2E Judaism - Section A: Self, death and afterlife — AQA A-Level Religious Studies
2E Judaism - Section A: Self, death and afterlife explained
2E Judaism - Section A: Self, death and afterlife covers 3 specification points, including Different purposes of life and their relative… and In the Tenakh: including I Samuel 28:11–20 and….
Read the full explanation
Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
The meaning and purpose of life: different purposes of life and their relative importance: obedience; to bring the Messiah and to repair the world; different Jewish understandings of the Messianic Age.
Judaism offers several accounts of what life is for, and learners must weigh their relative importance. One purpose is obedience to God’s commandments (mitzvot), understood as a way of living faithfully within the covenant. Another is to bring the Messiah, so that daily conduct and communal faithfulness are seen as preparing the world for messianic times. A third is tikkun olam, repairing the world, often expressed through justice, charity and care for creation. Jewish understandings of the Messianic Age differ: some expect a personal Messiah, others emphasise a messianic era of peace and justice, and some stress human responsibility in bringing it about. A learner should compare these purposes, judge their relative weight, and explain the differing views of the Messianic Age.
Life after death: In the Tenakh: including I Samuel 28:11–20 and the concept of She’ol; nature of the soul; resurrection of the flesh in the Thirteen Principles of the Faith and modern attitudes to this belief; immortality of the soul in later Jewish thinking including the expression of these beliefs in the Pittsburgh Platform; the link between belief in the afterlife and belief in the justice of God.
This topic traces Jewish belief about death from the Tenakh to modern platforms. In I Samuel 28:11–20 Saul has the medium at Endor summon Samuel, and the text presents a figure rising from the earth; learners should read the passage itself rather than assume it settles later doctrine. She'ol names the shadowy place of the dead in the Tenakh, not a developed heaven or hell. The nature of the soul is debated: some texts treat the person as a living whole (nephesh), while later thinkers separate a soul that survives. Maimonides' Thirteen Principles include resurrection of the flesh, and modern attitudes range from literal acceptance to reinterpretation as national or spiritual revival.
Reincarnation in some kabbalistic thinking.
Kabbalah is the Jewish mystical tradition, and within some kabbalistic thinking there is a belief in reincarnation, often called gilgul. The idea holds that a soul may return in another body to complete a task, make amends or fulfil commandments it did not complete in a previous life. This is not a uniform or mainstream doctrine: it appears in some kabbalistic texts and among some Hasidic thinkers, while many Jewish authorities do not accept it or treat it as symbolic. Learners should keep the scope precise: the specification asks about reincarnation in some kabbalistic thinking, not about Judaism as a whole. A good answer distinguishes this mystical belief from the more widely discussed ideas of resurrection of the flesh and immortality of the soul, and explains that kabbalistic reincarnation is offered as a way of understanding divine justice and the soul's journey.
Your focus
- Explain obedience, bringing the Messiah and tikkun olam as purposes of life.
- Compare the relative importance of these purposes.
- Describe different Jewish understandings of the Messianic Age.
Show all 9 objectives
- Identify the key texts and concepts about life after death in the Tenakh, including I Samuel 28:11–20 and She'ol.
- Distinguish resurrection of the flesh from immortality of the soul and locate each in its Jewish source.
- Explain how belief in the afterlife connects to belief in the justice of God.
- Identify Kabbalah as the tradition in which reincarnation appears in some Jewish thinking.
- Explain reincarnation as the return of a soul in another body and distinguish it from other afterlife beliefs.
- Recognise that kabbalistic reincarnation is a minority mystical idea rather than a uniform Jewish doctrine.
2E Judaism - Section A: Self, death and afterlife exam tips
Marking Points
- Explains obedience to the mitzvot as one purpose of life, rooted in covenant faithfulness.
- Describes the purpose of bringing the Messiah and how conduct is seen as preparing for messianic times.
- Explains tikkun olam, repairing the world, through justice, charity and care for creation.
- Compares the relative importance of these purposes rather than merely listing them.
- Outlines different Jewish understandings of the Messianic Age, such as a personal Messiah or a messianic era of peace and justice.
- Identifies I Samuel 28:11–20 as the account in which Saul asks the medium at Endor to bring up Samuel.
- Explains She'ol as the shadowy realm of the dead in the Tenakh rather than a fully developed heaven or hell.
- Distinguishes the nature of the soul as a living whole from later views of a soul that survives death.
- States that the Thirteen Principles of the Faith include belief in resurrection of the flesh.
- Describes modern attitudes that range from literal acceptance of resurrection to reinterpretation as spiritual or national revival.
- Explains immortality of the soul in later Jewish thinking and its expression in the Pittsburgh Platform.
- Links belief in the afterlife to belief in the justice of God as a way of accounting for apparent injustice in this life.
- Identifies Kabbalah as the Jewish mystical tradition in which reincarnation appears.
- Explains reincarnation as the return of a soul in another body, often termed gilgul.
- States that reincarnation is found in some kabbalistic thinking rather than as a uniform or mainstream Jewish doctrine.
- Connects kabbalistic reincarnation to ideas of completing commandments, making amends or divine justice.
- Distinguishes reincarnation from resurrection of the flesh and immortality of the soul.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Use the phrase ‘relative importance’ explicitly when comparing the purposes of life.
- 💡Give a short example of tikkun olam, such as acts of justice or charity, to make the concept concrete.
- 💡Contrast at least two Jewish understandings of the Messianic Age to show awareness of diversity.
- 💡Read the wording of each option against the exact source: She'ol, resurrection of the flesh and immortality of the soul are distinct ideas.
- 💡Use the Pittsburgh Platform as a specific example of later Jewish thinking rather than a vague reference to 'modern Jews'.
- 💡When an option links the afterlife to God's justice, check that it explains how apparent injustice in this life is addressed.
- 💡Keep the qualifier 'some kabbalistic thinking' in mind and reject options that generalise to all Judaism.
- 💡Link reincarnation to the soul's purpose, such as completing commandments or making amends, to distinguish it from other afterlife beliefs.
- 💡Check that an option names Kabbalah or gilgul rather than a general claim about Jewish belief.
Common Mistakes
- Lists the purposes of life without weighing their relative importance; compare and rank them instead.
- Treats all Jews as holding one view of the Messianic Age; present the range of understandings instead.
- Confuses tikkun olam with a purely private spiritual goal; explain its social and ethical dimension of repairing the world.
- Separates obedience from covenant relationship; show instead how mitzvot express covenant faithfulness.
- Treats She'ol as a developed doctrine of heaven and hell; correct this by describing it as the shadowy place of the dead in the Tenakh.
- Assumes the medium at Endor passage settles later Jewish doctrine; correct this by reading it as a narrative that later thinkers interpret differently.
- Attributes resurrection of the flesh to the Pittsburgh Platform; correct this by noting that the Platform expresses immortality of the soul instead.
- Separates afterlife belief from the justice of God; correct this by explaining how post-mortem reward and punishment address apparent injustice.
- Presents reincarnation as a belief held by all Jews; correct this by limiting it to some kabbalistic thinking.
- Confuses reincarnation with resurrection of the flesh; correct this by explaining that reincarnation involves a soul returning in another body.
- Treats kabbalistic reincarnation as a settled official doctrine; correct this by describing it as a mystical idea found in some texts and thinkers.