Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    2E Judaism - Section A: Judaism, gender and sexuality — AQA A-Level Religious Studies

    2E Judaism - Section A: Judaism, gender and sexuality explained

    2E Judaism - Section A: Judaism, gender and sexuality covers 4 specification points, including The changing roles of men and women in society… and Debates about the ordination of women as….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    Historical and social factors that have influenced developments in Jewish thinking about these issues including: the changing roles of men and women in society outside of religion; different understandings of the Torah and Halakah; the rights given to women by secular governments.

    This topic asks you to trace how Jewish thinking on gender and sexuality has been shaped by forces beyond the synagogue. Three strands must be covered. First, the changing roles of men and women in wider society: women's entry into paid work, higher education and public office from the nineteenth and twentieth centuries onwards prompted Jewish communities to reconsider what women may do religiously. Second, different understandings of the Torah and Halakah: some Jews read certain commandments as fixed and binding, while others treat legal reasoning as a living process in which rabbinic interpretation can develop, so the same texts yield different conclusions about women's roles. Third, the rights given to women by secular governments: laws on equality, employment and divorce in countries where Jews live have pressed communities to align or explain their practice.

    Debates about the ordination of women as rabbis from c1970 to the present.

    This topic requires you to examine arguments for and against ordaining women as rabbis within Judaism from about 1970 to the present. Reform and Liberal Judaism led the way, ordaining women rabbis from the 1970s and 1980s, while Conservative (Masorti) Judaism reached its own decision later, and Orthodox Judaism generally does not ordain women as rabbis, though some Orthodox institutions train women for related roles. Present the reasoning on each side. Supporters appeal to egalitarian values, to women's scholarship and leadership, and to readings of Torah and Halakah that permit change. Opponents appeal to traditional halakhic categories, to continuity of practice, and to communal authority. Show that this is a live debate with different positions across the Jewish world, and keep your examples within the stated period.

    The work of the Jewish Orthodox Feminist Alliance, including its views on the issues of agunot and minyan.

    JOFA, the Jewish Orthodox Feminist Alliance, works within Orthodox halakhah rather than against it, campaigning for women's fuller participation in ritual and communal life while accepting the authority of rabbinic law. On agunot, women whose husbands refuse or cannot grant a get, JOFA presses for solutions such as prenuptial agreements, rabbinic pressure on recalcitrant husbands and support for women trapped in this position. On minyan, JOFA advocates expanding women's roles in prayer and communal leadership, yet it does not claim that Orthodox halakhah permits women to count in the prayer quorum; the question of women counting in a minyan remains contested and is not JOFA's settled position. Learn to distinguish what JOFA campaigns for from what it argues halakhah already allows.

    Different Jewish views about celibacy, marriage, homosexuality and transgender issues, including the views of Rachel Adler.

    Jewish attitudes to sexuality and gender vary across movements. On celibacy, traditional Judaism generally treats marriage and procreation as a positive duty, so lifelong celibacy is unusual, though some individuals and strands value it. On marriage, Orthodox Judaism upholds heterosexual marriage and the get, while Progressive movements accept same-sex marriage and ordain gay and lesbian rabbis. On homosexuality, Orthodox bodies typically retain the biblical prohibition, whereas Conservative, Reform and Liberal Judaism have revised their positions. On transgender issues, movements differ over ritual inclusion and terminology. Rachel Adler, a theologian, critiques traditional marriage and gender assumptions from within Jewish thought, arguing for more egalitarian and covenantal understandings of relationships.

    Your focus

    1. Explain how at least two social changes outside religion influenced Jewish thinking on gender.
    2. Compare fixed and developmental understandings of Torah and Halakah and their consequences.
    3. Evaluate how secular government rights for women shaped Jewish communal practice.
    Show all 12 objectives
    1. Describe the range of Jewish positions on ordaining women as rabbis since about 1970.
    2. Explain the arguments for and against ordination using accurate halakhic and social reasoning.
    3. Evaluate the debate by weighing the strengths of each side's case.
    4. Outline JOFA's aims as an Orthodox feminist organisation.
    5. Explain JOFA's approach to the problem of agunot.
    6. Distinguish JOFA's advocacy on women's prayer participation from any claim that women count in the minyan.
    7. Describe different Jewish views on celibacy and marriage.
    8. Compare Orthodox and Progressive positions on homosexuality and transgender issues.
    9. Explain Rachel Adler's contribution to Jewish thinking on gender and relationships.

    2E Judaism - Section A: Judaism, gender and sexuality exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Explains how women's changing roles in employment, education and public life outside religion prompted Jewish communities to revisit assumptions about women's religious participation.
    • Distinguishes between readings that treat Torah and Halakah as fixed and readings that treat halakhic reasoning as open to development, and shows how each reading shapes conclusions about gender.
    • Explains how secular legal rights for women, such as equality and divorce legislation, created pressure on Jewish communities to align or justify their practice.
    • Shows interaction between the factors, for example how a secular divorce law and a particular reading of Halakah together shape a community's response.
    • Supports each factor with a specific, accurate example drawn from modern Jewish history rather than a general assertion.
    • Outlines the range of positions on ordaining women as rabbis, distinguishing Reform, Liberal, Masorti and Orthodox approaches.
    • Explains arguments in favour, such as egalitarian values, women's scholarship and leadership, and readings of Halakah that allow development.
    • Explains arguments against, such as traditional halakhic categories, continuity of practice and communal authority.
    • Uses accurate examples from the period from about 1970 to the present to illustrate how different movements reached their positions.
    • Evaluates the debate by weighing the reasoning on each side rather than merely describing the positions.
    • Identifies JOFA as an Orthodox feminist organisation that works within halakhah rather than rejecting it.
    • Explains JOFA's concern with agunot as women denied a religious divorce by a husband's refusal to grant a get.
    • Describes JOFA's practical responses to the agunot problem, such as prenuptial agreements and rabbinic pressure.
    • States that JOFA advocates wider women's participation in prayer without asserting that Orthodox halakhah counts women in the minyan.
    • Distinguishes JOFA's campaigning aims from claims about what halakhah already permits.
    • Outlines the traditional Jewish valuation of marriage and procreation and the limited place of celibacy.
    • Contrasts Orthodox retention of heterosexual marriage norms with Progressive acceptance of same-sex marriage.
    • Explains that Orthodox bodies generally maintain the biblical prohibition on homosexual acts while other movements have revised their positions.
    • Describes differing approaches to transgender inclusion across Jewish movements.
    • Presents Rachel Adler's critique of traditional marriage and gender assumptions and her case for egalitarian, covenantal relationships.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Plan your answer around the three named factors so each clause of the question is visibly addressed.
    • 💡Use precise vocabulary such as Halakah, responsa and egalitarian to signal accurate understanding.
    • 💡Link each factor to a concrete consequence for Jewish practice rather than leaving it abstract.
    • 💡Structure your answer by position, giving the reasoning for each before evaluating.
    • 💡Name the movements precisely and avoid treating one movement's ruling as universal.
    • 💡Reserve time to weigh the arguments so the answer evaluates rather than lists.
    • 💡Read the question stem carefully to see whether it asks what JOFA campaigns for or what it claims halakhah permits.
    • 💡Use precise vocabulary: agunah, get, minyan, halakhah.
    • 💡Link each example of JOFA's work to a specific issue rather than describing the organisation in general terms.
    • 💡Name the movement (Orthodox, Conservative, Reform, Liberal) whenever you state a view.
    • 💡Use Rachel Adler's name and summarise her argument rather than paraphrasing vaguely.
    • 💡Keep each issue (celibacy, marriage, homosexuality, transgender) distinct in your answer.
    Common Mistakes
    • Treats the three factors as a list to be described separately; connect them and show how one factor reinforces or conflicts with another.
    • Assumes all Jews read Torah and Halakah identically; distinguish Orthodox, Conservative and Reform approaches and explain the reasoning behind each.
    • Dates the debate only to ancient times; anchor the discussion in the modern period when women's social roles and secular rights changed.
    • Presents Judaism as a single position; distinguish the movements and their differing decisions.
    • Places the debate outside the stated period; anchor examples from about 1970 onwards.
    • Describes positions without explaining the reasoning behind them; give the arguments each side uses.
    • Claims that JOFA argues women count in the prayer quorum; correct this by noting that the minyan question remains contested and is not JOFA's settled position.
    • Treats JOFA as a non-Orthodox or Reform movement; correct this by stressing that JOFA works inside Orthodox halakhah.
    • Confuses agunah with a woman who has simply not yet remarried; correct this by defining an agunah as a woman whose husband refuses or cannot grant a get.
    • Assumes JOFA rejects rabbinic authority; correct this by showing that JOFA seeks change through halakhic argument and rabbinic engagement.
    • Treats all Jews as holding one view on homosexuality; correct this by contrasting Orthodox and Progressive positions.
    • Assumes Judaism uniformly rejects celibacy; correct this by noting the traditional emphasis on marriage while acknowledging minority valuing of celibacy.
    • Attributes to Rachel Adler a blanket rejection of Judaism; correct this by presenting her as a theologian working critically within Jewish thought.
    • Ignores transgender issues entirely; correct this by outlining differing movement approaches to inclusion.