Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Nationalism — AQA A-Level Politics

    Nationalism explained

    Nationalism covers 10 specification points, including Nation, sovereignty of the people, human… and debates about the nature of nationalism.

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    Key concepts and terminology: nation, sovereignty of the people, human nature, the state, society and the economy, minority nationalism, state nationalism.

    This concept set gives you the vocabulary for analysing nationalism. A nation is a group sharing a sense of identity, often built on culture, language, history or descent, and it need not coincide with a state. Sovereignty of the people means ultimate political authority rests with the nation's members, so nationalists often claim self-government as a right. Human nature is the assumption about whether people are naturally cooperative or competitive, which shapes how far a thinker trusts shared identity to bind strangers together. The state is the legal-political apparatus of institutions and territory; society is the network of social relationships and groups; the economy is the system of production and exchange.

    debates about the nature of nationalism

    This topic asks you to weigh competing views of what nationalism fundamentally is. One debate concerns whether nationalism is primarily a cultural and ethnic bond or a civic and political loyalty open to all citizens. Another asks whether nationalism is inherently aggressive and exclusionary or can be liberal, inclusive and compatible with international cooperation. A further debate concerns whether nationalism is a rational response to modernity, industrialisation and the need for a cohesive state, or a constructed and sometimes manipulated identity. You should also consider whether nationalism liberates peoples through self-determination or fragments states and threatens minorities. Effective answers set out rival positions, support each with thinkers and examples, and reach a reasoned judgement rather than listing views.

    types of nationalism including minority nationalism and state nationalism and the extent to which they vary

    Nationalism is not one doctrine but a family of arguments about who the nation is and who should control it. Minority nationalism arises where a distinct people within a larger state seeks recognition, autonomy or independence, as with Scottish or Catalan movements pressing for self-government. State nationalism works from the existing state outward, using shared citizenship, symbols and institutions to bind a population together, and it may be civic and inclusive or ethnic and exclusive. The two types overlap: a minority nation may build its own state-building project, and a state may contain several national identities. Variation shows in the goal (recognition, autonomy, secession), the basis of belonging (civic or ethnic), the attitude to outsiders, and the means used (electoral, constitutional, cultural or violent).

    recent developments

    Recent developments in nationalism means analysing how nationalist politics has changed in the contemporary period covered by the specification, not reciting a timeline. You should identify developments such as the rise of populist nationalist parties, independence referendums, debates over immigration and sovereignty, and the use of social media to mobilise identity politics. For each development, explain what changed, which type of nationalism it reflects, and what it reveals about the continuing appeal and limits of nationalist argument. Link developments to the concepts already studied, such as civic and ethnic nationalism, self-determination and state sovereignty, so the answer analyses rather than lists. Assess how far recent developments confirm or challenge earlier theories of nationalism, and reach a supported judgement about their significance.

    types and recent developments of minority nationalism, state nationalism, and the extent these different types of nationalism vary

    This topic asks you to distinguish minority nationalism from state nationalism and to judge how far the two differ. Minority nationalism is pursued by a national group within, or divided across, existing states that seeks greater self-government or independence; examples include Scottish and Welsh nationalism within the UK and Catalan and Basque movements within Spain. State nationalism is promoted by or on behalf of an existing state to build loyalty to it, often through shared citizenship, symbols and institutions, as with French republican nation-building. Recent developments to weigh include devolution and independence referendums in the UK, the 2017 Catalan crisis, and the growth of civic and populist-nationalist parties across Europe. Assess variation by comparing aims, the unit each claims to represent, the means used and the relationship to existing sovereignty.

    Jean Jacques Rousseau – the 'general will' of the people, sovereignty of the people, opposition to representative assembly

    Rousseau's nationalism rests on popular sovereignty: legitimate authority comes from the people as a whole, not from a monarch or a separate ruling body. He argued that citizens should will the common good, which he called the general will, distinct from the sum of private individual wills. Because sovereignty belongs to the people collectively, Rousseau was suspicious of representative assemblies that transfer decision-making to delegates; he favoured citizens participating directly in making law. In nationalist terms this supports the idea that a people has the right to govern itself. For a multiple-choice question, identify the option that correctly links the general will to collective popular sovereignty and to Rousseau's preference for direct over representative decision-making.

    Johann Gottfried von Herder – importance of language and cultural traditions to create a nation, concept of nationality and patriotism

    Herder is a cultural nationalist: for him a nation grows from a shared language, folk traditions, songs and customs rather than from borders, constitutions or consent. Language carries a people's way of thinking, so a community speaking and inheriting the same culture forms a nation (a Volk). Nationality is therefore something you inherit and feel, not something you choose or are given by a state. Patriotism, on this view, is attachment to one's own cultural community and its traditions, and each nation has its own value rather than being ranked against others. A question may test the link between language, tradition and national identity, or ask how Herder's patriotism differs from a state-centred or civic version.

    Giuseppe Mazzini – promotion of ideas of republicanism and nationalism, concept of 'thought and action'

    Mazzini combined nationalism with republicanism: he held that each nation should be free and self-governing, and that Italy should be a unified republic rather than a collection of monarchies or foreign-ruled states. His idea of 'thought and action' means that holding a national ideal is not enough; the belief must be turned into practical political struggle, through organisation, education and revolutionary activity. So nationalism for Mazzini is both a moral duty and a call to act, and republicanism supplies the political form the free nation should take. A question may test the meaning of republicanism, the link between nationalism and self-government, or what 'thought and action' requires of the nationalist.

    Marcus Garvey – Garveyism, philosophy to inspire a global mass movement and economic empowerment focussed on Africa, pan-Africanism movement

    Garveyism is the body of ideas associated with Marcus Garvey, a Black nationalist who organised mass movements among people of African descent in the early twentieth century. The specification asks you to know three linked elements. First, Garveyism as a philosophy designed to inspire a global mass movement: it aimed to unite Black people across national borders into a collective force rather than a scattered set of local campaigns. Second, economic empowerment: Garvey stressed self-help, Black-owned business and independent finance as the route to genuine independence, since political rights without economic power were seen as hollow. Third, the focus on Africa and pan-Africanism: Garvey promoted the idea of Africa as a homeland and destination, most famously through the back-to-Africa movement and the Universal Negro Improvement Association.

    Charles Maurras – integral nationalism, anti-France (anti-Protestants, Jews, Freemasons and foreigners), rejection of democratic principles.

    Charles Maurras was a French nationalist thinker associated with integral nationalism, a form of nationalism that demands total loyalty to the nation and treats the nation as an organic whole. The specification highlights three features. First, integral nationalism: the nation is seen as a single body whose unity must be enforced, leaving little room for dissent or pluralism. Second, the idea of an 'anti-France': Maurras identified groups he regarded as internal enemies undermining the true nation, naming Protestants, Jews, Freemasons and foreigners. This exclusionary hostility is central to his thought and is a clear example of chauvinistic nationalism. Third, rejection of democratic principles: Maurras distrusted popular sovereignty and parliamentary government, preferring hierarchy and authority.

    Your focus

    1. Define each key concept accurately in nationalist terms
    2. Distinguish nation, state, society and economy from one another
    3. Classify examples as minority nationalism or state nationalism
    Show all 30 objectives
    1. Explain rival conceptions of the nature of nationalism
    2. Evaluate competing claims about nationalism using thinkers and examples
    3. Reach and justify a reasoned judgement on the nature of nationalism
    4. Explain the distinguishing features of minority nationalism and state nationalism.
    5. Compare the two types across goal, basis of belonging, inclusivity and political means.
    6. Evaluate the extent to which types of nationalism vary, using accurate examples.
    7. Identify recent developments in nationalist politics within the specified period.
    8. Explain how recent developments reflect different types of nationalism.
    9. Evaluate the significance of recent developments for theories of nationalism.
    10. Distinguish minority nationalism from state nationalism with accurate examples.
    11. Explain recent developments in each type of nationalism.
    12. Evaluate the extent to which the two types vary across aims, methods and sovereignty.
    13. Define the general will and distinguish it from private individual wills.
    14. Explain Rousseau's commitment to sovereignty of the people.
    15. Recognise Rousseau's opposition to representative assembly and his preference for direct participation.
    16. Explain how Herder links language and cultural traditions to the creation of a nation.
    17. Distinguish Herder's concept of nationality from state-based definitions.
    18. Describe Herder's understanding of patriotism as cultural attachment.
    19. Explain Mazzini's republicanism and its link to nationalism.
    20. Interpret the concept of 'thought and action' in Mazzini's thought.
    21. Describe how Mazzini presents nationalism as a duty requiring practical action.
    22. State the three elements of Garveyism named in the specification.
    23. Explain how economic empowerment fits Garvey's philosophy.
    24. Distinguish Garvey's pan-Africanism from other forms of nationalism.
    25. Define integral nationalism as presented in the specification.
    26. Identify the groups Maurras labelled the 'anti-France'.
    27. Explain why Maurras rejected democratic principles.

    Nationalism exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Defines a nation as a community sharing identity markers such as culture, language, history or descent rather than merely a legal territory
    • Explains sovereignty of the people as the claim that political authority ultimately belongs to the members of the nation
    • Identifies human nature as an assumption about whether people are naturally cooperative or competitive that underpins nationalist arguments
    • Distinguishes the state as legal-political institutions and territory from society as social relationships and groups
    • Distinguishes the economy as the system of production and exchange from the state and from society
    • Defines minority nationalism as a national group within a larger state seeking self-determination
    • Defines state nationalism as promotion of the existing state's identity and unity from above
    • Distinguishes ethnic and cultural conceptions of nationalism from civic and political conceptions, explaining what each emphasises
    • Evaluates the claim that nationalism is inherently aggressive and exclusionary against evidence of liberal and inclusive nationalism
    • Assesses whether nationalism is a rational response to modernity and the need for state cohesion or a constructed identity
    • Weighs the liberating potential of national self-determination against the risk of fragmenting states and threatening minorities
    • Supports rival positions with named thinkers and appropriate examples
    • Reaches a sustained and reasoned judgement rather than merely listing competing views
    • Distinguishes minority nationalism from state nationalism by identifying who claims the nation and against or through which political unit.
    • Explains that minority nationalism typically seeks recognition, autonomy or independence within or from a larger state, using a concrete example.
    • Explains that state nationalism uses existing state institutions, citizenship and shared symbols to integrate a population.
    • Compares the two types across dimensions such as goal, basis of belonging, inclusivity and political means.
    • Assesses the extent of variation, recognising overlap and cases that combine minority and state-building features.
    • Supports each claim with accurate examples drawn from the specified nationalism topic.
    • Identifies specific recent developments in nationalist politics within the contemporary period covered by the specification.
    • Explains what each development involves and which type or conception of nationalism it reflects.
    • Links developments to core concepts such as sovereignty, self-determination, civic and ethnic identity.
    • Assesses the significance of recent developments for the appeal and limits of nationalism.
    • Reaches a supported judgement on how far recent developments confirm or challenge earlier theories.
    • Distinguishes minority nationalism, pursued by a national group within or across states, from state nationalism, promoted by an existing state to secure loyalty.
    • Explains the aims of minority nationalism, such as autonomy, devolution or independence, using a concrete example such as Scotland or Catalonia.
    • Explains how state nationalism builds a shared civic identity through institutions, symbols and citizenship, using a concrete example.
    • Uses recent developments, such as UK devolution and independence referendums or the 2017 Catalan crisis, to show how these types have evolved.
    • Compares the two types across aims, the unit represented, methods and relationship to sovereignty, and reaches a judgement on how far they vary.
    • Weighs similarities as well as differences, for example that both types can use civic or ethnic appeals and both claim to represent a people.
    • Identifies the general will as the collective will of the people directed at the common good, distinct from private individual wills.
    • Explains that sovereignty of the people means legitimate authority resides in the people collectively rather than in a monarch or ruling elite.
    • Recognises Rousseau's opposition to representative assembly in favour of citizens participating directly in law-making.
    • Links these ideas to nationalist claims that a people has the right to self-government.
    • Identifies language and shared cultural traditions as the basis of nationhood in Herder's account.
    • Explains that nationality is inherited and culturally rooted rather than chosen or granted by a state.
    • Distinguishes Herder's cultural patriotism from civic or state-based conceptions of the nation.
    • Recognises that Herder treats each nation's culture as valuable in its own right rather than ranking nations.
    • Explains Mazzini's republicanism as support for a free, self-governing nation without monarchy.
    • Links Mazzini's nationalism to the unification and independence of a people such as the Italians.
    • Interprets 'thought and action' as the requirement to turn national ideals into practical political struggle.
    • Shows that Mazzini treats nationalism as a moral duty as well as a political programme.
    • Identifies Garveyism as a philosophy intended to inspire a global mass movement of people of African descent.
    • Explains that Garveyism links national or racial pride to economic empowerment through self-help and independent business.
    • Recognises pan-Africanism as the strand that treats Africa as a shared homeland and focus of loyalty.
    • Distinguishes Garvey's mass-movement and economic emphasis from territorial or state-centred nationalism.
    • Connects the back-to-Africa idea and the Universal Negro Improvement Association to Garvey's pan-African vision.
    • Defines integral nationalism as a demand for total loyalty to an organic, unified nation.
    • Identifies the 'anti-France' idea as Maurras's designation of internal enemies, including Protestants, Jews, Freemasons and foreigners.
    • Explains that Maurras rejected democratic principles in favour of hierarchy and authority.
    • Distinguishes Maurras's exclusionary, chauvinistic nationalism from liberal or civic nationalism.
    • Recognises that the 'anti-France' concept treats certain groups as threats to national unity.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Learn each term with a one-line definition and a short example so you can match definitions to scenarios in multiple-choice items
    • 💡Watch for distractors that swap nation and state, or minority and state nationalism, and eliminate them on that basis
    • 💡Read the whole stem before choosing, because several options may be partly true but only one fits the term precisely
    • 💡Plan two or three clear lines of debate and allocate a paragraph to each, keeping the judgement visible throughout
    • 💡Anchor each position with a named thinker and a concrete example so evaluation is evidenced rather than asserted
    • 💡Reserve time to state and justify an overall conclusion that answers the question directly
    • 💡Define both types briefly before comparing, so the examiner sees the distinction you will test.
    • 💡Organise the essay around dimensions of variation rather than describing one example after another.
    • 💡Reach a judgement on how far the types vary and where they converge, and keep it consistent with your evidence.
    • 💡Use precise examples from the nationalism topic and explain what each demonstrates.
    • 💡Select a small number of well-understood developments and analyse them in depth rather than cataloguing many.
    • 💡For each development, state what changed and why it matters for theories of nationalism.
    • 💡Keep examples within the contemporary period the specification covers.
    • 💡End with a clear judgement on the significance of recent developments.
    • 💡Define both types briefly before comparing, so the essay has clear terms of reference.
    • 💡Anchor each analytical point in a named recent example to satisfy the 'recent developments' clause.
    • 💡Plan a judgement on the extent of variation and return to it in the conclusion rather than only describing.
    • 💡Balance similarities and differences so the comparison is genuinely evaluative.
    • 💡Read all options before choosing, since distractors often swap the general will for private interests.
    • 💡Check whether an option places sovereignty in the people or in an assembly, and match Rousseau's view.
    • 💡Eliminate options that credit Rousseau with supporting representative assembly.
    • 💡Anchor answers on the two named elements: language and cultural traditions.
    • 💡Use a concrete illustration such as folk songs or a shared mother tongue to show how culture creates a nation.
    • 💡Contrast Herder's cultural view with a state-centred view to show precise understanding.
    • 💡Define republicanism precisely before linking it to Mazzini's nationalism.
    • 💡Use 'thought and action' to show how belief must become practice.
    • 💡Give a concrete example of nationalist organisation or education to illustrate the action element.
    • 💡Read the stem carefully to see whether it asks about philosophy, economic empowerment or pan-Africanism, then match the option to that specific clause.
    • 💡Eliminate options that describe state-building or territorial expansion, since Garveyism is a transnational racial movement.
    • 💡Link each option to one of the three specification elements before choosing, so you can justify your answer.
    • 💡Watch for distractors that mention Africa only symbolically; the specification ties Africa to a concrete pan-African movement.
    • 💡Match the option to the specific clause: integral nationalism, the 'anti-France' idea or rejection of democracy.
    • 💡Eliminate options describing pluralism or civic inclusion, since these contradict Maurras's thought.
    • 💡Check that any list of 'anti-France' groups matches the specification exactly before selecting.
    • 💡Use the term 'chauvinistic nationalism' to link Maurras to the exclusionary strand of nationalist thought.
    Common Mistakes
    • Treats nation and state as synonyms; keep them distinct, since a nation is an identity community and a state is a legal-political apparatus
    • Assumes sovereignty of the people means rule by a monarch; correct this by linking it to authority resting with the nation's members
    • Confuses minority nationalism with state nationalism; separate claims made by a group within a state from promotion of the state's own identity
    • Lists rival views without weighing them; build an argument that compares and judges the positions
    • Treats nationalism as a single fixed ideology; recognise the ethnic, civic, liberal and conservative variants and their differences
    • Asserts a judgement without evidence; support each claim with a thinker or example before concluding
    • Treats nationalism as a single uniform ideology; separate minority and state variants and show where they diverge.
    • Assumes minority nationalism always seeks full independence; distinguish recognition, autonomy and secession as different goals.
    • Equates state nationalism with ethnic exclusivity only; allow for civic and inclusive forms as well as exclusive ones.
    • Lists examples without linking them to a dimension of variation; connect each example to goal, basis of belonging or means.
    • Lists recent events without analysis; explain what each development shows about nationalist argument.
    • Uses material from outside the contemporary period as if it were a recent development; keep examples within the specified period.
    • Treats all recent nationalism as identical; distinguish populist, civic, ethnic and independence variants.
    • Offers a judgement unsupported by evidence; tie the conclusion to the developments discussed.
    • Treats minority nationalism and state nationalism as identical; separate them by who promotes each and what unit it claims to represent.
    • Describes recent developments without linking them to the types; connect each example to a specific feature of minority or state nationalism.
    • Lists examples without comparing them; build explicit points of comparison on aims, methods and sovereignty.
    • Assumes all minority nationalism is ethnic and all state nationalism is civic; test that assumption against examples rather than asserting it.
    • Confuses the general will with the sum of everyone's private preferences; treat it as the collective will aimed at the common good.
    • Attributes support for representative government to Rousseau; recall his preference for direct citizen participation.
    • Places sovereignty in a monarch or elite rather than the people; locate it in the people collectively.
    • Treats Rousseau's ideas as purely individualist; connect them to collective popular sovereignty.
    • Treats Herder as a civic nationalist who defines the nation by consent or citizenship; correct this by stressing shared language and inherited culture.
    • Confuses Herder's cultural patriotism with loyalty to a state or government; keep the focus on attachment to a cultural community.
    • Assumes Herder ranks nations as superior or inferior; note instead that he values each nation's distinct culture.
    • Treats Mazzini's nationalism as mere sentiment without political commitment; correct this by stressing the demand for action.
    • Describes Mazzini as a supporter of monarchy or foreign rule; note his republicanism instead.
    • Reads 'thought and action' as contemplation alone; explain that it requires organised practical struggle.
    • Treats Garveyism as a purely cultural movement with no economic dimension; include economic empowerment and self-help as a core element.
    • Confuses Garvey's pan-Africanism with European territorial nationalism; keep the focus on a global racial movement centred on Africa.
    • Assumes Garvey sought immediate physical return of all Black people to Africa; recognise the back-to-Africa idea as one expression of a broader pan-African vision.
    • Ignores the global, cross-border ambition of the movement; stress that Garveyism aimed at mass mobilisation beyond any single state.
    • Treats Maurras as a liberal or civic nationalist; recognise his integral nationalism as exclusionary and anti-democratic.
    • Lists the 'anti-France' groups vaguely without naming Protestants, Jews, Freemasons and foreigners as the specification does.
    • Assumes integral nationalism tolerates dissent; stress that it demands total loyalty and unity.
    • Overlooks the rejection of democracy; include Maurras's hostility to popular sovereignty and parliamentary government.