Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Criticisms of families — AQA GCSE Sociology

    Criticisms of families explained

    Criticisms of families covers 6 specification points, including Different criticisms of families (isolation… and The work of Zaretsky on developments in….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    Different criticisms of families (isolation and unrealistic idealisation, loss of traditional functions, lack of contact with wider kinship networks, the status and role of women within families, marital breakdown, dysfunctional families).

    This topic asks you to evaluate the family rather than simply describe it. Critics argue that the nuclear family can be socially isolated, cut off from wider kin, and that images of the happy family idealise it unrealistically. Functionalist claims about the family retaining important functions are challenged by the argument that many functions have been lost to other institutions such as schools, the NHS and the welfare state. Feminist criticism focuses on the status and role of women, including unequal domestic labour and the 'triple shift'. Other criticisms point to lack of contact with wider kinship networks, the impact of marital breakdown, and the experience of dysfunctional families where conflict, abuse or neglect occur. Learn each criticism with a brief explanation and, where possible, a theorist or example.

    The work of Zaretsky on developments in families from a Marxist perspective and Delphy and Leonard’s feminist critique of families.

    This row asks you to know two named criticisms of the family. Zaretsky works from a Marxist perspective: he argues that the family developed to serve capitalism, acting as a unit that reproduces and maintains the workforce and absorbs the frustration workers feel, so that the family cushions the effects of exploitation rather than challenging it. Delphy and Leonard offer a feminist critique: they argue that the family is a site of unequal domestic labour and power, where women's work is exploited and men benefit, so the family maintains gender inequality. Learn each theorist's perspective, the key claim and one example, and be ready to distinguish the Marxist view from the feminist view in a multiple-choice question.

    identify, describe and explain different criticisms of families

    This row asks you to identify, describe and explain criticisms of families. Criticisms come from different perspectives: Marxists such as Zaretsky argue the family serves capitalism by reproducing the workforce and absorbing frustration; feminists such as Delphy and Leonard argue the family exploits women's domestic labour and maintains gender inequality; other criticisms point to issues such as domestic abuse, unequal power or the family failing some members. In a multiple-choice question, identify which criticism is being described, describe what the criticism claims and explain why it is a criticism, linking it to the perspective behind it.

    describe, compare and contrast a variety of sociological perspectives on these issues (functionalist, feminist and Marxist)

    This criterion asks you to describe how functionalist, feminist and Marxist perspectives each criticise or evaluate family life, then to compare and contrast them. Describe means setting out each perspective's key claims about the family accurately. Compare means identifying where the perspectives agree, for example that all three see the family as linked to wider society and performing functions for it. Contrast means identifying where they diverge: functionalists stress harmony and the family's contribution to social stability, feminists stress patriarchy and the unequal domestic division of labour, and Marxists stress the family's role in reproducing class inequality and serving capitalism. Build your answer by taking each perspective in turn, giving its criticism of the family, then drawing explicit links and differences between them.

    describe the key ideas of Zaretsky (page 46) on families

    This criterion asks you to describe the key ideas of Zaretsky on families. Zaretsky is a Marxist thinker who argues that the family serves the interests of capitalism. He claims the family provides a private refuge from the pressures of work, which helps workers recover so they can return to exploited labour. He also argues the family is a unit of consumption, encouraging its members to buy goods that profit capitalism, and that it reproduces the next generation of workers and the ideology that supports capitalism. In a multiple-choice question you must select the option that accurately matches Zaretsky's Marxist position, distinguishing it from functionalist claims that the family benefits society as a whole or feminist claims centred on patriarchy. Read each option carefully and reject any that misattribute ideas to Zaretsky or describe a different perspective.

    describe the key ideas of Delphy and Leonard (page 45) on families.

    Delphy and Leonard offer a feminist critique of the family. They argue that the family is a site of unpaid domestic labour performed mainly by women, and that this work benefits men, who receive services and support without equivalent return. They see the family as an economic unit in which men gain from women's labour, and they stress that power within families is unequal, with men typically holding more authority. Their approach is a radical feminist one that connects the private sphere of family life to wider gender inequality in society. A useful example is the unequal division of housework and childcare, where women often do a 'double shift' of paid work plus domestic tasks. Learners should be able to identify these ideas and distinguish them from other feminist perspectives, such as liberal feminism, which focuses more on legal and social reform.

    Your focus

    1. Explain at least three criticisms of the family with supporting detail.
    2. Distinguish feminist criticism of women's role from functionalist claims about family functions.
    3. Apply the concept of the dysfunctional family to concrete examples of conflict or neglect.
    Show all 18 objectives
    1. Identify Zaretsky's Marxist view of the family and its role in supporting capitalism.
    2. Identify Delphy and Leonard's feminist critique of unequal domestic labour and power in families.
    3. Distinguish between Marxist and feminist criticisms of the family in a multiple-choice question.
    4. Identify different criticisms of families and the perspectives they come from.
    5. Describe what a named criticism claims about the family.
    6. Explain why a criticism counts as a criticism by linking it to its perspective.
    7. Describe the functionalist, feminist and Marxist perspectives on the family.
    8. Compare the perspectives by identifying where they agree.
    9. Contrast the perspectives by explaining where they differ.
    10. Describe Zaretsky's key ideas about the family.
    11. Identify the Marxist basis of Zaretsky's argument.
    12. Distinguish Zaretsky's ideas from functionalist and feminist perspectives.
    13. State the key ideas of Delphy and Leonard about families.
    14. Explain how their ideas link unpaid domestic labour to male advantage.
    15. Distinguish their radical feminist view from other feminist perspectives.

    Criticisms of families exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Explains isolation and unrealistic idealisation as a criticism, noting that the private nuclear household can be cut off and that media images of family life overstate harmony.
    • Outlines the loss of traditional functions argument, showing that education, health care and production have largely moved to other institutions.
    • Describes lack of contact with wider kinship networks, contrasting the isolated nuclear family with extended kin support.
    • Explains feminist criticism of the status and role of women, including unequal division of domestic labour and the burden of paid and unpaid work.
    • Identifies marital breakdown and dysfunctional families as criticisms, linking them to conflict, instability, abuse or neglect within households.
    • Identifies Zaretsky as writing from a Marxist perspective on the family.
    • States that Zaretsky sees the family as supporting capitalism by reproducing and maintaining the workforce.
    • Explains that Zaretsky argues the family absorbs workers' frustration and so cushions exploitation.
    • Identifies Delphy and Leonard as offering a feminist critique of the family.
    • States that Delphy and Leonard argue the family exploits women's domestic labour and maintains gender inequality.
    • Distinguishes the Marxist emphasis on capitalism from the feminist emphasis on patriarchy and unequal domestic labour.
    • Identifies a named criticism of the family and the perspective it comes from.
    • Describes what the criticism claims about the family, for example that it serves capitalism or exploits women's labour.
    • Explains why the claim counts as a criticism, linking it to the perspective's concerns.
    • Distinguishes between different criticisms, such as Marxist and feminist, rather than treating them as one.
    • Describes functionalist criticisms of the family by explaining how functionalists see the family as performing positive functions for society while acknowledging dysfunctions such as domestic conflict.
    • Describes feminist criticisms of the family by explaining how feminists identify patriarchy, unequal domestic labour and gender socialisation within family life.
    • Describes Marxist criticisms of the family by explaining how Marxists see the family as reproducing class inequality and serving the interests of capitalism.
    • Compares the perspectives by identifying shared ground, such as all three treating the family as connected to wider social structures.
    • Contrasts the perspectives by explaining where they disagree, for example over whether the family benefits society as a whole or mainly benefits particular groups.
    • Uses concrete examples, such as the gendered division of domestic labour or the family as a unit of consumption, to illustrate each perspective.
    • Identifies that Zaretsky takes a Marxist perspective on the family.
    • Recognises that Zaretsky sees the family as providing a refuge from the pressures of work under capitalism.
    • Recognises that Zaretsky sees the family as a unit of consumption that supports capitalism.
    • Recognises that Zaretsky argues the family reproduces the workforce and capitalist ideology.
    • Rejects options that attribute functionalist or feminist ideas to Zaretsky.
    • Identifies that Delphy and Leonard see the family as a site of unpaid domestic labour performed mainly by women.
    • Explains that they argue men benefit economically from women's unpaid work within the family.
    • States that they view power within families as unequal, with men holding greater authority.
    • Links their ideas to a radical feminist critique that connects family life to wider gender inequality.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Use the wording of the specification to structure your answer, taking each criticism in turn.
    • 💡Attach a theorist or concept to each criticism, such as the triple shift for feminist analysis, to show understanding.
    • 💡When asked to evaluate, balance criticisms against strengths of family life rather than listing only negatives.
    • 💡Read the question stem carefully to see whether it asks about the Marxist or the feminist perspective before choosing.
    • 💡Link each named theorist to one clear key claim so you can eliminate wrong options quickly.
    • 💡Watch for options that swap the theorists' perspectives, as these are common distractors.
    • 💡Check whether the question asks you to identify, describe or explain, and match your answer to that demand.
    • 💡Use the perspective name as a clue to eliminate options that belong to a different criticism.
    • 💡Look for options that describe a criticism but give the wrong perspective, as these are common distractors.
    • 💡Plan your answer by allocating a paragraph to each perspective before writing the comparison and contrast.
    • 💡Use connectives such as 'similarly', 'whereas' and 'in contrast' to make comparisons explicit.
    • 💡Anchor each perspective with a concrete example of family life to demonstrate understanding.
    • 💡Check that you have addressed description, comparison and contrast, since the criterion names all three.
    • 💡Read all options before choosing, since several may sound plausible.
    • 💡Eliminate options that describe functionalist or feminist perspectives rather than Zaretsky's Marxist view.
    • 💡Look for the option that links the family to the interests of capitalism.
    • 💡Check that the chosen option matches Zaretsky's specific ideas rather than general statements about families.
    • 💡Learn two or three core ideas (unpaid labour, male benefit, unequal power) and be ready to state them precisely.
    • 💡Use a concrete example such as the unequal division of housework to illustrate the ideas.
    • 💡Distinguish Delphy and Leonard from other feminist thinkers to show accurate understanding.
    Common Mistakes
    • Lists criticisms without explaining them; add a sentence showing what each criticism claims and why it matters.
    • Treats all families as dysfunctional; frame the criticism as a risk or tendency that some families experience, not a universal description.
    • Presents functionalist claims as criticisms; keep the functionalist view separate and show how critics challenge it.
    • Ignores the status and role of women; include feminist criticism of unequal domestic labour as a distinct point.
    • Attributes a feminist critique to Zaretsky; keep Zaretsky as the Marxist theorist and Delphy and Leonard as the feminist critics.
    • Claims Zaretsky sees the family as challenging capitalism; remember he sees it as maintaining capitalism.
    • Treats Delphy and Leonard as functionalists who praise the family; recognise their critique of unequal domestic labour and power.
    • Confuses the two theorists' perspectives; link each name to its own perspective and key claim.
    • Describes a criticism without naming the perspective it comes from; link each criticism to its perspective.
    • Confuses one criticism with another; keep Marxist and feminist criticisms distinct.
    • Offers a description but no explanation of why it is a criticism; add the reason it counts as a criticism.
    • Describes only one perspective and ignores the others; cover functionalist, feminist and Marxist views so the comparison can be made.
    • Lists perspectives without comparing or contrasting them; draw explicit links and differences between them.
    • Treats all feminists or all Marxists as holding one identical view; recognise that each perspective contains internal variety.
    • Presents personal opinion as a sociological perspective; ground each claim in the named perspective.
    • Selects an option describing functionalist ideas about family harmony; Zaretsky's view is Marxist and critical of capitalism.
    • Selects an option describing feminist ideas about patriarchy as Zaretsky's view; keep his Marxist focus on class and capitalism.
    • Ignores the idea of the family as a unit of consumption; recognise this as central to Zaretsky's argument.
    • Chooses an option that misattributes a different thinker's ideas to Zaretsky; check that the option matches his Marxist position.
    • Confuses Delphy and Leonard with liberal feminists who emphasise legal reform; keep the focus on their radical feminist critique of unpaid labour and unequal power.
    • Assumes their work only concerns paid employment; remember it centres on unpaid domestic labour within the family.
    • Treats their ideas as describing all families equally; note that they highlight a general pattern of gender inequality rather than every individual family.