Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    2D Islam - Section B: The dialogue between Islam and ethics — AQA A-Level Religious Studies

    2D Islam - Section B: The dialogue between Islam and ethics explained

    2D Islam - Section B: The dialogue between Islam and ethics covers 8 specification points, including deontological, with reference to Kant and Teleological and consequential, with reference….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    deontological, with reference to Kant

    This item tests whether you can identify a deontological approach and connect it to Kant. Deontology judges an action by whether it fulfils duty and conforms to moral rules, not by its consequences. Kant grounds duty in the categorical imperative: act only on maxims you could will as universal law, and treat persons as ends, never merely as means. So a Kantian asks whether an act respects rational agents and can be universalised, regardless of the outcome. Contrast this with consequentialism, which weighs results such as happiness or harm. In the dialogue between Islam and ethics, you may compare Kantian duty with Islamic obligation grounded in divine command and sharīʿah. For a multiple-choice question, read each option and eliminate those that justify actions by outcomes or by emotion rather than duty.

    teleological and consequential, with reference to Bentham

    This item asks you to place Bentham's ethics within the dialogue between Islam and ethics. Bentham's utilitarianism is teleological because it judges an action by its outcome, the greatest happiness of the greatest number, and consequential because only consequences carry moral weight. In the dialogue, you compare this with Islamic ethics, where divine command, the Qur'an and the Sunnah, and the pursuit of maslahah (public benefit) shape moral judgement. Note the overlap: both can weigh outcomes and community welfare. Note the tension: Bentham's secular, this-worldly calculus does not appeal to revelation or divine accountability, while Islamic ethics grounds obligation in God's will. A strong answer identifies which feature of Bentham's theory is being compared and how an Islamic ethical framework responds to it.

    character based, with reference to virtue ethics.

    This item asks you to recognise virtue ethics as character based and to relate it to the dialogue between Islam and ethics. Virtue ethics, associated with Aristotle and revived by MacIntyre, asks what kind of person one should be rather than what rule to follow or what outcome to calculate. It centres on virtues such as courage, temperance and justice, cultivated through habit and guided by a conception of human flourishing (eudaimonia). In the dialogue, compare this with Islamic ethics, where character is shaped by the Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Prophet's example, and where virtues such as taqwa (God-consciousness) and justice are cultivated in community. Note the overlap in emphasis on formation of character and the tension over whether flourishing is defined by human reason or by divine guidance.

    How far Muslim ethics can be considered to be deontological, teleological, consequential, or character based.

    This essay asks you to weigh four ethical frameworks against Islamic moral reasoning and judge how far each fits. Deontological ethics judges acts by duty and rule; teleological ethics judges by the goal or purpose pursued; consequential ethics judges by outcomes produced; character-based (virtue) ethics judges by the agent's dispositions and formation. Work through each in turn using concrete Islamic material: divine command and Shari'ah rules, the maqasid (aims of the law) protecting religion, life, intellect, lineage and property, maslahah (public benefit) reasoning, and the Prophet's character as a model. Then argue a degree of fit rather than a simple label, since a rule may serve a purpose and a purpose may shape character. Reach a reasoned judgement on how far, and in what respects, Muslim ethics can be described by each category.

    Muslim response to: the issues of human life and death and issues of animal life and death prescribed for study; theft and lying; marriage; homosexuality and transgender issues; genetic engineering including.

    This area tests your knowledge of Muslim responses across a set of prescribed ethical issues. For human life and death, expect teaching on the sanctity of life, abortion and euthanasia. For animal life and death, expect stewardship (khalifah), kindness to animals and rules on slaughter. For theft and lying, expect Shari'ah prohibitions and their moral reasoning. For marriage, expect contract, consent and roles. For homosexuality and transgender issues, expect a range of Muslim positions and debate. For genetic engineering, expect reasoning about intervention in creation and benefit versus harm. A multiple-choice question will ask you to select the accurate statement, so learn the precise position and its justification rather than a vague impression.

    Muslim responses to issues surrounding wealth, tolerance and freedom of religious expression.

    This topic asks you to connect Islamic teaching with three contested ethical areas. On wealth, Muslim responses draw on the idea that property is held in trust from God, so zakat (the obligatory annual giving of a fixed proportion of qualifying wealth) and sadaqah (voluntary giving) shape attitudes to earning, lending and poverty, while some argue Islamic finance should avoid interest (riba). On tolerance, responses appeal to Qur'anic teaching that there is no compulsion in religion and to the Prophet's agreements with non-Muslim communities, though Muslims disagree about how far this extends to law and public life. On freedom of religious expression, responses weigh the duty to uphold Islam against respect for apostasy, blasphemy and conversion debates. Strong answers distinguish the teaching from the interpretation and give a concrete example.

    Muslim understandings of free will and moral responsibility, and the value of conscience in Muslim moral decision-making.

    This topic examines how Muslims reconcile divine sovereignty with human accountability. Many Muslims hold that God knows and wills all things, yet humans are given reason and revelation and are therefore morally responsible for their choices; the Qur'an speaks of each person being accountable for what they earn. Some stress predestination more strongly, others emphasise human freedom within God's overall will. On conscience, Muslims generally treat it as an inner capacity to recognise right and wrong, but they do not make it the sole authority: it is tested against the Qur'an, the Sunnah and scholarly reasoning. A good answer distinguishes the role of conscience from that of revelation and shows how the two are related rather than opposed.

    The impact of other ethical perspectives and ethical studies on Muslim views about these issues, both past and present. This may include challenges to and support for Muslim views; compatibility of Muslim views with those of other ethical perspectives; the relative strengths and weaknesses of Muslim perspectives and the other ethical perspectives studied on these issues; the implications of criticisms of Muslim ethical teaching for the religion as a whole and its sources of authority.

    This dialogue topic asks you to put Muslim ethical teaching on the studied issues into conversation with the other ethical perspectives and ethical studies you have covered, across past and present contexts. Take a specific issue, state the Muslim position and its reasoning from sources such as the Qur'an, Sunnah, qiyas and ijma', then set beside it a named other perspective, for example a natural law or situation ethics approach, and show whether it challenges or supports the Muslim view. Assess compatibility: where do the conclusions converge and where do the underlying authorities diverge? Weigh relative strengths and weaknesses of both sides on that issue rather than listing them. Finally trace the implication of criticisms for Islam as a whole and for its sources of authority, asking whether a challenge undermines the sources themselves or only one interpretation of them.

    Your focus

    1. Define deontology and distinguish it from consequentialism.
    2. Explain Kant's categorical imperative and respect for persons.
    3. Select the option that correctly applies Kantian reasoning to a moral case.
    Show all 24 objectives
    1. Explain why Bentham's utilitarianism counts as teleological and consequential.
    2. Compare Bentham's outcome-based ethics with Islamic ethical reasoning.
    3. Identify points of contact and tension between utilitarian and Islamic ethics.
    4. Explain why virtue ethics is described as character based.
    5. Compare character formation in virtue ethics with Islamic ethical teaching.
    6. Identify points of contact and tension between virtue ethics and Islamic ethics.
    7. Explain the four ethical frameworks and their defining features.
    8. Apply each framework to specific concepts in Muslim ethics.
    9. Reach and justify a reasoned judgement on how far each label fits Muslim ethics.
    10. State Muslim responses to the prescribed issues of human and animal life and death.
    11. Explain Muslim teaching on theft, lying, marriage, homosexuality, transgender issues and genetic engineering.
    12. Select the accurate statement about Muslim responses from a set of options.
    13. Explain at least two Muslim responses to issues of wealth using named practices.
    14. Describe Muslim reasoning on tolerance and freedom of religious expression.
    15. Distinguish between different Muslim interpretations of the same ethical issue.
    16. Explain how Muslims reconcile free will with divine sovereignty.
    17. Describe the role of conscience in Muslim moral decision-making.
    18. Distinguish conscience from revelation as sources of moral authority in Islam.
    19. Compare a named Muslim ethical position with a named other ethical perspective on a specific issue.
    20. Assess the compatibility of Muslim views with other ethical perspectives studied.
    21. Evaluate the implications of criticisms of Muslim ethical teaching for the religion and its sources of authority.

    2D Islam - Section B: The dialogue between Islam and ethics exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies deontology as judging actions by duty and rules rather than consequences.
    • Links Kant to the categorical imperative and the universalisability of maxims.
    • Recognises that Kant treats persons as ends in themselves, never merely as means.
    • Distinguishes the Kantian approach from consequentialist reasoning that weighs outcomes.
    • Identifies Bentham's utilitarianism as teleological because it evaluates actions by the ends or outcomes they produce.
    • Explains that Bentham's theory is consequential because the moral value of an act rests solely on its consequences, measured by the hedonic calculus.
    • States the principle of utility as the greatest happiness of the greatest number and links it to the dialogue with Islamic ethics.
    • Compares Bentham's secular outcome-based reasoning with Islamic ethics grounded in divine command, the Qur'an and the Sunnah.
    • Recognises maslahah (public benefit) as a point of contact between consequential reasoning and Islamic ethical thought.
    • Distinguishes Bentham's this-worldly calculus from Islamic accountability before God as a point of tension.
    • Identifies virtue ethics as character based because it focuses on the kind of person an agent becomes rather than on isolated acts.
    • Explains that virtue ethics asks what constitutes a virtuous character and how virtues are cultivated through habit and practice.
    • Links virtue ethics to eudaimonia, human flourishing, as the goal that guides the cultivation of virtues.
    • Compares character formation in virtue ethics with Islamic ethics shaped by the Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Prophet's example.
    • Recognises shared emphasis on cultivating virtues such as justice and self-control in both frameworks.
    • Distinguishes reasoning about flourishing from divine guidance as a point of tension in the dialogue.
    • Distinguishes deontological reasoning from teleological, consequential and character-based reasoning with accurate definitions.
    • Applies divine command and Shari'ah rule-following as evidence for a deontological reading of Muslim ethics.
    • Uses the maqasid and maslahah to show teleological and consequential strands in Islamic moral reasoning.
    • Explains how the Prophet's example and the formation of virtuous character support a character-based reading.
    • Weighs the frameworks against each other and reaches a reasoned judgement on how far each label fits.
    • Identifies the sanctity of life as grounding Muslim responses to abortion and euthanasia.
    • Recognises khalifah and kindness as shaping Muslim teaching on animal life and death.
    • Distinguishes Shari'ah prohibitions on theft and lying from their underlying moral reasoning.
    • Selects the accurate statement on Muslim positions on marriage, homosexuality, transgender issues or genetic engineering.
    • Identifies zakat as an obligatory giving calculated on qualifying wealth and links it to a Muslim attitude to wealth.
    • Explains that many Muslims treat wealth as a trust from God rather than absolute ownership, supporting responsible use.
    • Connects tolerance to the principle that there is no compulsion in religion and to examples of coexistence.
    • Distinguishes freedom of religious expression from the separate question of legal punishment for apostasy or blasphemy.
    • Contrasts two Muslim responses to the same issue and explains the reasoning behind each.
    • Explains that Muslims hold humans morally responsible even though God's will and knowledge are supreme.
    • Distinguishes stronger predestinarian views from views that give greater weight to human free choice.
    • Describes conscience as an inner moral awareness that Muslims test against revelation rather than treat as final.
    • Links moral decision-making to the Qur'an, the Sunnah and scholarly reasoning alongside conscience.
    • Explains how free will and moral responsibility are held together rather than treated as contradictory.
    • Sets a named Muslim position on a specific ethical issue alongside a named other ethical perspective and states clearly whether that perspective challenges or supports the Muslim view.
    • Explains the reasoning behind the Muslim position by reference to identified sources of authority such as the Qur'an, Sunnah, qiyas or ijma'.
    • Assesses compatibility by comparing the conclusions each perspective reaches and the authorities on which each depends.
    • Weighs relative strengths and weaknesses of the Muslim perspective and the other perspective on the same issue rather than treating them separately.
    • Traces the implications of a criticism for Islam as a whole and for its sources of authority, distinguishing a challenge to one interpretation from a challenge to the sources themselves.
    • Uses past and present examples to show how the dialogue has developed rather than confining the answer to one period.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Read every option before choosing and eliminate those that justify acts by their results.
    • 💡Look for the option naming duty, universal law or respect for persons as the Kantian marker.
    • 💡Check that the chosen option fits deontology rather than a religious or utilitarian framework.
    • 💡Read the stem carefully to see whether it asks about teleological, consequential or both features before choosing.
    • 💡Eliminate options that describe Bentham as deontological or as ignoring consequences.
    • 💡Check that the chosen option actually engages Islamic ethics, since the section is a dialogue.
    • 💡Use precise terms such as hedonic calculus and principle of utility to distinguish close options.
    • 💡Look for options that mention character, virtues or flourishing rather than rules or calculations.
    • 💡Eliminate options that describe virtue ethics as deontological or purely consequential.
    • 💡Check that the option connects character formation with Islamic ethics, since the section is a dialogue.
    • 💡Use terms such as eudaimonia and virtue to distinguish close options.
    • 💡Define each framework briefly before applying it, so your judgement is grounded.
    • 💡Use a different piece of Islamic evidence for each framework to show range.
    • 💡End with an explicit 'how far' judgement rather than a list of labels.
    • 💡Read every option fully before choosing, since distractors often swap a ruling with its justification.
    • 💡Recall the specific concept (sanctity of life, khalifah, maslahah) linked to each issue.
    • 💡Eliminate options that present one Muslim view as the only view on contested matters.
    • 💡Read the stem carefully to see which of the three areas (wealth, tolerance, expression) is being tested before choosing.
    • 💡Reject options that present a single monolithic Muslim view where the specification expects diversity.
    • 💡Link each option back to a named teaching or practice such as zakat or the no-compulsion principle.
    • 💡Watch for options that swap tolerance for forced conversion or vice versa.
    • 💡Check whether the stem asks about free will, moral responsibility or conscience before selecting.
    • 💡Reject options that make conscience independent of revelation in Islam.
    • 💡Look for options that show humans as accountable agents rather than passive recipients of fate.
    • 💡Distinguish the role of reason and conscience from the authority of the Qur'an and Sunnah.
    • 💡Anchor each paragraph to one issue so the dialogue stays focused and comparable.
    • 💡Name the other ethical perspective precisely and give its key principle before comparing.
    • 💡Reserve time to address the implications for Islam as a whole and its sources of authority, since that clause is easily missed.
    • 💡Use evaluative language that weighs rather than merely describes, for example judging which challenge is most serious and why.
    Common Mistakes
    • Confuses deontology with consequentialism; keep duty-based and outcome-based reasoning separate.
    • Attributes a results-based test to Kant; tie Kant to the categorical imperative and respect for persons.
    • Treats any rule-following as automatically Kantian; specify duty grounded in the categorical imperative.
    • Confuses teleological with deontological; keep teleological tied to ends or purposes and deontological tied to duties or rules.
    • Treats Bentham's theory as rule-based; keep the focus on outcome-based calculation of pleasure and pain.
    • Assumes Islamic ethics is purely consequential; keep divine command and revelation central while noting maslahah as a related concern.
    • Ignores the dialogue requirement; keep the comparison with Islam explicit rather than describing Bentham in isolation.
    • Confuses virtue ethics with rule-based ethics; keep the focus on character rather than duties or commands.
    • Treats virtue ethics as purely about outcomes; keep attention on the agent's character and formation.
    • Assumes Islamic ethics has no concern with character; keep the Prophet's example and cultivation of virtues central.
    • Describes virtue ethics without linking it to the Islamic dialogue; keep the comparison explicit.
    • Treats the four frameworks as mutually exclusive; recognise that Islamic ethics can combine rule, purpose, outcome and character.
    • Asserts that Muslim ethics is purely deontological without engaging the maqasid or maslahah; balance the rule-based evidence with purposive and outcome reasoning.
    • Describes a framework without applying it to specific Islamic material; anchor each label in a named concept or practice.
    • Assumes all Muslims hold one identical view on contested issues; recognise the range of positions and debate.
    • Confuses the prohibition with its justification; learn both the ruling and the reasoning behind it.
    • Treats genetic engineering as uniformly forbidden; distinguish benefit-versus-harm reasoning from a blanket ban.
    • Treats zakat and sadaqah as identical; distinguish the obligatory annual giving from voluntary charity.
    • Assumes all Muslims hold one view on apostasy or blasphemy; present a range of interpretations with reasons.
    • Confuses tolerance with indifference to religious truth; explain how Muslims can respect others while holding firm beliefs.
    • Ignores the wealth clause and writes only about tolerance; address all three areas named in the statement.
    • Claims Islam denies all human free will; explain that most Muslims affirm accountability within God's will.
    • Treats conscience as the supreme authority in Islam; show that revelation and scholarship guide and test it.
    • Presents predestination and free will as simply incompatible; explain how Muslims reconcile them.
    • Ignores the moral responsibility clause and writes only about conscience; address both parts of the statement.
    • Describes the Muslim view and the other perspective in separate blocks without ever putting them into dialogue; connect them explicitly with challenge, support or compatibility.
    • Treats a criticism of one scholar's ruling as if it discredited the Qur'an itself; distinguish criticism of an interpretation from criticism of a source of authority.
    • Lists strengths and weaknesses of each side in isolation; weigh them against each other on the same issue.
    • Asserts compatibility or conflict without explaining the reasoning behind either position; ground each claim in a named authority.