OCR · A-Level · Psychology
Course version: H567 · Version from Sept 2015
Option 2 Criminal psychology: Effect of imprisonment (Social) – Punishment…
Full specification wording
Section B: Option 2 Criminal psychology: Effect of imprisonment (Social) – Punishment and reform as responses to criminal behaviour. Haney et al. (1973) Study of prisoners and guards in a simulated prison. At least one strategy for reducing reoffending.
Imprisonment serves multiple aims: deterrence, incapacitation, punishment, and reform.
- Point 6 of 6
Study notes
From the teaching notes for this specification point.
The idea
Imprisonment serves multiple aims: deterrence, incapacitation, punishment, and reform. Haney et al. (1973) investigated the psychological effects of prison life. They randomly allocated 24 stable male students to prisoner or guard roles in a simulated prison. Prisoners were unexpectedly arrested at home by real police, deloused, and deindividuated; guards wore uniforms and mirrored sunglasses. Guards quickly escalated to authoritarian behaviour. The planned 14-day study was terminated after six days due to acute distress in prisoners. The researchers concluded that situational factors drove the behaviour. While the statement includes '(Social)', this topic spans social and criminal psychology.
What earns the marks
- Outlining the aims of imprisonment (punishment, reform, deterrence, incapacitation) and evaluating them using recidivism rates to question the effectiveness of short custodial sentences.
- Detailing the procedure and controls of Haney et al.: screening for psychological stability, random allocation to roles (the independent variable), and deindividuation techniques.
- Describing specific behaviours observed: the prisoner rebellion on day two, guards' use of privilege cells, and the early release of prisoners experiencing emotional breakdowns.
- Explaining a strategy to reduce reoffending: e.g., restorative justice conferencing, which brings offenders and victims together to increase empathy and reduce recidivism.
- Evaluation credit for challenging the situational conclusion using Reicher and Haslam's BBC prison study, which suggests participants do not blindly conform to roles but act based on shared social identity.
- Ethical evaluation: discussing the lack of protection from harm, the compromised right to withdraw, and Zimbardo's dual role as researcher and prison superintendent.
Common mistakes and how to put them right
Claiming the study lacked an independent variable.
Put it right: The independent variable was the randomly assigned role of either prisoner or guard.
Concluding that the study proves all prisons brutalise inmates.
Put it right: The sample consisted of male students in a brief simulation without actual criminal histories or sentences, limiting generalisability to real prisons.
Stating that participants were fully informed about the arrests.
Put it right: The arrest at home by real police was a deliberate deception; participants were not told this would happen, which breached informed consent.
Exam tips
- When discussing strategies for reducing reoffending, ensure you link the strategy back to how it achieves reform, such as how anger management addresses cognitive deficits.
- Use Zimbardo's dual role as a key evaluation point to explain why the study was allowed to continue despite the severe distress of the participants.
Try the lesson
The start of the Section B: Option 2 Criminal psychology: Effect of imprisonment (Social) – Punishment and reform as responses to criminal behaviour. Haney et al. (1973) Study of prisoners and guards in a simulated prison. At least one strategy for reducing reoffending. lesson, made from teaching notes for this specification point.
Have a go first
What was the primary conclusion drawn from Haney et al.'s (1973) simulated prison study regarding the behaviour of the participants?
Listen
Imprisonment serves multiple aims: deterrence, incapacitation, punishment, and reform. Haney et al. (1973) investigated the psychological effects of prison life. They randomly allocated 24 stable male students to prisoner or guard roles in a simulated prison. Prisoners were unexpectedly arrested at home by real police, deloused, and deindividuated; guards wore uniforms and mirrored sunglasses. Guards quickly escalated to authoritarian behaviour. The planned 14-day study was terminated after six days due to acute distress in prisoners. The researchers concluded that situational factors drove the behaviour. While the statement includes '(Social)', this topic spans social and criminal psychology. A strong answer earns marks for these points. outlining the aims of imprisonment (punishment, reform, deterrence, incapacitation) and evaluating them using recidivism rates to question the effectiveness of short custodial sentences. detailing the procedure and controls of Haney et al.: screening for psychological stability, random allocation to roles (the independent variable), and deindividuation techniques. describing specific behaviours observed: the prisoner rebellion on day two, guards' use of privilege cells, and the early release of prisoners experiencing emotional breakdowns. explaining a strategy to reduce reoffending: e.g., restorative justice conferencing, which brings offenders and victims together to increase empathy and reduce recidivism. A common slip: Claiming the study lacked an independent variable. Instead, The independent variable was the randomly assigned role of either prisoner or guard. Exam tip: When discussing strategies for reducing reoffending, ensure you link the strategy back to how it achieves reform, such as how anger management addresses cognitive deficits.
There is more to this lesson
The full lesson goes on to check your understanding and help you earn the marks. Create a free account to carry on, with your progress saved.
A week of Premium from your first lesson · Then the free plan continues · No card, no charge
Test your understanding of Section B: Option 2 Criminal psychology: Effect of imprisonment (Social) – Punishment and reform as responses to criminal behaviour. Haney et al. (1973) Study of prisoners and guards in a simulated prison. At least one strategy for reducing reoffending.
Active recall beats re-reading. Take an instant quiz now to test what you’ve learned and lock it into long-term memory.
A week of Premium from your first lesson · Then the free plan continues · No card, no charge