2E Judaism - Section A: Judaism and science — AQA A-Level Religious Studies
2E Judaism - Section A: Judaism and science explained
2E Judaism - Section A: Judaism and science covers 4 specification points, including Science’s emphasis on evidence and reason;… and Maimonides: how contemplation of nature….
Read the full explanation
Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
How and why science has influenced Judaism and how Judaism has responded, with particular reference to: science’s emphasis on evidence and reason; specific scientific discoveries; science as a stimulus to Jewish ethical thinking.
This topic asks you to trace a two-way relationship. First, explain how science has shaped Judaism: its stress on evidence and reason has encouraged Jewish thinkers to read scripture through rational enquiry, so that claims about the natural world are tested rather than simply asserted. Second, show how Judaism has responded, sometimes welcoming scientific method as a way of understanding God's creation and sometimes defending revealed teaching where a discovery appears to conflict. Third, examine specific scientific discoveries, such as cosmology describing an expanding universe with an origin, or genetics and evolutionary biology describing change over time, and assess how Jewish thinkers have interpreted them. Fourth, treat science as a stimulus to Jewish ethical thinking, for example where medical technology raises questions about the sanctity of life and the duty to heal.
The importance of science: Maimonides: how contemplation of nature reveals the glory of God.
This item tests your understanding of Maimonides' view that studying the natural world is a religious activity. For Maimonides, careful contemplation of nature, its order, complexity and design, leads the mind towards knowledge of God and so reveals God's glory. Science therefore has religious importance: it is not a rival to faith but a route to deeper awareness of the creator. In a multiple-choice question, look for the option that captures this idea that observing and reasoning about nature draws the thinker towards God. Reject options that present science as irrelevant to faith, as purely secular, or as necessarily opposed to belief. The correct answer will connect contemplation of nature with recognition of God's glory.
How science can challenge religious beliefs; different Jewish responses to Darwin’s theory of evolution and the Big Bang theory of the origin of the universe, including the views of Gerald Schroeder.
Science can challenge religious belief when its methods and findings appear to conflict with revealed teaching. Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection offers a gradual, natural account of species, including humans, which can seem to remove the need for a creator. The Big Bang theory describes an expanding universe from an extremely hot, dense early state, and some believers ask where God fits if natural processes explain origins. Jewish responses differ. Some read Genesis 1 as literal history and reject the scientific timescale; others treat the creation account as theological truth about God as source, not as a scientific timetable; others, notably Gerald Schroeder, argue that the six Genesis days and the roughly 13.8-billion-year cosmological timescale can be reconciled by treating the days as measured from a different reference frame, so apparent conflict dissolves.
Different Jewish responses to ethical issues raised by science: genetic engineering.
Genetic engineering raises ethical questions about modifying living organisms, including humans, and about the limits of human control over creation. Jewish responses draw on principles such as the sanctity of life, the duty to heal, stewardship of creation and concern for human dignity. Some Jews argue that genetic engineering can be permitted where it heals disease, treating medicine as a religious obligation. Others express caution about altering the human genome, about unintended consequences and about treating life as a product to be designed. Responses also differ over the distinction between therapeutic and non-therapeutic modification. A strong answer recognises that Judaism is not monolithic and that different authorities reach different conclusions by weighing these principles differently.
Your focus
- Explain how science's emphasis on evidence and reason has influenced Judaism.
- Assess Jewish responses to specific scientific discoveries.
- Evaluate science as a stimulus to Jewish ethical thinking.
Show all 12 objectives
- State Maimonides' view that contemplation of nature reveals God's glory.
- Explain why science has religious importance for Maimonides.
- Select the option that best reflects Maimonides' teaching on nature and God.
- Explain how evolution and the Big Bang theory can challenge religious belief.
- Distinguish different Jewish responses to Darwin's theory and the Big Bang.
- Describe Gerald Schroeder's reconciliation of Genesis days with cosmological time.
- Explain ethical issues raised by genetic engineering.
- Describe different Jewish responses to genetic engineering.
- Apply Jewish principles such as sanctity of life and the duty to heal to genetic engineering.
2E Judaism - Section A: Judaism and science exam tips
Marking Points
- Explains how science's emphasis on evidence and reason has encouraged Jewish thinkers to interpret scripture rationally rather than accept it uncritically.
- Identifies a specific scientific discovery and assesses how a named Jewish thinker or tradition has responded to it.
- Evaluates science as a stimulus to Jewish ethical thinking by linking a scientific development to a concrete moral question such as medical treatment.
- Distinguishes between Jewish responses that welcome scientific method and those that defend revealed teaching where conflict appears.
- Reaches a supported judgement on how far science has influenced Judaism rather than merely listing examples.
- Identifies that Maimonides treats contemplation of nature as a route to knowledge of God.
- Recognises that for Maimonides the order and complexity of nature reveal God's glory.
- Rejects the view that science is religiously irrelevant or necessarily opposed to faith.
- Connects the study of the natural world with deepened awareness of the creator rather than with purely secular enquiry.
- Identifies that evolution by natural selection offers a natural explanation of species and can appear to make a creator redundant.
- Explains that the Big Bang theory accounts for the origin of the universe through natural processes and so raises the question of God's role.
- Contrasts a literal reading of Genesis 1 with readings that treat the creation account as theological rather than scientific.
- Describes Gerald Schroeder's reconciliation of the six Genesis days with the cosmological timescale by reference to differing frames of time.
- Identifies the sanctity of life as a principle shaping Jewish responses to genetic engineering.
- Explains the duty to heal as a basis for permitting therapeutic genetic intervention.
- Describes caution about altering the human genome or treating life as a designed product.
- Distinguishes therapeutic from non-therapeutic modification as a factor in Jewish ethical reasoning.
- Recognises that Jewish authorities reach different conclusions by weighing principles differently.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Anchor each paragraph on one clause of the question: evidence and reason, a specific discovery, or ethical stimulus.
- 💡Name thinkers or texts where you can, and explain the reasoning behind their response rather than just labelling it.
- 💡Reserve time to state and justify a final judgement on how far science has influenced Judaism.
- 💡Read every option before choosing, and eliminate those that make science and faith simply opposed.
- 💡Look for the option that links observing nature with knowledge or glory of God.
- 💡Check that your chosen answer reflects reasoned contemplation rather than emotion or blind acceptance.
- 💡Learn at least three distinct Jewish responses and be ready to contrast them.
- 💡State precisely what each scientific theory claims before explaining the challenge it poses.
- 💡Link Gerald Schroeder's view to the specific mechanism of reconciling timescales rather than merely naming him.
- 💡Look for options that name a specific Jewish principle rather than a vague attitude.
- 💡Reject options that present one ruling as the only Jewish position.
- 💡Check whether an option distinguishes healing from enhancement.
Common Mistakes
- Treats science and Judaism as simply opposed; recognise that many Jewish thinkers welcome evidence and reason as aids to understanding creation.
- Describes a scientific discovery without linking it to a Jewish response; connect each discovery to a named thinker, text or ethical debate.
- Asserts that all Jews respond to science in one way; distinguish between different thinkers and traditions and evaluate their reasoning.
- Assumes Maimonides saw science as a threat to faith; recognise that he treats contemplation of nature as revealing God's glory.
- Treats the study of nature as purely secular; connect it to knowledge and glory of God in Maimonides' thought.
- Confuses Maimonides' rational approach with simple literal reading; focus on reasoned contemplation of the natural world.
- Treats all Jews as holding one response to evolution; correct this by distinguishing literalist, allegorical and reconciliatory positions.
- Assumes the Big Bang theory denies God outright; correct this by explaining that it describes natural processes and leaves the theological question open.
- Omits Gerald Schroeder's specific reconciliation; correct this by naming his view that the Genesis days and cosmological time can be harmonised.
- Confuses the timescale of the universe with the age of the Earth; correct this by keeping the roughly 13.8-billion-year cosmological figure distinct.
- Treats Judaism as having a single settled ruling on genetic engineering; correct this by noting that different authorities weigh principles differently.
- Ignores the distinction between therapeutic and non-therapeutic modification; correct this by explaining that this distinction shapes Jewish reasoning.
- Reduces the issue to a simple science-versus-religion conflict; correct this by explaining that Jewish principles such as the duty to heal can support genetic medicine.