2E Judaism - Section B: The dialogue between Judaism and ethics — AQA A-Level Religious Studies
2E Judaism - Section B: The dialogue between Judaism and ethics explained
2E Judaism - Section B: The dialogue between Judaism and ethics covers 8 specification points, including Jewish responses to the following approaches… and deontological, with reference to Kant..
Read the full explanation
Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
Jewish responses to the following approaches to moral decision-making in the light of key Jewish moral principles:
This criterion requires an extended answer on how Jewish thinkers and communities respond to named approaches to moral decision-making, judged against key Jewish moral principles. The approaches are those listed in the specification for this theme, so identify each one and treat it separately rather than merging them. For each approach, set out the Jewish response: which principles support it, which qualify or resist it, and why. Key Jewish moral principles to draw on include the belief that the human person is made in the image of God, the covenant and its obligations, the centrality of law and its reasoned interpretation, the value of preserving life, and themes of justice, mercy and responsibility for others. A strong response explains the reasoning behind a Jewish position, shows where principles pull in different directions, and reaches a supported judgement.
deontological, with reference to Kant.
This row asks you to handle the deontological strand of the dialogue between Judaism and ethics, using Kant as the reference thinker. Deontology locates moral rightness in duty and in the form of the moral law rather than in outcomes. Kant's categorical imperative tests whether a maxim can be universalised and whether it treats persons as ends, never merely as means. In the Judaism-and-ethics dialogue, you weigh this duty-centred framework against Jewish ethical reasoning, for example the role of divine command, covenant obligation and halakhic rule-following, and ask whether acting from duty alone captures what Jewish ethics requires. AQA A-Level Religious Studies is assessed through essay-style written responses, not multiple-choice items, so prepare to argue this comparison in continuous prose with accurate use of Kantian terms.
teleological and consequential, with reference to Bentham.
This fragment sits inside the dialogue between Judaism and ethics, where you classify an ethical approach as teleological and consequential and connect it to Bentham. A teleological approach judges an act by its end or purpose rather than by the act itself, and a consequential approach judges it by its outcomes. Bentham's utilitarianism is the standard example: the right act is the one producing the greatest happiness for the greatest number, assessed through his hedonic calculus of intensity, duration, certainty, proximity, fecundity, purity and extent. In a multiple-choice item you identify which option correctly labels Bentham's ethics as teleological and consequential, and reject options that call it deontological or describe it as rule-based regardless of results.
character based, with reference to virtue ethics.
This fragment names one option in the dialogue between Judaism and ethics: the claim that Jewish ethics is character based, assessed through virtue ethics. Virtue ethics asks what sort of person one should become, focusing on traits such as humility, justice, compassion and faithfulness rather than on rules or outcomes alone. A learner should be able to identify this character-centred reading, connect it to virtues cultivated in Jewish life, and distinguish it from deontological, teleological and consequential readings. A strong answer recognises that virtue ethics is one lens among several and that the same tradition may be read through more than one. The task is to select the option that matches the description given, not to argue a full case.
How far Jewish ethics can be considered to be deontological, teleological, consequential, or character based.
This question asks how far Jewish ethics fits four lenses: deontological (duty and rules), teleological (purpose or end), consequential (outcomes) and character based (virtue). A strong response weighs evidence for each lens, using Jewish sources and practices, then judges how far each captures the tradition. For example, commandments and legal codes support a deontological reading; covenantal purpose and pursuit of holiness support a teleological reading; concern for welfare of others supports a consequential reading; cultivation of traits such as justice and compassion supports a character-based reading. The answer should reach a reasoned judgement about the extent to which each lens applies, acknowledging that the tradition may resist a single label.
Jewish response to: the issues of human life and death and issues of animal life and death prescribed for study; theft and lying; marriage; homosexuality and transgender issues; genetic engineering.
This topic asks you to explain how Jewish thought responds to a set of ethical issues: the value of human life and death, the treatment of animals, theft and lying, marriage, homosexuality and transgender issues, and genetic engineering. A strong answer links each issue to a Jewish source or principle, such as the sanctity of life (pikuach nefesh), the command to avoid unnecessary suffering to animals (tza'ar ba'alei chayim), the prohibition of theft and dishonest speech, the value placed on marriage and family, and debate about how far human beings may alter creation. Show that Judaism is not a single voice: Orthodox and Progressive Jews may reach different conclusions on the same issue. For each issue, state the Jewish teaching, explain the reasoning behind it, and note where Jews disagree.
Jewish responses to issues surrounding wealth, tolerance and freedom of religious expression.
This topic asks you to explain how Jewish thought responds to three linked areas: wealth, tolerance, and freedom of religious expression. On wealth, draw on Jewish teaching about the responsible use of money, charity (tzedakah) and justice in economic life, and note that attitudes to acquiring and using wealth can differ. On tolerance, explain Jewish teaching about respecting people of other faiths and about how Jews expect to be treated within a wider society. On freedom of religious expression, explain the value Jews place on being able to practise their faith openly, such as observing Shabbat and festivals, and how this connects to tolerance of others. Show that Judaism contains more than one voice, and support each response with a named principle or source rather than a personal opinion.
Jewish understandings of free will and moral responsibility, and the value of conscience in Jewish moral decision-making. The impact of other ethical perspectives and ethical studies on Jewish views about these issues, both past and present. This may include challenges to and support for Jewish views; compatibility of Jewish views with those of other ethical perspectives; the relative strengths and weaknesses of Jewish perspectives and the other ethical perspectives studied on these issues; the implications of criticisms of Jewish ethical teaching for the religion as a whole and its sources of authority.
This dialogue topic asks you to weigh Jewish teaching on free will, moral responsibility and conscience against the other ethical perspectives you have studied, past and present. Begin by setting out the Jewish position: that humans are created with genuine choice, that the yetzer ha-tov and yetzer ha-ra describe an inner inclination toward good and toward selfishness, and that Torah and halakhah give guidance while responsibility for the choice remains with the person. Then bring in a named ethical perspective, such as a natural-law or a Kantian or a utilitarian approach, and test both directions: where does the other perspective support Jewish reasoning, and where does it challenge it? Weigh relative strengths and weaknesses of each, and finally consider what sustained criticism would mean for Judaism's sources of authority, such as Torah, rabbinic interpretation and conscience.
Your focus
- Explain Jewish responses to each named approach to moral decision-making.
- Apply key Jewish moral principles accurately to those approaches.
- Evaluate how far each approach is compatible with Jewish moral principles and justify a conclusion.
Show all 24 objectives
- Explain the deontological approach with accurate reference to Kant.
- Compare Kantian duty ethics with Jewish ethical reasoning in the specified dialogue.
- Evaluate the strengths and limitations of a deontological framework in this context.
- Define teleological and consequential in ethical theory.
- Explain why Bentham's utilitarianism counts as teleological and consequential.
- Select the option that correctly classifies Bentham's approach within the Judaism and ethics dialogue.
- Identify the character-based reading of Jewish ethics and its link to virtue ethics.
- Distinguish virtue ethics from deontological, teleological and consequential readings.
- Recognise that multiple ethical lenses may be applied to a tradition.
- Explain deontological, teleological, consequential and character-based readings of Jewish ethics.
- Support each reading with evidence from Jewish sources and practice.
- Reach a reasoned judgement on how far each lens applies to Jewish ethics.
- Explain Jewish responses to the prescribed issues of human and animal life and death.
- Apply Jewish teachings on theft, lying and marriage to ethical situations.
- Compare Orthodox and Progressive Jewish responses to homosexuality, transgender issues and genetic engineering.
- Explain Jewish teachings on wealth and the responsible use of money.
- Describe Jewish views on tolerance and freedom of religious expression with supporting principles.
- Compare differing Jewish responses to issues of wealth, tolerance and religious freedom.
- Explain Jewish understandings of free will, moral responsibility and conscience.
- Evaluate how other ethical perspectives support or challenge Jewish views, past and present.
- Assess the implications of criticism for Judaism and its sources of authority.
2E Judaism - Section B: The dialogue between Judaism and ethics exam tips
Marking Points
- Identifies each approach to moral decision-making named in the specification and treats it separately.
- Explains the Jewish response to each approach with reference to specific key Jewish moral principles.
- Shows where Jewish principles support an approach and where they qualify or resist it, giving reasons.
- Uses accurate terminology and sources appropriate to Judaism to support the argument.
- Reaches and justifies a judgement about how far the approach is compatible with Jewish moral principles.
- Defines deontology as an approach that judges an action by conformity to duty and the moral law rather than by its consequences.
- Explains Kant's categorical imperative as a formal test of maxims, including universalisability and treating persons as ends rather than merely as means.
- Applies Kantian duty ethics to the Judaism-and-ethics dialogue by comparing duty for duty's sake with obligation grounded in covenant and divine command.
- Assesses the strengths and limits of a Kantian framework when set against Jewish ethical reasoning, reaching a supported judgement.
- Identifies Bentham's ethics as teleological because it evaluates an action by the purpose or end it serves rather than by the action's intrinsic nature.
- Explains that consequentialism locates moral rightness in the outcomes an act produces, which matches Bentham's focus on resulting happiness.
- Links Bentham's greatest happiness principle to the hedonic calculus as the method for weighing pleasures and pains.
- Rejects the option that classifies Bentham's ethics as deontological, since deontology judges acts by duty or rule independent of results.
- Distinguishes act-focused outcome assessment from rule-based approaches that fix duties before consequences are considered.
- Identifies the character-based reading as the one that foregrounds the kind of person an agent becomes rather than the rule followed or the outcome produced.
- Links the character-based reading to virtue ethics by naming traits such as humility, justice or compassion cultivated through practice.
- Distinguishes the character-based reading from deontological, teleological and consequential alternatives by naming what each emphasises.
- Recognises that a single tradition may be interpreted through more than one ethical lens rather than only one.
- Explains a deontological reading by pointing to commandments and duty as central to Jewish ethics.
- Explains a teleological reading by pointing to covenantal purpose or the pursuit of holiness as the end of ethical life.
- Explains a consequential reading by pointing to concern for outcomes and welfare of others.
- Explains a character-based reading by pointing to virtues such as justice and compassion cultivated in Jewish life.
- Weighs the four lenses against one another and reaches a reasoned judgement about how far each applies.
- Identifies a Jewish principle relevant to the sanctity of human life, such as pikuach nefesh, and explains how it shapes a response to an end-of-life issue.
- Explains a Jewish teaching on the treatment of animals, such as the duty to avoid unnecessary suffering, and applies it to a named issue of animal life and death.
- States the Jewish prohibition of theft and of dishonest speech and links it to a practical ethical situation.
- Describes a Jewish view of marriage as a valued relationship and covenant and explains what this implies for sexual ethics.
- Explains that Orthodox and Progressive Jews may hold different views on homosexuality and transgender issues and gives a reason for the difference.
- Outlines a Jewish response to genetic engineering that weighs the duty to heal against limits on altering creation.
- Explains a Jewish teaching on the responsible use of wealth, such as the duty of tzedakah, and applies it to an economic situation.
- Describes a Jewish view of tolerance towards people of other faiths and gives a reason drawn from Jewish teaching.
- Explains why freedom of religious expression matters to Jews, referring to an example such as observing Shabbat or festivals.
- Shows that Jewish responses to wealth, tolerance or religious freedom can differ between Orthodox and Progressive Jews and gives a reason for the difference.
- Explains Jewish teaching that human beings possess genuine free will and are therefore morally responsible for their choices.
- Uses the concepts of yetzer ha-tov and yetzer ha-ra to explain the inner struggle and the role of human choice.
- Assesses the value of conscience within Jewish moral decision-making alongside Torah and halakhah.
- Brings in a named other ethical perspective and shows how it supports or challenges Jewish views.
- Compares the relative strengths and weaknesses of the Jewish perspective and the other ethical perspective studied.
- Considers the implications of criticisms of Jewish ethical teaching for the religion as a whole and its sources of authority.
- Distinguishes past from present impact of other ethical perspectives on Jewish views.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Plan by approach: give each named method its own paragraph with the principles that support and challenge it.
- 💡Anchor each claim in a named principle, such as the image of God or the value of life, and explain the link.
- 💡End with an explicit judgement that weighs the principles against each other rather than summarising only.
- 💡Write in continuous essay prose, since this qualification is assessed through extended written responses rather than multiple-choice questions.
- 💡Anchor each Kantian claim in a named concept such as the categorical imperative or the formula of humanity, then link it explicitly to the Jewish ethical material in the theme.
- 💡Build a clear line of argument that weighs deontology against the Jewish framework and states a reasoned conclusion rather than listing views.
- 💡Read the stem for the exact terms teleological and consequential, then check which option uses both correctly.
- 💡Eliminate options that describe duty or rule-following independent of results, because those signal deontology.
- 💡Recall that Bentham measures outcomes through the hedonic calculus, and prefer options that mention happiness or its measurement.
- 💡Check the option against the Judaism-and-ethics context so the classification fits the dialogue being studied.
- 💡Read the stem carefully to see which ethical lens is being described before choosing.
- 💡Eliminate options that describe rules or outcomes when the stem asks about character.
- 💡Check that the chosen option names virtue ethics explicitly where the stem requires it.
- 💡Structure the answer around the four lenses, giving evidence and evaluation for each.
- 💡Use Jewish sources and practices to support each reading rather than asserting labels.
- 💡Reserve space for a clear judgement on how far each lens captures Jewish ethics.
- 💡Name the specific issue in the question and answer it directly rather than writing generally about Jewish ethics.
- 💡Support each response with a named Jewish principle or concept and explain how it applies.
- 💡Show diversity within Judaism by contrasting at least two positions where the issue is contested.
- 💡Keep to the issues listed in the specification and avoid drifting into unrelated ethical topics.
- 💡Address all three areas named in the question: wealth, tolerance and freedom of religious expression.
- 💡Anchor each response in a named Jewish principle or concept and explain how it applies.
- 💡Use a concrete example, such as charitable giving or festival observance, to make the response specific.
- 💡Show awareness that Jewish opinion is not uniform and contrast positions where relevant.
- 💡Plan your answer around the clauses of the question: free will, conscience, other perspectives, comparison, and implications for authority.
- 💡Anchor each claim in specific Jewish teaching or a named ethical theory rather than general assertion.
- 💡Reserve time to evaluate, since the question rewards weighing strengths and weaknesses, not just describing views.
- 💡Use the final paragraph to address what criticism means for Judaism's sources of authority.
Common Mistakes
- Merges all the listed approaches into one general discussion; address each named approach in turn with its own reasoning.
- Cites Jewish principles without explaining how they bear on the specific approach; connect each principle to the decision-making method it supports or challenges.
- Presents Judaism as a single undifferentiated voice; acknowledge that principles can be weighed differently and reach a reasoned position.
- Confuses deontology with consequentialism; keep the distinction clear by stating that deontology grounds rightness in duty and the form of the moral law, not in outcomes.
- Treats Kant's ethics as identical to Jewish ethics; distinguish them by noting that Kant grounds duty in reason and the categorical imperative, whereas Jewish ethics typically grounds obligation in God, covenant and revealed law.
- Describes the categorical imperative as a prediction of results; correct this by presenting it as a test of whether a maxim can be willed as universal law and whether it respects persons as ends.
- Labels Bentham's ethics as deontological; correct this by stating that he judges acts by their consequences and end, making the approach teleological and consequential.
- Treats the hedonic calculus as a set of fixed moral rules; correct this by describing it as a tool for measuring the pleasure and pain an act is expected to produce.
- Confuses teleological with theological; correct this by defining teleological as concerned with ends or purposes rather than with religious doctrine.
- Assumes any religious ethics must be non-consequential; correct this by focusing on what the question asks about Bentham's method rather than on the religion's general character.
- Confuses the character-based reading with a rule-based one; keep virtue ethics focused on dispositions and the sort of person formed.
- Treats virtue ethics as identical to judging outcomes; separate character formation from consequence calculation.
- Assumes only one lens can apply to Jewish ethics; allow that several readings may be defended.
- Treats one lens as the only valid reading; weigh all four and judge how far each applies.
- Describes a lens without linking it to Jewish sources or practice; connect each claim to evidence from the tradition.
- Offers a list of lenses without a judgement; reach a reasoned conclusion about extent.
- Treats Judaism as a single uniform voice; distinguish Orthodox and Progressive positions and give a reason for each.
- Gives a general ethical opinion without a Jewish source or principle; anchor each point in a named teaching or concept.
- Confuses the sanctity of human life with a blanket ban on all medical intervention; explain how pikuach nefesh can permit saving life.
- Lists issues without explaining the reasoning; add the principle behind each Jewish response.
- Treats wealth as simply condemned or simply approved; explain the Jewish emphasis on responsible use and charity instead.
- Gives a personal view on tolerance without a Jewish principle; support the point with a named teaching.
- Assumes all Jews share one position on religious expression in wider society; note diversity and give a reason.
- Describes freedom of religious expression in the abstract without a Jewish example; add a concrete practice such as festival observance.
- Treats free will as an uncontested Jewish doctrine; acknowledge that thinkers differ on how far divine foreknowledge limits human freedom.
- Describes conscience as the sole Jewish moral authority; place conscience alongside Torah and halakhah rather than replacing them.
- Names an ethical perspective without applying it; show precisely where it supports or challenges the Jewish view.
- Lists strengths and weaknesses without comparing them; weigh the two perspectives against each other on the same issue.
- Ignores the final clause about sources of authority; explain what criticism implies for Torah and rabbinic authority.