Pearson Edexcel · GCSE · Religious Studies
Overview guide · Check your current course specification before revising.
Good, Evil, and Suffering
This study guide tackles the profound philosophical problem of evil and suffering, a cornerstone of the Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies specification. It unpacks why the existence of a good, powerful God is questioned and explores the key theological defences, equipping candidates to analyse, evaluate, and excel in their exam.
- 6 min read
- 3 worked examples
- 2 practice questions
- 6 key terms
Study Notes
Overview
The problem of evil and suffering is a central challenge to theistic belief and a core component of the Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies course. Examiners expect candidates to demonstrate a precise understanding of the philosophical problem, known as the Inconsistent Triad, and to be able to clearly distinguish between moral and natural evil. This guide will equip you with the knowledge to explain the key theological responses, or theodicies — specifically the Free Will Defence and the Soul-Making Theodicy. A high-level response requires not just describing these ideas, but critically evaluating their strengths and weaknesses, integrating specific Sources of Wisdom and Authority (SOWA), and applying this knowledge to structured exam answers. Marks are awarded for demonstrating this analytical and evaluative skillset, moving beyond simple description to a sustained appraisal of complex arguments.
Key Concepts & Developments
The Inconsistent Triad
What it is: The philosophical puzzle, famously articulated by philosophers like Epicurus and later J.L. Mackie, that highlights a logical contradiction between three core beliefs about God in classical theism.
The Triad:
- God is Omnipotent (All-Powerful)
- God is Omnibenevolent (All-Good and All-Loving)
- Evil and Suffering Exist
Why it matters: The core of the problem is that if God is all-powerful, He could prevent evil. If He is all-good, He would want to prevent evil. Yet, evil exists. This apparent contradiction leads to the conclusion that either God does not exist, or He does not possess all these qualities. This is the fundamental argument candidates must understand and address.
Specific Knowledge: J.L. Mackie, David Hume, Epicurus.
Open full-size image (opens in a new tab)
Moral vs. Natural Evil
What it is: A critical distinction required in all exam answers.
- Moral Evil: Suffering that results from the free choices of human beings. Examples include murder, theft, war, and genocide (e.g., the Holocaust). The key concept is human agency.
- Natural Evil: Suffering that results from the workings of the natural world, independent of human action. Examples include earthquakes, tsunamis, disease (e.g., cancer), and famine caused by drought.
Why it matters: Examiners award marks for precise use of these terms and for using distinct examples. Conflating the two is a common mistake that limits marks. Theodicies often explain moral evil more effectively than natural evil, which is a key point for evaluation.
Key Individuals & Theodicies
St. Augustine of Hippo
Role: Early Christian theologian who formulated the classic Free Will Defence.
Key Actions: Argued that God created a perfect world, declaring it "very good" (Genesis 1:31). Evil is not a substance created by God, but a "privation of good" (privatio boni), just as darkness is an absence of light. Moral evil entered the world through the Fall (Genesis 3), when Adam and Eve misused their free will to disobey God. This original sin disrupted the perfect natural order, also leading to natural evil.
Impact: His theodicy became the foundation of traditional Christian attempts to resolve the problem of evil. It places the blame for evil squarely on humanity, preserving God's goodness.
John Hick
Role: 20th-century philosopher who developed the Soul-Making Theodicy.
Key Actions: Drawing on the ideas of the early church father Irenaeus, Hick argued that God did not create humans as perfect beings. Instead, He created them in His "image" with the potential to grow into His "likeness". The world is a "vale of soul-making", an environment designed for spiritual and moral development. Suffering and challenges are necessary tools for this growth, allowing humans to develop virtues like courage, compassion, and perseverance.
Impact: Hick's theodicy offers a purpose for suffering, framing it as a necessary part of a greater good. It is often seen as a more modern and scientifically compatible response, but is criticised for potentially justifying immense suffering.
Open full-size image (opens in a new tab)
Second-Order Concepts
Causation
- Cause of Moral Evil: According to the Free Will Defence, the direct cause is human misuse of God-given free will. The theological cause is the original sin of Adam and Eve.
- Cause of Suffering (Soul-Making): God allows suffering as an instrumental good, a necessary condition for humans to develop virtues and grow spiritually.
Consequence
- Consequence of the Fall: The introduction of sin, death, and suffering into the world. The disruption of the relationship between God and humanity, and the corruption of the natural order.
- Consequence of Soul-Making: The ultimate goal is universal salvation, where all individuals eventually achieve spiritual perfection and enter into a relationship with God.
Significance
- Significance of the Problem of Evil: It is arguably the greatest intellectual obstacle to belief in the God of classical theism. A candidate's ability to grapple with it demonstrates high-level theological and philosophical understanding.
- Significance of Theodicies: They represent sophisticated attempts to defend the rationality of religious belief in the face of evidence to the contrary. Evaluating their success is a key AO2 skill.
Check what you remember
Read the wording for your board, then hide it and explain Theodicy in your own words. Rough notes are fine. This is a self-check, with no mark or grade.
Reference: Pearson Edexcel
A philosophical and theological argument that attempts to justify the existence of God in light of the existence of evil and suffering.
Interactive Diagrams
1 interactive diagram to visualise key concepts
Conceptual Flow Outline
A diagram showing the logical contradiction at the heart of the Inconsistent Triad.
Worked Examples
3 worked examples — open one to explore the question and available guidance.
Practice Questions
Try the question, then reveal an answer plan or example response
Explain two ways the story of Job can be used to understand suffering. Refer to a source of wisdom and authority in your answer. (5 marks)
Hint: Think about what Job's experience teaches about faith and God's nature. Remember P.E.S.L.
'The Soul-Making Theodicy is the most convincing response to the problem of evil.' Evaluate this statement. (12 marks)
Hint: Compare the strengths of Soul-Making (e.g., purpose for suffering, compatibility with science) against its weaknesses (e.g., justifies suffering) and against the Free Will Defence.
Ready to test yourself interactively?
Active recall beats reading alone. Answer questions on Good, Evil, and Suffering with instant AI scoring and mark scheme guidance.
A week of Premium from your first lesson · Then the free plan continues · No card, no charge
Exam technique
How to turn what you know into marks
How to approach the question
1. **BUG** the question: Box the command word, Underline the key terms, Glance back at it. 2. Plan your points, especially for 5- and 12-mark questions. 3. Write your answer, following the specific structure for that question type.
How to structure your answer
- Essay questions
- For 12-mark questions: Introduction setting out your view. 2-3 developed paragraphs with arguments and counter-arguments, using evidence and SOWA. A justified conclusion that directly answers the question and weighs up the arguments.
- Source questions
- Not applicable for this paper.
- Explain questions
- For 5-mark questions: Two P.E.S.L. paragraphs. Point, Explain, Source of Wisdom/Authority, Link back to the question.
Timing
Approximately 1.25 minutes per mark. For a 12-mark question, this means allocating 15 minutes.
Common pitfalls
- Conflating moral and natural evil.
- Forgetting to include a Source of Wisdom and Authority in 5-mark questions (caps you at 2 marks).
- Writing a 'tennis match' essay for 12-mark questions without a clear line of argument or conclusion.
- Describing the story of the Fall without explaining its theological significance (i.e., the origin of evil).
What the command words want
- Explain
- Provide reasons or causes. For 5-mark questions, this requires SOWA.
- Describe
- Give a detailed account of two points.
- How far do you agree / Evaluate
- Make a judgement. You must consider both sides of the argument but come to a clear, justified conclusion.
Watch or listen (optional)
Test your understanding of Good, Evil, and Suffering
Active recall beats re-reading. Take an instant quiz now to test what you’ve learned and lock it into long-term memory.
A week of Premium from your first lesson · Then the free plan continues · No card, no charge