Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    The social construction of crime and deviance — AQA GCSE Sociology

    The social construction of crime and deviance explained

    The social construction of crime and deviance covers 7 specification points, including The social construction of concepts of crime… and The work of Merton on the causes of crime from….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    The social construction of concepts of crime and deviance and explanations of crime and deviance.

    This topic asks you to see crime and deviance as socially constructed: what counts as criminal or deviant varies between societies and over time, and depends on who has the power to make and enforce rules. Deviance is behaviour that breaks social norms, while crime is behaviour that breaks the law, so an act can be deviant without being criminal. Labelling theory shows that behaviour becomes deviant when others define it as such, and agents such as the police may apply labels unequally. You also need explanations of crime and deviance, including functionalist, strain, subcultural, labelling and Marxist accounts, and you should compare how each explains why some groups appear more criminal than others.

    The work of Merton on the causes of crime from a functionalist perspective and Becker from an interactionist perspective.

    This content requires you to know two named theorists and to keep their perspectives apart. Merton works within functionalism: he argues that society sets shared goals, such as material success, but not everyone has equal access to the legitimate means of reaching them. Where the goals are stressed but the means are blocked, a strain or gap opens between what people are encouraged to want and what they can legitimately achieve, and some respond by innovating, that is, using illegitimate means such as theft. Becker works within interactionism: he argues that deviance is not simply a quality of an act but a label applied by others. Rules are created and enforced by powerful groups, and a person becomes defined as deviant through labelling, which can shape self-identity and future behaviour.

    identify, describe and explain various sociological explanations of crime and deviance including anomie, labelling, structural theories, subcultural theories and interactionist theory

    This content asks you to identify, describe and explain several sociological explanations of crime and deviance and to recognise which is which. Anomie explanations, associated with functionalism and Merton, argue that crime results from a strain between socially approved goals and the legitimate means available to reach them. Structural theories locate the causes of crime in features of society such as inequality, blocked opportunity and the distribution of power rather than in individual pathology. Subcultural theories argue that groups develop their own norms and values that may support or normalise deviant behaviour, for example where members are excluded from mainstream success.

    explain the social construction of concepts of crime and deviance

    This item tests whether you can explain that crime and deviance are not fixed natural categories but meanings built up through social processes. Crime is behaviour that breaks the criminal law of a particular society at a particular time; deviance is behaviour that breaks the norms and values of a group, which may or may not be illegal. Both shift across time, place and culture: an act treated as criminal in one country may be lawful in another, and behaviour once seen as deviant may later be accepted. Social construction means these labels are produced through social interaction, socialisation, media reporting and the decisions of agencies such as the police and courts, who define and enforce the rules. A strong answer explains this process and uses an example, such as changing laws on smoking in public places, rather than simply asserting that crime is relative.

    describe, compare and contrast a variety of sociological perspectives on the social construction of crime and deviance (interactionist, functionalist, feminist and Marxist)

    This extended response asks you to describe four perspectives on how crime and deviance are socially constructed, then compare and contrast them. Interactionists argue that deviance arises through labelling and the reactions of others, so agencies such as the police apply labels unevenly. Functionalists see crime and deviance as produced by society's shared norms and as having functions, such as marking boundaries and prompting social change. Feminists argue that definitions and enforcement reflect patriarchy, so women's behaviour is judged differently and some harms against women are under-recognised. Marxists argue that laws protect the interests of the ruling class, so the powerful define crime and select who is criminalised.

    describe the key ideas of Merton (page 50) on the causes of crime

    Merton explains crime through strain theory, which sits within the functionalist tradition. Society sets culturally approved goals, such as wealth and status, and provides legitimate means to reach them, such as education and work. When people accept the goals but are blocked from the legitimate means, they experience strain, and some respond by innovating: they pursue the goal through illegitimate means such as theft or fraud. Merton links this gap between goals and means to the structure of unequal society rather than to individual pathology. He also identifies other adaptations, including ritualism, retreatism and rebellion, but innovation is the one most directly tied to utilitarian crime. A strong answer names the goals-means gap, explains blocked opportunity and applies it to a concrete example, such as a person denied secure work turning to illegal earning.

    describe the key ideas of Becker (page 48) on the causes of crime.

    Becker explains crime through labelling theory, an interactionist approach. He argues that deviance is not simply a quality of an act but a label applied by others, so behaviour becomes deviant when powerful groups define it as such. Agencies of social control, such as the police and courts, apply labels selectively, and this selectivity can reflect the interests of those with power. Once labelled, a person may be treated as an outsider, which can push them towards further deviance through a self-fulfilling prophecy and a deviant career. Becker therefore locates the cause of crime in social reaction and the labelling process rather than in the act itself. A strong answer defines labelling, explains who applies it and shows how a label can shape future behaviour, for example a pupil labelled a troublemaker who then lives up to the label.

    Your focus

    1. Explain why crime and deviance are described as socially constructed.
    2. Distinguish crime from deviance with examples.
    3. Compare explanations of crime and deviance and their view of social construction.
    Show all 21 objectives
    1. State that Merton explains crime from a functionalist perspective through strain between goals and means.
    2. State that Becker explains deviance from an interactionist perspective through labelling.
    3. Distinguish clearly between the functionalist and interactionist explanations of crime.
    4. Identify anomie, labelling, structural, subcultural and interactionist explanations of crime and deviance.
    5. Describe the central claim of each named sociological explanation.
    6. Explain how each explanation accounts for crime and deviance and distinguish between them.
    7. Define crime and deviance and distinguish between them.
    8. Explain how definitions of crime and deviance vary across time, place and culture with an example.
    9. Identify the social processes and agencies that construct and enforce labels of crime and deviance.
    10. Describe the interactionist, functionalist, feminist and Marxist perspectives on the social construction of crime and deviance.
    11. Compare and contrast these perspectives by identifying shared assumptions and points of difference.
    12. Support each perspective with an example and reach a reasoned judgement about their explanations.
    13. Outline Merton's strain theory and its functionalist roots.
    14. Explain the gap between culturally approved goals and legitimate means.
    15. Apply the concept of innovation to an example of utilitarian crime.
    16. Outline Becker's labelling theory and its interactionist roots.
    17. Explain how labels applied by powerful groups construct deviance.
    18. Apply labelling and the self-fulfilling prophecy to an example of deviant behaviour.

    The social construction of crime and deviance exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Explains that crime and deviance are socially constructed because definitions vary between societies and change over time.
    • Distinguishes deviance as breaking social norms from crime as breaking the law, noting that an act can be deviant without being criminal.
    • Explains that labelling by others, including agencies such as the police, makes behaviour deviant and may be applied unequally.
    • Outlines at least one explanation of crime and deviance, such as functionalism, strain theory, subcultural theory, labelling theory or Marxism, and links it to the social construction of crime.
    • Identifies Merton as a functionalist who explains crime through the strain between socially approved goals and blocked legitimate means.
    • Explains that Merton's concept of anomie or strain arises when people cannot reach shared goals by approved routes and some turn to illegitimate means.
    • Identifies Becker as an interactionist who explains deviance as a label applied by others rather than an inherent quality of the act.
    • Explains that Becker sees rule-making and labelling by powerful groups as central to how behaviour comes to be defined as deviant.
    • Distinguishes the two perspectives clearly, showing that Merton focuses on structural strain while Becker focuses on social reaction and labelling.
    • Identifies anomie as an explanation in which crime results from a strain between approved goals and the legitimate means of reaching them.
    • Describes structural theories as locating the causes of crime in features of society such as inequality and blocked opportunity rather than in individuals.
    • Explains that subcultural theories see groups developing norms and values that may support or normalise deviant behaviour.
    • Explains that labelling and interactionist theory treat deviance as socially constructed through rule-making and the reactions of others.
    • Distinguishes the explanations from one another, showing how anomie, structural, subcultural and interactionist accounts differ in where they locate the cause of crime.
    • Explains that crime is behaviour breaking the criminal law of a given society at a given time, while deviance breaks social norms and may be legal.
    • Explains that definitions of crime and deviance vary across time, place and culture, giving a concrete example of such variation.
    • Explains that labels of crime and deviance are produced through social processes such as socialisation, media reporting and the decisions of agencies like the police and courts.
    • Distinguishes deviance from crime by noting that some deviant acts are not illegal and some crimes are widely regarded as not deviant.
    • Describes the interactionist perspective, explaining that deviance is constructed through labelling and the reactions of others, including agencies such as the police.
    • Describes the functionalist perspective, explaining that crime and deviance arise from shared norms and perform functions such as boundary maintenance and prompting change.
    • Describes the feminist perspective, explaining that definitions and enforcement of crime reflect patriarchy and treat women's behaviour differently.
    • Describes the Marxist perspective, explaining that laws serve ruling-class interests and that the powerful shape which acts are defined and punished as criminal.
    • Compares the perspectives by identifying shared ground, such as agreement that definitions of crime are not neutral or natural.
    • Contrasts the perspectives by explaining where they differ, for example on whether the construction of crime serves society as a whole or a dominant group.
    • Supports each perspective with a relevant example and reaches a reasoned overall judgement about the explanations.
    • Identifies strain theory as Merton's functionalist explanation of crime.
    • Explains the gap between culturally approved goals and the legitimate means available to reach them.
    • Links blocked legitimate opportunity to innovation, where illegitimate means are used to pursue approved goals.
    • Applies the goals-means gap to a concrete example of utilitarian crime such as theft or fraud.
    • Recognises that Merton locates the cause in social structure and unequal opportunity rather than in individual defect.
    • Identifies labelling theory as Becker's interactionist explanation of crime.
    • Explains that deviance is a label applied by others rather than an inherent quality of an act.
    • Shows that powerful groups and agencies of social control apply labels selectively.
    • Explains how a label can produce a self-fulfilling prophecy and a deviant career.
    • Applies labelling to a concrete example, such as a person labelled a troublemaker who then behaves accordingly.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Use a concrete example of behaviour that is deviant in one setting but not another to show social construction.
    • 💡Name the explanation you use and state its key claim before applying it.
    • 💡Compare at least two explanations briefly to show the range required by the topic.
    • 💡Read the question carefully to check whether it asks about Merton, Becker or both, and answer only what is asked.
    • 💡Use the theorist's name and perspective in your first sentence so the examiner can see immediately that you know who said what.
    • 💡Add one concrete example, such as theft as innovation for Merton or a person defined as criminal through labelling for Becker, to show understanding.
    • 💡Keep the two perspectives in separate paragraphs so their differences are clear.
    • 💡Name the specific explanation in each answer so the examiner can see which theory you are describing.
    • 💡Use the command words: identify means name it, describe means set out its central claim, and explain means show how it accounts for crime.
    • 💡Give a brief example for each explanation, such as blocked opportunity for structural theory or a label applied by others for interactionism.
    • 💡Keep each explanation in its own paragraph so the differences between them are clear.
    • 💡Read every option fully and eliminate any that treats crime and deviance as the same thing.
    • 💡Look for the option that names a social process, such as labelling by agencies or media reporting, rather than one that simply says behaviour is wrong.
    • 💡Check whether the option gives a reason why definitions vary, since the command word explain requires a mechanism, not just a definition.
    • 💡Plan before writing by allocating a short paragraph to each perspective, then a section that compares and contrasts them.
    • 💡Use comparative connectives such as similarly, whereas and in contrast so the examiner can see the comparison is deliberate.
    • 💡Anchor each perspective with a brief example and finish with a judgement that weighs the explanations rather than merely summarising them.
    • 💡Name the theory (strain) and its tradition (functionalism) in your first sentence so the examiner can locate your answer.
    • 💡Define the goals-means gap before applying it, then use one clear example to show innovation.
    • 💡Link the explanation back to social structure and unequal opportunity to show understanding of the cause of crime.
    • 💡State that Becker's approach is interactionist and centred on labelling in your opening sentence.
    • 💡Explain who does the labelling and why selectivity matters, rather than only defining the term.
    • 💡Use one example to show the label shaping later behaviour through a self-fulfilling prophecy.
    Common Mistakes
    • Treats crime and deviance as identical; correct this by distinguishing legal rules from social norms.
    • Assumes definitions of crime are fixed and universal; correct this by showing they vary across societies and over time.
    • Lists an explanation without linking it to social construction; correct this by showing how that theory explains who gets defined as criminal.
    • Attributes labelling theory to Merton; keep Merton within functionalist strain theory and Becker within interactionism.
    • Describes Becker as a functionalist explaining shared goals; link Becker instead to labelling and social reaction.
    • Treats deviance as an obvious quality of an act without reference to labelling; explain that Becker sees deviance as socially constructed through labels.
    • Confuses anomie with labelling; keep anomie and strain with Merton and labelling with Becker.
    • Treats all sociological explanations as saying the same thing; distinguish anomie, structural, subcultural and interactionist accounts by their central claims.
    • Locates the cause of crime in individual personality alone; explain instead how the named sociological theories locate causes in society, structure or social reaction.
    • Confuses labelling with subcultural theory; keep labelling and interactionism with social reaction and subcultural theory with group norms and values.
    • Describes a theory without explaining how it accounts for crime; add the explanatory link between the theory's central idea and deviant behaviour.
    • Treats crime and deviance as identical categories; keep them distinct by defining crime through the criminal law and deviance through social norms.
    • Assumes definitions of crime are fixed and universal; show instead that they change across time, place and culture with an example.
    • Presents social construction as a personal opinion rather than a social process; explain the interaction, socialisation and agency decisions that produce the labels.
    • Lists the four perspectives without comparing them; build explicit links that state what they share and where they diverge.
    • Confuses functionalism with Marxism by claiming both see crime as serving everyone; keep the functionalist view of shared norms separate from the Marxist view of ruling-class interests.
    • Describes labelling without naming it as the interactionist mechanism; connect the process of labelling and reaction to the interactionist perspective explicitly.
    • Omits the feminist perspective or reduces it to a single sentence; explain how patriarchy shapes definitions and enforcement of crime.
    • Confuses Merton with Becker; keep strain theory attributed to Merton and labelling to Becker.
    • Treats strain as a personal failing; explain it as a structural gap between shared goals and blocked legitimate means.
    • Lists every adaptation without explaining innovation; focus on how blocked means produce illegitimate routes to approved goals.
    • Confuses Becker with Merton; keep labelling attributed to Becker and strain theory to Merton.
    • Treats the label as a fixed property of the act; explain that deviance depends on who applies the label and with what power.
    • Stops at the label without explaining its effect; show how labelling can lead to a self-fulfilling prophecy and further deviance.