Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - 5th Century developments — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - 5th Century developments explained

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - 5th Century developments covers 12 specification points, including selection of archons by lot and The role of the Athenian Empire in the….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    selection of archons by lot

    Archons were Athens' senior annual magistrates, and their selection by lot is a key democratic mechanism of the 5th century. Aristotle's Constitution of Athens dates the change to 487/6 BC. Sortition meant that office depended on chance within an eligible pool, not on popularity, wealth or winning votes. Candidates were first selected in advance, and the lot then decided who held office for the year. Students should explain why this was democratic: it spread the chance of office across citizens and reduced the advantage of influential families. They should also recognise limits: the lot worked within a pre-selected group, and the archonship was less powerful than the generalship.

    the role of the Athenian Empire in the development of democracy

    The Athenian Empire helped shape Athenian democracy in the 5th century BC. Explain the Empire as a resource base: tribute from allies, held in the Delian League treasury from 478/7 BC and moved to Athens in 454 BC, helped fund public pay and the navy. Naval service drew heavily on the thetes, the poorest citizens, which strengthened their political claims. Use a dated example, such as pay for jury service introduced in the mid-5th century BC. A strong answer separates what the Empire enabled from what caused change and sets its benefits against the costs to allies. Historians debate whether the link was causal or coincidental, so a supported judgement weighs both sides.

    the reforms of Ephialtes and Pericles and their consequences

    This statement asks you to explain two stages of fifth-century Athenian democratic change: the reforms of Ephialtes, dated to 462–461 BCE, and those associated with Pericles, together with their consequences. Ephialtes stripped the Areopagus of its political oversight of officials and shifted power to the Council of Five Hundred, the Assembly and the law courts. Pericles introduced pay for jurors in the 450s BCE, allowing poorer citizens to serve, and his citizenship law of 451/0 BCE restricted citizenship to those with two Athenian parents. Consequences means showing effects on the distribution of power: wider civic participation, reliance on large juries and tighter citizenship boundaries. Method: state each reform, name its mechanism, then judge its effect on who held power.

    change in powers of the Areopagus

    This statement asks you to understand how and why the Areopagus, the council traditionally composed of former archons, changed in its powers during the fifth century BCE. Before Ephialtes' reforms of 462–461 BCE, it oversaw officials and acted as a guardian of the laws, giving an aristocratic body a check on the demos. Ephialtes removed these political functions, so the council was left with its established jurisdictions, principally homicide and some religious cases, while the Council of Five Hundred, the Assembly and the jury courts gained power. Method: identify the specific power that changed, state the before and after, and avoid treating the Areopagus as abolished. Distractors often claim total abolition or attribute the change to the wrong leader.

    payment for office

    Payment for office means the Athenian state paying citizens for public duties, so poorer men could take part without losing income. The 5th-century landmark was pay for jury service in the people's courts, which Aristotle's Constitution of Athens links to Pericles, traditionally dated to the 450s BCE. Other public roles attracted pay at different times, and the sources do not give one clear date for each. Pay for attending the Assembly came later, in the 4th century, so treat it as causal context rather than 5th-century content. In a multiple-choice question, check whether an option describes 5th-century payment for public roles, and reject options with the wrong period or a different reform.

    citizenship laws

    Citizenship laws defined who held full political rights in Athens, such as voting in the Assembly, serving on juries and holding office. The key 5th-century measure was a law of 451/0 BCE, attributed to Pericles by Aristotle's Constitution of Athens, requiring two Athenian citizen parents. Before it, descent from an Athenian father was generally enough, so the law narrowed entry. Learners must identify its scope: who counted as citizens, not women's voting or the status of slaves. Explain how restriction linked to democracy's idea of a defined citizen body, and why motives are debated.

    the organs of democracy

    The organs of democracy were the bodies through which Athenian citizens held and exercised power in the fifth century. Learn each body through its function. The Assembly (ekklesia) voted on decrees and major decisions. The Council of Five Hundred (boule) prepared business for the Assembly and oversaw officials. Law courts (dikasteria) judged cases before large juries of citizens chosen by lot. Magistracies (archai) carried out administration; most were filled by lot, while generals (strategoi) were elected. Method: identify the function named in the question, then match it to one body, rejecting options that give a body another body's role. For example, if a question asks which body set the Assembly's agenda, the answer is the Council, not the Assembly.

    the Assembly: organisation of meetings and importance of public speaking skills

    The Assembly was where Athenian citizens made collective decisions, so its organisation and speaking were central. Membership was open to adult male citizens, who met in the open air on the Pnyx hill. The Council prepared the agenda in advance, and a prytany drawn from the Council presided over proceedings. Quorums applied to certain votes; ostracism, for example, needed at least 6000 votes. Because every citizen had an equal right to speak (isegoria), persuasive speaking shaped influence over decisions. Method: test each option against these facts, for example rejecting any claim that only officials or the wealthy could address the Assembly.

    the Boule: function and powers

    The Boule was Athens' council of 500 citizens, 50 drawn by lot from each of the ten tribes for a one-year term. Its function was to prepare business: it drafted proposals (probouleumata) for the Assembly to vote on and supervised administration such as finance and the navy. Its powers were practical rather than sovereign. It scrutinised incoming officials before they took office and could hold magistrates to account. Students should explain how preparation shaped Assembly decisions without treating the Boule as the final authority. A strong answer uses one concrete example, such as its oversight of the fleet, and states clearly what the Boule could and could not decide alone.

    the law-courts: function and powers

    Athenian law-courts (dikasteria) were citizen juries, typically several hundred strong, selected by lot on the day of hearing to decide cases without professional judges. Their function was to hear private and public suits and to reach a verdict by majority vote. Their powers were significant but bounded: jurors decided guilt or liability, and in many cases the court also set the penalty. There was no public prosecutor, so litigants presented their own cases. Students should explain how the jury system gave ordinary citizens authority over justice, and how that authority was limited by procedure, time limits and the speeches of the parties. A strong answer uses one concrete example, such as a public suit (graphe), and states clearly what the court could decide.

    qualification and accountability of magistrates

    This statement asks you to explain how Athenian magistrates were qualified and held to account in the 5th century. Most magistracies were filled by lot, so qualification mainly meant meeting requirements of male citizenship and minimum age, with some posts also restricted by property class. The dokimasia (scrutiny) checked each selected candidate's eligibility before office was taken up. Accountability operated through the euthyna, an audit at the end of a term, and officials could face prosecution in the lawcourts. Teach the two clauses separately: entry into office versus conduct during and after it. Name the mechanism, state what it checked, then link it to limiting individual power.

    demagogues and their influence, including exploitation of the lawcourts

    This statement asks you to explain who demagogues were, how they gained influence, and how they exploited the lawcourts in 5th-century Athens. A demagogue was a leading citizen who swayed the Assembly (ekklesia) by speaking, so influence rested on persuasion and reputation rather than formal office. Cleon, Cleophon and Hyperbolus are common examples, but much of the evidence is hostile, coming from sources such as Thucydides and Aristophanes. Exploitation of the lawcourts (dikasteria) meant using public prosecutions against rivals before large juries whose members were paid for service. Teach the three clauses separately, and name the arena and outcome for each example.

    Your focus

    1. Identify selection by lot as the method used to choose archons in the 5th century.
    2. Explain how a pre-selected pool limited the operation of sortition.
    3. Justify the democratic significance of selecting archons by lot, using the date 487/6 BC.
    Show all 36 objectives
    1. Explain how tribute and the Delian League treasury supported democratic institutions in Athens.
    2. Evaluate the Empire's role against other factors in the development of democracy.
    3. Assess the costs of empire for allies in a supported judgement.
    4. Explain the mechanism by which Ephialtes' reforms shifted power away from the Areopagus.
    5. Assess the consequences of Pericles' jury pay and citizenship law for participation.
    6. Evaluate the balance between change and continuity in Athenian democracy in the fifth century BCE.
    7. Identify the specific powers removed from the Areopagus by Ephialtes.
    8. Distinguish between the abolition of an institution and the reduction of its powers.
    9. Explain why the Areopagus's retained jurisdictions still mattered in Athenian society.
    10. Identify the 5th-century reform of jury pay in the people's courts.
    11. Distinguish 5th-century payment for public office from 4th-century Assembly pay.
    12. Explain how payment for public duties affected access to participation in Athenian democracy.
    13. State the date and parent requirement of the 451/0 BCE citizenship law.
    14. Distinguish citizenship rules from political rights such as voting and jury service.
    15. Explain how restricting citizenship affected the composition of the Athenian citizen body.
    16. Identify the main organs of Athenian democracy and their functions.
    17. Match a given function to the correct body in a multiple-choice question.
    18. Explain how selection by lot or election affected each body's operation.
    19. Describe how the Assembly's meetings were organised, including who presided and who set the agenda.
    20. Explain why the equal right to speak made public speaking skills important.
    21. Identify the correct statement about Assembly membership or quorum in a multiple-choice question.
    22. Identify the membership and selection of the Boule accurately.
    23. Explain how the Boule's preparatory role fed into Assembly decisions.
    24. Evaluate the limits of the Boule's powers using a specific example.
    25. Identify how jurors were selected and how verdicts were reached.
    26. Explain the range of powers the law-courts held over guilt and penalty.
    27. Evaluate the procedural limits on the courts using a specific example.
    28. Identify the eligibility requirements for Athenian magistrates in the 5th century.
    29. Describe the dokimasia and the euthyna as separate accountability mechanisms.
    30. Explain how selection by lot and public scrutiny limited the power of individual officials.
    31. Define a demagogue and distinguish influence through persuasion from formal office.
    32. Identify ways in which prosecutions in the lawcourts could be used against political rivals.
    33. Evaluate how far the evidence of hostile sources can be trusted about named demagogues.

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - 5th Century developments exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies selection by lot as a process in which chance, not voting, determines who holds the archonship.
    • Dates the introduction of sortition for archons to 487/6 BC and attributes this dating to Aristotle's Constitution of Athens.
    • Explains that the lot operated within a pre-selected pool of eligible citizens.
    • Links sortition to the democratic idea of equal opportunity for citizens to hold office.
    • Recognises a limit, such as the archonship's reduced power compared with the generalship.
    • Explains that tribute from allies provided money that supported Athenian public pay and institutions.
    • Explains that the Delian League treasury moved to Athens in 454 BC, increasing Athenian control of the funds.
    • Links naval service, drawn heavily from the thetes, to stronger political claims by poorer citizens.
    • Evaluates whether the Empire caused democratic change or coincided with it, reaching a supported judgement.
    • Considers the costs to allies, showing the coercive side of Athenian imperial control alongside its benefits.
    • Places Empire-related developments in their 5th-century chronology and does not treat them as a single moment.
    • Explains Ephialtes' reforms as a transfer of political power from the Areopagus to the Council of Five Hundred, the Assembly and the courts.
    • Describes Pericles' introduction of jury pay as a mechanism that widened participation for poorer citizens.
    • Evaluates the citizenship law of 451/0 BCE as a restriction on who could hold civic rights.
    • Connects each reform to its consequence, such as larger juries or greater civic participation, supported by specific evidence.
    • Assesses how far the reforms changed the balance of power, including any continuities such as the Areopagus keeping homicide jurisdiction.
    • Identifies that the Areopagus lost its political oversight of officials rather than being abolished.
    • Recognises that the council retained homicide and some religious jurisdiction after the change.
    • Links the reduction of its powers to Ephialtes' reforms of 462–461 BCE.
    • Distinguishes the council's earlier role as guardian of the laws from the narrower judicial role that remained.
    • Identifies payment for office as state pay for public duties rather than pay for any paid employment.
    • Links jury pay in the people's courts to 5th-century Athenian democracy.
    • Explains that pay widened access for citizens who could not afford to lose income.
    • Distinguishes 5th-century developments from later reforms such as Assembly pay.
    • Attributes the jury pay reform to Pericles, citing Aristotle's Constitution of Athens as the source.
    • Identifies the 451/0 BCE law as the key 5th-century citizenship measure.
    • States that the law required two Athenian citizen parents for citizenship.
    • Explains that the law narrowed entry to the citizen body and reduced the number with full political rights.
    • Recognises that the law governed citizenship, not the separate exclusion of women from voting or the status of slaves and metics.
    • Links the law to the democracy's definition of the Athenian people as a defined community.
    • Identifies the Assembly as the body in which citizens voted on decrees and major decisions.
    • Distinguishes the Council of Five Hundred as the body that prepared business and oversaw officials.
    • Recognises law courts as large juries of citizens, chosen by lot, that judged cases.
    • Explains that most magistrates were filled by lot, whereas generals were elected.
    • Matches each function named in the question to one specific body rather than to democracy in general.
    • Identifies the Assembly as open to adult male citizens who met in the open air on the Pnyx hill.
    • Explains that the Council prepared the agenda in advance and that a prytany drawn from the Council presided.
    • Notes that quorums applied to certain votes, such as ostracism, which needed at least 6000 votes.
    • Links isegoria, the equal right of citizens to address the Assembly, to the need for persuasive speaking.
    • Evaluates how skill in argument, proposing motions and answering rivals could shape a citizen's influence over decisions.
    • Identifies the Boule as a council of 500 citizens, with 50 chosen by lot from each of the ten tribes.
    • Explains that the Boule prepared proposals for the Assembly rather than making binding decisions alone.
    • Describes supervisory responsibilities such as finance, the navy and the scrutiny of incoming officials.
    • Recognises that the Assembly held the final vote, so the Boule's authority was bounded.
    • Supports a point on function or power with a specific example, such as oversight of the fleet.
    • Identifies the law-courts as citizen juries selected by lot on the day of the hearing.
    • Explains that juries reached verdicts by majority vote rather than through professional judges.
    • Describes the court's power to decide guilt or liability and, in many cases, to set the penalty.
    • Recognises that litigants prosecuted their own cases because there was no public prosecutor.
    • Notes a procedural limit on the court, such as time limits on speeches, and supports it with an example.
    • Identifies that most magistracies were filled by lot, so eligibility rules applied to candidates selected at random.
    • States that qualification included male citizenship and a minimum age, with some offices also restricted by property class.
    • Describes the dokimasia as a scrutiny of a selected candidate's eligibility before he took up office.
    • Explains the euthyna as an audit of an official's conduct and accounts at the end of a term.
    • Links accountability to the possibility of prosecution in the lawcourts if misconduct was found.
    • Identifies a demagogue as an influential citizen whose power came mainly from persuading the Assembly rather than from a formal office.
    • Recognises that influence depended on speaking skill, reputation and repeated success in debate.
    • Names examples such as Cleon, Cleophon or Hyperbolus and links each to the Assembly or the courts.
    • Explains that public prosecutions in the lawcourts could be used against political rivals.
    • Notes that large paid juries gave leaders a wide audience and a route to shape outcomes.
    • Evaluates the hostility of sources such as Thucydides and Aristophanes when judging named demagogues.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Eliminate options that describe election, wealth-based selection or a show of hands, because these contradict the lot.
    • 💡Recall 487/6 BC as the date of the change and check that any date given in an option falls within the 5th century.
    • 💡Reject distractors that imply every citizen could be drawn directly, since the lot selected from a pre-selected group.
    • 💡Plan your judgement before writing, so every paragraph tests a link between the Empire and democratic change.
    • 💡Use dated, specific examples such as the move of the treasury in 454 BC or jury pay, and state what each one shows.
    • 💡Make the chain explicit in each paragraph: resource, then state action, then effect on citizens.
    • 💡Plan each paragraph around one reform, its mechanism and its consequence.
    • 💡Anchor each claim with a specific date and a named institution.
    • 💡Finish by weighing how far the reforms changed the balance of power, rather than only describing what changed.
    • 💡Eliminate options that describe abolition before choosing the one describing a loss of specific powers.
    • 💡Check whether an option names the power that changed, not just the institution.
    • 💡Match the date and the leader to Ephialtes' reforms before selecting an answer.
    • 💡Check the period first and reject any option dated outside the 5th century unless it is labelled as causal context.
    • 💡Look for the phrase public duties or public roles, since the statement concerns office rather than private employment.
    • 💡Match jury pay to Pericles and the people's courts, and do not attach it to later reforms.
    • 💡Read the date and parent requirement in each option before choosing an answer.
    • 💡Eliminate options that confuse citizenship with the political rights of women or slaves.
    • 💡Check whether an option describes the law's motives; these are debated, so prefer options that present them as interpretations.
    • 💡Underline the function named in each MCQ stem before reading the options.
    • 💡Eliminate any option that gives one body a role that belongs to another body.
    • 💡Learn the selection method (lot or election) alongside each body's function so that both can be checked together.
    • 💡Note which details concern organisation (place, membership, agenda, presiding officers) and which concern speaking (isegoria, persuasion).
    • 💡Check each MCQ option against a single fact, and reject the option if any part of it is wrong.
    • 💡Remember that the Council, not the Assembly, set the agenda in advance.
    • 💡Check each answer option against the two parts of the statement: what the Boule did and what powers it held.
    • 💡Eliminate any option that gives the Boule final decision-making authority, since the Assembly held that role.
    • 💡When choosing between options, prefer the one that names a specific responsibility, such as finance or scrutiny of officials, over a vague description.
    • 💡Check each answer option against both parts of the statement: the function of the courts and the powers they held.
    • 💡Eliminate any option that describes professional judges or a public prosecutor, since neither matches the Athenian system.
    • 💡When choosing between options, prefer the one that describes a concrete procedure, such as selection by lot or time-limited speeches, over a general claim about democracy.
    • 💡Pair each Greek term with an English gloss, such as dokimasia (scrutiny) or euthyna (audit), so your reasoning names a specific mechanism.
    • 💡When an option combines a correct mechanism with an incorrect timing, check the timing against entry into office and the end of the term before selecting it.
    • 💡Before choosing an answer, decide whether the question concerns qualification or accountability, and eliminate options that address the other clause.
    • 💡Name the arena, either the Assembly or the lawcourt, in every example you give, because this shows you understand how influence operated.
    • 💡When an option describes a demagogue's influence, check whether it relies on persuasion or on a specific office before selecting it.
    • 💡Consider whether the evidence for a named demagogue comes from a hostile author, and eliminate options that treat that evidence as uncontested.
    Common Mistakes
    • Describes archons as elected by majority vote; state that they were chosen by lot in this period.
    • Treats the lot as drawing from all citizens without restriction; explain the pre-selected pool of candidates.
    • Confuses the introduction of sortition with the reforms of Ephialtes in 462/1 BC; keep sortition separate from the reforms that reduced the Areopagus's powers.
    • Describes the Empire as the sole cause of democracy; weigh other factors such as the reforms of Ephialtes.
    • Presents tribute as purely voluntary contributions; explain the increasing compulsion Athens used over its allies.
    • Lists Empire facts without linking them to democratic participation; explain how each point affected citizens' involvement in government.
    • Lists the reforms without explaining their consequences; correct this by stating the effect of each reform on the distribution of power.
    • Attributes all the reforms to Pericles; correct this by separating Ephialtes' measures of 462–461 BCE from Pericles' measures in the 450s BCE and the citizenship law of 451/0 BCE.
    • Describes the Areopagus as abolished; correct this by stating that it lost political oversight but kept specified judicial functions.
    • Treats the Areopagus as abolished; correct this by recognising that it kept specified judicial functions.
    • Credits Pericles with stripping the Areopagus of its political powers; correct this by attributing the change to Ephialtes.
    • Confuses the Areopagus with the Council of Five Hundred; correct this by noting that the Five Hundred were a separate body that gained power.
    • Treats all public pay as one reform with a single date; keep jury pay separate from other roles.
    • Assigns Assembly pay to the 5th century; place it in the 4th century as causal context.
    • Describes pay as a reward for wealth rather than a means of access; explain that it aimed to let poorer citizens participate.
    • Gives the citizenship law a date outside 451/0 BCE; correct it to 451/0 BCE.
    • Describes descent from one Athenian parent as the requirement; correct it to two Athenian citizen parents.
    • Treats women's exclusion from voting as the content of the citizenship law; separate political exclusion from the citizenship rules.
    • Treats the organs of democracy as meaning only the Assembly; correct to include the Council, the courts and the magistracies.
    • Assigns the Assembly control over setting its own agenda; correct to the Council, which prepared business in advance.
    • Describes all officials as elected; correct to note that most magistrates were chosen by lot and only generals were elected.
    • Assumes women, enslaved people or resident foreigners could address the Assembly; correct to adult male citizens only.
    • Assigns presidency of the Assembly to the generals; correct to a prytany drawn from the Council.
    • Treats speaking as restricted to officials or the wealthy; correct to any citizen who chose to address the meeting.
    • Describes the Boule as the sovereign body of Athens; correct this by stating that the Assembly made the final decisions.
    • Presents the Boule's members as elected for their expertise; correct this by stating that members were selected by lot for one year.
    • Assigns the Boule control of the law-courts; correct this by separating its council duties from the juries that decided cases.
    • Lists the Boule's powers without linking them to the Assembly; correct this by explaining how its preparatory role fed into the vote.
    • Describes the law-courts as staffed by professional judges; correct this by stating that citizen juries decided cases.
    • Assumes the state brought most prosecutions; correct this by stating that private litigants brought their own cases.
    • Presents the jury as deciding only guilt; correct this by noting that in many cases it also fixed the penalty.
    • Treats the juries as permanent officials; correct this by stating that they were selected by lot for each hearing.
    • Assumes all magistrates were elected; correct this by recognising that most were chosen by lot, while generals were elected.
    • Places the dokimasia at the end of an official's term; correct this by placing scrutiny before the official entered office.
    • Treats the euthyna as a criminal trial for every official; correct this by describing it as a routine audit that could lead to prosecution if faults were found.
    • Treats every demagogue as a holder of an elected office; correct this by distinguishing influence through persuasion from formal authority.
    • Confuses the Assembly with the lawcourts, attributing debate-based power to the jury alone; correct this by keeping the two institutions separate.
    • Assumes demagogues always acted corruptly, presenting hostile source claims as neutral fact; correct this by attributing each claim to its source.