OCR · A-Level · Psychology
Course version: H567 · Version from Sept 2015
Core studies: Social – Responses to people in need: Piliavin et al. (1969)…
Full specification wording
Section A: Core studies: Social – Responses to people in need: Piliavin et al. (1969) Subway Samaritan; Levine et al. (2001) Cross-cultural altruism
Helping is studied here in the field rather than the laboratory.
- Point 2 of 14
- 2 key terms
Study notes
From the teaching notes for this specification point.
The idea
Helping is studied here in the field rather than the laboratory. Piliavin staged collapses on a New York subway train and recorded who helped, finding that a victim with a cane was helped spontaneously on almost every trial while an apparently drunk victim was helped about half the time and after a far longer delay, that helpers were overwhelmingly male, and that help did not slow as the number of bystanders rose. Levine dropped pens, dropped magazines while wearing a leg brace, and had a blind man wait at a kerb, repeating all three in one large city in each of twenty three countries, and found helping rates ranging from over ninety per cent in Rio de Janeiro to around forty per cent in Kuala Lumpur, with economically productive cities helping least.
What earns the marks
- Describe what was manipulated on the subway, the type of victim, the race of the victim, and whether and when a model helped, alongside the recorded measures of frequency of help, latency and sex of the helper.
- Naming simpatia, the cultural value placed on friendly concern for others, as the account offered for the high rates in Latin American cities shows explanation rather than description.
Common mistakes and how to put them right
Claiming the subway research demonstrated the bystander effect.
Put it right: It found the opposite in a carriage where nobody could leave and everyone could see everyone else.
Saying the cross cultural work compared countries.
Put it right: One city stood in for each country, so the claim is about cities and cannot be read as a national characteristic.
Describing the drunk condition as a separate study.
Put it right: Victim type was varied across trials run by the same teams on the same route.
Treating the cross cultural comparison as an imposed etic problem without saying what the problem is, that a dropped pen and a kerb crossing were devised by researchers in one culture and may carry a different meaning elsewhere.
Exam tips
- This pair is a favourite for questions on ecological validity and on ethics, so be ready to argue that the realism of a moving train is bought at the cost of consent, debriefing and the right to withdraw.
- Application questions often describe someone walking past a person in trouble and ask you to suggest why, so use the weighing of costs and rewards rather than simply naming diffusion of responsibility.
- For a comparison, note that both are field experiments using covert observation, but one varies the victim while the other holds the situation steady and varies the culture around it.
Try the lesson
The start of the Section A: Core studies: Social – Responses to people in need: Piliavin et al. (1969) Subway Samaritan; Levine et al. (2001) Cross-cultural altruism lesson, made from teaching notes for this specification point.
Have a go first
In Piliavin et al.'s (1969) 'Subway Samaritan' study, which of the following was manipulated as an independent variable?
Listen
Helping is studied here in the field rather than the laboratory. Piliavin staged collapses on a New York subway train and recorded who helped, finding that a victim with a cane was helped spontaneously on almost every trial while an apparently drunk victim was helped about half the time and after a far longer delay, that helpers were overwhelmingly male, and that help did not slow as the number of bystanders rose. Levine dropped pens, dropped magazines while wearing a leg brace, and had a blind man wait at a kerb, repeating all three in one large city in each of twenty three countries, and found helping rates ranging from over ninety per cent in Rio de Janeiro to around forty per cent in Kuala Lumpur, with economically productive cities helping least. A strong answer earns marks for these points. Describe what was manipulated on the subway, the type of victim, the race of the victim, and whether and when a model helped, alongside the recorded measures of frequency of help, latency and sex of the helper. Report the cross cultural measures as three standardised non emergency situations performed by trained male experimenters, and name the correlate that mattered, economic productivity, which was negatively related to helping. Explanation marks come from applying the arousal cost reward model, that witnessing distress creates unpleasant arousal which a person reduces by taking whichever option carries the lowest net cost, so a drunk or bleeding victim raises the cost of intervening. Naming simpatia, the cultural value placed on friendly concern for others, as the account offered for the high rates in Latin American cities shows explanation rather than description. Exam tip: This pair is a favourite for questions on ecological validity and on ethics, so be ready to argue that the realism of a moving train is bought at the cost of consent, debriefing and the right to withdraw.
Key words
Say what each word means before you turn the card.
arousal cost reward model
Try answering aloud or in your head before turning the card.
field experiments
Try answering aloud or in your head before turning the card.
See every definition
- arousal cost reward model
- Witnessing distress creates unpleasant arousal which a person reduces by taking whichever option carries the lowest net cost.
- field experiments
- Studies using covert observation in a real setting, such as a moving train or a city street, rather than the laboratory.
There is more to this lesson
The full lesson goes on to check your understanding and help you earn the marks. Create a free account to carry on, with your progress saved.
A week of Premium from your first lesson · Then the free plan continues · No card, no charge
Test your understanding of Section A: Core studies: Social – Responses to people in need: Piliavin et al. (1969) Subway Samaritan; Levine et al. (2001) Cross-cultural altruism
Active recall beats re-reading. Take an instant quiz now to test what you’ve learned and lock it into long-term memory.
A week of Premium from your first lesson · Then the free plan continues · No card, no charge