Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Constitutional arrangements — AQA A-Level Politics

    Constitutional arrangements explained

    Constitutional arrangements covers 5 specification points, including Key similarities and differences between the… and Their nature(codified/uncodified), sources and….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    key similarities and differences between the UK and US constitutions and their impact on government and politics in their respective countries

    This comparison asks you to set the UK and US constitutions side by side and then trace consequences for how each country is governed. A strong answer pairs each similarity or difference with an effect. For example, both systems divide power between branches, yet the US codified constitution entrenches that division through separate elections and fixed terms, while the UK's uncodified constitution fuses executive and legislature through the fusion of powers in a parliamentary system. Similarities include a shared commitment to rule of law, judicial review and bicameralism. Differences include codification, entrenchment, federalism, sovereignty location and the role of conventions. Always link the feature to an outcome such as gridlock, strong executive control, or frequent constitutional change.

    their nature(codified/uncodified), sources and provisions, separation of powers, checks and balances

    This item tests precise knowledge of constitutional nature, sources, provisions and the machinery of separated power. The UK constitution is uncodified: it draws on statutes, common law, conventions and works of authority, and it is flexible because Parliament is sovereign. The US constitution is codified and entrenched in a single document, amended rarely through a demanding process, and it establishes federalism and a rigid separation of powers. Separation of powers allocates legislative, executive and judicial functions to distinct bodies; checks and balances let each branch restrain the others, for example presidential veto or judicial review. Distinguish the concepts: separation is about allocation, checks are about mutual restraint.

    similarities and differences between the devolution model in the UK and the federal model in the USA

    Both systems share power between a central government and territorial units, but they do so on different constitutional foundations. In the UK, devolution is a top-down transfer of powers that Parliament retains the legal right to reverse, so the Scotland Act, Government of Wales Act and Northern Ireland Act create bodies whose authority is ultimately derived from Westminster. In the USA, federalism is entrenched: the states hold reserved powers under the Tenth Amendment and their existence cannot be abolished by Congress. A strong answer compares the sources of authority, the entrenchment of each settlement, the asymmetry of UK devolution against the symmetry of US statehood, and the mechanisms for resolving disputes.

    the legislatures: their relative strengths and weaknesses and the extent to which their roles are similar and their powers equal

    This comparison asks you to weigh the UK Parliament against the US Congress on strengths, weaknesses, roles and the equality of their powers. Parliament is fused with the executive, so a government with a majority usually carries its legislation, while Congress is separated from the president and can block or amend executive proposals. Consider scrutiny: Parliament uses Prime Minister's Questions and select committees, whereas Congress uses congressional committees with subpoena power and can reject presidential appointments and treaties. Weigh representation, legitimacy and the ability to hold the executive to account. A strong answer compares specific mechanisms, such as the UK confidence relationship against US checks and balances, and reaches a judgement on whether their powers are genuinely equal or merely different in kind.

    powers, composition, structure, strengths and weaknesses.

    This comparative topic examines the constitutional arrangements of the UK and the US, so every answer must connect the two systems rather than describe one alone. For powers, distinguish the UK's uncodified, parliamentary-sovereignty settlement, where a government with a Commons majority can legislate broadly, from the US codified Constitution, which grants enumerated powers and divides them between Congress, the President and the Supreme Court. For composition and structure, compare the UK's fusion of executive and legislature in Parliament with the US separation of institutions and federal division between Washington and the states. For strengths and weaknesses, weigh flexibility and strong government against weak legal limits in the UK, and entrenched rights and checks against gridlock and rigidity in the US.

    Your focus

    1. Compare key similarities and differences between the UK and US constitutions
    2. Explain the impact of constitutional features on government and politics in each country
    3. Reach a supported judgement on the significance of the differences
    Show all 15 objectives
    1. Distinguish codified from uncodified constitutions
    2. Identify sources and provisions of the UK and US constitutions
    3. Explain separation of powers and checks and balances with examples
    4. Explain the constitutional basis of UK devolution and US federalism.
    5. Compare the entrenchment and reversibility of each settlement.
    6. Evaluate the extent to which the two models are similar using concrete examples.
    7. Compare the strengths and weaknesses of Parliament and Congress.
    8. Explain how each legislature scrutinises the executive.
    9. Evaluate the extent to which their roles are similar and their powers equal.
    10. Compare the powers held under the UK and US constitutional arrangements
    11. Describe the composition and structure of each arrangement
    12. Evaluate one strength and one weakness of each arrangement

    Constitutional arrangements exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies a genuine similarity such as bicameralism or rule of law and links it to a comparable governing outcome in both countries
    • Explains a key difference such as codification or entrenchment and traces its effect on how power is exercised
    • Uses a concrete example, such as the US amendment process or UK constitutional statutes, to support the comparison
    • Evaluates which differences most shape government, weighing flexibility against stability
    • Sustains a comparative structure that discusses both countries throughout rather than describing one then the other
    • Identifies the UK constitution as uncodified and the US constitution as codified
    • Recognises the sources of the UK constitution such as statute, common law, convention and works of authority
    • Explains that the US constitution is entrenched and amended through a demanding process
    • Distinguishes separation of powers from checks and balances as allocation versus mutual restraint
    • Applies a provision such as the presidential veto or judicial review to illustrate checks and balances
    • Explains that UK devolution is a transfer of powers from a sovereign Parliament that could in law legislate to reverse it, whereas US federalism divides sovereignty between the federal government and states whose existence is constitutionally protected.
    • Compares the entrenchment of the two settlements, noting that the US Constitution is codified and hard to amend while the UK devolution statutes are ordinary Acts of Parliament.
    • Identifies the asymmetry of UK devolution, where Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland hold different powers and England has no equivalent devolved body, against the formal equality of US states.
    • Uses a concrete example, such as the Sewel convention or a Supreme Court ruling on federal-state conflict, to show how each model resolves disputes in practice.
    • Evaluates the extent to which the two models are genuinely similar, distinguishing shared features such as territorial power-sharing from deeper differences in legal foundation.
    • Compares the fusion of executive and legislature in the UK with the separation of powers in the USA, explaining how each affects the legislature's ability to scrutinise the executive.
    • Explains that a UK government with a Commons majority usually secures its legislation, whereas Congress can block or amend presidential proposals.
    • Contrasts scrutiny mechanisms, such as Prime Minister's Questions and select committees in the UK against congressional committees with subpoena power and the Senate's role in confirming appointments and ratifying treaties.
    • Assesses the relative strengths and weaknesses of each legislature, for example Parliament's responsiveness to the electorate against Congress's capacity to check the executive.
    • Reaches a judgement on the extent to which the roles are similar and the powers equal, distinguishing differences in kind from differences in degree.
    • Compares the powers of the UK and US constitutional arrangements rather than describing only one system
    • Identifies the UK's uncodified constitution and parliamentary sovereignty as a source of broad legislative power
    • Explains the US codified Constitution and enumerated powers as limits on each branch
    • Contrasts the UK fusion of executive and legislature with the US separation of powers
    • Distinguishes the UK unitary structure from US federalism and state powers
    • Weighs a strength and a weakness of each arrangement with a reason
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Plan by pairing each similarity or difference with a named impact before you write
    • 💡Anchor every claim in a specific example such as federalism, entrenchment or parliamentary sovereignty
    • 💡Reserve time to weigh which differences matter most and reach a judgement
    • 💡Use comparative connectives such as 'whereas' and 'by contrast' to keep the comparison explicit
    • 💡Learn one clear definition each for codified, uncodified, separation of powers and checks and balances
    • 💡Match each source of the UK constitution to a concrete example
    • 💡Read the whole option before choosing, since distractors often swap UK and US features
    • 💡Link each provision to the branch it constrains
    • 💡Anchor each comparison in a specific constitutional feature rather than a general claim about 'more' or 'less' power.
    • 💡Use named legislation or rulings to support points, such as the Scotland Act or a relevant Supreme Court case.
    • 💡Structure the answer around clear comparative criteria, for example source of authority, entrenchment and dispute resolution.
    • 💡Reserve time to reach a judgement on how far the models are similar rather than listing differences only.
    • 💡Compare like with like by pairing specific mechanisms, such as UK select committees against US congressional committees.
    • 💡Support each strength or weakness with a concrete example of the mechanism in action.
    • 💡Address both parts of the question: similarity of roles and equality of powers.
    • 💡Conclude with a clear judgement rather than a summary of points already made.
    • 💡Read the stem for the word 'compare' and check the chosen option covers both countries
    • 💡Eliminate options that describe one system accurately but make no comparison
    • 💡Match each option to a named clause: powers, composition, structure, strengths or weaknesses
    • 💡Reject options that confuse UK and US institutions before weighing the remaining two
    Common Mistakes
    • Lists features of each constitution without linking them to impact; add an explicit consequence for government or politics
    • Treats the UK as having no constitution at all; explain that it is uncodified but still exists across statutes, conventions and common law
    • Assumes the US and UK share identical separation of powers; distinguish the US rigid separation from the UK's partial fusion
    • Describes only one country in a comparative paragraph; keep both sides of the comparison present
    • Confuses separation of powers with checks and balances; treat separation as allocation of functions and checks as mutual restraint
    • Claims the UK constitution is codified because statutes exist; recognise that no single entrenched document exists
    • Treats conventions as legally enforceable; note that they are binding politically rather than in law
    • Assumes the US amendment process is easy; recognise its demanding supermajority requirements
    • Treats UK devolution as equivalent to federalism; correct this by explaining that devolved powers remain legally subordinate to Parliament.
    • Assumes all UK nations hold identical devolved powers; correct this by noting the asymmetry between Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
    • Describes US states as creations of Congress; correct this by explaining that states hold reserved powers under the Tenth Amendment.
    • Ignores the role of courts in the US system; correct this by explaining how the Supreme Court arbitrates federal-state disputes.
    • Assumes Parliament and Congress hold identical powers; correct this by explaining the different constitutional relationships each has with the executive.
    • Overstates the weakness of Parliament by ignoring select committees and the confidence relationship; correct this by weighing scrutiny mechanisms fairly.
    • Treats the US Senate and House as a single body; correct this by distinguishing their separate roles in confirmation and legislation.
    • Claims the two legislatures are equal in power without evidence; correct this by comparing specific mechanisms and reaching a reasoned judgement.
    • Describes only the UK constitution; add the matching US feature and compare the two
    • Treats parliamentary sovereignty as a US principle; keep it as the UK feature and contrast it with US entrenchment
    • Asserts a strength without a reason; link each strength to a consequence such as flexibility or protection of rights
    • Ignores the composition clause; state which institutions make up each arrangement and how they relate