Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Other constructions (hace/hacía, cleft sentences, comparatives, indirect speech) — Edexcel A-Level Spanish

    Test yourself on Other constructions (hace/hacía, cleft sentences, comparatives, indirect speech) with PEARSON EDEXCEL A-Level practice questions.

    Start free

    7 days Premium · Then free forever · No card, no charge

    Other constructions (hace/hacía, cleft sentences, comparatives, indirect speech) explained

    This topic covers advanced grammatical constructions in Spanish, specifically focusing on time expressions with hace/hacía, cleft sentences, comparative structures, and indirect speech.

    Read the Other constructions (hace/hacía, cleft sentences, comparatives, indirect speech) study guideFull revision notes for Edexcel A-Level Spanish

    What to demonstrate

    1. Accurate use of hace/hacía for time expressions
    2. Correct formation and application of cleft sentences for emphasis
    3. Precise use of comparative and superlative structures
    Show all 4 objectives
    1. Correct application of rules for indirect speech

    Other constructions (hace/hacía, cleft sentences, comparatives, indirect speech) exam tips

    Topic Overview

    This topic covers a range of advanced Spanish constructions that are essential for achieving high marks in the Edexcel A-Level exam. You will learn how to use 'hace' and 'hacía' to express time durations, master cleft sentences for emphasis, form comparatives and superlatives accurately, and report speech indirectly. These structures allow you to vary your sentence patterns and demonstrate a sophisticated command of Spanish grammar, which is crucial for the writing and speaking components of the exam.

    Understanding these constructions is not just about memorising rules; it's about using them to communicate more precisely and naturally. For example, 'hace' and 'hacía' help you talk about how long something has been happening or had been happening, which is a common need in both written and spoken Spanish. Cleft sentences, like 'Fue en Madrid donde...', enable you to highlight specific information, making your arguments more persuasive. Comparatives and superlatives are fundamental for expressing opinions and making comparisons, while indirect speech is vital for reporting what others have said without quoting them directly. Mastering these will significantly enhance your fluency and accuracy.

    These constructions are interconnected and build on your existing knowledge of tenses and sentence structure. They frequently appear in exam texts and are often tested in translation and grammar exercises. By mastering them, you will be able to tackle complex sentences with confidence, whether you are analysing a literary text, writing an essay, or engaging in a discussion. This topic is a cornerstone of advanced Spanish and will serve you well beyond the A-Level exam.

    Key Concepts
    • →Use 'hace' + time + 'que' + present tense for actions that started in the past and continue: 'Hace dos años que estudio español.' Use 'hacía' + time + 'que' + imperfect tense for actions that had been happening up to a point in the past: 'Hacía dos años que estudiaba español cuando fui a España.'
    • →Cleft sentences (oraciones hendidas) use 'ser' + relative clause to emphasise a specific element. For example: 'Fue Juan quien lo dijo' (It was Juan who said it) or 'Lo que necesito es tiempo' (What I need is time).
    • →Comparatives: 'más/menos + adjective + que' (more/less... than), 'tan + adjective + como' (as... as). Superlatives: 'el/la/los/las + más/menos + adjective + de' (the most/least... in/of). Irregular forms: 'mejor' (better), 'peor' (worse), 'mayor' (older/bigger), 'menor' (younger/smaller).
    • →Indirect speech (estilo indirecto) requires changes in tense, pronouns, and time expressions. For example, direct: 'Dijo: "Estudio español"' becomes indirect: 'Dijo que estudiaba español.' Common changes: present → imperfect, future → conditional, preterite → pluperfect.
    Marking Points
    • Accurate use of hace/hacía for time expressions
    • Correct formation and application of cleft sentences for emphasis
    • Precise use of comparative and superlative structures
    • Correct application of rules for indirect speech
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Practice converting direct speech to indirect speech to master tense shifts
    • 💡Use cleft sentences in writing to add variety and emphasis
    • 💡Ensure comparative structures are used with the correct conjunctions (que/de lo que)
    • 💡Review the specific grammar list in Appendix 3 for all required constructions
    • 💡In the translation section, pay close attention to time expressions. If you see 'for' + a duration (e.g., 'for two years'), consider whether the action is still ongoing (use 'hace...que' + present) or was ongoing in the past (use 'hacía...que' + imperfect). This distinction often carries marks.
    • 💡When using cleft sentences, ensure you are emphasising the correct element. For example, to emphasise the place: 'Fue en Madrid donde nos conocimos.' To emphasise the time: 'Fue en 2020 cuando empezó la pandemia.' This shows you can manipulate sentence structure for effect.
    • 💡For comparatives, remember that 'que' is used after comparatives of inequality, but 'de' is used before numbers: 'más de diez' (more than ten). Also, avoid the common error of using 'más mejor' – use 'mejor' alone.
    Common Mistakes
    • Incorrect tense usage with hace/hacía
    • Misplacement of emphasis in cleft sentences
    • Errors in comparative structures (e.g., using 'más' with 'que' incorrectly)
    • Failure to adjust pronouns and tenses when converting to indirect speech
    • Confusing 'hace' and 'hacía': 'Hace' is used for actions still ongoing in the present, while 'hacía' is used for actions that were ongoing up to a past moment. For example, 'Hace una hora que espero' (I have been waiting for an hour) vs. 'Hacía una hora que esperaba cuando llegó' (I had been waiting for an hour when he arrived).
    • In cleft sentences, forgetting to use the correct relative pronoun: 'que' for people and things, 'quien' only for people. Also, ensure the verb after 'ser' agrees with the emphasised element: 'Fueron ellos quienes llegaron tarde.'
    • In indirect speech, failing to adjust time expressions: 'ahora' becomes 'entonces', 'hoy' becomes 'aquel día', 'mañana' becomes 'al día siguiente'. Also, remember that commands in direct speech become 'que + subjunctive' in indirect speech: 'Dijo: "Ven"' → 'Dijo que viniera.'
    Frequently Asked Questions
    What's the difference between 'hace' and 'hacía' in time expressions?
    'Hace' is used with the present tense to describe an action that started in the past and continues into the present. For example, 'Hace tres años que vivo en Madrid' means 'I have been living in Madrid for three years' (and I still live there). 'Hacía' is used with the imperfect tense to describe an action that had been happening up to a specific point in the past. For example, 'Hacía tres años que vivía en Madrid cuando conocí a María' means 'I had been living in Madrid for three years when I met María' (but I may not live there now).
    How do I form cleft sentences in Spanish?
    Cleft sentences in Spanish are formed using the verb 'ser' followed by the element you want to emphasise, and then a relative clause. The structure is: 'Ser + emphasised element + que/quien + rest of sentence'. For example, to emphasise the subject: 'Fue Juan quien rompió el vaso' (It was Juan who broke the glass). To emphasise the object: 'Lo que rompió Juan fue el vaso' (What Juan broke was the glass). To emphasise time or place: 'Fue ayer cuando ocurrió' (It was yesterday when it happened) or 'Fue en el parque donde nos vimos' (It was in the park where we saw each other).
    What are the irregular comparatives and superlatives in Spanish?
    The main irregular comparatives and superlatives are: 'bueno' (good) becomes 'mejor' (better) and 'el mejor' (the best); 'malo' (bad) becomes 'peor' (worse) and 'el peor' (the worst); 'grande' (big) becomes 'mayor' (older/bigger) and 'el mayor' (the oldest/biggest); 'pequeño' (small) becomes 'menor' (younger/smaller) and 'el menor' (the youngest/smallest). Note that 'más grande' and 'más pequeño' are also used for physical size, while 'mayor' and 'menor' are more common for age or importance.
    How do I change tenses in indirect speech?
    When converting direct speech to indirect speech, tenses usually shift back one step. Present tense becomes imperfect: 'Dice: "Estudio"' → 'Dice que estudiaba.' Future becomes conditional: 'Dirá: "Estudiaré"' → 'Dirá que estudiaría.' Preterite becomes pluperfect: 'Dijo: "Estudié"' → 'Dijo que había estudiado.' Imperfect stays the same: 'Dijo: "Estudiaba"' → 'Dijo que estudiaba.' Also, commands become 'que + imperfect subjunctive': 'Dijo: "Estudia"' → 'Dijo que estudiara.'
    Can I use 'más que' and 'más de' interchangeably?
    No, they have different uses. 'Más que' is used in comparisons of inequality: 'Tengo más libros que tú' (I have more books than you). 'Más de' is used before numbers or quantities: 'Tengo más de diez libros' (I have more than ten books). The same applies to 'menos que' and 'menos de'. Also, note that 'que' is used after 'tan' in equal comparisons: 'Tengo tantos libros como tú' (I have as many books as you).
    What is the difference between 'quien' and 'que' in cleft sentences?
    In cleft sentences, 'que' can be used for both people and things, while 'quien' is used only for people. For example, 'Fue María quien/que lo dijo' (It was María who said it) – both are correct, but 'quien' is more formal. For things, only 'que' is possible: 'Fue el libro que compré' (It was the book that I bought). Also, 'quien' must agree in number: 'Fueron ellos quienes llegaron' (It was they who arrived).