Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    The executives — AQA A-Level Politics

    The executives explained

    The executives covers 2 specification points, including The role and powers of the UK prime minister… and A comparison of the relationship of the UK….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    the role and powers of the UK prime minister and of the US president, how they differ from each other and the extent of their accountability to the legislatures

    This topic requires a comparative analysis of two executives. Cover the role and powers of the UK prime minister: appointing and dismissing ministers, setting the direction of government, controlling the Cabinet agenda and using prerogative and patronage powers, while depending on party majority and collective responsibility. Cover the US president: head of state and head of government, commander-in-chief, veto power, appointment and treaty powers subject to Senate confirmation, and executive orders, while facing separation of powers and an independently elected legislature. Explain how they differ, for example fused versus separated executive and legislature, collective versus individual accountability, and confidence versus fixed terms.

    a comparison of the relationship of the UK prime minister and of the US president to other institutions of government.

    This comparison asks you to set the UK prime minister beside the US president and analyse how each relates to the other institutions of government: legislature, judiciary, cabinet and the wider executive, and the devolved or federal layers. Take each institution in turn and compare the structural relationship rather than listing powers. For example, the UK prime minister leads a party that usually commands a Commons majority, so the relationship with the legislature is fused: the executive sits inside Parliament and depends on it, yet a working majority gives strong control of the agenda. The US president is separately elected and is not a member of Congress, so the relationship is one of separated institutions sharing powers, with divided government possible when the opposing party controls a chamber.

    Your focus

    1. Explain the role and powers of the UK prime minister and the US president
    2. Compare how the two executives differ in structure and accountability
    3. Evaluate the extent to which each executive is accountable to its legislature
    Show all 6 objectives
    1. Compare the relationship of the UK prime minister and the US president to the legislature.
    2. Explain how each executive relates to the judiciary and to cabinet.
    3. Reach a supported judgement on which executive is more institutionally constrained.

    The executives exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Outlines the role and powers of the UK prime minister with reference to patronage, Cabinet management and prerogative authority
    • Outlines the role and powers of the US president with reference to veto, commander-in-chief status and appointment and treaty powers
    • Explains how the two executives differ, for example fused versus separated institutions and collective versus individual accountability
    • Assesses the extent of the prime minister's accountability to Parliament through mechanisms such as PMQs, select committees and confidence votes
    • Assesses the extent of the president's accountability to Congress through mechanisms such as oversight, confirmation and impeachment
    • Reaches a supported comparative judgement on how far each executive is accountable to its legislature
    • Compares the UK prime minister's fused relationship with Parliament, where the executive sits within the legislature, against the US president's separate election and non-membership of Congress.
    • Explains that a UK governing majority usually gives the prime minister strong agenda control, while divided government can leave the US president facing a hostile chamber.
    • Contrasts judicial appointments, noting UK independent appointment commissions against US presidential nomination with Senate confirmation.
    • Contrasts cabinet, noting UK ministers drawn from Parliament and bound by collective responsibility against US cabinet members outside Congress.
    • Reaches a supported judgement on which executive faces the greater institutional constraint and why.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Plan around the three demands of the question: role and powers, differences, and accountability, so no clause is left uncovered
    • 💡Anchor each comparative point in a concrete mechanism, such as Senate confirmation or a confidence vote, rather than general assertion
    • 💡Build towards a judgement on the extent of accountability rather than describing mechanisms in isolation
    • 💡Structure the answer institution by institution so each paragraph makes a direct comparison.
    • 💡Use precise terms such as fused executive, separation of powers, divided government and collective responsibility.
    • 💡Anchor each claim to a concrete structural feature rather than a single recent event.
    • 💡Finish with an explicit judgement that weighs the constraints on each executive.
    Common Mistakes
    • Lists powers of each executive without comparing them; draw an explicit contrast in each paragraph
    • Treats the prime minister as directly elected; note that the PM derives authority from party and parliamentary majority
    • Assumes the US president is fully accountable because of checks and balances; weigh gridlock and executive orders against congressional oversight
    • Ignores the legislature's role in accountability; connect each executive to the specific mechanisms its legislature uses
    • Treats the two executives as identical because both are called leaders; distinguish the fused UK executive-in-legislature from the separated US system.
    • Lists powers without comparing relationships; organise each paragraph around one institution and compare both executives on it.
    • Assumes the US president always controls Congress; note that divided government is a real structural possibility.
    • Ignores the judiciary and cabinet; cover every institution named in the comparison, not just the legislature.