e-waste, and the social impact of planned obsolescence. This critical thinking helps you become a more thoughtful and innovative designer.

    Why does this matter? Because technology is advancing rapidly, and designers have a responsibility to shape its direction. By evaluating technologies critically, you can anticipate potential problems—like job displacement due to automation or privacy concerns with smart devices—and design solutions that mitigate these issues. This topic also prepares you for the non-exam assessment (NEA), where you'll need to justify your design decisions with reference to these broader perspectives.

    Key Concepts
    • →Ethical perspectives: Consider moral issues such as data privacy, intellectual property, fair trade, and the impact on workers' rights when using new technologies.
    • →Environmental perspectives: Evaluate the full lifecycle of a product—from raw material extraction to disposal—including energy use, carbon footprint, recyclability, and pollution.
    • →Social perspectives: Assess how technology affects people's lives, including health, wellbeing, social interaction, and equality of access (digital divide).
    • →Economic perspectives: Analyse costs and benefits, including manufacturing costs, market demand, job creation vs. job loss, and long-term value for money.
    • →Future scenarios: Use foresight techniques like trend analysis and scenario planning to predict how emerging technologies might evolve and shape society.
    Marking Points
    • Understanding of sustainability and environmental issues in design and manufacture
    • Application of the SIX R's (rethink, reuse, recycle, repair, reduce, refuse)
    • Use of Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) to determine environmental impact
    • Understanding of Fair-trade policies and carbon/ecological footprints
    • Consideration of social, cultural, economic, and environmental responsibilities
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Always justify design decisions by referencing environmental or ethical impacts
    • 💡Use the SIX R's as a framework when evaluating existing products or your own designs
    • 💡Be prepared to discuss how future scenarios (e.g., resource scarcity) might change design requirements
    • 💡Ensure you can explain the difference between carbon footprint and ecological footprint
    • 💡Use specific examples: When discussing ethics, mention real cases like the use of conflict minerals in electronics or the ethical concerns of facial recognition technology. This shows depth of knowledge.
    • 💡Structure your evaluation: For any technology, systematically consider each perspective (ethical, environmental, social, economic) in separate paragraphs. Use connectives like 'however' and 'on the other hand' to show critical thinking.
    • 💡Link to design decisions: Always explain how your evaluation influences a design choice. For example, 'Because of the ethical issues with child labour in cobalt mining, I would design a phone with a recyclable battery that uses alternative materials.'
    Common Mistakes
    • Failing to link environmental considerations to specific design decisions
    • Superficial understanding of the SIX R's without practical application
    • Ignoring the social or ethical implications of design choices
    • Inability to apply Life Cycle Analysis to a specific product
    • Misconception: 'New technology is always better for the environment.' Correction: While some technologies reduce waste (e.g., 3D printing), others increase energy consumption or use rare materials. Always evaluate the full lifecycle.
    • Misconception: 'Ethics only applies to controversial topics like AI weapons.' Correction: Ethics applies to everyday design decisions, such as using sustainable materials or ensuring products are repairable (right to repair).
    • Misconception: 'Economic factors are the most important in design.' Correction: In the WJEC specification, you must balance economic, ethical, environmental, and social factors equally—marks are awarded for a holistic evaluation.
    Frequently Asked Questions
    How do I evaluate the ethics of a new technology in my design project?
    Start by identifying the stakeholders affected—users, workers, communities, and the environment. Ask questions like: Does this technology respect privacy? Does it use fair labour practices? Could it be used for harmful purposes? Then, consider trade-offs: for example, a smart home device may offer convenience but raise data security concerns. In your evaluation, weigh these factors and explain how your design addresses ethical issues, such as by using encrypted data storage or sourcing materials from certified suppliers.
    What is the difference between environmental and social perspectives?
    Environmental perspectives focus on the natural world—resource depletion, pollution, carbon emissions, and ecosystem damage. Social perspectives focus on people—health, wellbeing, employment, culture, and equality. For example, a new manufacturing process might reduce energy use (environmental benefit) but could lead to job losses in local communities (social drawback). In your evaluation, you must consider both separately and then discuss how they interact.
    How can I predict future scenarios for emerging technologies?
    Use trend analysis: look at current developments (e.g., AI in healthcare) and project forward. Consider best-case, worst-case, and most likely scenarios. For instance, with autonomous vehicles, a best-case scenario might be fewer accidents and reduced traffic; a worst-case could be massive job losses for drivers and hacking risks. In your design, you can then propose features that promote the best-case outcome, like fail-safe systems or ethical programming.
    Do I need to include economic factors in my evaluation?
    Yes, absolutely. Economics is one of the four key perspectives (alongside ethics, environment, and social). You should consider costs of production, pricing, market demand, and potential profits. For example, a biodegradable material might be more expensive but could attract eco-conscious customers. Explain how economic factors influence your design decisions, such as choosing a cheaper material to keep the product affordable, but also note any ethical trade-offs.
    What are some examples of emerging technologies I should know for the exam?
    Key examples include: artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning, 3D printing (additive manufacturing), smart materials (e.g., shape memory alloys, thermochromic pigments), biotechnology (e.g., lab-grown leather, genetically modified organisms), renewable energy technologies (solar, wind), and the Internet of Things (IoT). For each, be ready to discuss ethical, environmental, social, and economic implications.
    How can I get top marks in the evaluation section of my NEA?
    To achieve top marks, you must demonstrate critical evaluation—not just description. Use a balanced approach: discuss both advantages and disadvantages for each perspective. Use specific, accurate terminology (e.g., 'carbon footprint', 'planned obsolescence', 'digital divide'). Link your evaluation directly to your design decisions, showing how your research informed your choices. Finally, consider future scenarios and suggest improvements or innovations that address potential issues.