Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Democracy critiqued — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Democracy critiqued explained

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Democracy critiqued covers 8 specification points, including The ideas in the set sections of the Old… and Why he feels democracy works for the….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    the ideas in the set sections of the Old Oligarch’s Constitution of the Athenians:

    This statement asks you to explain the ideas in the set sections of the Constitution of the Athenians, attributed to the Old Oligarch, a critique of Athenian democracy written in the late fifth century BCE. The writer is usually called Pseudo-Xenophon and does not argue against democracy in a conventional way. He accepts that democracy serves the common people and the poor, and he explains why this works, for example through the importance of the navy and the empire in giving the masses power and income. For each set idea, state the claim the writer makes, identify a specific example from the set text that supports it, and explain what the idea shows about his attitude to democracy. The statement ends with a colon, so the exact ideas to revise are those listed in the specification; do not assume a list you have not checked.

    why he feels democracy works for the Athenians, and its main beneficiaries

    This criterion asks why the author thinks Athenian democracy works for Athens and who gains most from it. Treat it as two linked tasks. First, trace the reasoning: identify the claim, then the mechanism that makes it work, such as the argument that the poor who row the fleet make Athens powerful and therefore deserve a share of power. Second, name the main beneficiaries and state the advantage each receives. Keep these separate: the mechanism answers why, and the named groups answer who. Paraphrase the argument in your own words, since no quotation is supplied, and present it as his view rather than established fact.

    why he disapproves of the Athenian democratic constitution

    This criterion asks why the author disapproves of the Athenian democratic constitution. Answer in two stages. First, state the objection: he dislikes a system that gives decisive power to the common people rather than the wealthy. Second, explain the reasoning linking structure to outcome: where the poor form the majority and vote on decisions, the system serves their interests, not those of the better sort. His complaint concerns whose interests the constitution serves, not only its efficiency. Describing how the assembly or courts work is not enough. Paraphrase his argument, since no quotation is supplied, and keep your modern verdict out.

    Plato’s criticisms of democracy as illustrated in the set sections of the Republic:

    Plato's critique of democracy in the Republic is developed through the account of the decline of the ideal city and the corresponding types of soul. In the set sections, democracy is presented as the constitution that follows oligarchy, arising when the poor defeat the rich and distribute freedom and equality to all. Plato criticises it because it treats all desires and all citizens as equal, so offices are often filled by lot rather than by expertise, and the city becomes disorderly. He argues that excessive freedom breeds licence, that citizens come to resent any authority, and that democracy contains the seeds of tyranny, since the extreme freedom of the many invites a champion who becomes a tyrant. Students should locate these criticisms in the prescribed passages and explain the reasoning, not merely list them.

    the idea of a common good

    The idea of a common good is the benefit of the whole city rather than of any single ruler or faction, and it gives Plato a standard against which to judge democracy. Plato's Socrates argues that a city is sound when each part performs its proper function so that the whole flourishes. Democratic politics, driven by freedom and competing interests, may serve a majority or factions rather than the city as a whole. Work through it step by step: define the common good, explain how democracy departs from it, then evaluate whether Plato's standard is convincing. Keep Plato's account separate from modern notions of public interest.

    the benefits of philosopher rulers

    This topic asks you to explain the advantages critics claimed would follow if philosophers ruled, set against Athenian democracy. The core argument is that governing is a form of knowledge: a ruler who understands what is genuinely good for the community makes just and consistent decisions, not decisions shaped by popularity. Plato's Socrates, in the Republic, develops this through an ideal state in which those best able to grasp the good are trained to rule. For a multiple-choice question, first identify which benefit the stem describes, such as informed judgement or justice, then reject options that credit voting or personal gain. Keep the focus on the rulers' understanding, because that is what the question tests.

    the dangers of rule by the people

    This topic asks you to explain the dangers critics identified in rule by the people, meaning decision-making by the citizen body rather than by experts. The central worry is that a majority may lack the knowledge needed for sound judgement and can be swayed by persuasive speakers who flatter or mislead it. Critics pointed to Athenian examples, such as the Assembly's condemnation of the generals after the battle of Arginusae in 406 BCE, to show how collective decisions can be hasty or unjust. Plato's Republic extends the argument, presenting democracy as an unstable stage that can decline into tyranny. In a multiple-choice question, identify which danger the stem describes, such as manipulation or instability, and reject options that present popular participation itself as the benefit.

    the dangers of ‘popular’ leaders and sophists

    Athenian critics of democracy feared individuals as well as the crowd. Popular leaders, or demagogues, such as Cleon, gained influence in the Assembly by flattering citizens and urging harsh policies, so they could steer majority opinion towards hasty or unjust decisions. Sophists, paid teachers of persuasion such as Protagoras, raised a related danger: training in rhetoric could make the weaker argument seem stronger, equipping ambitious men to win the Assembly and law courts regardless of truth. Plato and the Old Oligarch treat both figures as symptoms of a system that rewards persuasion over wisdom.

    Your focus

    1. Explain each set idea from the Constitution of the Athenians, using a specific example.
    2. Analyse the writer's attitude to Athenian democracy as shown in the set sections.
    3. Evaluate how the set ideas develop a critique of the democratic system.
    Show all 24 objectives
    1. Explain, in your own words, the author's reason for thinking Athenian democracy works for Athens.
    2. Identify the main groups that the author says benefit from the democratic system and the advantage each gains.
    3. Distinguish between a mechanism that explains a claim and a group that gains from it.
    4. Explain, in your own words, the author's objection to the Athenian democratic constitution.
    5. Identify the group the author believes the constitution favours and the group it disadvantages.
    6. Distinguish between describing how an institution works and explaining why the author disapproves of it.
    7. Explain Plato's criticisms of democracy as presented in the set sections of the Republic.
    8. Relate the critique of the democratic city to the democratic type of soul.
    9. Trace Plato's argument that excessive freedom leads towards tyranny.
    10. Define the common good and explain how Plato uses it.
    11. Explain how democratic decision-making can depart from the common good.
    12. Evaluate whether Plato's standard of the common good is convincing, giving a reasoned judgement.
    13. Identify the benefits claimed for philosopher rulers in critiques of democracy.
    14. Select the option that links a claimed benefit to the rulers' knowledge.
    15. Distinguish philosopher rule from democratic and tyrannical forms of government in a given question.
    16. Identify the dangers attributed to rule by the people in critiques of democracy.
    17. Select the option that links a claimed danger to the citizens' collective decisions.
    18. Distinguish dangers of rule by the people from dangers associated with tyranny or oligarchy in a given question.
    19. Identify two named examples of popular leaders and sophists associated with Athenian critiques of democracy
    20. Explain why critics saw demagogic flattery as a threat to reasoned decision-making in the Assembly
    21. Evaluate the link between sophistic rhetorical training and demagogic manipulation using ancient sources

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Democracy critiqued exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies the main ideas in the set sections of the Constitution of the Athenians, using the wording in the specification.
    • Explains each idea by stating the claim the writer makes about Athenian democracy.
    • Uses a specific example from the set text to support each idea.
    • Explains the writer's attitude, showing where he accepts democracy and where he criticises it.
    • Links ideas about the navy, the empire or the poor to the writer's wider critique of the system.
    • Identifies the author's central claim that democracy works for the Athenians.
    • Explains the causal mechanism behind that claim, linking a feature of the system to its effect.
    • Links the rowing of the fleet to the political weight and entitlement of the poor majority.
    • Names the main beneficiaries as the common people and states the specific advantage each receives.
    • Keeps the reason and the beneficiaries distinct rather than merging them into one sentence.
    • Paraphrases the argument accurately without inventing a quotation.
    • Identifies the author's core objection: the constitution gives decisive power to the common people rather than the wealthy.
    • Explains that the objection concerns whose interests the system serves, not simply its efficiency.
    • Connects the criticism to the institutions through which the many exercise power, as described in the source.
    • Notes that the author sees the poor gaining at the expense of the better sort.
    • Distinguishes the author's disapproval from a neutral description of how the constitution operates.
    • Paraphrases the argument accurately without inserting a modern verdict.
    • Identifies that Plato presents democracy as the constitution arising after oligarchy, when the poor overcome the rich and share freedom and equality among all citizens.
    • Explains that Plato criticises democracy for treating all citizens and all desires as equal, so that the city lacks the expertise-based order he values.
    • States that Plato links the excessive freedom of democracy to licence and to the eventual rise of a tyrant from within the democratic city.
    • Recognises that Plato's critique is developed through the parallel between the democratic city and the democratic type of soul, in which unnecessary desires dominate.
    • Locates the criticisms in the set passages of the Republic rather than attributing them to a general or invented summary of Plato's views.
    • Defines the common good as the benefit of the whole city rather than of a ruling group or individual.
    • Explains the Republic's view that a city is healthy when each part performs its own function for the whole.
    • Shows how democratic decision-making, driven by freedom and competing interests, can depart from the common good.
    • Evaluates Plato's standard, for example by considering whether a single agreed good can be identified in a diverse citizen body.
    • Identifies that the benefit rests on the philosopher-ruler's knowledge of what is good for the state, not on popular opinion.
    • Explains that such knowledge is expected to produce just and consistent decisions rather than decisions driven by flattery or passing pressure.
    • Links the argument to Plato's ideal of a state in which rulers are trained for their role.
    • Distinguishes philosopher rule from rule by one tyrant, which the critics treat as a separate and worse form of government.
    • Recognises that the claim is a theoretical argument about what good government requires rather than a description of Athenian practice.
    • Identifies that the danger lies in the citizen body lacking the knowledge needed for sound political judgement.
    • Explains that popular assemblies can be swayed by persuasive speakers who flatter or mislead the citizens.
    • Links instability and sudden shifts of policy to the absence of a stable principle guiding collective decisions.
    • Cites the Athenian Assembly's condemnation of the generals after Arginusae in 406 BCE as an example critics used to show hasty or unjust collective decisions.
    • Recognises that Plato's Republic presents democracy as a stage in decline that can lead to tyranny.
    • Defines a demagogue as a popular leader whose influence rested on appeal to the Assembly rather than on holding fixed office
    • Explains how flattery and harsh policy proposals could push majority opinion towards rash or unjust decisions
    • Explains how sophistic rhetorical training could make the weaker argument appear stronger, threatening reasoned decision-making
    • Links the two dangers by showing how sophistic skill could enable demagogic manipulation of citizens
    • Uses a named example, such as Cleon or Protagoras, accurately and in its proper context
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Create a list of the set ideas from the specification and write one claim and one supporting example beside each.
    • 💡Use specific passages from the set sections for every idea, rather than general impressions of the text.
    • 💡End each paragraph by stating what the idea shows about the writer's attitude to Athenian democracy.
    • 💡Underline the words 'why' and 'beneficiaries' in the statement and plan two labelled parts before writing.
    • 💡Write the mechanism in one sentence using 'because' or 'so' to show cause and effect.
    • 💡Name at least one specific group and one specific advantage rather than writing 'the people' in general.
    • 💡Check that every sentence about the beneficiaries answers who gains, not how the system works.
    • 💡Write the objection in one sentence before explaining the reasoning behind it.
    • 💡Use 'because' or 'so' to link the institution to the outcome he complains about.
    • 💡Name the groups involved, the common people and the better sort, and state which one he thinks is favoured.
    • 💡Finish by checking that your answer explains disapproval rather than only describing procedures.
    • 💡Anchor each criticism in a specific set passage and explain the reasoning Plato gives rather than listing criticisms.
    • 💡Use the city–soul parallel to show how Plato's political criticism connects to his account of character.
    • 💡Explain the causal chain from excessive freedom to tyranny, since examiners reward understanding of the argument's structure.
    • 💡Define the idea in one sentence before applying it, so that your argument has a clear anchor.
    • 💡Test each claim about democracy against the set passage it depends on.
    • 💡Finish with an evaluation of whether Plato's standard is convincing, and support that judgement with a reason.
    • 💡Read the stem for the key term, such as knowledge, justice or stability, and match it to a benefit before reading the options.
    • 💡Eliminate options that attribute the benefit to democratic procedure, such as voting, since that procedure is what the critics were challenging.
    • 💡When two options seem plausible, choose the one that explains why the ruler would act well, not merely that the outcome is good.
    • 💡Identify the danger named in the stem, such as manipulation, ignorance or instability, before comparing the options.
    • 💡Eliminate options that present voting or popular participation as the benefit, since those options reverse the critique.
    • 💡Check that the chosen option describes a danger of rule by the people as a whole, not a danger of a single leader or a faction alone.
    • 💡Name one popular leader and one sophist, and state the specific danger each represents in a single clear sentence
    • 💡Treat the two dangers separately first, then connect them explicitly in your closing paragraph
    • 💡Attach each named critic to a source and check that the source fits the date and context you describe
    Common Mistakes
    • Treats the Old Oligarch as a straightforward opponent of democracy; explain that he accepts democratic outcomes while criticising their effects.
    • Summarises the set text without stating the idea it supports; state the idea first, then use the example to support it.
    • Presents the writer as a modern political theorist without placing him in the Athenian context of the late fifth century BCE; explain the historical setting of the text.
    • Lists the beneficiaries without explaining why the system delivers any benefit to them; add the mechanism.
    • Treats the named beneficiaries as the explanation; state the mechanism separately.
    • Presents the author's view as historical fact; frame it explicitly as his interpretation.
    • Assumes the benefit goes equally to every citizen; the argument singles out the common people.
    • Writes a modern verdict on democracy; stay with the author's reasoning.
    • Describes how the constitution works without stating the objection; add his judgement.
    • Treats the complaint as a general claim that democracy is inefficient; state who is harmed instead.
    • Presents the criticism as a modern liberal objection; keep to the author's standpoint.
    • Quotes wording that is not in the supplied source; paraphrase the argument instead.
    • Omits the group that loses out; name the better sort as the group whose interests are sidelined.
    • Treats Plato's critique as a simple preference for monarchy; correct this by explaining that Plato measures democracy against his ideal of rule by those with knowledge.
    • Asserts that Plato praises democracy for its freedom; correct this by showing that he presents that freedom as excessive and as leading to licence.
    • Attributes the critique to a passage outside the set sections; correct this by grounding each point in the prescribed Republic material.
    • Confuses the democratic city with the oligarchic city; correct this by keeping the sequence of constitutions and their defining features distinct.
    • Equates the common good with majority opinion; separate what most citizens want from what Plato says benefits the whole city.
    • Describes the common good as equal distribution of wealth alone; Plato's account concerns the health of the city as a whole and the proper function of its parts.
    • Assumes the common good is an idea Plato accepts without argument; identify the reasoning Socrates uses to support it.
    • Uses the phrase 'common good' as a modern term without tying it to the Republic; anchor each use to the text.
    • Credits the philosopher-ruler with benefits that depend on election by the citizens; correct this by tying every benefit to the ruler's knowledge.
    • Describes the benefit as wealth or personal power for the ruler; correct this by emphasising the ruler's understanding of the good of the community.
    • Presents the Athenian Assembly as already governed by philosophers; correct this by treating the Assembly as the contrast the critics set their ideal against.
    • Treats every criticism of government as a danger of rule by the people; correct this by restricting answers to dangers arising from collective decision-making by the citizens.
    • Assumes the critics rejected all popular participation; correct this by recognising that the objection concerns rule by the majority's decisions without the safeguards of knowledge.
    • Presents the trial of Socrates as proof that Athenian democracy always executes philosophers; correct this by treating it as one example used within a wider argument.
    • Treats every prominent Athenian politician as a demagogue; restrict the term to leaders whose authority depended on popular appeal rather than office
    • Describes sophists only as fee-charging teachers; add the critical claim that their rhetorical skill could undermine truth in debate
    • Assumes every critic rejected democracy altogether; distinguish criticism of particular practices from outright rejection of the system