Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity and science — AQA A-Level Religious Studies

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity and science explained

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity and science covers 4 specification points, including Emphasis on evidence and reason in science;… and How scientific explanation has challenged….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    How and why science has influenced Christianity and how Christianity has responded, with particular reference to: emphasis on evidence and reason in science; specific scientific discoveries; science as a stimulus to Christian ethical thinking.

    This topic has two directions: how science shapes Christianity and how Christianity answers back. On evidence and reason, explain that science tests claims against observation and experiment, which pushed Christian thinkers to defend faith rationally and to distinguish empirical from revealed knowledge. On specific discoveries, use examples such as Darwinian evolution challenging literal readings of Genesis, cosmology reshaping ideas of creation, and genetics raising questions about human uniqueness. On science as a stimulus to ethics, show how medical and biological advances prompt Christian reflection on the beginning and end of life, stewardship of creation and genetic technology. Then cover responses: literalist rejection, allegorical or non-literal readings, and integration that treats science and faith as answering different questions.

    How scientific explanation has challenged Christian belief with reference to the ‘God of the gaps’; 19th century Christian responses to Darwin’s theory of evolution and contemporary responses to the Big Bang theory, including reference to creationist views.

    This topic asks how scientific explanation has challenged Christian belief in three connected areas. The 'God of the gaps' is the move of explaining what science cannot yet account for by appealing to God; as science fills those gaps, the space left for God appears to shrink, so the challenge is that faith looks like a stopgap. For Darwin's theory of evolution, nineteenth-century Christians responded in different ways: some accepted evolution as God's method of creation, others defended a literal reading of Genesis and rejected the theory. For the Big Bang, contemporary Christians respond variously: some see a beginning to the universe as consistent with creation, others stress that cosmology answers 'how' rather than 'why', and creationists hold that Genesis gives a factual account that conflicts with mainstream cosmology.

    The belief that science is compatible with Christianity with reference to the views John Polkinghorne.

    This topic concerns the belief that science and Christianity are compatible, illustrated by the views of John Polkinghorne, a physicist who became an Anglican priest. Polkinghorne argues that science and theology are complementary ways of understanding one reality: science addresses how the world works, while theology addresses meaning, purpose and God's action. He rejects the 'God of the gaps' because it makes God a stopgap that science will displace, and instead holds that God sustains the universe continuously through its lawful processes. He also treats the fine-tuning of the universe and the intelligibility of nature as pointers towards a creator. A strong answer explains what 'compatible' means here and gives specific Polkinghorne positions rather than a general claim that religion and science can coexist.

    Different Christian responses to issues raised by science: genetic engineering.

    Genetic engineering covers altering an organism's DNA, from gene therapy treating disease in a patient to germline editing that passes changes to descendants, and to modifying crops or animals. Christians weigh the same science differently. Some welcome it as stewardship and healing, arguing that relieving suffering fulfils love of neighbour and that humans hold a God-given responsibility for creation. Others set limits: they accept somatic therapy but oppose germline editing because it crosses into redesigning future people, or they stress that humans are creatures, not creators, so humility and the sanctity of life constrain what may be done. A further strand appeals to the natural order and to care for the vulnerable, warning about eugenics, unequal access and treating embryos as means.

    Your focus

    1. Explain how evidence and reason in science influence Christian thought
    2. Give named scientific discoveries and Christian responses to them
    3. Show how science stimulates Christian ethical thinking
    Show all 12 objectives
    1. Explain how the 'God of the gaps' has been used and why scientific advance challenges it.
    2. Distinguish at least two nineteenth-century Christian responses to Darwin's theory of evolution.
    3. Describe contemporary Christian responses to the Big Bang, including creationist views, and link each to its effect on belief.
    4. Explain Polkinghorne's view that science and theology are complementary.
    5. Describe why Polkinghorne rejects the 'God of the gaps'.
    6. Use at least one further Polkinghorne argument to show how he holds science and Christianity to be compatible.
    7. Outline at least two different Christian responses to genetic engineering.
    8. Connect each response to a specific Christian belief or teaching.
    9. Apply a Christian response to a named case such as gene therapy or germline editing.

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity and science exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Explains how scientific method's stress on evidence and reason pressures Christian apologetics
    • Uses a named discovery, such as evolution, to show a challenge to literal biblical reading
    • Shows how scientific advances stimulate Christian ethical debate on life issues or ecology
    • Contrasts literalist, non-literal and integrative Christian responses
    • Distinguishes the questions science and theology each claim to answer
    • Identifies the 'God of the gaps' as explaining what science cannot yet explain by appeal to God, and notes that as scientific knowledge grows the apparent need for God shrinks.
    • Distinguishes at least two nineteenth-century Christian responses to Darwinian evolution, such as accepting evolution as God's means of creation and rejecting it on the basis of a literal Genesis.
    • Explains at least two contemporary Christian responses to the Big Bang, such as seeing a beginning as consistent with creation and distinguishing 'how' questions from 'why' questions.
    • Describes creationist views accurately, showing that they treat Genesis as a factual account and therefore see conflict with mainstream cosmology and evolution.
    • Links each challenge to a specific effect on Christian belief rather than asserting a general 'science versus religion' conflict.
    • Explains that Polkinghorne treats science and theology as complementary, addressing different questions about one reality rather than competing for the same ground.
    • Shows that Polkinghorne rejects the 'God of the gaps' because it makes God a stopgap that scientific progress will remove.
    • Describes Polkinghorne's view that God sustains the universe continuously through its lawful processes rather than intervening only where science fails.
    • Uses at least one further Polkinghorne argument, such as the fine-tuning of the universe or the intelligibility of nature, as a pointer towards a creator.
    • Connects each Polkinghorne view explicitly to the claim that science is compatible with Christianity.
    • Identifies at least two distinct Christian responses to genetic engineering, such as acceptance as stewardship and caution about humans acting as creators.
    • Links each response to a specific Christian belief, for example imago Dei, sanctity of life, stewardship or agape love of neighbour.
    • Applies a response to a concrete case, distinguishing somatic gene therapy from germline editing or from crop modification.
    • Explains why Christians disagree, showing that the same beliefs can support acceptance or restriction depending on how they are interpreted.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Pair every discovery with a specific Christian response
    • 💡Use the phrase 'evidence and reason' explicitly when discussing scientific method
    • 💡Keep ethical examples tied to a scientific advance, not general morality
    • 💡Name the specific challenge before describing the response, so each point is clearly paired.
    • 💡Use precise terms such as 'literal reading of Genesis' and 'God's method of creation' rather than vague phrases like 'they believed in God'.
    • 💡When a question asks about 'challenge', make the effect on belief explicit rather than only describing the science.
    • 💡Anchor each point to a named Polkinghorne idea, such as complementarity or continuous sustaining, rather than general statements.
    • 💡Explain what 'compatible' means in his account before giving examples.
    • 💡Contrast his rejection of the 'God of the gaps' with the gap strategy to show understanding of the difference.
    • 💡Name the specific technology in each point so the ethical issue is clear rather than abstract.
    • 💡Anchor every response in a named Christian belief to show reasoning, not just opinion.
    • 💡Show the disagreement explicitly by contrasting at least two responses in the same answer.
    Common Mistakes
    • Claims science simply destroyed Christian belief; correct this by showing varied responses including integration
    • Treats all Christians as literalists; correct this by naming non-literal readings of Genesis
    • Lists discoveries without linking them to a Christian response; correct this by pairing each discovery with a reaction
    • Treats the 'God of the gaps' as a strong argument for God; correct this by explaining that it is a vulnerable strategy because scientific advance closes the gaps.
    • Assumes all Christians rejected Darwin in the nineteenth century; correct this by showing that responses ranged from acceptance of evolution as God's method to literalist rejection.
    • Presents creationism as the only Christian response to the Big Bang; correct this by including non-literal and 'how/why' responses.
    • Collapses the three areas into one claim that science disproves religion; correct this by treating each challenge and response separately.
    • Presents Polkinghorne as rejecting science or as a creationist; correct this by showing he accepts mainstream science and sees it as compatible with faith.
    • Attributes a 'God of the gaps' position to Polkinghorne; correct this by explaining that he explicitly rejects it.
    • Describes compatibility only as 'they don't contradict'; correct this by explaining the complementary-questions and continuous-sustaining ideas.
    • Confuses Polkinghorne's arguments with those of other scholars; correct this by keeping his specific claims distinct.
    • Treats 'Christianity' as a single uniform voice; distinguish several responses and attribute each to a stated belief.
    • Confuses somatic gene therapy with germline editing; state which is being discussed and why the distinction matters ethically.
    • Asserts a response without grounding it in a belief; connect every claim to creation, imago Dei, stewardship or sanctity of life.