Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Prescribed Literary Sources — OCR A-Level Classical Civilisation

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Prescribed Literary Sources explained

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Prescribed Literary Sources covers 6 specification points, including Aeschylus, Eumenides, 674–710 and Euripides, Suppliants, 399–456.

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    Aeschylus, Eumenides, 674–710

    This passage, Aeschylus' Eumenides lines 674 to 710, sits within the Areopagus trial of Orestes that closes the play. Because it is a prescribed literary source for Democracy and the Athenians, your task is to understand what this section reveals about how an Athenian-style court argues, decides and reaches a verdict, not merely to retell the plot. Start by identifying who speaks at each stage, because the trial mixes the Furies' accusations, Apollo's defence and Athena's role in overseeing the jury. Then pick out the argument being made in the section and explain how it supports the wider theme of justice being settled through shared civic procedure rather than private vengeance. Finally, check every line reference against your own edition, since numbering varies between editions.

    Euripides, Suppliants, 399–456

    This section of Euripides' Suppliants, lines 399 to 456, belongs to the debate in which Theseus, king of Athens, must decide whether to help the Argive mothers recover their dead from Thebes. For Democracy and the Athenians, this passage matters because it stages a direct argument about the merits of democratic and single-ruler government, with the Theban herald speaking against Athenian democracy. Read the herald's speech as direct speech, identify its specific criticisms, and then consider how Theseus's response in the wider debate defends the city's political system. Learn to separate what a character claims from what the play as a whole presents, and recognise the exchange as an exploration of civic values rather than a simple verdict. Use short, accurate references to lines 399 to 456 when explaining your points, and check numbering against your own edition.

    Aristophanes • Acharnians 1–203 • Ecclesiazusae (Assemblywomen) 1–310 • Knights 147–395 • Peace 729–760 • Wasps 471–712; 824–862; 891–994 • Frogs 686–737

    This entry prescribes specific line ranges from six Aristophanic comedies for Democracy and the Athenians: Acharnians 1–203, Ecclesiazusae (Assemblywomen) 1–310, Knights 147–395, Peace 729–760, Wasps 471–712, 824–862 and 891–994, and Frogs 686–737. Only these lines form the assessment boundary, so do not draw examples from outside them, even if the wider play is interesting. Wasps has three separate blocks, so treat each as its own unit rather than one continuous passage. Read each passage in translation with line numbers, and note where Athenian institutions such as the Assembly, law courts and public pay appear. For each passage, record who speaks and whether that figure is a citizen, slave, woman or comic type, since comedy exaggerates for effect. Keep separate notes for each range so you can locate evidence quickly in the exam.

    Thucydides, The Peloponnesian War, 2.36–42; 2.65

    This entry prescribes two parts of Thucydides, The Peloponnesian War, for Democracy and the Athenians: sections 2.36–42 and section 2.65. Sections 2.36–42 form part of Pericles' Funeral Oration, which Thucydides as narrator reports; the praise of the constitution and of citizens' public spirit belongs to Pericles as speaker, not to Thucydides' own voice. Section 2.65 is Thucydides' narration of how the Athenians turned against Pericles after the plague. Use these passages to examine how democratic values, equality before the law and civic duty are presented. Always name the speaker or narrator and the section when you make a point, for example Pericles in 2.36–42 or Thucydides in 2.65. Consider how Thucydides' framing shapes the reader's view, and remember that these sections are the only boundary for this entry.

    Plato, Republic, 6.485–487a; 6.488–489; 6.493

    This statement names three passages from Plato's Republic, book 6: 485–487a, 488–489 and 493. Here Socrates, the speaker, criticises the many's role in political life. Passage 485–487a describes a future philosopher's natural qualities and how a city's upbringing can corrupt them. Passage 488–489 gives the ship: the shipowner, the people, is large but short-sighted; the sailors, the politicians, quarrel over the helm; the true pilot, the philosopher, is dismissed as a stargazer. Passage 493 gives the great beast: the many are the beast, and teachers study its moods and call what pleases it good. Read each image by asking who holds authority and who is shaped by whom.

    Old Oligarch (‘Pseudo-Xenophon’), Constitution of the Athenians, Sections 1.1–1.20; 2.9–2.10; 2.14–3.13

    This row asks you to read three sets of sections from the Constitution of the Athenians, the work traditionally attributed to Pseudo-Xenophon and often called the Old Oligarch. Sections 1.1–1.20 set out the author's hostile view that the Athenian democracy favours the poor and common people, which he presents as a deliberate outcome. Sections 2.9–2.10 continue his account of who benefits from Athenian policy. Sections 2.14–3.13 cover the empire, the allies and the institutions through which the demos exercises power. Read these passages as a critic's argument: identify each claim, the evidence offered for it and the value judgement behind it. The author is anonymous and openly favours oligarchy, so do not treat his account as a neutral description of Athens. Record which institutions he discusses in each section.

    Your focus

    1. Identify the speaker and main argument in lines 674 to 710 of Eumenides.
    2. Explain how the passage presents the procedure and legitimacy of the Areopagus court.
    3. Evaluate how the passage contributes to the play's treatment of justice and civic order.
    Show all 18 objectives
    1. Identify the Theban herald as speaker and summarise the main argument in lines 399 to 456 of Suppliants.
    2. Explain how the herald's speech presents criticisms of Athenian democracy.
    3. Evaluate how the debate presents competing views of government and how far the play endorses either.
    4. Identify the six plays and eight prescribed line ranges that make up this entry.
    5. Locate specified passages in a translation using line numbers and separate the Wasps blocks correctly.
    6. Record the speaker and democratic issue raised in each prescribed passage.
    7. Identify which parts of Book 2 are prescribed and which speaker or narrator is responsible for each section.
    8. Summarise the democratic values presented in sections 2.36–42 with reference to section numbers.
    9. Explain how section 2.65 presents the Athenians' attitude to Pericles, with reference to the text.
    10. Identify who the shipowner, the sailors and the true pilot represent in the ship image.
    11. Explain the relationship between the great beast and the teachers who study it.
    12. Summarise how passage 485–487a links a future philosopher's natural qualities to the influence of a city's upbringing.
    13. Identifies the main claims made in sections 1.1–1.20, 2.9–2.10 and 2.14–3.13.
    14. Explains how the author's standpoint shapes his account of Athenian institutions.
    15. Records the institutions discussed in each set of sections, with section references.

    Democracy and the Athenians (H408/34) - Prescribed Literary Sources exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies which speaker or group is addressing the court at each point in lines 674 to 710.
    • Explains the specific argument made in the section, showing who makes it and what it is designed to achieve in the trial.
    • Links the passage to the theme of justice being settled through a civic procedure rather than private vengeance.
    • Uses an accurate line reference from 674 to 710 to support each point, matching the numbering in the edition studied.
    • Evaluates how the passage shapes the audience's view of the court's legitimacy and fairness.
    • Identifies the Theban herald as the speaker in the section and distinguishes his voice from Theseus's.
    • Explains the specific criticisms of democracy made in the herald's speech.
    • Compares the herald's position with Theseus's defence of Athenian government as presented in the wider debate.
    • Assesses whether the play endorses the herald's argument or presents it as one view within a debate.
    • Supports each point with an accurate line reference from 399 to 456.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Write a one-sentence summary of the speaker's argument before analysing it, so your point is clear from the start.
    • 💡Select one or two precise details from the lines and explain their effect, rather than listing many details without analysis.
    • 💡Finish each paragraph by stating how the detail contributes to the play's presentation of civic justice and the court.
    • 💡Write a one-sentence summary of the herald's argument before analysing it, so your point is clear from the start.
    • 💡Select one or two precise details from the section and explain their effect, rather than listing many details without analysis.
    • 💡Finish each paragraph by stating how the detail contributes to the play's presentation of Athenian democracy.
    • 💡Mark each prescribed range in your copy of the text before you start, so you know exactly where your evidence must come from.
    • 💡Create one summary card per range that records the speaker, the institution or democratic issue raised, and the line numbers.
    • 💡Practise locating a line reference quickly in a translation with line numbers, because you will need to point to specific lines rather than vague episodes.
    • 💡Write the section number and speaker or narrator at the start of each note, so you can attribute every point correctly.
    • 💡Summarise the main democratic values in 2.36–42 under headings such as the constitution, law and civic duty, then check each heading against the text.
    • 💡Compare your reading of 2.65 with 2.36–42 to explain how the Athenians' attitude to democratic leadership changes across the two passages.
    • 💡Write a one-line summary of each image before reading closely, so the three passages stay distinct in your notes.
    • 💡When you explain the great beast, state in your own words who the beast is and who studies it, rather than relying on memory of a quotation.
    • 💡Record the Stephanus reference beside each claim in your notes so you can locate it quickly during revision.
    • 💡Compare the three images by asking who holds authority in each, and note the points where the answer changes.
    • 💡Annotate each claim you find with the section number and a note of the evidence the author offers.
    • 💡Create a table with columns for the institution, the group it benefits and the author's stated judgement of it.
    • 💡Compare your notes on the author's claims with your notes on Plato's Republic, identifying where the two critics share concerns about popular rule.
    Common Mistakes
    • Retells the plot without linking the passage to democratic procedure; add an explanation of what the lines reveal about how the court operates.
    • Attributes lines to the wrong speaker; check the speaker in your edition before writing about the argument.
    • Gives an unspecific reference such as 'around line 700'; state the exact line range and confirm it against your edition.
    • Treats the herald's speech as the playwright's direct statement; separate the character's argument from the play's overall position.
    • Describes the debate without naming who is speaking; identify the herald and Theseus for each point.
    • Confines the analysis to the section without placing it in the debate; explain its function within the exchange.
    • Assumes the whole of each play is prescribed; restrict your reading and examples to the stated line ranges.
    • Treats the three Wasps ranges as one block; study 471–712, 824–862 and 891–994 as separate units.
    • Takes comic characters as straightforward evidence of Athenian opinion; note the exaggeration and ask what effect the joke is meant to create.
    • Reads the line numbers as optional guidance; use them to check each point you plan to make.
    • Assumes Thucydides is speaking in his own voice throughout 2.36–42; identify that Pericles is the speaker within the narrated speech.
    • Treats 2.65 as part of the Funeral Oration; recognise it as Thucydides' narration of the Athenians' changed attitude to Pericles.
    • Presents Thucydides' account as a neutral record of Athenian opinion; consider how his framing shapes the reader's view.
    • Draws evidence from other parts of Book 2 to support points; keep examples within the prescribed sections.
    • Reads the great beast as teachers forming an obedient crowd; correct this by noting that the many are the beast and the teachers study and follow its temper.
    • Treats the ship as a picture of the philosopher ruling the people; correct this by identifying the shipowner as the people and the true pilot as the philosopher, who is ignored.
    • Assumes the three passages make separate points; correct this by tracing how the ship and the beast both show the many's judgement steering political outcomes.
    • Presents the crowd as passive; correct this by showing that the teachers are shaped by the crowd's opinions, so the many keep influence over what is taught.
    • Treats the Constitution of the Athenians as an objective account of Athenian government; instead identify the author's hostile standpoint and the judgements it produces.
    • Reads the three sets of sections as one continuous block; instead note the boundary between 1.1–1.20, 2.9–2.10 and 2.14–3.13 and what each set focuses on.
    • Accepts the author's claims without checking what evidence he offers; instead mark each claim and note whether he supports it with an example or an assertion.
    • Assumes the author speaks for all oligarchs; instead treat him as one anonymous writer whose views shape the argument.