New and emerging technologies - How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions — AQA GCSE Design and Technology
New and emerging technologies - How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions explained
Critical evaluation of a new or emerging technology means judging it from more than one viewpoint before a design decision is made.
Read the full explanation
A designer might weigh a product's benefits for the user against its cost to the manufacturer, its environmental impact, its ethical implications and its effect on employment. Taking a single perspective, such as only the profit for the company, hides trade-offs that later cause problems. A practical method is to list the stakeholders affected, state what each gains and loses, then compare the scenarios. For example, a delivery drone may suit a retailer and a remote customer but disturb residents and displace courier jobs. The statement is truncated after 'considering:', so treat the listed perspectives as the ones taught in the specification rather than inventing extra official wording.
Your focus
- Identify at least two different perspectives from which a new technology can be evaluated
- Explain how comparing scenarios from different perspectives informs a design decision
- Apply stakeholder analysis to a named new or emerging technology
New and emerging technologies - How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions exam tips
Marking Points
- Identifies more than one perspective, such as the user, the manufacturer, the environment or society, when judging a new technology
- Explains how comparing scenarios from different perspectives reveals trade-offs that a single viewpoint would hide
- Applies a stakeholder method by naming who gains and who loses from a design decision
- Links the evaluation to a specific design decision rather than describing the technology in general terms
Examiner Tips
- 💡Name the specific perspectives you are comparing, for example the user, the environment and the workforce, rather than saying 'different views'
- 💡Use a short scenario to show the conflict, such as a drone delivery that helps a customer but disturbs residents
- 💡Finish by stating which design decision the evaluation supports and why
Common Mistakes
- Judges a technology from only one viewpoint, such as cost to the manufacturer; compare at least two stakeholder perspectives before deciding
- Describes the technology's features without reaching a judgement; state what each perspective shows and what decision follows
- Treats every perspective as equally favourable; identify the trade-offs and conflicts between stakeholders