Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    2D Islam - Section A: Islam, migration and religious pluralism — AQA A-Level Religious Studies

    2D Islam - Section A: Islam, migration and religious pluralism explained

    2D Islam - Section A: Islam, migration and religious pluralism covers 4 specification points, including How migration has created multicultural… and Emphasis on exclusivism; its basis in the….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    How migration has created multicultural societies which include Islam, with particular reference to migration by Muslims into the United Kingdom from the 1950s onwards; the diversity within the Muslim community in Britain; freedom of religion as a human right in European law and religious pluralism as a feature of modern secular states; the influence of this context on Muslim thought.

    Migration after the Second World War produced multicultural societies in which Islam is a visible presence. In the United Kingdom, Muslims arrived from the 1950s onwards, notably from South Asia, and later through family reunion and further migration; communities settled, built mosques and established schools and organisations. This community is internally diverse: Sunni and Shi'ah traditions, different schools of law, Sufi orders, and varying ethnic and linguistic backgrounds. European law protects freedom of religion as a human right, and modern secular states treat religious pluralism as a normal feature of public life. This context shapes Muslim thought, prompting reflection on how to live faithfully as a minority, how to engage with secular law and how to present Islam in plural societies.

    Emphasis on exclusivism; its basis in the Qur’an, 3:85; attitudes within Islam to minority Muslim groups.

    Exclusivism holds that one religious tradition possesses the decisive truth, and some Muslims ground this position in the Qur'an, 3:85, which speaks of Islam as the religion accepted by God and warns that other paths will not be accepted. This verse is read by exclusivist thinkers as affirming that salvation and right guidance are found within Islam. The same emphasis shapes attitudes within Islam to minority Muslim groups: communities regarded as outside the mainstream, such as certain sectarian movements, may be treated with caution or described as deviating from orthodox teaching. Learners should explain the exclusivist claim, cite the verse accurately as its basis, and describe how attitudes to minority Muslim groups within the tradition reflect that emphasis, while noting that Muslims interpret the verse in different ways.

    Inclusivism and its basis in the Qur’an with reference to both Abrahamic and non-Abrahamic faiths; the debate about whether good deeds without faith in God or Islam are rewarded by God.

    Inclusivism holds that salvation is available beyond one's own tradition, and Muslim inclusivists ground this in Qur'anic verses such as 2:62, which names believers, Jews, Christians and Sabians who believe in God and the Last Day and do good as having their reward with their Lord. Learners must distinguish inclusivism from exclusivism (only one path saves) and pluralism (many equally valid paths), and apply the Qur'anic basis to both Abrahamic faiths (Judaism, Christianity) and non-Abrahamic faiths (for example Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism). The second clause is a genuine debate: some argue sincere good deeds without explicit faith in God or Islam are rewarded because God is just and merciful; others argue that correct belief (tawhid) is a precondition, citing verses that tie acceptance to faith. A strong answer weighs both readings against the Qur'anic text rather than asserting one.

    Muslim responses to issues of freedom of religious expression in society.

    This criterion asks learners to explain and evaluate how Muslims respond to questions of freedom of religious expression in a plural society. Responses range from those who defend freedom of expression and interfaith dialogue, citing Qur'anic principles such as 'no compulsion in religion' (2:256) and the value of reasoned debate, to those who argue expression should be limited where it causes serious offence, blasphemy or social harm, drawing on concepts of respect for the sacred and public order. A strong extended response sets out these positions, links them to Qur'anic and prophetic sources and to the realities of migration and plural societies, and evaluates which responses are most defensible and why. It should recognise that Muslims disagree among themselves, so 'the Muslim response' is not monolithic.

    Your focus

    1. Outline how migration created multicultural societies including Islam
    2. Describe the diversity of the Muslim community in Britain
    3. Explain how freedom of religion and pluralism influence Muslim thought
    Show all 12 objectives
    1. Define exclusivism and explain its basis in Qur'an, 3:85
    2. Describe attitudes within Islam to minority Muslim groups
    3. Recognise that Muslims interpret the verse in different ways
    4. Explain what inclusivism means and how it differs from exclusivism and pluralism.
    5. Use a Qur'anic verse to support an inclusivist position for Abrahamic and non-Abrahamic faiths.
    6. Evaluate arguments on whether good deeds without faith in God or Islam are rewarded.
    7. Explain a range of Muslim responses to freedom of religious expression in society.
    8. Support each response with relevant Islamic sources and reasoning.
    9. Evaluate the competing responses and reach a justified conclusion.

    2D Islam - Section A: Islam, migration and religious pluralism exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies migration from the 1950s onwards as the key period for Muslim settlement in the United Kingdom
    • Explains how migration produced multicultural societies in which Islam is one of several religious communities
    • Describes diversity within the British Muslim community, such as Sunni and Shi'ah traditions or differing schools of law
    • States that freedom of religion is protected as a human right in European law
    • Explains religious pluralism as a feature of modern secular states
    • Connects this minority context to its influence on Muslim thought and practice
    • Defines exclusivism as the claim that one tradition holds the decisive religious truth
    • Cites the Qur'an, 3:85, as the textual basis for the exclusivist emphasis
    • Explains how the verse is read to affirm Islam as the religion accepted by God
    • Describes attitudes within Islam towards minority Muslim groups, such as caution towards groups seen as deviating
    • Acknowledges that Muslims interpret the verse in differing ways
    • Distinguishes inclusivism from exclusivism and pluralism using clear definitions.
    • Cites a Qur'anic basis such as 2:62 and explains how it supports inclusivism.
    • Applies the inclusivist position to both Abrahamic and non-Abrahamic faiths.
    • Presents the debate over whether good deeds without faith in God or Islam are rewarded, giving arguments on both sides.
    • Evaluates the strength of each side using Qur'anic evidence and concepts of divine justice and mercy.
    • Explains at least two distinct Muslim responses to freedom of religious expression, showing that Muslims disagree.
    • Supports each response with Qur'anic or prophetic evidence and explains the reasoning.
    • Links the responses to the context of migration and religious pluralism in society.
    • Evaluates the strengths and weaknesses of the competing responses and reaches a reasoned judgement.
    • Distinguishes freedom of religious expression from freedom to offend, and discusses where limits might legitimately fall.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Anchor answers in the specified period, beginning with migration from the 1950s onwards
    • 💡Use named examples of diversity rather than a general claim that the community varies
    • 💡Distinguish clearly between European human-rights law and the secular character of the state
    • 💡Show the causal link from context to Muslim thought in a final sentence
    • 💡Quote the reference precisely as Qur'an, 3:85, and explain its content in your own words
    • 💡Define exclusivism before applying it to Islam
    • 💡Give a concrete example of a minority Muslim group and the attitude shown towards it
    • 💡Balance the exclusivist emphasis with a brief note on differing interpretations
    • 💡Define inclusivism, exclusivism and pluralism in one sentence each before applying them.
    • 💡Quote or closely paraphrase the Qur'anic verse and explain its reasoning, not just its wording.
    • 💡Structure the debate clause as 'some argue... others argue... this is stronger because...'.
    • 💡Keep every example inside the topic of Islam, migration and religious pluralism.
    • 💡Open by defining freedom of religious expression and why it is contested in plural societies.
    • 💡Use a clear paragraph structure: position, evidence, reasoning, evaluation.
    • 💡Include the migration and pluralism context explicitly rather than treating the issue abstractly.
    • 💡Conclude with a justified judgement rather than a summary of points already made.
    Common Mistakes
    • Dates Muslim migration to Britain only to recent decades; place the main settlement from the 1950s onwards
    • Treats British Muslims as a single uniform group; recognise internal diversity of tradition, law school and ethnicity
    • Confuses freedom of religion with freedom from religion; keep the human right to hold and practise a faith
    • Ignores the effect of the context on thought; link minority status and pluralism to how Muslims reason about living in Britain
    • Treats exclusivism as the only Muslim position; recognise that the tradition contains a range of readings
    • Cites the wrong chapter and verse; refer to Qur'an, 3:85
    • Assumes all minority Muslim groups are treated identically; describe the range of attitudes
    • Presents one interpretation as the settled meaning of the verse; note that readings differ
    • Confuses inclusivism with pluralism; keep the distinction that inclusivism locates saving truth in one's own tradition while allowing others may be saved.
    • Treats the Qur'anic verse as automatically settling the debate; present it as evidence that must be interpreted and weighed.
    • Ignores non-Abrahamic faiths and discusses only Jews and Christians; address both categories named in the statement.
    • Asserts one answer on good deeds without faith without weighing the opposing reading; give both sides before concluding.
    • Presents a single 'Muslim view' as if all Muslims agree; show the range of responses and their reasoning.
    • Cites a source without explaining how it supports the position; connect evidence to the argument.
    • Confuses freedom of religious expression with freedom of speech in general; keep the focus on religious expression.
    • Offers only description with no evaluation; weigh the responses and reach a judgement.