Elections and referendums — AQA A-Level Politics
Elections and referendums explained
Elections and referendums covers 3 specification points, including Majoritarian and proportional electoral… and Debates and issues around the performance of….
Read the full explanation
Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
Key concepts and terminology: majoritarian and proportional electoral systems, representative democracy, suffrage, participation, voting behaviour, manifesto, campaign, referendums.
This row asks you to command a working vocabulary for elections, not to argue a case. Learn each term with a definition and a UK illustration. Majoritarian systems, such as first past the post, tend to manufacture a single-party majority from a plurality of votes; proportional systems, such as the additional member system used for the Scottish Parliament and the Senedd, allocate seats more closely in line with vote share. Representative democracy means voters choose people to decide on their behalf between elections. Suffrage is the right to vote, extended to women in stages in 1918 and 1928. Participation covers turnout, party membership and campaigning. Voting behaviour explains how and why people vote, including class and age patterns. A manifesto is a party's published programme of promises. A campaign is the organised effort to win support.
Students will be required to analyse and evaluate the characteristics of different systems used in parliamentary elections and in elections to one of the devolved bodies in the UK including: debates and issues around the performance of those systems; the advantages and disadvantages of those systems; three key elections since 1945 should be selected for detailed study. These should include:; the 1997 general election; one election from before 1997; one election since 1997.
This requirement asks you to analyse and evaluate electoral systems at two levels: parliamentary elections at Westminster, using first past the post, and elections to one devolved body, such as the Scottish Parliament or the Senedd, which use the additional member system. Analyse means break down how each system works and what it produces; evaluate means weigh advantages against disadvantages and judge how well each performs. Cover the debates around performance, including the link between votes and seats, representation, government formation and voter choice. Support your argument with detailed study of three key elections since 1945: the 1997 general election, one election from before 1997, and one election since 1997. Use each case to show how the system operated in practice.
The study of these elections, the wider political context in which they occurred and the techniques used by political parties in their campaigns will provide perspectives on the issues and outcomes of each election, particularly in relation to the following: patterns of voting behaviour/changes over time – as revealed by relevant national data sources, and explanations of how and why they varied in different elections; the influence of the media on the outcomes; the reasons for and the impact of party policies on the outcomes; the reasons for and the influence of manifestos on the outcomes; the impact of campaigns and leadership on the outcomes; the role of elections and their influence on policy and policy making; likely effects of the electoral system on the party system. These elections should be selected because they exemplify particular characteristics of the British electoral system, electoral behaviour or electoral outcomes eg:; an election resulting in a landslide victory for one party; an election where results reveal a clear discrepancy between the number of votes and the number of seats gained; an election which shows how large numbers of voters are effectively disenfranchised by the preponderance of voters for one party in large areas of the country; an election the outcome of which is greatly influenced by a particular leadership style or personality; Students should analyse and evaluate the nature and use of referendums in the UK and their impact.
Build each case-study election as a layered argument, not a narrative. Set the wider political context first (economic conditions, governing record, salient issues), then trace the campaign techniques parties used, and finally weigh the outcome against national data on voting behaviour and change over time. Work through each required lens: media influence, party policies, manifestos, campaigns and leadership, the role of elections in shaping policy and policy making, and the likely effects of the electoral system on the party system. Choose elections that exemplify a characteristic: a landslide, a votes-seats discrepancy, effective disenfranchisement where one party dominates large areas, or a leadership-dominated result. Then analyse and evaluate the nature, use and impact of UK referendums, judging when they are appropriate and what they achieve.
Your focus
- Identify the defining feature of a majoritarian and of a proportional electoral system.
- Match each key term to an accurate definition and a UK illustration.
- Distinguish representative democracy, suffrage, participation and voting behaviour from one another.
Show all 9 objectives
- Analyse the characteristics of first past the post and of the additional member system used in a devolved body.
- Evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of each system and the debates about their performance.
- Apply detailed knowledge of the 1997 election, one election before 1997 and one election since 1997 as evidence.
- Analyse patterns of voting behaviour across selected elections using national data
- Evaluate the influence of media, policies, manifestos, campaigns and leadership on outcomes
- Assess the nature, use and impact of UK referendums
Elections and referendums exam tips
Marking Points
- Defines a majoritarian system as one that usually gives the largest party a bonus in seats, illustrated by first past the post at Westminster.
- Defines a proportional system as one that distributes seats broadly in line with vote share, illustrated by the additional member system in Scotland and Wales.
- Defines representative democracy as a system in which voters elect representatives to take decisions on their behalf.
- Defines suffrage as the legal right to vote and links it to the extension of the franchise to women in 1918 and 1928.
- Defines participation as the range of ways citizens engage, including turnout, membership and campaigning.
- Defines voting behaviour as the study of how and why electors cast their votes, including social and regional patterns.
- Defines a manifesto as a party's published set of commitments offered to voters at an election.
- Defines a campaign as the organised activity a party or group undertakes to persuade voters.
- Defines a referendum as a direct vote by the electorate on a specific question rather than a choice between candidates.
- Explains how first past the post works in parliamentary elections and how the additional member system works in elections to a chosen devolved body.
- Analyses the characteristics of each system, including the constituency link, the number of representatives per area and the way seats are allocated.
- Evaluates the advantages of first past the post, such as single-party government and a clear local representative, against its disadvantages, such as disproportionality and wasted votes.
- Evaluates the advantages of the additional member system, such as a closer match between votes and seats, against its disadvantages, such as two classes of representative and more complex coalition formation.
- Assesses debates about the performance of each system, including how far each delivers fair representation and effective government.
- Uses the 1997 general election as detailed evidence, showing the scale of the Labour landslide and its effect under first past the post.
- Uses one election from before 1997 as detailed evidence, drawing on its outcome to illustrate how the system performed.
- Uses one election since 1997 as detailed evidence, drawing on its outcome to illustrate how the system performed.
- Reaches a reasoned judgement on the relative merits of the systems, supported by the evidence from the three elections studied.
- Uses relevant national data sources to identify patterns of voting behaviour and change over time across the selected elections
- Explains how and why voting behaviour varied between different elections with reference to context and evidence
- Assesses the influence of the media on the outcome of each election discussed
- Explains the reasons for party policies and evaluates their impact on outcomes
- Explains the reasons for manifestos and evaluates their influence on outcomes
- Evaluates the impact of campaigns and leadership on outcomes
- Analyses the role of elections and their influence on policy and policy making
- Evaluates the likely effects of the electoral system on the party system
- Justifies the selection of each election by identifying the characteristic it exemplifies, such as a landslide, a votes-seats discrepancy, effective disenfranchisement or a leadership-dominated result
- Analyses and evaluates the nature and use of referendums in the UK and their impact
- Reaches a supported overall judgement rather than listing factors separately
Examiner Tips
- 💡Learn each term with one precise definition and one UK example so a multiple-choice option can be matched quickly.
- 💡Distinguish paired terms such as majoritarian and proportional by their effect on the link between votes and seats.
- 💡Read every option fully, because distractors often swap a correct definition onto the wrong term.
- 💡Plan your answer around the two levels, parliamentary and devolved, so both are covered before you write.
- 💡Anchor each evaluative point in a named election so the argument rests on evidence rather than assertion.
- 💡Reserve time to state a clear judgement that answers the question directly rather than merely summarising both sides.
- 💡Open each case study by naming the characteristic the election exemplifies, so selection is explicit
- 💡Anchor voting-behaviour claims in named national data sources and explain variation between elections
- 💡Balance each lens (media, policies, manifestos, campaigns, leadership) with an evaluative judgement, not just description
- 💡Reserve a distinct section for referendums covering nature, use and impact
- 💡Finish with a synoptic judgement on how the electoral system shapes the party system
Common Mistakes
- Confuses majoritarian with proportional systems; remember that first past the post is majoritarian and the additional member system is proportional.
- Treats suffrage as identical to turnout; keep the right to vote separate from the act of using it.
- Uses manifesto and campaign as synonyms; a manifesto is a written programme, while a campaign is the activity of persuading voters.
- Assumes a referendum elects a government; a referendum decides a single question and does not choose representatives.
- Describes how a system works without evaluating it; add a judgement about performance and support it with evidence.
- Chooses three elections that all fall after 1997; include the 1997 election, one from before 1997 and one from after 1997 as required.
- Treats the devolved body as using first past the post; identify the additional member system used for the Scottish Parliament or the Senedd.
- Lists advantages and disadvantages without weighing them; compare them and reach a supported conclusion.
- Describes election events chronologically without analysing causes; organise the answer around the required lenses instead
- Asserts media influence without evidence; link specific coverage or framing to measurable shifts in support
- Treats the votes-seats discrepancy as proof of unfairness without explaining how the electoral system produces it
- Lists party policies without evaluating their impact on the outcome; connect each policy to voter response
- Discusses referendums descriptively without evaluating their nature, use and impact
- Ignores the requirement to justify why each election was selected; state the characteristic it exemplifies