Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Criminal and deviant behaviour — AQA GCSE Sociology

    Criminal and deviant behaviour explained

    Criminal and deviant behaviour covers 7 specification points, including Factors affecting criminal and deviant… and The work of Albert Cohen on delinquent….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    Factors affecting criminal and deviant behaviour and ways in which criminal and deviant behaviour have generated public debate.

    This topic has two halves. First, factors affecting criminal and deviant behaviour: biological and psychological accounts, socialisation and the family, peer groups, education, income and poverty, neighbourhood and opportunity, and labelling by agencies of control. Second, public debate: how far crime is rising or falling, the role of the media in shaping fear of crime and moral panics, debates about punishment and rehabilitation, and arguments about the causes of crime such as poverty or individual responsibility. A strong answer distinguishes structural factors from individual ones, uses evidence carefully and recognises that public debate is often shaped by media representation rather than by statistics alone.

    The work of Albert Cohen on delinquent subcultures and Carlen on women, crime and poverty.

    This topic asks you to know two named sociological contributions. Albert Cohen studied delinquent subcultures: he argued that working-class boys who could not meet mainstream success goals experienced status frustration and collectively developed alternative values, so behaviour labelled delinquent became a way of gaining status among peers. Pat Carlen studied women, crime and poverty: she argued that most women who offend face poverty and limited opportunities, and that when the rewards of conformity seem unavailable, some turn to crime, often within a context of class and gender inequality. Learn each theorist's key concept, the group studied and the explanation offered, and be ready to distinguish Cohen's subcultural explanation from Carlen's focus on poverty and gender.

    identify, describe and explain factors affecting criminal and deviant behaviour including social class, gender, ethnicity and age

    This topic requires you to identify, describe and explain social factors that affect criminal and deviant behaviour. The four named factors are social class, gender, ethnicity and age. Identifying means naming the factor; describing means outlining a pattern, such as differences in recorded offending between groups; explaining means giving sociological reasons for the pattern, for example differences in opportunity, policing, socialisation or labelling. For each factor, learn a pattern and at least one explanation, and be ready to distinguish description from explanation. Remember that recorded crime statistics reflect reporting and policing as well as actual behaviour, so explanations should consider how patterns are produced and measured.

    identify and describe various public debates over criminal and deviant behaviour including concerns over violent crime, sentencing, the treatment of young offenders, the prison system and media coverage of crime

    Public debates are disagreements aired in politics, press and everyday talk about how society should respond to crime. This item asks you to identify a debate and describe what is contested. Take violent crime: people argue over whether levels are rising and whether tougher policing or tackling poverty is the answer. Sentencing debates ask whether punishments fit the offence and whether they deter. Treatment of young offenders debates ask whether the youth justice system should punish or rehabilitate. Prison system debates ask whether prisons rehabilitate or simply warehouse people, and whether they are overcrowded. Media coverage debates ask whether newspapers and broadcasters distort crime by over-reporting violence and creating moral panics. For each, name the concern, say who disagrees and why, and use a brief example.

    describe, compare and contrast a variety of sociological perspectives on factors affecting criminal and deviant behaviour (interactionist, functionalist, feminist and Marxist)

    This extended response asks you to describe four perspectives on what causes criminal and deviant behaviour, then compare and contrast them. Functionalists such as Durkheim treat crime as normal and boundary-maintaining, while Merton links deviance to a gap between goals and means. Interactionists focus on labelling and how definitions of deviance are applied, so Becker asks who gets labelled and why. Marxists link crime to capitalism, inequality and the law protecting ruling-class interests. Feminists examine how crime, victimisation and the justice system are shaped by gender, including why female offending is often treated differently. To compare, set perspectives against each other: structural versus interactional, consensus versus conflict, and whether gender is central or absent.

    describe the key ideas of Albert Cohen (page 49) on delinquent subcultures

    Albert Cohen explains delinquency as a group response to status frustration. Working-class boys who cannot meet the school's middle-class standards of achievement and respectability experience repeated failure and humiliation. Rather than accept that they are failures, they turn to other boys in the same position and build a subculture with its own values. In this delinquent subculture, the mainstream virtues are inverted: trouble becomes a source of prestige, toughness and defiance of adult authority win respect, and school success is dismissed. Delinquent acts are therefore non-utilitarian, malicious and negativistic in Cohen's account: they express rejection of the dominant value system rather than pursuit of profit. The behaviour is collective and gains meaning through the group.

    describe the key ideas of Carlen (page 49) on women, crime and poverty.

    Carlen studied women in poverty and argued that two linked deals shape whether they offend. The class deal offers rewards, such as a wage and a decent standard of living, in return for paid work. The gender deal offers rewards, such as love, security and respect, in return for conforming to expected family roles. Women in poverty who cannot access either deal have little stake in conformity, so the rational calculation of costs and rewards can tip towards crime. Carlen linked this to the 'carers' and 'victims' who felt trapped by poverty and limited options. A strong answer names both deals, explains the exchange each offers, and connects blocked access to poverty with the decision to offend.

    Your focus

    1. Identify and explain factors affecting criminal and deviant behaviour.
    2. Describe ways in which criminal and deviant behaviour have generated public debate.
    3. Distinguish structural from individual explanations and recognise the role of media representation in public debate.
    Show all 21 objectives
    1. State the key idea of Albert Cohen's theory of delinquent subcultures.
    2. State the key idea of Pat Carlen's work on women, crime and poverty.
    3. Distinguish between the two theorists' explanations of criminal and deviant behaviour.
    4. Identify social class, gender, ethnicity and age as factors affecting criminal and deviant behaviour.
    5. Describe patterns of criminal and deviant behaviour associated with each named factor.
    6. Explain sociological reasons for differences in criminal and deviant behaviour by class, gender, ethnicity and age.
    7. Identify at least one named public debate about criminal or deviant behaviour
    8. Describe the competing concerns within that debate
    9. Link a debate to a concrete example such as media reporting or youth justice policy
    10. Describe functionalist, interactionist, Marxist and feminist perspectives on criminal and deviant behaviour
    11. Compare perspectives by identifying shared assumptions about the causes of crime
    12. Contrast perspectives by explaining clear differences in how they account for the same example
    13. Outline Cohen's concept of status frustration and its link to working-class boys' experience of failure.
    14. Explain how a delinquent subculture inverts mainstream values and provides alternative status.
    15. Describe the collective and non-utilitarian character of delinquent acts in Cohen's theory.
    16. State the class deal and the gender deal and the rewards each offers.
    17. Explain how blocked access to both deals in poverty can make offending more likely.
    18. Apply Carlen's ideas to a short scenario about a woman in poverty.

    Criminal and deviant behaviour exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies at least two distinct factors affecting criminal and deviant behaviour, such as socialisation, peer groups, poverty or labelling.
    • Explains how a named factor can increase or reduce the likelihood of criminal or deviant behaviour.
    • Describes a way in which criminal or deviant behaviour has generated public debate, such as media reporting, fear of crime or arguments about punishment.
    • Distinguishes structural explanations from individual explanations of criminal behaviour.
    • Recognises that public debate may be shaped by media representation as well as by official statistics.
    • Identifies Albert Cohen as the theorist of delinquent subcultures and status frustration among working-class boys.
    • Explains that Cohen saw delinquent subcultures as a collective response to blocked opportunities for mainstream status.
    • Identifies Pat Carlen as the theorist linking women, crime and poverty.
    • Explains that Carlen emphasised poverty and limited opportunities as pressures shaping some women's offending.
    • Distinguishes Cohen's subcultural explanation from Carlen's class-and-gender explanation of crime.
    • Identifies social class as a factor affecting criminal and deviant behaviour.
    • Describes a pattern linked to gender, such as differences in recorded offending between men and women.
    • Explains how ethnicity may be associated with differences in recorded offending, considering policing or labelling.
    • Explains how age relates to patterns of criminal and deviant behaviour.
    • Distinguishes description of a pattern from explanation of why the pattern occurs.
    • Identifies a named public debate such as sentencing, youth justice, prisons, violent crime or media coverage of crime
    • Describes what is contested within that debate, for example whether prison rehabilitates or merely punishes
    • Explains why the concern matters, linking it to public opinion, policy or media influence
    • Uses a concrete example, such as concern that tabloid reporting exaggerates violent crime and fuels fear
    • Describes functionalist explanations, such as Durkheim's view that crime is normal and reinforces shared norms, or Merton's strain between goals and means
    • Describes interactionist explanations, such as labelling theory and the claim that deviance depends on how others respond
    • Describes Marxist explanations, such as the idea that inequality under capitalism and laws protecting the powerful shape crime
    • Describes feminist explanations, such as the role of gender in offending, victimisation and treatment by the justice system
    • Compares perspectives by identifying a shared feature, such as agreement that social structure or social reaction shapes behaviour
    • Contrasts perspectives by identifying a clear difference, such as consensus versus conflict views of law
    • Identifies status frustration as the starting point: working-class boys experience failure against middle-class standards and feel humiliated.
    • Explains that the boys collectively construct a delinquent subculture with inverted values that rewards what mainstream society condemns.
    • States that delinquent acts are non-utilitarian and express rejection of mainstream values rather than material gain.
    • Shows that the subculture provides status and belonging to boys who are denied status through legitimate channels.
    • Links the collective, group nature of the subculture to the shared norms that guide members' behaviour.
    • Names the class deal as the bargain offering material rewards such as a wage and a decent standard of living in return for paid work.
    • Names the gender deal as the bargain offering rewards such as love, security and respect in return for conforming to expected family roles.
    • Explains that women in poverty who cannot access either deal have little stake in conformity, so offending becomes a more rational option.
    • Links Carlen's ideas to poverty and limited opportunities rather than treating women's crime as a product of biology or personality.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Use the two-part structure of the statement: factors first, then public debate.
    • 💡Give a concrete example for each factor, such as peer pressure or low income.
    • 💡When discussing public debate, refer to media coverage, fear of crime or arguments about punishment.
    • 💡Learn one key concept for each theorist and use it precisely in your answer.
    • 💡Link each theorist to the specific group they studied rather than treating them as general theories of all crime.
    • 💡When comparing, state clearly what each theorist emphasises and how the emphases differ.
    • 💡Use the command words: identify names the factor, describe outlines the pattern, explain gives the reason.
    • 💡For each factor, give one clear pattern and one sociological explanation.
    • 💡Refer to how crime statistics are produced when explaining apparent differences between groups.
    • 💡Read all options before choosing; eliminate any option that names a topic but states no debate
    • 💡Look for the option that pairs a concern with a reason people disagree about it
    • 💡Check that the chosen option stays within the five named debates rather than drifting to unrelated issues
    • 💡Use comparative connectives such as 'whereas', 'similarly' and 'in contrast' to signal comparison and contrast explicitly
    • 💡Anchor each perspective to one shared example so the comparison is concrete rather than abstract
    • 💡Balance coverage across all four perspectives before adding depth to any single one
    • 💡Use the phrase status frustration and immediately explain what it means in Cohen's argument.
    • 💡Contrast mainstream values with subcultural values to show the inversion clearly.
    • 💡Give a brief example of a subcultural value such as toughness or defiance to illustrate the mechanism.
    • 💡Keep the focus on the group process rather than listing individual motives.
    • 💡Learn the two deals as a matched pair, with the reward each offers and what is expected in return.
    • 💡Use the phrase 'stake in conformity' to explain why blocked access to the deals can make offending rational.
    • 💡Anchor every point in poverty and limited opportunities, since that is the focus of the question.
    Common Mistakes
    • Lists factors without explaining how they affect behaviour; correct this by linking each factor to a mechanism.
    • Treats public debate as identical to official statistics; correct this by explaining how media reporting can shape perception and debate.
    • Assumes one factor explains all crime; correct this by acknowledging multiple interacting factors.
    • Confuses deviance with crime; correct this by noting that deviant behaviour may not be illegal.
    • Confuses Cohen with Carlen; keep Cohen for delinquent subcultures and Carlen for women, crime and poverty.
    • Treats Cohen's theory as about individual personality rather than a shared subcultural response; emphasise the collective alternative values.
    • Ignores poverty in Carlen's account; link her explanation to material hardship and limited opportunities.
    • Assumes Carlen's theory applies equally to men; keep her focus on women's experiences.
    • Lists the four factors without describing or explaining any of them; develop each factor with a pattern and a reason.
    • Treats recorded statistics as a direct measure of actual offending; note the influence of reporting and policing.
    • Explains only one factor when the question asks about several; cover class, gender, ethnicity and age.
    • Offers a description where an explanation is required; state why the pattern occurs.
    • Names a debate without saying what is disputed; add the competing views and the reason for disagreement
    • Treats media coverage as neutral reporting; explain that selection and exaggeration can shape public fear
    • Confuses the treatment of young offenders with the prison system generally; keep the youth justice focus distinct
    • Lists four perspectives without comparing them; add explicit points of similarity and difference between at least two
    • Treats functionalism as saying crime is always good; explain that it can be functional for society while still harmful to victims
    • Describes feminism only as about female criminals; include victimisation and how the justice system treats women
    • Presents Marxism as claiming all crime is political; explain the emphasis on inequality and law-making instead
    • Treats Cohen's theory as claiming delinquency stems from poverty alone; correct this by stressing status frustration and the subcultural response to blocked status.
    • Presents the subculture as random individual rule-breaking; correct this by explaining that shared inverted values give the behaviour group meaning.
    • Assumes delinquent acts aim at financial profit; correct this by noting Cohen's emphasis on non-utilitarian, negativistic acts.
    • Describes the theory without naming the mechanism of status frustration; correct this by tracing failure, humiliation, collective solution and new norms.
    • Calls the gender deal the 'gender contract'; use Carlen's term 'gender deal' and pair it with the class deal.
    • Describes only one deal; name both the class deal and the gender deal and explain what each offers.
    • Treats Carlen as claiming all women in poverty offend; explain that blocked access to the deals makes offending more likely, not inevitable.