Poverty as a social issue — AQA GCSE Sociology
Poverty as a social issue explained
Poverty as a social issue covers 6 specification points, including Different interpretations of poverty as a… and The work of Townsend on relative deprivation….
Read the full explanation
Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
Different interpretations of poverty as a social issue.
Poverty is interpreted in different ways as a social issue. Absolute poverty means lacking the basic necessities for survival, such as food, clean water and shelter. Relative poverty means falling below the living standards regarded as normal in a particular society, so it changes over time and place. Some interpretations blame individual behaviour or culture, while others point to structural causes such as low pay, unemployment, poor housing and unequal life chances. These interpretations matter because they shape how poverty is measured and what policies are proposed. A strong answer distinguishes the definitions, identifies who offers each interpretation, and explains the consequences for individuals and society, such as poor health, limited education and social exclusion.
The work of Townsend on relative deprivation and Murray on the underclass.
Townsend and Murray offer contrasting explanations of poverty in the UK. Townsend argues that poverty is relative: people are poor when their income falls so far below the customary standard of their society that they are excluded from normal activities, so deprivation is measured against what others around them have. Murray argues that a welfare-dependent underclass has formed, whose members are said to hold values and behaviours that keep them poor, so he locates the cause in culture and behaviour rather than in the structure of the economy. A question may ask you to identify which thinker said what, to describe one claim, or to explain why the two accounts differ. Read the stem carefully: if it names Townsend, choose the relative-deprivation option; if it names Murray, choose the underclass option.
identify, describe and explain different interpretations of poverty as a social issue including, the culture of poverty, material deprivation, the way in which governments have attempted to alleviate poverty and unemployment, the impact of globalisation
This topic asks you to identify, describe and explain competing interpretations of poverty as a social issue. The culture of poverty interpretation holds that particular values and behaviours are passed on within poor communities and keep people poor. The material deprivation interpretation focuses on lacking the goods, resources and living conditions that are customary in a society. Government attempts to alleviate poverty and unemployment include measures such as welfare benefits, tax credits, the national minimum and living wage, and employment or training schemes, each of which can be evaluated for its strengths and limits. Globalisation affects poverty through the movement of jobs, trade and investment across countries, which can create employment in some places while removing secure work in others.
describe, compare and contrast a variety of sociological perspectives on poverty (functionalist, feminist and Marxist)
This extended-response task asks you to describe three named perspectives on poverty, then compare and contrast them. Describe means setting out each perspective's key ideas in its own terms: functionalists such as Herbert Spencer and later writers see some inequality as necessary for society to function, arguing that unequal rewards motivate people to fill important roles, while critics say this underplays structural disadvantage. Marxists link poverty to capitalism: low wages, the reserve army of labour and the unequal ownership of the means of production keep some people poor. Feminists focus on gender, showing how women's lower pay, unpaid caring work and dependence within households produce female poverty. Compare by identifying shared ground, such as all three treating poverty as socially produced rather than purely personal.
describe the key ideas of Townsend (page 53) on relative deprivation
Peter Townsend developed the concept of relative deprivation to explain poverty in affluent societies. He argued that poverty should be measured against the living standards and customary activities of the society in which people live, not against a fixed minimum of subsistence. People are relatively deprived when they lack the resources to participate in the normal diet, activities and social relationships expected in their community. Townsend used indicators such as going without a cooked meal, a holiday or social participation to build a deprivation index. This means poverty is socially defined and can exist even when absolute survival needs are met. The key idea is that deprivation is relative to the norms of a particular society at a particular time.
describe the key ideas of Murray (page 52) on the underclass including links to New Right theories.
Charles Murray, writing from a New Right perspective, argues that a distinct underclass exists beneath the working class, marked by long-term welfare dependency, weak attachment to paid work and, in his account, a culture that transmits these traits across generations. He links this to New Right thinking, which stresses individual responsibility, the value of the traditional two-parent family and the belief that generous welfare can create perverse incentives that discourage paid work and stable family life. A learner should be able to identify Murray's core claims, connect them to New Right values, and recognise the criticisms that structural explanations of poverty raise against his cultural account.
Your focus
- Distinguish absolute from relative poverty.
- Compare individual, cultural and structural interpretations of poverty.
- Explain the social consequences of poverty for individuals and society.
Show all 18 objectives
- Identify Townsend's relative deprivation account of poverty.
- Identify Murray's underclass account of poverty.
- Explain how the two accounts differ in what they treat as the cause of poverty.
- Identify the culture of poverty and material deprivation interpretations of poverty.
- Describe ways governments have attempted to alleviate poverty and unemployment.
- Explain how globalisation affects poverty and why interpretations of poverty differ.
- Describe the key ideas of functionalist, feminist and Marxist perspectives on poverty.
- Compare the perspectives by identifying shared assumptions about the social production of poverty.
- Contrast the perspectives by explaining their differing accounts of causes and remedies.
- Describe Townsend's concept of relative deprivation.
- Explain how relative deprivation is measured against social norms and participation.
- Distinguish relative deprivation from absolute poverty.
- State Murray's definition of the underclass.
- Explain how Murray's ideas connect to New Right values.
- Identify a criticism of Murray's cultural explanation of poverty.
Poverty as a social issue exam tips
Marking Points
- Defines absolute poverty as a lack of basic necessities needed for survival.
- Defines relative poverty as falling below the normal living standards of a particular society.
- Contrasts individual or cultural explanations of poverty with structural explanations such as low pay and unemployment.
- Explains how different interpretations shape measurement of poverty and the policies proposed to address it.
- Identifies social consequences of poverty such as poor health, limited education and social exclusion.
- Identifies Townsend with the claim that poverty is relative to the standards of the society in which a person lives.
- Identifies Murray with the claim that a welfare-dependent underclass exists whose culture keeps its members poor.
- Explains that Townsend locates the cause of poverty in low income relative to others rather than in individual behaviour.
- Explains that Murray locates the cause in the values and behaviour of an underclass rather than in economic structure.
- Distinguishes the two accounts by contrasting a structural, relative measure of poverty with a cultural, behavioural explanation.
- Identifies the culture of poverty as an interpretation that locates the cause of poverty in values and behaviour passed on within poor communities.
- Identifies material deprivation as an interpretation that locates poverty in a lack of the goods, resources and living conditions customary in a society.
- Describes a government measure intended to alleviate poverty or unemployment, such as welfare benefits, tax credits, a minimum or living wage, or an employment scheme.
- Explains how globalisation can affect poverty, for example by shifting jobs and investment between countries and changing the security of available work.
- Explains why these interpretations differ, contrasting cultural, material and structural accounts of what causes poverty.
- Describes functionalist ideas on poverty, including the claim that unequal rewards motivate people to fill important roles.
- Describes Marxist ideas on poverty, including low wages, the reserve army of labour and ownership of the means of production.
- Describes feminist ideas on poverty, including women's lower pay, unpaid caring work and household dependence.
- Compares the perspectives by identifying shared ground, such as all three treating poverty as socially produced.
- Contrasts the perspectives by explaining where they disagree about causes and remedies.
- Supports each perspective with appropriate sociological concepts and named thinkers where relevant.
- Defines relative deprivation as lacking the resources to participate in the normal activities and relationships of one's society.
- Explains that Townsend measured poverty against the living standards and customs of the society concerned rather than a fixed subsistence minimum.
- Identifies that Townsend used indicators of deprivation, such as going without a cooked meal, a holiday or social participation.
- States that relative deprivation means poverty can exist even when absolute survival needs are met.
- Identifies Murray as a New Right thinker who argues that an underclass exists beneath the working class.
- Explains that Murray links the underclass to welfare dependency and a culture that discourages paid work.
- Connects Murray's ideas to New Right values such as individual responsibility and the traditional two-parent family.
- Recognises that Murray's cultural explanation contrasts with structural explanations that emphasise low pay, unemployment and inadequate housing.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Define both absolute and relative poverty before comparing interpretations.
- 💡Name the perspective behind each interpretation, for example individual, cultural or structural.
- 💡Link each interpretation to a consequence or policy to show understanding.
- 💡Match the named thinker in the stem to the correct theory before reading the options.
- 💡Eliminate options that swap the two thinkers' claims.
- 💡When asked to explain a difference, name both thinkers and state what each locates as the cause of poverty.
- 💡Read the stem to see whether it asks you to identify, describe or explain, and match the depth of your answer to that command.
- 💡Link each interpretation to a concrete example, such as a named type of government measure or a way globalisation changes employment.
- 💡When explaining differences, state what each interpretation treats as the main cause of poverty.
- 💡Plan your answer so each perspective gets a clear descriptive paragraph before you compare them.
- 💡Use comparative connectives such as 'similarly' and 'whereas' to make contrasts explicit.
- 💡Anchor each perspective in a named thinker or concept to show sociological knowledge.
- 💡Reserve time to state at least one similarity and one difference between the perspectives.
- 💡Read the question carefully to check whether it asks about relative or absolute poverty.
- 💡Link the concept to Townsend by name to secure the knowledge mark.
- 💡Use a concrete example of a socially expected activity to illustrate relative deprivation.
- 💡Check that your chosen option reflects social participation, not just low income.
- 💡Learn two or three specific Murray claims so you can name them precisely rather than vaguely.
- 💡Practise linking each Murray claim to a New Right value such as self-reliance or family responsibility.
- 💡Prepare one criticism of Murray so you can evaluate his ideas, not just describe them.
Common Mistakes
- Treats absolute and relative poverty as the same thing; distinguish survival needs from socially normal standards.
- Assumes poverty is caused only by individual choices; include structural explanations such as low pay and unemployment.
- Describes poverty without linking interpretations to measurement or policy; show the consequences of each view.
- Attributes the underclass thesis to Townsend; keep Townsend with relative deprivation and Murray with the underclass.
- Treats relative deprivation as meaning that a person has no income at all; recognise that it compares income with the customary standard of the surrounding society.
- Presents Murray's underclass as an accepted fact rather than as one contested interpretation; describe it as his argument.
- Assumes both thinkers explain poverty in the same way; state clearly that they offer competing interpretations.
- Confuses the culture of poverty with material deprivation; keep the cultural explanation about values and behaviour and the material explanation about lacking resources.
- Describes a government measure without saying how it is meant to reduce poverty or unemployment; link each measure to its intended effect.
- Treats globalisation as having only one effect on poverty; recognise that it can create work in some places while removing secure work in others.
- Lists interpretations without explaining them; add a reason why each interpretation treats poverty as it does.
- Lists the three perspectives without explaining their key ideas; develop each one with concepts and reasoning.
- Treats functionalism as simply approving of poverty; explain the argument about necessary inequality and rewards.
- Ignores gender when discussing poverty; include feminist points on women's pay and unpaid work.
- Presents comparison as separate summaries; explicitly state similarities and differences between perspectives.
- Confuses relative deprivation with absolute poverty; keep the distinction between social norms and a fixed subsistence minimum.
- Attributes the concept to the wrong thinker; link relative deprivation specifically to Townsend.
- Treats deprivation as only about income; include participation in normal activities and social relationships.
- Assumes relative deprivation means people are always poor; explain that it depends on the norms of the society.
- Confuses Murray with a Marxist or social democratic thinker; place him firmly within New Right theory.
- Treats the underclass as simply 'the poor'; explain that Murray means a group with distinct cultural and behavioural traits.
- Ignores the welfare-incentive argument; state that Murray sees generous benefits as creating perverse incentives.