Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Cleisthenes — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Cleisthenes explained

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Cleisthenes covers 9 specification points, including reforms of Cleisthenes: and demes.

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    reforms of Cleisthenes:

    Cleisthenes, an Alcmaeonid who gained popular backing in 508/7 BC after his struggle with Isagoras, reorganised Athens' citizens. Four old tribes gave way to ten new ones, each made of three trittyes from city, coast and inland, so 10 × 3 = 30 trittyes. Local demes became the basis of citizenship. Each tribe supplied fifty councillors to a Council of 500 (10 × 50 = 500) that prepared Assembly business. Ostracism and equality under the law are also linked to him. Multiple-choice items test exact numbers, terms and purposes.

    demes

    Demes were the local communities forming the basic units of Cleisthenes' reorganised citizen body from c. 508/7 BCE. Attica contained roughly 139 demes, each with its own assembly, officials and register. A man was enrolled in his deme on reaching adulthood, and that enrolment recorded his citizenship. Official identity used the deme name, as in Alcibiades of Scambonidae. Each deme sat within one of three regions (city, coast, inland) and fed into one of the ten tribes. Study demes by tracing a citizen's path from deme to trittys to tribe. Explain the aim of breaking up older aristocratic family networks through this local layer. Keep demes distinct from tribes: demes are local, tribes are the wider units.

    tribes

    Tribes (phylai) were the ten units Cleisthenes created from c. 508/7 BCE to organise the Athenian citizen body. Each tribe combined three trittyes from the city, coast and inland regions, so no tribe was purely urban or rural. Tribes took their names from heroes selected through Delphi and structured the Council of 500, which drew fifty members from each tribe. Tribes also structured military service, with each supplying a regiment. Earlier, four kinship-based Ionian tribes existed; treat this only as causal context, since Cleisthenes replaced them. Study tribes by linking each one to its demes, its council seats and the regional mix within it.

    Council of 500 (Boule)

    The Council of 500, called the boulē in Greek, was a central body of Athenian democracy established by Cleisthenes' reforms of 508/7 BCE. Its size reflects its structure: 10 tribes (phylai) × 50 councillors = 500 members. Each tribe supplied 50 members drawn from its demes, so the Council represented the whole citizen body rather than one region or social group. Councillors served for one year. The Boule's main job was preparatory: it drafted proposals that the Assembly (ekklesia) then debated and voted on, and it also supervised administrative matters. Students should be able to give the name in English and Greek, explain the tribal basis of membership, and describe how the Boule related to the Assembly.

    sortition

    Sortition is selection by lot, so people were chosen by chance rather than by election or personal ambition. In Athenian democracy it was a deliberate principle of equal opportunity: eligible citizens had the same chance of being selected. Allotment devices called kleroteria were used to draw names, and lot filled many offices, jury panels and the seats of the Council of 500. The main contrast is with election by vote, carried out by show of hands (cheirotonia), which was used for some posts, most notably the generals (strategoi). Students should define sortition, explain its democratic rationale, and identify both where it was used and where it was not.

    possible introduction of ostracism

    This statement concerns the possible introduction of ostracism under Cleisthenes' reforms of Athenian democracy. Ostracism allowed citizens to vote, by writing a name on a potsherd (ostrakon), to exile a named individual for ten years without confiscating property. Aristotle links the procedure to Cleisthenes as a safeguard against tyranny, but 'possible' signals scholarly debate over this attribution. Explain the purpose ostracism was meant to serve, the evidence for connecting it with Cleisthenes, and why its origin remains uncertain. Use one concrete example, such as the first recorded ostracism in 487 BC, to show how it worked in practice.

    subsequent introduction of strategoi (generals)

    This statement concerns the subsequent introduction of strategoi (generals) after Cleisthenes' core reforms. The strategoi were ten officers elected each year, traditionally one from each of the ten tribes, who commanded Athenian forces and held wide political influence. Aristotle's later account associates their election with the tribal organisation of Cleisthenes, but the precise date of the office's creation is debated. Explain what the office involved, how the tribal system shaped selection, and why 'subsequent' matters: it places the change after the core reforms. Use the battle of Marathon in 490 BC, where Herodotus names ten generals, to test your understanding of the office in practice.

    responses to and consequences of his reforms

    This criterion asks you to evaluate how Athenians responded to Cleisthenes' reforms and what those reforms led to. Identify the key changes first: citizens regrouped into demes, demes combined into ten tribes, a Boule of 500, and ostracism introduced. For responses, look for acceptance, resistance or adaptation, and treat ancient accounts such as Herodotus and Aristotle with care, noting their date and perspective. For consequences, separate immediate effects on participation and council membership from longer-term developments. A strong answer weighs these against each other: state a judgement, support it with one reform and its outcome, then assess how far the evidence supports it.

    the extent to which these reforms redefined how Athenians viewed themselves in relation to each other and the state

    This criterion asks how far Cleisthenes' reforms changed the way Athenians saw themselves in relation to one another and the state. Define both relationships first. Citizen-to-citizen ties could shift when demes and the ten new tribes mixed people from different regions. Citizen-to-state ties could shift through roles such as membership of the Boule of 500 and the use of ostracism. Separate evidence of changed attitudes from evidence of new institutions, because structural change does not prove a change in belief. Ancient sources are limited and partisan, so infer carefully. Finish with a judgement weighing transformation against continuity in family, locality and social ties.

    Your focus

    1. Recall the main Cleisthenic reforms with correct terms and numbers.
    2. Distinguish Cleisthenes' reforms from those of Solon.
    3. Explain the purpose of the reforms in reshaping political life in Athens.
    Show all 27 objectives
    1. Explain the function of demes in Cleisthenes' reorganisation of citizenship.
    2. Trace the route from deme to trittys to tribe.
    3. Identify an example of the deme name being used to identify a citizen.
    4. Explain how each Cleisthenic tribe combined city, coast and inland trittyes.
    5. Link tribal membership to the Council of 500.
    6. Distinguish the Cleisthenic tribes from the earlier four Ionian tribes.
    7. State the Council's size and explain the 10 × 50 = 500 calculation.
    8. Distinguish the Boule's preparatory role from the Assembly's decision-making role.
    9. Explain how the tribal organisation shaped the Council's membership.
    10. Define sortition in one clear sentence.
    11. Identify two Athenian bodies or offices that were filled by lot.
    12. Explain why lot was regarded as a democratic method of selection.
    13. State that ostracism was a citizen vote that exiled a named individual for ten years without confiscation of property.
    14. Evaluate the evidence for linking ostracism to Cleisthenes, including the role of Aristotle's account.
    15. Explain the purpose ostracism served within Athenian democracy, using a concrete example.
    16. State that the strategoi were ten officers elected annually, traditionally one from each tribe.
    17. Explain how the tribal system shaped the selection of generals.
    18. Assess the significance of the word 'subsequent' for the chronology of Cleisthenes' reforms.
    19. Identify at least three Cleisthenic reforms and state the change each made to citizen organisation or government.
    20. Explain how a named group or institution responded to the reforms, using a specific piece of evidence.
    21. Evaluate the balance between responses and consequences in a reasoned conclusion.
    22. Explain how the demes and tribes could change ties between Athenians from different regions.
    23. Evaluate evidence for changed self-perception, distinguishing it from institutional change.
    24. Justify a judgement on the extent of redefinition in a supported conclusion.

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Cleisthenes exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies the replacement of the four old tribes with ten new tribes as the central restructuring of the citizen body.
    • States that each new tribe combined three trittyes, one each from city, coast and inland, giving thirty trittyes in total.
    • Recognises the deme as the local unit used for citizen registration and as the building block of the tribal system.
    • Gives the Council of 500 correctly as fifty members from each of the ten tribes, preparing business for the Assembly.
    • Connects ostracism and the idea of equality under the law with Cleisthenes, and recognises the purpose of weakening aristocratic local power.
    • Places the reforms in the right context of 508/7 BC and the rivalry with Isagoras, rather than confusing them with Solon's earlier changes.
    • Defines demes as local communities that formed the basic units of Cleisthenes' citizen body.
    • Explains that a man was enrolled in his deme on reaching adulthood, and that enrolment recorded his citizenship.
    • Links each deme to a trittys and then to one of the ten tribes, showing the route from local to wider level.
    • Uses the deme name in identifying a citizen, as in Alcibiades of Scambonidae.
    • Distinguishes demes as local units from tribes as the wider units.
    • Defines tribes as the ten units Cleisthenes created to organise the citizen body.
    • Explains that each tribe combined three trittyes drawn from the city, coast and inland regions.
    • Identifies the Council of 500 as drawing fifty members from each tribe.
    • Notes that tribes took their names from heroes selected through Delphi.
    • Compares the Cleisthenic tribes with the earlier four kinship-based Ionian tribes, treating the earlier system as causal context only.
    • Identifies the Council of 500 as the boulē, the body of 500 councillors.
    • Explains that each of the 10 tribes supplied 50 members, giving a total of 500.
    • Describes the Boule's preparatory role of drafting business before Assembly votes.
    • Links membership to the demes and the tribal structure created by Cleisthenes.
    • Defines sortition as selection by lot, meaning chance rather than vote.
    • Explains that lot gave each eligible citizen an equal chance of selection.
    • Links sortition to the filling of the Council of 500 from the tribes.
    • Contrasts lot with election, using the generals (strategoi) as the main example.
    • Explains that ostracism was a vote to exile a named individual for ten years without confiscation of property.
    • Identifies Aristotle's Constitution of the Athenians as the main ancient source linking the procedure to Cleisthenes.
    • Recognises that the word 'possible' signals that the attribution to Cleisthenes is debated rather than certain.
    • Describes the purpose of ostracism as a safeguard against the rise of a tyrant or an overly dominant individual.
    • Uses a concrete case, such as the first recorded ostracism in 487 BC, to show the procedure in operation.
    • Describes the strategoi as ten officers elected annually who commanded Athenian forces.
    • Explains that the tribal organisation of Cleisthenes shaped how the generals were selected.
    • Recognises that 'subsequent' places the introduction of the office after the core reforms rather than within them.
    • Notes that the precise date of the office's creation is debated among scholars.
    • Uses the battle of Marathon in 490 BC, where Herodotus names ten generals, as evidence of the office in use.
    • Identifies specific Cleisthenic reforms, such as demes, the ten tribes, the Boule of 500 and ostracism, and links each to a response or consequence.
    • Explains a response to the reforms by identifying who reacted, how they reacted and what evidence shows this.
    • Distinguishes immediate consequences from longer-term developments and explains the causal link between each change and its effect.
    • Evaluates source evidence on responses and consequences, noting the date and perspective of accounts such as those by Herodotus and Aristotle.
    • Reaches a supported judgement on the balance between responses and consequences rather than describing them in sequence.
    • Identifies how the demes and tribes regrouped citizens across regions and explains how this could alter ties between Athenians.
    • Explains how membership of the Boule of 500 gave citizens a role in government and how this could affect their view of the state.
    • Distinguishes evidence of changed self-perception, such as civic identity, from evidence of institutional change alone.
    • Evaluates the limits of ancient evidence on attitudes, noting that identity must often be inferred from institutions and sources.
    • Reaches a judgement on how far the reforms redefined identity, weighing the case for change against continuity in social ties.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Learn the key numbers with their calculations: 10 tribes, 3 trittyes each, 30 trittyes, 50 councillors per tribe, 500 councillors.
    • 💡Read every option fully and eliminate those that belong to Solon or to later periods before choosing.
    • 💡Use a quick grid of term, definition and purpose for tribe, trittys, deme, Council and ostracism to avoid mixing similar words.
    • 💡Keep demes and tribes separate in every answer and state which level you are discussing.
    • 💡Use a precise route, such as deme to trittys to tribe, to show how the units connected.
    • 💡Present the aims of Cleisthenes as interpretation and support each claim with evidence from the reforms.
    • 💡Name the three regions and explain how their mixing in each tribe supported Cleisthenes' aims.
    • 💡Link tribes to the Council of 500 with the figure of fifty members per tribe, and state the source of that figure.
    • 💡Keep the earlier Ionian tribes in a clearly labelled context sentence so they are not confused with the reformed system.
    • 💡Memorise 10 × 50 = 500 as the link between the Council's structure and its name.
    • 💡Distinguish the boule (Council) from the ekklesia (Assembly) in every answer you write or check.
    • 💡When an option describes the Council as making final decisions, check whether it should describe preparing business instead.
    • 💡Learn the contrast between lot and election, using the generals as your example of election.
    • 💡Use the term sortition with a definition rather than just the word itself.
    • 💡When an option names a particular office, check whether that office was filled by lot or by election.
    • 💡Check each option against the word 'possible' and reject any option that treats the Cleisthenic link as certain.
    • 💡Recall the key details of the procedure, namely the potsherd, the ten-year exile and the absence of confiscation, and use them to eliminate distractors.
    • 💡When two options both mention tyranny, prefer the one that also describes the procedure accurately.
    • 💡Note the word 'subsequent' and check that each option places the development after the core reforms.
    • 💡Remember the number ten, linked to one general from each of the ten tribes, and use it to test options.
    • 💡Distinguish the strategoi from other bodies such as the Boule or the archons when options list several institutions.
    • 💡Plan two columns before writing, one for responses and one for consequences, each with a named reform and one piece of evidence.
    • 💡Open each paragraph with a claim about a response or consequence, then support it with a specific example and explain its significance.
    • 💡Finish with a judgement that compares the strength of responses and consequences, and state what the evidence cannot establish.
    • 💡Define self-perception early in the answer, then test each reform against it: does it change how citizens see each other, the state or both?
    • 💡Use inference carefully: say what the evidence suggests about attitudes and what it cannot prove.
    • 💡Conclude with a clear judgement on extent that names the strongest and weakest evidence for change.
    Common Mistakes
    • Confuses the Council of 500 with Solon's Council of 400; remember ten tribes each sending fifty members.
    • Mixes up tribes, trittyes and demes; remember a tribe contained three trittyes and trittyes were made up of demes.
    • Assigns the four property classes to Cleisthenes; attribute them to Solon and keep the two reformers separate.
    • Claims ostracism removed people by a vote in the Council; remember that it was linked to the citizen body voting, and check the option wording carefully.
    • Treats the reforms as purely administrative; recall that the sources connect them with reducing the power of regional and aristocratic groupings.
    • Treats demes as the ten tribes; correct by remembering that there were ten tribes and roughly 139 demes.
    • Describes demes as bodies that sent their members to the Council as whole units; correct by explaining that members were chosen by lot within quotas allotted to each deme in proportion to its size.
    • Uses only a father's name for official identity; correct by showing that the deme name was added to a citizen's identification.
    • Presents the figure of 139 demes as exact; correct by describing it as roughly 139.
    • Confuses tribes with demes; correct by stating that tribes were ten large units and demes were local communities within them.
    • Describes tribes as purely local; correct by stating that each tribe mixed city, coast and inland trittyes.
    • Treats the four Ionian tribes as the Cleisthenic system; correct by noting that Cleisthenes replaced them with ten tribes.
    • Confuses the Boule with the Assembly (ekklesia), which all eligible citizens could attend; correct by stating that the Boule prepared business and the Assembly decided it.
    • Assumes the Council was made up of elected aristocrats; correct by noting that members were drawn from each tribe, giving broad representation.
    • Gives the Council's size without the tribal structure that explains it; correct by showing the calculation 10 tribes × 50 councillors = 500.
    • Treats sortition as random selection of anyone, ignoring eligibility rules; correct by noting that only eligible citizens entered the lot.
    • Assumes every Athenian office was filled by lot; correct by noting that the generals were elected.
    • Confuses sortition with election by show of hands; correct by defining lot as chance-based selection and show of hands as a vote.
    • Treats ostracism as a punishment for a proven crime; correct this by stating that it was a political vote held without a trial for wrongdoing.
    • Presents the link to Cleisthenes as settled fact; correct this by framing the attribution as debated, in line with the word 'possible'.
    • Confuses ostracism with a death sentence or with confiscation of property; correct this by recalling that the exile was temporary and property was not seized.
    • Assumes the generals were created in 508/7 BC alongside the ten tribes; correct this by separating the tribal reform from the later introduction of the office.
    • Treats the strategoi as purely civilian magistrates; correct this by stating that they held military command and considerable political influence.
    • Describes the generals as elected for life; correct this by stating that they were elected annually.
    • Describes the reforms only as a list without explaining their effect on Athenians; correct this by linking each reform to a named response or consequence.
    • Assumes every Athenian welcomed the reforms without evidence; correct this by showing where support and resistance are attested and noting gaps in the evidence.
    • Treats a later democratic development as proof of Cleisthenes' direct intention; correct this by distinguishing his aims, the outcomes and later developments.
    • Uses Aristotle or Herodotus as neutral reports of events; correct this by stating their date and perspective and considering what each may omit.
    • Treats institutional change as proof that attitudes changed; correct this by showing evidence of belief or behaviour, not structure alone.
    • Describes Athenians as a single group with one shared view; correct this by distinguishing groups, such as citizens from different regions or social backgrounds.
    • Assumes that demes erased all older local loyalties; correct this by considering both the intended aims and the limits of their effect.
    • Presents the state and fellow citizens as separate topics; correct this by explaining how each relationship shapes the other.