Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    Social control — AQA GCSE Sociology

    Social control explained

    Social control covers 5 specification points, including Formal and informal methods of social control.

    Read the full explanation

    and The work of Heidensohn on female conformity in…. Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    Formal and informal methods of social control.

    Social control means the ways a society persuades or compels people to follow its norms. Formal methods are written, official and enforced by bodies with authority: laws passed by Parliament, police powers of arrest, courts imposing sentences, and schools or workplaces applying published rules and sanctions. Informal methods are unwritten and applied through everyday interaction: family praise or disapproval, peer pressure, ridicule, gossip, the disapproval of neighbours, and the sense of shame or embarrassment a person feels. The two work together; a law against theft is formal, but most people also refrain because friends and family would disapprove. A useful test is to ask who applies the sanction, whether it is written down, and what the consequence is.

    The work of Heidensohn on female conformity in male dominated patriarchal societies.

    Frances Heidensohn studied why women appear to conform more closely than men to social expectations and commit less recorded crime. She argued that patriarchal societies control women through a range of everyday pressures rather than mainly through the criminal justice system. In the home, women carry greater responsibility for domestic work and childcare, which limits their opportunities and time outside it. In public, women face the fear of male violence and harassment, so they avoid certain places and times. At work, women are supervised and their behaviour scrutinised. These controls together produce conformity, so Heidensohn explains female low crime rates through social control rather than through women being naturally more law-abiding.

    identify, describe and explain formal and informal methods of social control including unwritten rules and sanctions

    Social control means the ways a society persuades or forces its members to follow accepted behaviour. Formal control is carried out by agencies with written rules and official powers: the police, courts, prisons and schools with their codes of conduct. Informal control works through everyday relationships: family, friends, peers and the wider community, using approval, disapproval, gossip and the desire to fit in. Unwritten rules are shared expectations that are not written down, such as queuing politely or giving up a seat on a bus; breaking them usually brings mild disapproval rather than legal punishment. Sanctions are the rewards and punishments that enforce both kinds of control. Formal sanctions include fines, cautions and imprisonment; informal sanctions include praise, being ignored or being gossiped about.

    describe, compare and contrast a variety of sociological perspectives on social control (interactionist, functionalist, feminist and Marxist)

    This question asks you to describe four perspectives on social control and then compare and contrast them. Functionalists see social control as necessary for order: shared norms and values, taught through socialisation and enforced by agencies such as the law, keep society stable. Marxists see control as serving the ruling class: the law and the state protect property and profit, and the working class is controlled through coercion and ideology. Feminists see control as gendered: patriarchy shapes rules and sanctions so that women's behaviour is regulated, for example through expectations about appearance or domestic roles. Interactionists focus on how control happens in face-to-face encounters: labels, meanings and the reactions of others shape whether behaviour is seen as deviant.

    describe the key ideas of Heidensohn (page 49) on female conformity.

    Heidensohn asks why women offend less than men and answers with social control rather than biology. She argues that women's lives are patrolled by controls operating in the home, at work and in public space. At home, the domestic role and the responsibilities of caring for children and partners reduce opportunity and raise the cost of rule-breaking. In public, the fear of male violence and of being judged as disreputable keeps women indoors at night and away from risky situations. At work, male supervision and unequal power limit freedom. Conformity is therefore produced by patriarchal control, not simply chosen. A strong answer links each sphere to reduced opportunity or increased risk of sanction.

    Your focus

    1. Distinguish formal from informal methods of social control.
    2. Give one example of a formal sanction and one example of an informal sanction.
    3. Explain how formal and informal control can operate together on the same behaviour.
    Show all 15 objectives
    1. Outline Heidensohn's explanation of female conformity in patriarchal societies.
    2. Identify the settings in which Heidensohn says women are controlled.
    3. Explain why Heidensohn's account links social control to lower recorded female offending.
    4. Distinguish formal methods of social control from informal methods and give an example of each.
    5. Describe unwritten rules and explain how shared expectations enforce them.
    6. Explain how formal and informal sanctions encourage conformity in society.
    7. Describe functionalist, Marxist, feminist and interactionist perspectives on social control.
    8. Compare perspectives by identifying where they agree about social control.
    9. Contrast perspectives by explaining where they differ in their view of whose interests control serves.
    10. State Heidensohn's explanation of female conformity in terms of patriarchal social control.
    11. Describe how control operates in the home, in public space and at work.
    12. Explain how these controls reduce opportunity and raise the risk of sanction for women.

    Social control exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies formal social control as written, official rules enforced by agencies such as the police, courts, schools and employers.
    • Identifies informal social control as unwritten pressure applied through family, peers, neighbours and everyday interaction.
    • Gives a correct example of a formal sanction, such as a court sentence, a fine or a school exclusion.
    • Gives a correct example of an informal sanction, such as ridicule, gossip, praise or disapproval from family or peers.
    • Explains that formal and informal control often operate together on the same behaviour rather than as alternatives.
    • Explains that Heidensohn accounts for female conformity through patriarchal social control rather than through biology.
    • Identifies control in the home, where domestic responsibilities and the supervision of girls restrict opportunity.
    • Identifies control in public space, where fear of male violence and harassment leads women to avoid certain places and times.
    • Identifies control at work, where women are supervised and their behaviour is closely scrutinised.
    • Concludes that these combined controls explain lower recorded female offending and greater conformity.
    • Identifies formal control as control exercised by agencies with written rules and official authority, such as the police, courts and prisons.
    • Identifies informal control as control exercised through everyday relationships and shared expectations, such as family, peers and community.
    • Describes an unwritten rule, such as queuing or showing respect, and explains that it is enforced by shared expectation rather than law.
    • Explains a sanction as a reward or punishment that encourages conformity, distinguishing formal sanctions such as fines from informal sanctions such as disapproval.
    • Explains why a method produces conformity, for example because people fear legal penalties or because they want to avoid social disapproval.
    • Describes the functionalist view that social control maintains order through shared norms and values enforced by socialisation and agencies such as the law.
    • Describes the Marxist view that social control serves the ruling class by protecting property and profit through coercion and ideology.
    • Describes the feminist view that social control is gendered and regulates women's behaviour through patriarchy and expectations about roles.
    • Describes the interactionist view that social control operates through labels, meanings and the reactions of others in face-to-face encounters.
    • Compares perspectives by identifying an agreement, such as functionalists and Marxists both seeing control as maintaining order.
    • Contrasts perspectives by identifying a difference, such as interactionists focusing on small-scale interaction while structural perspectives focus on society as a whole.
    • Explains the implication of a perspective for how control operates, for example that Marxist control protects ruling-class interests rather than benefiting everyone equally.
    • Identifies Heidensohn's central claim that women conform because patriarchal social control restricts their opportunities and raises the risks of deviance.
    • Explains the role of the home and domestic responsibilities in reducing women's opportunity to offend.
    • Explains how fear of male violence and of moral judgement in public space constrains women's behaviour.
    • Explains how control at work, including male supervision and unequal power, contributes to female conformity.
    • Links the explanation to the question of why women appear to commit less crime than men.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Read the question stem carefully to see whether it asks for formal, informal or both before choosing an option.
    • 💡Test each option by asking who applies the sanction and whether it is written down.
    • 💡Reject options that describe deviance rather than the response to deviance.
    • 💡Where two options seem similar, prefer the one naming a recognised agency or a recognised everyday pressure.
    • 💡Link each control Heidensohn identifies to a specific setting: home, public space or workplace.
    • 💡Use the term patriarchal to show you understand the structure of her argument.
    • 💡Check that the option explains conformity rather than merely describing women's lives.
    • 💡Reject options that present conformity as a fixed natural trait.
    • 💡Read the question carefully to check whether it asks you to identify, describe or explain, because each command word needs a different depth of answer.
    • 💡Name the type of control first, then give a concrete example such as a fine or a disapproving look, so the examiner can see you understand the distinction.
    • 💡When asked to explain, add a linking reason using words such as 'because' or 'therefore' to show how the method produces conformity.
    • 💡Plan your answer so each of the four perspectives is described before you move to comparison and contrast.
    • 💡Use linking words such as 'similarly', 'whereas' and 'in contrast' to make comparisons explicit to the examiner.
    • 💡Support each perspective with a brief example and explain what it shows about how social control works.
    • 💡Name the three spheres of control (home, public space, work) and give one concrete example for each.
    • 💡Use the phrase 'social control' explicitly and connect it to reduced opportunity or increased risk of sanction.
    • 💡Answer the question asked: focus on why women conform, not on a general theory of crime.
    Common Mistakes
    • Treats all social control as formal; recognise that informal control operates through everyday interaction without written rules.
    • Classifies the family as a formal agency; place the family among informal agencies because its sanctions are unwritten and personal.
    • Assumes informal control has no consequences; note that ridicule, gossip and disapproval can strongly shape behaviour.
    • Confuses social control with crime; keep the focus on how norms are enforced, whether or not a law is broken.
    • Attributes female conformity to natural or biological differences; explain it through patriarchal social control instead.
    • Reduces Heidensohn's argument to policing alone; include control in the home, in public and at work.
    • Treats the fear of violence as a minor point; recognise it as a central mechanism restricting women's freedom of movement.
    • Confuses Heidensohn with explanations of male crime; keep the focus on female conformity and control.
    • Confuses formal and informal control by treating the family as a formal agency; keep the family as an informal agency because it relies on shared expectations rather than written law.
    • Treats a sanction as only a punishment; include rewards such as praise or status because sanctions can be positive as well as negative.
    • Assumes unwritten rules carry legal penalties; explain that unwritten rules are enforced by social approval and disapproval rather than by law.
    • Describes a method without explaining why it produces conformity; add a reason such as fear of punishment or desire for acceptance.
    • Lists perspectives without comparing them; add a sentence that states where two perspectives agree or differ.
    • Treats all perspectives as saying the same thing about social control; contrast their views on whose interests control serves.
    • Describes a perspective without an example; add a concrete example such as the law protecting property for the Marxist view.
    • Confuses the interactionist focus on small-scale encounters with the structural focus of functionalism and Marxism; keep the level of analysis clear.
    • Claims Heidensohn explains female conformity through biological differences; correct this by stating that she uses social control and patriarchy.
    • Treats the home as the only sphere of control; correct this by including public space and work as well.
    • Assumes Heidensohn says women are naturally law-abiding; correct this by explaining that conformity is produced by external controls and the fear of sanctions.
    • Ignores the role of fear of violence; correct this by explaining how perceived danger in public space restricts women's freedom of movement.